Publish adoption of the independent item b training-entry review

This commit is contained in:
NewMeltAssist committed 2026-11-18 22:47:41 +08:00
1 parent e912070436
commit 18398c2b2f
9 files changed
+527

No files matched your search

@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
Review audit attempt1: session17768, chunk e894a5, exit1 before tests.
AssertionError: entry['index']==reuse['index']==result['index'] at audit.py line63.
Reviewer assumption was too strict: historical source result retains original local index after hash reuse into a later roster.
429 of552 results retain different historical indices. All429 have original E1 reused_geometry provenance; case and result/extra hashes remain the actual join identity.
Example case00000049_aa208c45e8734584a147f595_step_000: current index6, original result index2, original source phase2-b13-gate-2026-11-17/parts/0002.
Audit corrected to assert current entry index equals reuse mapping index, and trace mismatching result indices to unchanged original source result hashes.
No production code or data changed. This was not a scientific or production failure.
@@ -0,0 +1,99 @@
"""Independent b entry: frozen identities, historical metadata and CPU synthetic checks."""
import ast,copy,hashlib,json,os,resource,subprocess,sys,time
from collections import Counter
from pathlib import Path
B=Path('/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind')
R=Path('/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18')
OUT=Path(__file__).resolve().parent
def read(p):return json.loads(Path(p).read_text())
def sha(p):
h=hashlib.sha256()
with Path(p).open('rb') as f:
for b in iter(lambda:f.read(1048576),b''):h.update(b)
return h.hexdigest()
def write(n,d):
with (OUT/n).open('x') as f:json.dump(d,f,indent=2);f.write('\n')
c=read(R/'contract.json');p=read(R/'implementation-git-freeze.json');binding=read(R/'expected-review-binding.json')
expected=dict(reviewed_commit=p['commit'],contract_sha256=sha(R/'contract.json'),implementation_proof_sha256=sha(R/'implementation-git-freeze.json'),comparison_contract_sha256=sha(R/'comparison-contract.json'),code_sha256=c['code_sha256'])
assert binding==expected
assert p['commit']=='b2a9dfdc4a2c237416452ff6b4c32bdbf34e172e'
assert expected['contract_sha256']=='df80f3b4bbb0d4ee285401ff50b40cfc6bfd06f3302abcd53b41f14a20a204de'
assert expected['implementation_proof_sha256']=='0501275106a0698c9dac6f75554b570bb82f7d4640e76b84f51cf759a8bdadd2'
assert expected['comparison_contract_sha256']=='06556bf1f7bd5a1a79451bd9eed47fc6ec027e7e06bc63c6f490a50dfbee6d20'
assert sha(R/'expected-review-binding.json')=='e5b01d81f8bfee991dee9a2971f8048d77b6c15ab61e3de08b2f97385f413261'
for mapping in [c['code_sha256'],c['source_sha256'],p['files']]:
for path,h in mapping.items():assert sha(path)==h,path
for path,h in p['files'].items():
raw=subprocess.check_output(['git','-C',p['local_repository'],'show',p['commit']+':'+p['git_paths'][path]])
assert hashlib.sha256(raw).hexdigest()==h,path
from phase3_item_b_common import config
_,pilot=config(R)
old_pins={}
for folder in ['phase3-item-c-2026-11-18','phase3-item-1b-2026-11-18','phase3-seed1-v2-2026-11-18','track-a-recovery-2026-11-18']:
old=read(R.parent/folder/'contract.json')
for path,h in old['code_sha256'].items():assert sha(path)==h,path
old_pins[folder]=len(old['code_sha256'])
shared=str(B/'tools/phase3_shared_capacity.py')
approved=read(B/'artifacts/meltassist-item-c-reservation-delta-review-2026-11-18/review.json')
assert c['code_sha256'][shared]==approved['code_sha256'][shared]
prior=read(R.parent/'phase3-item-1b-2026-11-18/contract.json')
assert c['baseline_models']==prior['baseline_models']
# Join all552 historical B13 context records by metadata and opaque hashes.
original=B/'artifacts/phase2-b13-e1b-2026-11-17'
oc=read(original/'contract.json')
assert read(original/'complete.json')['status']=='COMPLETE' and not oc['new_geometry_indices']
rows={r['case']:r for r in read(c['query_roster_contract'])['rows']}
entries={x['case']:x for x in read(original/'features-manifest.json')['entries']}
reused={x['case']:x for x in oc['reused_geometry']}
source_rows={x['case']:x for x in oc['parts']}
e1=read(B/'artifacts/phase2-b13-e1-2026-11-17/contract.json')
prior_reused={x['case']:x for x in e1['reused_geometry']}
assert set(c['context'])==set(rows)==set(entries)==set(reused)==set(source_rows) and len(rows)==552
counts=Counter();historical_index_cases=[]
for case,ctx in c['context'].items():
entry=entries[case];reuse=reused[case];oldrow=source_rows[case];meta=pilot['parts'][case]
result=read(ctx['result']);counts[result['status']]+=1
assert ctx['case']==result['case']==case
assert ctx['nodes']==oldrow['nodes']==meta['nodes']
assert ctx['component_id']==oldrow['component_id']==rows[case]['component_id']
assert oldrow['preparation']==rows[case]['preparation']
assert oldrow['v5_cache']['output_sha256']==meta['output_sha256']
assert ctx['raw_ids_sha256']==meta['output_sha256']['raw_ids.npy']
assert ctx['features_sha256']==meta['output_sha256']['features.npy']
assert entry['index']==reuse['index']
assert sha(Path(reuse['source'])/'result.json')==ctx['result_sha256']
if result['index']!=entry['index']:
prior=prior_reused[case]
assert prior['result_sha256']==ctx['result_sha256']
assert prior['extra_sha256']==ctx['extra_sha256']
assert sha(Path(prior['source'])/'result.json')==ctx['result_sha256']
assert read(Path(prior['source'])/'result.json')['index']==result['index']
historical_index_cases.append(case)
assert ctx['result_sha256']==entry['result_sha256']==reuse['result_sha256']==sha(ctx['result'])
assert ctx['extra_sha256']==result['extra_sha256']==reuse['extra_sha256']==sha(ctx['extra'])
assert ctx['status']==result['status'] and result['kind']=='B13' and result['labels_read'] is False
assert counts==Counter(GEOMETRY_COMPLETE=510,SCIENTIFIC_MISSING=42)
def loop(name):
tree=ast.parse((B/'tools'/name).read_text())
return next(n for n in ast.walk(tree) if isinstance(n,ast.For) and ast.unparse(n.target)=='epoch')
oldloop=copy.deepcopy(loop('phase2_h2_s2_worker.py'))
for node in ast.walk(oldloop):
if isinstance(node,ast.Constant) and node.value=='WAIT_ALL_FIRST_EPOCH_COST_GATE':node.value='WAIT_THIS_FOLD_FIRST_EPOCH_COST_GATE'
if isinstance(node,ast.Call) and isinstance(node.func,ast.Name):
if node.func.id=='first_epoch_release':node.args=[ast.Name(id='root',ctx=ast.Load()),ast.Name(id='fold_id',ctx=ast.Load())]
