docs: S2 design v0.4 - A1-A4 rulings and G1 framework adoption

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
ClaudeandClaude Opus 5.5 committed 2026-11-14 09:45:03 +00:00
1 parent 69c58a7700
commit df90007dea
1 file changed
+44
+44
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,44 @@
# S2 design v0.4: rulings A1–A4 and adoption of the G1 framework (Claude, 2026-11-14)
Records the decisions already posted in Slack at 17:38 (thread 1794219487.255049) so the Git design record is complete.
Execution diff closing: codex/s2-execution-diff @ bf03ee8d.
## G1: grouping framework (MoldAstra freeze sheet, Drive 1UDhLnx2fNApKDF25Z0VjyC2J91CYpvyE), adopted
- Parts with the same source key always go to the same side.
- Across keys, three relationships are coded separately:
- rigid near-copies;
- mirror or scale templates;
- variants sharing a parent design with altered flow paths.
All three go to the same side to prevent leakage. This is not a claim of physical equivalence.
- Recall has two routes: physical scale and scale-free.
- Confirmation uses an area-weighted two-way residual plus checks of small holes and thin bridges. Each reviewed pair gets one of three states (PASS / REJECT / UNRESOLVED).
- An UNRESOLVED pair that could change a component puts S2 on HOLD.
- The old 30 pairs are marked exposed; the old 0.5 % / 1 % thresholds are not carried over.
- Thresholds, out-of-screen spot checks and the miss / false-link budget are frozen only after an independent held-out check.
- Deterministic fold and pool rounding: adopted.
- Still open: numeric calibration, review evidence, and the actual component and split artefacts.
## A1: width selection
- One global choice inside the pilot. The pilot's 4 runs (N and E x widths 128/256) are on one fold and the 100 % pool.
- Choose the width with the lowest mean of the N and E inner-validation errors; a tie goes to the smaller width. That width is then frozen for all 90 main runs.
- No additional search runs. The validation exposure is recorded honestly; this is not per-fold nested selection.
## A2: Kendall
- Standard tau-b over 5,000 pairs, keeping ties in the tie-corrected denominator.
- Pairs are drawn uniformly with replacement from i<j over distinct eligible IDs.
- Fewer than 2 IDs, or a zero denominator, gives NA with a reason.
## A3: 10-part sample
- 00000666 is excluded from the random top-tertile draw and then added as a fixed member, giving 10 distinct parts by construction.
## A4: ties, validity and τ
- An argmax tie goes to the smallest original ID.
- A component enters the paired comparison only if all its parts and all 3 seeds are valid in both arms. Excluded mass and reasons are reported.
- An empty or non-positive τ set is an error, and the step fails closed.
## Status
- Design rulings: closed.
- Grouping evidence, code, and supervision acceptance: pending.
- The 10-part measurement, the pilot and the full matrix each need Yanqi's explicit go for that scope.