diff --git a/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit-attempt1.txt b/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit-attempt1.txt new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a9e70097e --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit-attempt1.txt @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +Review audit attempt1: session17768, chunk e894a5, exit1 before tests. +AssertionError: entry['index']==reuse['index']==result['index'] at audit.py line63. +Reviewer assumption was too strict: historical source result retains original local index after hash reuse into a later roster. +429 of552 results retain different historical indices. All429 have original E1 reused_geometry provenance; case and result/extra hashes remain the actual join identity. +Example case00000049_aa208c45e8734584a147f595_step_000: current index6, original result index2, original source phase2-b13-gate-2026-11-17/parts/0002. +Audit corrected to assert current entry index equals reuse mapping index, and trace mismatching result indices to unchanged original source result hashes. +No production code or data changed. This was not a scientific or production failure. diff --git a/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit.py b/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3ee8485ef --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit.py @@ -0,0 +1,99 @@ +"""Independent b entry: frozen identities, historical metadata and CPU synthetic checks.""" +import ast,copy,hashlib,json,os,resource,subprocess,sys,time +from collections import Counter +from pathlib import Path + +B=Path('/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind') +R=Path('/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18') +OUT=Path(__file__).resolve().parent +def read(p):return json.loads(Path(p).read_text()) +def sha(p): + h=hashlib.sha256() + with Path(p).open('rb') as f: + for b in iter(lambda:f.read(1048576),b''):h.update(b) + return h.hexdigest() +def write(n,d): + with (OUT/n).open('x') as f:json.dump(d,f,indent=2);f.write('\n') +c=read(R/'contract.json');p=read(R/'implementation-git-freeze.json');binding=read(R/'expected-review-binding.json') +expected=dict(reviewed_commit=p['commit'],contract_sha256=sha(R/'contract.json'),implementation_proof_sha256=sha(R/'implementation-git-freeze.json'),comparison_contract_sha256=sha(R/'comparison-contract.json'),code_sha256=c['code_sha256']) +assert binding==expected +assert p['commit']=='b2a9dfdc4a2c237416452ff6b4c32bdbf34e172e' +assert expected['contract_sha256']=='df80f3b4bbb0d4ee285401ff50b40cfc6bfd06f3302abcd53b41f14a20a204de' +assert expected['implementation_proof_sha256']=='0501275106a0698c9dac6f75554b570bb82f7d4640e76b84f51cf759a8bdadd2' +assert expected['comparison_contract_sha256']=='06556bf1f7bd5a1a79451bd9eed47fc6ec027e7e06bc63c6f490a50dfbee6d20' +assert sha(R/'expected-review-binding.json')=='e5b01d81f8bfee991dee9a2971f8048d77b6c15ab61e3de08b2f97385f413261' +for mapping in [c['code_sha256'],c['source_sha256'],p['files']]: + for path,h in mapping.items():assert sha(path)==h,path +for path,h in p['files'].items(): + raw=subprocess.check_output(['git','-C',p['local_repository'],'show',p['commit']+':'+p['git_paths'][path]]) + assert hashlib.sha256(raw).hexdigest()==h,path +from phase3_item_b_common import config +_,pilot=config(R) +old_pins={} +for folder in ['phase3-item-c-2026-11-18','phase3-item-1b-2026-11-18','phase3-seed1-v2-2026-11-18','track-a-recovery-2026-11-18']: + old=read(R.parent/folder/'contract.json') + for path,h in old['code_sha256'].items():assert sha(path)==h,path + old_pins[folder]=len(old['code_sha256']) +shared=str(B/'tools/phase3_shared_capacity.py') +approved=read(B/'artifacts/meltassist-item-c-reservation-delta-review-2026-11-18/review.json') +assert c['code_sha256'][shared]==approved['code_sha256'][shared] +prior=read(R.parent/'phase3-item-1b-2026-11-18/contract.json') +assert c['baseline_models']==prior['baseline_models'] + +# Join all552 historical B13 context records by metadata and opaque hashes. +original=B/'artifacts/phase2-b13-e1b-2026-11-17' +oc=read(original/'contract.json') +assert read(original/'complete.json')['status']=='COMPLETE' and not oc['new_geometry_indices'] +rows={r['case']:r for r in read(c['query_roster_contract'])['rows']} +entries={x['case']:x for x in read(original/'features-manifest.json')['entries']} +reused={x['case']:x for x in oc['reused_geometry']} +source_rows={x['case']:x for x in oc['parts']} +e1=read(B/'artifacts/phase2-b13-e1-2026-11-17/contract.json') +prior_reused={x['case']:x for x in e1['reused_geometry']} +assert set(c['context'])==set(rows)==set(entries)==set(reused)==set(source_rows) and len(rows)==552 +counts=Counter();historical_index_cases=[] +for case,ctx in c['context'].items(): + entry=entries[case];reuse=reused[case];oldrow=source_rows[case];meta=pilot['parts'][case] + result=read(ctx['result']);counts[result['status']]+=1 + assert ctx['case']==result['case']==case + assert ctx['nodes']==oldrow['nodes']==meta['nodes'] + assert ctx['component_id']==oldrow['component_id']==rows[case]['component_id'] + assert oldrow['preparation']==rows[case]['preparation'] + assert oldrow['v5_cache']['output_sha256']==meta['output_sha256'] + assert ctx['raw_ids_sha256']==meta['output_sha256']['raw_ids.npy'] + assert ctx['features_sha256']==meta['output_sha256']['features.npy'] + assert entry['index']==reuse['index'] + assert sha(Path(reuse['source'])/'result.json')==ctx['result_sha256'] + if result['index']!