elif node.func.id=='load_part':node.args.insert(1,ast.Name(id='c',ctx=ast.Load()))
assert ast.dump(oldloop)==ast.dump(loop('phase3_item_b_worker.py'))
env=dict(os.environ,PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE='1',CUDA_VISIBLE_DEVICES='',PYTHONPATH=str(B/'tools'),OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS='1',OMP_NUM_THREADS='1',MKL_NUM_THREADS='1')
u0=resource.getrusage(resource.RUSAGE_CHILDREN);start=time.monotonic()
with (OUT/'synthetic-tests.log').open('x') as f:
run=subprocess.run([sys.executable,'-m','unittest','-v','tools/test_phase3_item_b.py'],cwd=B,env=env,stdout=f,stderr=subprocess.STDOUT,timeout=60)
u=resource.getrusage(resource.RUSAGE_CHILDREN)
tests=dict(exit_code=run.returncode,wall_seconds=time.monotonic()-start,child_cpu_seconds=u.ru_utime+u.ru_stime-u0.ru_utime-u0.ru_stime,log_sha256=sha(OUT/'synthetic-tests.log'))
assert run.returncode==0,tests
assert 'Ran 29 tests' in (OUT/'synthetic-tests.log').read_text()
evidence=dict(status='PASS',binding=expected,binding_file_sha256=sha(R/'expected-review-binding.json'),code_files=len(c['code_sha256']),source_files=len(c['source_sha256']),local_git_files=len(p['files']),old_code_pins=old_pins,shared_code_sha256=c['code_sha256'][shared],context_metadata_counts=dict(counts),context_join_rows=552,historical_index_cases=len(historical_index_cases),historical_index_resolution='Original reused results retain source-local indices; case and hashes join correctly, original source results independently hash-verified',first_audit_failure='audit-attempt1.txt; reviewer incorrectly required historical result index to equal current roster index',context_raw_array_values_read=False,training_and_validation_loop_ast='Equal to original S2 after declared context-loader argument and per-fold cost-gate substitutions; original200epoch schedule unchanged',tests=tests,entry_state={n:(R/n).exists() for n in ['review.json','started.json','complete.json']},scientific_execution=False,remote_raw_bytes_independently_checked=False)
write('evidence.json',evidence)
print(json.dumps({k:v for k,v in evidence.items() if k!='binding'}))
@@ -0,0 +1,114 @@
{
"status": "PASS",
"binding": {
"reviewed_commit": "b2a9dfdc4a2c237416452ff6b4c32bdbf34e172e",
"contract_sha256": "df80f3b4bbb0d4ee285401ff50b40cfc6bfd06f3302abcd53b41f14a20a204de",
"implementation_proof_sha256": "0501275106a0698c9dac6f75554b570bb82f7d4640e76b84f51cf759a8bdadd2",
"comparison_contract_sha256": "06556bf1f7bd5a1a79451bd9eed47fc6ec027e7e06bc63c6f490a50dfbee6d20",
"code_sha256": {
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/freeze_g1_components.py": "d0cee60d95243ac2c59ef3f2244ba818315718c4e3d1895f2f9f064f1f7f5ecd",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_models.py": "53b6fee8b700b9b982b06d29908ce2ce23e0c57512c46dbf74b2aade79e3ac3a",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_gate_outcome_review.py": "915617aeb8292d03c654e637bc34a014c254fd178a773f135d1806c4b41372a8",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h1_worker_v2.py": "1543df85b615bb69b79bacd572074a7c77ae19dab110197601573a7e5805ed20",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_data.py": "7e03dd7a94e7bb43593277f183c222473d7cb7aaf2f60e53b45ab8d9499fcb09",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_model.py": "fab2470dd0654ca74c3b7d893f35ad1f3ae6c5c08ffe334ef6312cf6ec87892a",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_pilot_worker.py": "14651ca402e6d02466d8afdb77bc9e62fb2e752f0c0c3d20d98593157d5ebe81",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_common.py": "38a29a34663a5d6310571eeff53b5d18a0355e51b9fa58a08033f64fa379a9df",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_home_freeze_io.py": "bf09204b85ed2a7038acdd202257f618474d1110a9d6d772f105a3ffb334d3ff",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_local_freeze_io.py": "60adf3382577613c5234f5cf30779336b9951b66e90c075cb7cd0adab9cc42dd",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_residual_math.py": "ffbd9624dec79bdaabf95244fe87209055908f31a977e73ea4377045d6f8fe62",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_capacity.py": "3915da37ead45f42fe620cb89bc7394b576f8e113047a4ad78e1bae50ded120c",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_common.py": "d00069d2ca5a346d8260dfb1829bf941f3ea09ebd7d75c1fe377120b553e02d2",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_data.py": "74e35b6268462c999078383e49e551c9da2562390d22977414713811bab164b3",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_guard.py": "e95cd5126f403881aebe137ed3f00bb6173881eea15709952142cb51136ad699",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_model.py": "13000ce6eb7cccfbefdc1710e37a59412be0391ae820b243f0d8fe7a9be4e986",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_queue.py": "0c6f5c9bde84f28bfc829701d97701188f43ed59fa0c5286228ca325cf88235c",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_worker.py": "d49a5e6f900850aabacc5825168b6f886215aff8c494937bea2238539e58f652",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_v2_common.py": "25ca6be14027369393bd3616209b08f30e25892cccca83300483c5a116e8d75d",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_shared_capacity.py": "7c07b0aaf1bc4e6a980d016defcac326c3bd871134d2583bb4dcd88bb34728f8",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item_b.py": "ac46c3c6d01d8023444d2f53f956d94d1d295ae95a3435f355c5c6e0f6ccd962",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_gpu_idle_gate.py": "e2b1613e7e6ea398a8d555220a9365a1ad998ab4ef4b2bf8ec7cc4e31f8b4b9f",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_main_memory_guard.py": "e094f5443e11518efe9018215c11718a8e18aa462a977bf43e974b2d0b2aebb1",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/__init__.py": "a0fa1323d3553172da66c5d442c5fc4fcb0d5055c886c776928604550ea97609",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/attention.py": "7714adfccf6a0fc6b52a44aee3a50321a88898bf3d743680a1108c01e1ff8a61",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/blocks.py": "b13e986cea5f1d7f325a1638c1505197b4a105baacff5a9a515f23fcaf28ea75",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/features.py": "3b34ae61cf8012ebd58b7505a73d7aa43d8ee1890ac54f98d7917b67887a45a4",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/network.py": "5137e845d81d1223afc13bf87e03ccba1132a3baa75d5189a8f320b2752be071",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/normalization.py": "7