Files
MeltMind/docs/claude/s2-design-v0.4-2026-11-14.md
T

45 lines
2.6 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# S2 design v0.4: rulings A1–A4 and adoption of the G1 framework (Claude, 2026-11-14)
Records the decisions already posted in Slack at 17:38 (thread 1794219487.255049) so the Git design record is complete.
Execution diff closing: codex/s2-execution-diff @ bf03ee8d.
## G1: grouping framework (MoldAstra freeze sheet, Drive 1UDhLnx2fNApKDF25Z0VjyC2J91CYpvyE), adopted
- Parts with the same source key always go to the same side.
- Across keys, three relationships are coded separately:
- rigid near-copies;
- mirror or scale templates;
- variants sharing a parent design with altered flow paths.
All three go to the same side to prevent leakage. This is not a claim of physical equivalence.
- Recall has two routes: physical scale and scale-free.
- Confirmation uses an area-weighted two-way residual plus checks of small holes and thin bridges. Each reviewed pair gets one of three states (PASS / REJECT / UNRESOLVED).
- An UNRESOLVED pair that could change a component puts S2 on HOLD.
- The old 30 pairs are marked exposed; the old 0.5 % / 1 % thresholds are not carried over.
- Thresholds, out-of-screen spot checks and the miss / false-link budget are frozen only after an independent held-out check.
- Deterministic fold and pool rounding: adopted.
- Still open: numeric calibration, review evidence, and the actual component and split artefacts.
## A1: width selection
- One global choice inside the pilot. The pilot's 4 runs (N and E x widths 128/256) are on one fold and the 100 % pool.
- Choose the width with the lowest mean of the N and E inner-validation errors; a tie goes to the smaller width. That width is then frozen for all 90 main runs.
- No additional search runs. The validation exposure is recorded honestly; this is not per-fold nested selection.
## A2: Kendall
- Standard tau-b over 5,000 pairs, keeping ties in the tie-corrected denominator.
- Pairs are drawn uniformly with replacement from i<j over distinct eligible IDs.
- Fewer than 2 IDs, or a zero denominator, gives NA with a reason.
## A3: 10-part sample
- 00000666 is excluded from the random top-tertile draw and then added as a fixed member, giving 10 distinct parts by construction.
## A4: ties, validity and τ
- An argmax tie goes to the smallest original ID.
- A component enters the paired comparison only if all its parts and all 3 seeds are valid in both arms. Excluded mass and reasons are reported.
- An empty or non-positive τ set is an error, and the step fails closed.
## Status
- Design rulings: closed.
- Grouping evidence, code, and supervision acceptance: pending.
- The 10-part measurement, the pilot and the full matrix each need Yanqi's explicit go for that scope.