180696d3845799e28d8c31ddef957d075de6a2e46d96a3a0f0df16fc05234a0",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/objectives.py": "5b6527a45f08690055d572335470ce5979e8bb86e1cab00de594f79ae21316b1",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_pilot_train.py": "e9cceead51a5cc092aad23409ad98909c84a62e7e10571e750d1e9be1ad3b948",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_precision_continuation_guard.py": "01235d897c7c03e5ffa109c58b14f5d24d128e8f1ba873e1f76cfb14e02f7a7f",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_gpu_supervisor.py": "689c0f3179e4fcd362e546d90214829a9e4f8739abdbdf74b560763e5a392f15",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_monitoring.py": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item_b.py": "bed8e21042971bb688b33c13903a28fab1772b980431a80afd205dbe4350dac2",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_common.py": "79918e7de887d1f0a2de5523156b27d00dc2d85ac930a07efc34d817d904fe65",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_prepare.py": "f657be036dc48fc5936f56c4b8510a4b295d4787af6877cc5ccaad663107be17",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_monitor.py": "4c423f8b0dff69304d0046c0a9c319bb31aa0c6d1cbaeb3942726b5e6caa0496",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_supervisor.py": "5ccb2a6eec95b0700b2063a2f8df414037528e90c206648c1c5e49c5e89e741d",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_capacity.py": "771faad0095712fd4fc8131ddcfabaa3901141592d2b055ea2faadf8ea3d3edf",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_common.py": "4e25effe8326ff8c7c3f751590315040209af054b32b0505dc3c6b001589db32",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_guard.py": "08b7d8ab2ac773fab8b749f9f61af259254422128e9634f8b715c81efce2651f",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_queue.py": "31dfd71369c63512c1d6fe176fd22e8db646520c92da533bb5530ca3843c388d",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_schedule.py": "06cb97594c3a87f42f712dcde6cec8c2d90e0b50a89a6be7954bdd2f5c18d5de",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_worker.py": "b781e56c519401bd38af6a522deb24506cba6993d2af008f85ea4e1715f1d9c6",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item1b.py": "c7bc9f3b7cf4137f52e1efad19dcb7045282d4e9a9c1aae50f066c9e488f7c01",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item1b.py": "b4d78f4384651711fe83ff00eb6719c6c61664699d801ecb34978b9546439da9",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_common.py": "4e85f5d211c4d3e2188422aa4c0cefa40dcfa14ef32e90894ed3412de1fd1d12",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_data.py": "fe3aa3e023f22f4fe55cd47e7ffa677b58f52a041867ac05620cbd329d913cb6",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_guard.py": "7144fa77ffe61a2a3c92c050234e370ef4dfeb0e31fafb419f752f969737ff1a",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_loss.py": "79e291866bda300ecdc5577c62903d34abeec14f5cc36db05e346f9ffd64c24b",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_queue.py": "a04879cc0169ecb523a88360cddca1e234d91b3adbc20b3ec31d02461ed767eb",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_worker.py": "0f8f35e1422021b2a4f097c2e62267fb935fe4658fd0ee8ccd251609a4062ea7",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item_c.py": "782c415b1f536eb2b85aa2c9c4a9a0dc278f9b7134e8a83e2a6af8199396c53a",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_common.py": "588c646101be0d50f505f9a12a1c98361aa3437c8c594eecb7321831f717a741",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_statistics.py": "188565801f6901d0192f79aec0889e632501e672a4149d76d1835efbb9b45447",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item_c.py": "3115aa9049974eac86657aa4cee7b5d716f6ee93268555cc86242029ebefce4c",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase2_h2_s2.py": "4235890fd194b7778e937f0be9245b964512df2c75d962ef703e3a988c5b8805",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_guard.py": "6bc7624b0cfe850591f77153cd2034eefdd62f7e63b93211ccdb87eb8aba346c",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_common.py": "308486507ae3589a0e6cc40565f6e60e6d2f63ae74c4d828bdacf33b3b8b8062",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_fixed_io.py": "ea17fdfc7508f3f980e3cdf69534b1eb8ceb8a8e469c32451b2d5e16d0ada575",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_worker.py": "37dfd75fff50b3d65f4ef37f4255536616582fe5f3d01155a0e037325ab5c7cd",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_worker.py": "ecee04b183ef2b93b7b39a447d48c40a5843d3190e48d2d7eb4939811a5db9b0",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_prepare.py": "964fae13ac95e4de4dc50b3c0a80791d86349ce3a9f3c5a6e7dc3cf8ca041fad",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_prepare.py": "3a31af0766f628a80f38e0b7286beb11ca3109188eabc4adfdb2ecb0eef3dc27",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_queue.py": "d82dfb365956e08250758bb4c651a19fbecce92fe209072f5f8ed35970450735",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_launch.py": "480fac25dea5a2006bb84130a4b0a0b253b3040b2150a56c38eada62b2c259e6",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_guard.py": "ae94711adc17a7630f398e8d4120fa3cc8f60979a00122c4cd2dc364c382ced5",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/docs/phase2-h2-s2-execution-contract-2026-11-17.md": "1e8e5ef31650519737cd6cd247abc0bd04744dd93ffb013eff88866d42f03073"
}
},
"binding_file_sha256": "e5b01d81f8bfee991dee9a2971f8048d77b6c15ab61e3de08b2f97385f413261",
"code_files": 69,
"source_files": 1300,
"local_git_files": 80,
"old_code_pins": {
"phase3-item-c-2026-11-18": 52,
"phase3-item-1b-2026-11-18": 60,
"phase3-seed1-v2-2026-11-18": 51,
"track-a-recovery-2026-11-18": 27
},
"shared_code_sha256": "7c07b0aaf1bc4e6a980d016defcac326c3bd871134d2583bb4dcd88bb34728f8",
"context_metadata_counts": {
"GEOMETRY_COMPLETE": 510,
"SCIENTIFIC_MISSING": 42
},
"context_join_rows": 552,
"historical_index_cases": 429,
"historical_index_resolution": "Original reused results retain source-local indices; case and hashes join correctly, original source results independently hash-verified",
"first_audit_failure": "audit-attempt1.txt; reviewer incorrectly required historical result index to equal current roster index",
"context_raw_array_values_read": false,
"training_and_validation_loop_ast": "Equal to original S2 after declared context-loader argument and per-fold cost-gate substitutions; original200epoch schedule unchanged",
"tests": {
"exit_code": 0,
"wall_seconds": 6.290130304987542,
"child_cpu_seconds": 6.210590999999999,
"log_sha256": "0d7985c40e8b70c1a576c39915cebde21467d3796ea949746368f49a8dca4654"
},
"entry_state": {
"review.json": false,
"started.json": false,
"complete.json": false
},
"scientific_execution": false,
"remote_raw_bytes_independently_checked": false
}
@@ -0,0 +1,113 @@
{
"reviewed_commit": "b2a9dfdc4a2c237416452ff6b4c32bdbf34e172e",
"contract_sha256": "df80f3b4bbb0d4ee285401ff50b40cfc6bfd06f3302abcd53b41f14a20a204de",
"implementation_proof_sha256": "0501275106a0698c9dac6f75554b570bb82f7d4640e76b84f51cf759a8bdadd2",
"comparison_contract_sha256": "06556bf1f7bd5a1a79451bd9eed47fc6ec027e7e06bc63c6f490a50dfbee6d20",
"code_sha256": {
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/freeze_g1_components.py": "d0cee60d95243ac2c59ef3f2244ba818315718c4e3d1895f2f9f064f1f7f5ecd",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_models.py": "53b6fee8b700b9b982b06d29908ce2ce23e0c57512c46dbf74b2aade79e3ac3a",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_gate_outcome_review.py": "915617aeb8292d03c654e637bc34a014c254fd178a773f135d1806c4b41372a8",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h1_worker_v2.py": "1543df85b615bb69b79bacd572074a7c77ae19dab110197601573a7e5805ed20",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_data.py": "7e03dd7a94e7bb43593277f183c222473d7cb7aaf2f60e53b45ab8d9499fcb09",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_model.py": "fab2470dd0654ca74c3b7d893f35ad1f3ae6c5c08ffe334ef6312cf6ec87892a",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_pilot_worker.py": "14651ca402e6d02466d8afdb77bc9e62fb2e752f0c0c3d20d98593157d5ebe81",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_common.py": "38a29a34663a5d6310571eeff53b5d18a0355e51b9fa58a08033f64fa379a9df",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_home_freeze_io.py": "bf09204b85ed2a7038acdd202257f618474d1110a9d6d772f105a3ffb334d3ff",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_local_freeze_io.py": "60adf3382577613c5234f5cf30779336b9951b66e90c075cb7cd0adab9cc42dd",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_residual_math.py": "ffbd9624dec79bdaabf95244fe87209055908f31a977e73ea4377045d6f8fe62",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_capacity.py": "3915da37ead45f42fe620cb89bc7394b576f8e113047a4ad78e1bae50ded120c",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_common.py": "d00069d2ca5a346d8260dfb1829bf941f3ea09ebd7d75c1fe377120b553e02d2",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_data.py": "74e35b6268462c999078383e49e551c9da2562390d22977414713811bab164b3",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_guard.py": "e95cd5126f403881aebe137ed3f00bb6173881eea15709952142cb51136ad699",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_model.py": "13000ce6eb7cccfbefdc1710e37a59412be0391ae820b243f0d8fe7a9be4e986",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_queue.py": "0c6f5c9bde84f28bfc829701d97701188f43ed59fa0c5286228ca325cf88235c",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_worker.py": "d49a5e6f900850aabacc5825168b6f886215aff8c494937bea2238539e58f652",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_v2_common.py": "25ca6be14027369393bd3616209b08f30e25892cccca83300483c5a116e8d75d",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_shared_capacity.py": "7c07b0aaf1bc4e6a980d016defcac326c3bd871134d2583bb4dcd88bb34728f8",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item_b.py": "ac46c3c6d01d8023444d2f53f956d94d1d295ae95a3435f355c5c6e0f6ccd962",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_gpu_idle_gate.py": "e2b1613e7e6ea398a8d555220a9365a1ad998ab4ef4b2bf8ec7cc4e31f8b4b9f",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_main_memory_guard.py": "e094f5443e11518efe9018215c11718a8e18aa462a977bf43e974b2d0b2aebb1",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/__init__.py": "a0fa1323d3553172da66c5d442c5fc4fcb0d5055c886c776928604550ea97609",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/attention.py": "7714adfccf6a0fc6b52a44aee3a50321a88898bf3d743680a1108c01e1ff8a61",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/blocks.py": "b13e986cea5f1d7f325a1638c1505197b4a105baacff5a9a515f23fcaf28ea75",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/features.py": "3b34ae61cf8012ebd58b7505a73d7aa43d8ee1890ac54f98d7917b67887a45a4",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/network.py": "5137e845d81d1223afc13bf87e03ccba1132a3baa75d5189a8f320b2752be071",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/normalization.py": "7180696d3845799e28d8c31ddef957d075de6a2e46d96a3a0f0df16fc05234a0",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/objectives.py": "5b6527a45f08690055d572335470ce5979e8bb86e1cab00de594f79ae21316b1",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_pilot_train.py": "e9cceead51a5cc092aad23409ad98909c84a62e7e10571e750d1e9be1ad3b948",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_precision_continuation_guard.py": "01235d897c7c03e5ffa109c58b14f5d24d128e8f1ba873e1f76cfb14e02f7a7f",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_gpu_supervisor.py": "689c0f3179e4fcd362e546d90214829a9e4f8739abdbdf74b560763e5a392f15",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_monitoring.py": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item_b.py": "bed8e21042971bb688b33c13903a28fab1772b980431a80afd205dbe4350dac2",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_common.py": "79918e7de887d1f0a2de5523156b27d00dc2d85ac930a07efc34d817d904fe65",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_prepare.py": "f657be036dc48fc5936f56c4b8510a4b295d4787af6877cc5ccaad663107be17",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_monitor.py": "4c423f8b0dff69304d0046c0a9c319bb31aa0c6d1cbaeb3942726b5e6caa0496",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_supervisor.py": "5ccb2a6eec95b0700b2063a2f8df414037528e90c206648c1c5e49c5e89e741d",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_capacity.py": "771faad0095712fd4fc8131ddcfabaa3901141592d2b055ea2faadf8ea3d3edf",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_common.py": "4e25effe8326ff8c7c3f751590315040209af054b32b0505dc3c6b001589db32",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_guard.py": "08b7d8ab2ac773fab8b749f9f61af259254422128e9634f8b715c81efce2651f",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_queue.py": "31dfd71369c63512c1d6fe176fd22e8db646520c92da533bb5530ca3843c388d",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_schedule.py": "06cb97594c3a87f42f712dcde6cec8c2d90e0b50a89a6be7954bdd2f5c18d5de",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_worker.py": "b781e56c519401bd38af6a522deb24506cba6993d2af008f85ea4e1715f1d9c6",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item1b.py": "c7bc9f3b7cf4137f52e1efad19dcb7045282d4e9a9c1aae50f066c9e488f7c01",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item1b.py": "b4d78f4384651711fe83ff00eb6719c6c61664699d801ecb34978b9546439da9",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_common.py": "4e85f5d211c4d3e2188422aa4c0cefa40dcfa14ef32e90894ed3412de1fd1d12",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_data.py": "fe3aa3e023f22f4fe55cd47e7ffa677b58f52a041867ac05620cbd329d913cb6",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_guard.py": "7144fa77ffe61a2a3c92c050234e370ef4dfeb0e31fafb419f752f969737ff1a",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_loss.py": "79e291866bda300ecdc5577c62903d34abeec14f5cc36db05e346f9ffd64c24b",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_queue.py": "a04879cc0169ecb523a88360cddca1e234d91b3adbc20b3ec31d02461ed767eb",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_worker.py": "0f8f35e1422021b2a4f097c2e62267fb935fe4658fd0ee8ccd251609a4062ea7",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item_c.py": "782c415b1f536eb2b85aa2c9c4a9a0dc278f9b7134e8a83e2a6af8199396c53a",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_common.py": "588c646101be0d50f505f9a12a1c98361aa3437c8c594eecb7321831f717a741",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_statistics.py": "188565801f6901d0192f79aec0889e632501e672a4149d76d1835efbb9b45447",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item_c.py": "3115aa9049974eac86657aa4cee7b5d716f6ee93268555cc86242029ebefce4c",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase2_h2_s2.py": "4235890fd194b7778e937f0be9245b964512df2c75d962ef703e3a988c5b8805",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_guard.py": "6bc7624b0cfe850591f77153cd2034eefdd62f7e63b93211ccdb87eb8aba346c",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_common.py": "308486507ae3589a0e6cc40565f6e60e6d2f63ae74c4d828bdacf33b3b8b8062",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_fixed_io.py": "ea17fdfc7508f3f980e3cdf69534b1eb8ceb8a8e469c32451b2d5e16d0ada575",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_worker.py": "37dfd75fff50b3d65f4ef37f4255536616582fe5f3d01155a0e037325ab5c7cd",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_worker.py": "ecee04b183ef2b93b7b39a447d48c40a5843d3190e48d2d7eb4939811a5db9b0",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_prepare.py": "964fae13ac95e4de4dc50b3c0a80791d86349ce3a9f3c5a6e7dc3cf8ca041fad",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_prepare.py": "3a31af0766f628a80f38e0b7286beb11ca3109188eabc4adfdb2ecb0eef3dc27",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_queue.py": "d82dfb365956e08250758bb4c651a19fbecce92fe209072f5f8ed35970450735",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_launch.py": "480fac25dea5a2006bb84130a4b0a0b253b3040b2150a56c38eada62b2c259e6",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_guard.py": "ae94711adc17a7630f398e8d4120fa3cc8f60979a00122c4cd2dc364c382ced5",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/docs/phase2-h2-s2-execution-contract-2026-11-17.md": "1e8e5ef31650519737cd6cd247abc0bd04744dd93ffb013eff88866d42f03073"
},
"verdict": "PASS",
"reviewer": "MeltAssist",
"scope": "Independent item b H2+B13-context five-fold200epoch training-entry review; no launch/postfit approval",
"evidence_sha256": "c762a1e578c3a1e6aad39b1bfa6ad1ac0d76668561bea4d61d3d8f223f495b33",
"audit_source_sha256": "5ce7c3131c3d89606eda2c2e5a83d6d35d7af2deb1cfa57b85f3d02590444229",
"findings": [],
"passed_checks": [
"Exact69code/1300source/80local immutable Git files verified; c52+1b60+seed1 51+TrackA27 code pins unchanged.",
"Moldde120e9d: original19features plus2 B13 means and1 joint-valid flag. Original H2 constructed first, encoder/head each append192 zero weights,384total, same shared parameters and RNG state. Synthetic nonzero-readout function equivalence and original train_step new-column learnability pass.",
"Original nineteen-column normalization unchanged; new mean/population scale over valid learning nodes only with unit-node weighting; zero variance scale1, no valid nodes stops. Invalid both columns zero AFTER normalization plus flag0; valid mean stillflag1.",
"Partial/asymmetric missingness, infinity, bad shape or historical status mismatch stops; original role guard precedes context reads. No new partition, K, geometry or labels.",
"All552 context entries independently joined to original E1b manifests/reuse/source by case, node/feature/rawID/geometry/query metadata and opaque hashes; historical510GEOMETRY_COMPLETE+42SCIENTIFIC_MISSING retained.",
"Original seed0/200epochs/MSE/AdamW/weight decay/clipping/cF/part order retained. Training and every10epoch diagnostic loop AST equals original S2 after declared context-loader argument and per-fold cost-gate changes. Final guard requires200 completeepochs and exact steps.",
"Shared adapter changes only b key/cap178200/GPU0..2; exact reviewed shared code hash7c07b0aa and unchanged functions. Existing pending/RESERVED/GUARD_BOUND/CPU/memory rules remain.",
"178200 includes7200post GPU/3600CPU reserve,prep600/setup/waiting/failures; remaining200epochs+20diagnostics multiplied1.5 pluscleanup;60000onlyactual runaway, totalprojection stop. Phase3reservations711581.3159993868<=720000;TrackA separate.",
"Complete five models freeze before TRAIN_COMPLETE_POSTFIT_PENDING; no automatic prediction/scoring, no retries, failed-worker peaks and freeze-tail charges preserved. Separate future pre-score review and actual worker exit/final-account gates required.",
"Comparison retains552parts/204components,equal components,paired2000bootstrap seed2026111408,95CI upperdelta<-.001 and abs effect>abs matched seed difference; missing seed waits for judgement. Full corpus, validity-subgroup reports and limitations remain.",
"Independent29CPU synthetic tests PASS; full childCPU6.210591s. Production scientific arrays/labels/model values never decoded."
],
"tests": {
"exit_code": 0,
"wall_seconds": 6.290130304987542,
"child_cpu_seconds": 6.210590999999999,
"log_sha256": "0d7985c40e8b70c1a576c39915cebde21467d3796ea949746368f49a8dca4654"
},
"limitations": [
"This PASS is bound onlyb2a9dfdc/df80f3b4 and full69code map. No c/1b entry PASS reused.",
"552context values were not numerically decoded;510/42 are historical metadata states. Runtime array validity and identity checks remain necessary.",
"429immutable results retain original local indices after roster reuse. Initial reviewer audit wrongly asserted index equality, failed before tests, and is preserved in audit-attempt1.txt. Corrected case/hash join traces all429 to original hashed sources; no production defect or edit.",
"Author28-test run did not catch copied guard100epoch condition; author corrected to200 before freeze and added29th assertion. Both logs remain; fixed source and new assertion independently checked.",
"Tests use tiny synthetic CPU networks/arrays and fake queue/registry fixtures only. No real scientific training, GPU query, label decode, live registry/source/Git edits.",
"No fresh-family claim, no pure spatial attribution if gains concentrate on missing-context pieces, no flow-conservation claim and no closure of O1/type/connectivity hypotheses. Uncached partition runtime remains unmeasured.",
"Actual shared-card memory/timing and capacity availability remain runtime checks, not established by entry PASS. This review does not override pending-queue launch holds or executor handover.",
"Postfit implementation and final seed-reference/statistical gates are not executed or reviewed here.",
"Publication31a20abd differs from implementationb2a9dfdc; local Git bytes independently checked, no independent remote raw-byte readback claim."
]
}
@@ -0,0 +1,34 @@
test_actual_runaway_stops (tools.test_phase3_item_b.BudgetTests) ... ok
test_incomplete_history_rejected (tools.test_phase3_item_b.BudgetTests) ... ok
test_initial_budget_includes_postfit (tools.test_phase3_item_b.BudgetTests) ... ok
test_late_validation_max_used (tools.test_phase3_item_b.BudgetTests) ... ok
test_no_single_fold_projection_gate (tools.test_phase3_item_b.BudgetTests) ... ok
test_remaining_validation_charged (tools.test_phase3_item_b.BudgetTests) ... ok
test_all_learning_invalid_stops (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok
test_infinity_or_wrong_shape_stops (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok
test_joint_missing_is_zero_after_normalization (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok
test_learning_only_iteration (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok
test_original_role_guard_precedes_context_read (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok
test_partial_missing_stops (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok
test_status_mismatch_not_scientific_missing (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok
test_unit_node_moments_not_equal_part_means (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok
test_valid_mean_still_has_flag (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok
test_zero_variance_scale_one (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok
test_all_shared_parameters_and_rng_match (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ModelTests) ... ok
test_exactly384_additional_parameters (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ModelTests) ... ok
test_guard_accepts_only_complete200_epoch_identity (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ModelTests) ... ok
test_new_columns_can_learn_without_changing_recipe (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ModelTests) ... ok
test_nonzero_readout_still_matches_original_initial_function (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ModelTests) ... ok
test_worker_uses_original200_recipe (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ModelTests) ... ok
test_wrong_input_columns_rejected (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ModelTests) ... ok
test_failure_no_retry_or_test (tools.test_phase3_item_b.QueueTests) ... ok
test_five_fits_stop_before_postfit (tools.test_phase3_item_b.QueueTests) ... ok
test_mixed_pending_c_reservation_blocks_b (tools.test_phase3_item_b.SharedWrapperTests) ... ok
test_mixed_two_visible_allows_only_one_new (tools.test_phase3_item_b.SharedWrapperTests) ... ok
test_shared_c_and_b_registration_independent (tools.test_phase3_item_b.SharedWrapperTests) ... ok
test_wrapper_changes_only_key_cap_gpu_set (tools.test_phase3_item_b.SharedWrapperTests) ... ok
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ran 29 tests in 1.485s
OK
@@ -0,0 +1,18 @@
{
"status": "PASS",
"scope": "independent training-entry review adopted",
"review_sha256": "8360e3f2f88d89fb39786c10e2185f1a04ae696b9e455350fed3a2ba4ceedf1a",
"binding_sha256": "e5b01d81f8bfee991dee9a2971f8048d77b6c15ab61e3de08b2f97385f413261",
"review_freeze": "584d2937bbdaf6aacc6b9c064ddf643a8a89b4c6",
"implementation": "b2a9dfdc4a2c237416452ff6b4c32bdbf34e172e",
"code_pins": 69,
"source_pins": 1300,
"reviewed_by": "MeltAssist",
"adopted_by": "NewMeltAssist",
"claude_acceptance": "1795012816.911319",
"reviewer_delivery": "1795012797.621519",
"slack_handover_confirmation": "1795013045.173339",
"started": false,
"postfit_started": false,
"unix": 1795013137.986224
}
@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
{
"contract_sha256": "df80f3b4bbb0d4ee285401ff50b40cfc6bfd06f3302abcd53b41f14a20a204de",
"proof_sha256": "039291ee8c43ba14495df526ef191a0bc3c39a43d1cbd74e7150d81a20c73109"
}
@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
{
"commit": "584d2937bbdaf6aacc6b9c064ddf643a8a89b4c6",
"files": {
"/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/contract.json": "df80f3b4bbb0d4ee285401ff50b40cfc6bfd06f3302abcd53b41f14a20a204de",
"/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/expected-review-binding.json": "e5b01d81f8bfee991dee9a2971f8048d77b6c15ab61e3de08b2f97385f413261",
"/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/review.json": "8360e3f2f88d89fb39786c10e2185f1a04ae696b9e455350fed3a2ba4ceedf1a",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/review.json": "8360e3f2f88d89fb39786c10e2185f1a04ae696b9e455350fed3a2ba4ceedf1a",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json": "c762a1e578c3a1e6aad39b1bfa6ad1ac0d76668561bea4d61d3d8f223f495b33",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit.py": "5ce7c3131c3d89606eda2c2e5a83d6d35d7af2deb1cfa57b85f3d02590444229",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/synthetic-tests.log": "0d7985c40e8b70c1a576c39915cebde21467d3796ea949746368f49a8dca4654",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit-attempt1.txt": "7ecdad9db43752087e6df86c9cf63c9bd1c30bcd8cf314c0ace9ec873e1d851b"
},
"git_paths": {
"/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/contract.json": "home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/contract.json",
"/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/expected-review-binding.json": "home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/expected-review-binding.json",
"/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/review.json": "home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/review.json",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/review.json": "artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/review.json",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json": "artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit.py": "artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit.py",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/synthetic-tests.log": "artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/synthetic-tests.log",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit-attempt1.txt": "artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit-attempt1.txt"
},
"remote_published": false,
"local_repository": "/tmp/meltmind-phase2-local-fixed-20261117"
}
@@ -0,0 +1,113 @@
{
"reviewed_commit": "b2a9dfdc4a2c237416452ff6b4c32bdbf34e172e",
"contract_sha256": "df80f3b4bbb0d4ee285401ff50b40cfc6bfd06f3302abcd53b41f14a20a204de",
"implementation_proof_sha256": "0501275106a0698c9dac6f75554b570bb82f7d4640e76b84f51cf759a8bdadd2",
"comparison_contract_sha256": "06556bf1f7bd5a1a79451bd9eed47fc6ec027e7e06bc63c6f490a50dfbee6d20",
"code_sha256": {
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/freeze_g1_components.py": "d0cee60d95243ac2c59ef3f2244ba818315718c4e3d1895f2f9f064f1f7f5ecd",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_models.py": "53b6fee8b700b9b982b06d29908ce2ce23e0c57512c46dbf74b2aade79e3ac3a",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_gate_outcome_review.py": "915617aeb8292d03c654e637bc34a014c254fd178a773f135d1806c4b41372a8",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h1_worker_v2.py": "1543df85b615bb69b79bacd572074a7c77ae19dab110197601573a7e5805ed20",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_data.py": "7e03dd7a94e7bb43593277f183c222473d7cb7aaf2f60e53b45ab8d9499fcb09",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_model.py": "fab2470dd0654ca74c3b7d893f35ad1f3ae6c5c08ffe334ef6312cf6ec87892a",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_pilot_worker.py": "14651ca402e6d02466d8afdb77bc9e62fb2e752f0c0c3d20d98593157d5ebe81",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_common.py": "38a29a34663a5d6310571eeff53b5d18a0355e51b9fa58a08033f64fa379a9df",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_home_freeze_io.py": "bf09204b85ed2a7038acdd202257f618474d1110a9d6d772f105a3ffb334d3ff",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_local_freeze_io.py": "60adf3382577613c5234f5cf30779336b9951b66e90c075cb7cd0adab9cc42dd",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_residual_math.py": "ffbd9624dec79bdaabf95244fe87209055908f31a977e73ea4377045d6f8fe62",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_capacity.py": "3915da37ead45f42fe620cb89bc7394b576f8e113047a4ad78e1bae50ded120c",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_common.py": "d00069d2ca5a346d8260dfb1829bf941f3ea09ebd7d75c1fe377120b553e02d2",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_data.py": "74e35b6268462c999078383e49e551c9da2562390d22977414713811bab164b3",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_guard.py": "e95cd5126f403881aebe137ed3f00bb6173881eea15709952142cb51136ad699",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_model.py": "13000ce6eb7cccfbefdc1710e37a59412be0391ae820b243f0d8fe7a9be4e986",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_queue.py": "0c6f5c9bde84f28bfc829701d97701188f43ed59fa0c5286228ca325cf88235c",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_worker.py": "d49a5e6f900850aabacc5825168b6f886215aff8c494937bea2238539e58f652",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_v2_common.py": "25ca6be14027369393bd3616209b08f30e25892cccca83300483c5a116e8d75d",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_shared_capacity.py": "7c07b0aaf1bc4e6a980d016defcac326c3bd871134d2583bb4dcd88bb34728f8",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item_b.py": "ac46c3c6d01d8023444d2f53f956d94d1d295ae95a3435f355c5c6e0f6ccd962",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_gpu_idle_gate.py": "e2b1613e7e6ea398a8d555220a9365a1ad998ab4ef4b2bf8ec7cc4e31f8b4b9f",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_main_memory_guard.py": "e094f5443e11518efe9018215c11718a8e18aa462a977bf43e974b2d0b2aebb1",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/__init__.py": "a0fa1323d3553172da66c5d442c5fc4fcb0d5055c886c776928604550ea97609",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/attention.py": "7714adfccf6a0fc6b52a44aee3a50321a88898bf3d743680a1108c01e1ff8a61",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/blocks.py": "b13e986cea5f1d7f325a1638c1505197b4a105baacff5a9a515f23fcaf28ea75",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/features.py": "3b34ae61cf8012ebd58b7505a73d7aa43d8ee1890ac54f98d7917b67887a45a4",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/network.py": "5137e845d81d1223afc13bf87e03ccba1132a3baa75d5189a8f320b2752be071",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/normalization.py": "7180696d3845799e28d8c31ddef957d075de6a2e46d96a3a0f0df16fc05234a0",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/objectives.py": "5b6527a45f08690055d572335470ce5979e8bb86e1cab00de594f79ae21316b1",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_pilot_train.py": "e9cceead51a5cc092aad23409ad98909c84a62e7e10571e750d1e9be1ad3b948",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_precision_continuation_guard.py": "01235d897c7c03e5ffa109c58b14f5d24d128e8f1ba873e1f76cfb14e02f7a7f",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_gpu_supervisor.py": "689c0f3179e4fcd362e546d90214829a9e4f8739abdbdf74b560763e5a392f15",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_monitoring.py": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item_b.py": "bed8e21042971bb688b33c13903a28fab1772b980431a80afd205dbe4350dac2",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_common.py": "79918e7de887d1f0a2de5523156b27d00dc2d85ac930a07efc34d817d904fe65",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_prepare.py": "f657be036dc48fc5936f56c4b8510a4b295d4787af6877cc5ccaad663107be17",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_monitor.py": "4c423f8b0dff69304d0046c0a9c319bb31aa0c6d1cbaeb3942726b5e6caa0496",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_supervisor.py": "5ccb2a6eec95b0700b2063a2f8df414037528e90c206648c1c5e49c5e89e741d",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_capacity.py": "771faad0095712fd4fc8131ddcfabaa3901141592d2b055ea2faadf8ea3d3edf",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_common.py": "4e25effe8326ff8c7c3f751590315040209af054b32b0505dc3c6b001589db32",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_guard.py": "08b7d8ab2ac773fab8b749f9f61af259254422128e9634f8b715c81efce2651f",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_queue.py": "31dfd71369c63512c1d6fe176fd22e8db646520c92da533bb5530ca3843c388d",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_schedule.py": "06cb97594c3a87f42f712dcde6cec8c2d90e0b50a89a6be7954bdd2f5c18d5de",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_worker.py": "b781e56c519401bd38af6a522deb24506cba6993d2af008f85ea4e1715f1d9c6",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item1b.py": "c7bc9f3b7cf4137f52e1efad19dcb7045282d4e9a9c1aae50f066c9e488f7c01",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item1b.py": "b4d78f4384651711fe83ff00eb6719c6c61664699d801ecb34978b9546439da9",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_common.py": "4e85f5d211c4d3e2188422aa4c0cefa40dcfa14ef32e90894ed3412de1fd1d12",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_data.py": "fe3aa3e023f22f4fe55cd47e7ffa677b58f52a041867ac05620cbd329d913cb6",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_guard.py": "7144fa77ffe61a2a3c92c050234e370ef4dfeb0e31fafb419f752f969737ff1a",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_loss.py": "79e291866bda300ecdc5577c62903d34abeec14f5cc36db05e346f9ffd64c24b",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_queue.py": "a04879cc0169ecb523a88360cddca1e234d91b3adbc20b3ec31d02461ed767eb",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_worker.py": "0f8f35e1422021b2a4f097c2e62267fb935fe4658fd0ee8ccd251609a4062ea7",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item_c.py": "782c415b1f536eb2b85aa2c9c4a9a0dc278f9b7134e8a83e2a6af8199396c53a",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_common.py": "588c646101be0d50f505f9a12a1c98361aa3437c8c594eecb7321831f717a741",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_statistics.py": "188565801f6901d0192f79aec0889e632501e672a4149d76d1835efbb9b45447",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item_c.py": "3115aa9049974eac86657aa4cee7b5d716f6ee93268555cc86242029ebefce4c",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase2_h2_s2.py": "4235890fd194b7778e937f0be9245b964512df2c75d962ef703e3a988c5b8805",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_guard.py": "6bc7624b0cfe850591f77153cd2034eefdd62f7e63b93211ccdb87eb8aba346c",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_common.py": "308486507ae3589a0e6cc40565f6e60e6d2f63ae74c4d828bdacf33b3b8b8062",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_fixed_io.py": "ea17fdfc7508f3f980e3cdf69534b1eb8ceb8a8e469c32451b2d5e16d0ada575",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_worker.py": "37dfd75fff50b3d65f4ef37f4255536616582fe5f3d01155a0e037325ab5c7cd",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_worker.py": "ecee04b183ef2b93b7b39a447d48c40a5843d3190e48d2d7eb4939811a5db9b0",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_prepare.py": "964fae13ac95e4de4dc50b3c0a80791d86349ce3a9f3c5a6e7dc3cf8ca041fad",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_prepare.py": "3a31af0766f628a80f38e0b7286beb11ca3109188eabc4adfdb2ecb0eef3dc27",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_queue.py": "d82dfb365956e08250758bb4c651a19fbecce92fe209072f5f8ed35970450735",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_launch.py": "480fac25dea5a2006bb84130a4b0a0b253b3040b2150a56c38eada62b2c259e6",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_guard.py": "ae94711adc17a7630f398e8d4120fa3cc8f60979a00122c4cd2dc364c382ced5",
"/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/docs/phase2-h2-s2-execution-contract-2026-11-17.md": "1e8e5ef31650519737cd6cd247abc0bd04744dd93ffb013eff88866d42f03073"
},
"verdict": "PASS",
"reviewer": "MeltAssist",
"scope": "Independent item b H2+B13-context five-fold200epoch training-entry review; no launch/postfit approval",
"evidence_sha256": "c762a1e578c3a1e6aad39b1bfa6ad1ac0d76668561bea4d61d3d8f223f495b33",
"audit_source_sha256": "5ce7c3131c3d89606eda2c2e5a83d6d35d7af2deb1cfa57b85f3d02590444229",
"findings": [],
"passed_checks": [
"Exact69code/1300source/80local immutable Git files verified; c52+1b60+seed1 51+TrackA27 code pins unchanged.",
"Moldde120e9d: original19features plus2 B13 means and1 joint-valid flag. Original H2 constructed first, encoder/head each append192 zero weights,384total, same shared parameters and RNG state. Synthetic nonzero-readout function equivalence and original train_step new-column learnability pass.",
"Original nineteen-column normalization unchanged; new mean/population scale over valid learning nodes only with unit-node weighting; zero variance scale1, no valid nodes stops. Invalid both columns zero AFTER normalization plus flag0; valid mean stillflag1.",
"Partial/asymmetric missingness, infinity, bad shape or historical status mismatch stops; original role guard precedes context reads. No new partition, K, geometry or labels.",
"All552 context entries independently joined to original E1b manifests/reuse/source by case, node/feature/rawID/geometry/query metadata and opaque hashes; historical510GEOMETRY_COMPLETE+42SCIENTIFIC_MISSING retained.",
"Original seed0/200epochs/MSE/AdamW/weight decay/clipping/cF/part order retained. Training and every10epoch diagnostic loop AST equals original S2 after declared context-loader argument and per-fold cost-gate changes. Final guard requires200 completeepochs and exact steps.",
"Shared adapter changes only b key/cap178200/GPU0..2; exact reviewed shared code hash7c07b0aa and unchanged functions. Existing pending/RESERVED/GUARD_BOUND/CPU/memory rules remain.",
"178200 includes7200post GPU/3600CPU reserve,prep600/setup/waiting/failures; remaining200epochs+20diagnostics multiplied1.5 pluscleanup;60000onlyactual runaway, totalprojection stop. Phase3reservations711581.3159993868<=720000;TrackA separate.",
"Complete five models freeze before TRAIN_COMPLETE_POSTFIT_PENDING; no automatic prediction/scoring, no retries, failed-worker peaks and freeze-tail charges preserved. Separate future pre-score review and actual worker exit/final-account gates required.",
"Comparison retains552parts/204components,equal components,paired2000bootstrap seed2026111408,95CI upperdelta<-.001 and abs effect>abs matched seed difference; missing seed waits for judgement. Full corpus, validity-subgroup reports and limitations remain.",
"Independent29CPU synthetic tests PASS; full childCPU6.210591s. Production scientific arrays/labels/model values never decoded."
],
"tests": {
"exit_code": 0,
"wall_seconds": 6.290130304987542,
"child_cpu_seconds": 6.210590999999999,
"log_sha256": "0d7985c40e8b70c1a576c39915cebde21467d3796ea949746368f49a8dca4654"
},
"limitations": [
"This PASS is bound onlyb2a9dfdc/df80f3b4 and full69code map. No c/1b entry PASS reused.",
"552context values were not numerically decoded;510/42 are historical metadata states. Runtime array validity and identity checks remain necessary.",
"429immutable results retain original local indices after roster reuse. Initial reviewer audit wrongly asserted index equality, failed before tests, and is preserved in audit-attempt1.txt. Corrected case/hash join traces all429 to original hashed sources; no production defect or edit.",
"Author28-test run did not catch copied guard100epoch condition; author corrected to200 before freeze and added29th assertion. Both logs remain; fixed source and new assertion independently checked.",
"Tests use tiny synthetic CPU networks/arrays and fake queue/registry fixtures only. No real scientific training, GPU query, label decode, live registry/source/Git edits.",
"No fresh-family claim, no pure spatial attribution if gains concentrate on missing-context pieces, no flow-conservation claim and no closure of O1/type/connectivity hypotheses. Uncached partition runtime remains unmeasured.",
"Actual shared-card memory/timing and capacity availability remain runtime checks, not established by entry PASS. This review does not override pending-queue launch holds or executor handover.",
"Postfit implementation and final seed-reference/statistical gates are not executed or reviewed here.",
"Publication31a20abd differs from implementationb2a9dfdc; local Git bytes independently checked, no independent remote raw-byte readback claim."
]
}