=entry['index']: + prior=prior_reused[case] + assert prior['result_sha256']==ctx['result_sha256'] + assert prior['extra_sha256']==ctx['extra_sha256'] + assert sha(Path(prior['source'])/'result.json')==ctx['result_sha256'] + assert read(Path(prior['source'])/'result.json')['index']==result['index'] + historical_index_cases.append(case) + assert ctx['result_sha256']==entry['result_sha256']==reuse['result_sha256']==sha(ctx['result']) + assert ctx['extra_sha256']==result['extra_sha256']==reuse['extra_sha256']==sha(ctx['extra']) + assert ctx['status']==result['status'] and result['kind']=='B13' and result['labels_read'] is False +assert counts==Counter(GEOMETRY_COMPLETE=510,SCIENTIFIC_MISSING=42) + +def loop(name): + tree=ast.parse((B/'tools'/name).read_text()) + return next(n for n in ast.walk(tree) if isinstance(n,ast.For) and ast.unparse(n.target)=='epoch') +oldloop=copy.deepcopy(loop('phase2_h2_s2_worker.py')) +for node in ast.walk(oldloop): + if isinstance(node,ast.Constant) and node.value=='WAIT_ALL_FIRST_EPOCH_COST_GATE':node.value='WAIT_THIS_FOLD_FIRST_EPOCH_COST_GATE' + if isinstance(node,ast.Call) and isinstance(node.func,ast.Name): + if node.func.id=='first_epoch_release':node.args=[ast.Name(id='root',ctx=ast.Load()),ast.Name(id='fold_id',ctx=ast.Load())] + elif node.func.id=='load_part':node.args.insert(1,ast.Name(id='c',ctx=ast.Load())) +assert ast.dump(oldloop)==ast.dump(loop('phase3_item_b_worker.py')) +env=dict(os.environ,PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE='1',CUDA_VISIBLE_DEVICES='',PYTHONPATH=str(B/'tools'),OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS='1',OMP_NUM_THREADS='1',MKL_NUM_THREADS='1') +u0=resource.getrusage(resource.RUSAGE_CHILDREN);start=time.monotonic() +with (OUT/'synthetic-tests.log').open('x') as f: + run=subprocess.run([sys.executable,'-m','unittest','-v','tools/test_phase3_item_b.py'],cwd=B,env=env,stdout=f,stderr=subprocess.STDOUT,timeout=60) +u=resource.getrusage(resource.RUSAGE_CHILDREN) +tests=dict(exit_code=run.returncode,wall_seconds=time.monotonic()-start,child_cpu_seconds=u.ru_utime+u.ru_stime-u0.ru_utime-u0.ru_stime,log_sha256=sha(OUT/'synthetic-tests.log')) +assert run.returncode==0,tests +assert 'Ran 29 tests' in (OUT/'synthetic-tests.log').read_text() +evidence=dict(status='PASS',binding=expected,binding_file_sha256=sha(R/'expected-review-binding.json'),code_files=len(c['code_sha256']),source_files=len(c['source_sha256']),local_git_files=len(p['files']),old_code_pins=old_pins,shared_code_sha256=c['code_sha256'][shared],context_metadata_counts=dict(counts),context_join_rows=552,historical_index_cases=len(historical_index_cases),historical_index_resolution='Original reused results retain source-local indices; case and hashes join correctly, original source results independently hash-verified',first_audit_failure='audit-attempt1.txt; reviewer incorrectly required historical result index to equal current roster index',context_raw_array_values_read=False,training_and_validation_loop_ast='Equal to original S2 after declared context-loader argument and per-fold cost-gate substitutions; original200epoch schedule unchanged',tests=tests,entry_state={n:(R/n).exists() for n in ['review.json','started.json','complete.json']},scientific_execution=False,remote_raw_bytes_independently_checked=False) +write('evidence.json',evidence) +print(json.dumps({k:v for k,v in evidence.items() if k!='binding'})) diff --git a/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json b/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fbad79b5e --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json @@ -0,0 +1,114 @@ +{ + "status": "PASS", + "binding": { + "reviewed_commit": "b2a9dfdc4a2c237416452ff6b4c32bdbf34e172e", + "contract_sha256": "df80f3b4bbb0d4ee285401ff50b40cfc6bfd06f3302abcd53b41f14a20a204de", + "implementation_proof_sha256": "0501275106a0698c9dac6f75554b570bb82f7d4640e76b84f51cf759a8bdadd2", + "comparison_contract_sha256": "06556bf1f7bd5a1a79451bd9eed47fc6ec027e7e06bc63c6f490a50dfbee6d20", + "code_sha256": { + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/freeze_g1_components.py": "d0cee60d95243ac2c59ef3f2244ba818315718c4e3d1895f2f9f064f1f7f5ecd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_models.py": "53b6fee8b700b9b982b06d29908ce2ce23e0c57512c46dbf74b2aade79e3ac3a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_gate_outcome_review.py": "915617aeb8292d03c654e637bc34a014c254fd178a773f135d1806c4b41372a8", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h1_worker_v2.py": "1543df85b615bb69b79bacd572074a7c77ae19dab110197601573a7e5805ed20", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_data.py": "7e03dd7a94e7bb43593277f183c222473d7cb7aaf2f60e53b45ab8d9499fcb09", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_model.py": "fab2470dd0654ca74c3b7d893f35ad1f3ae6c5c08ffe334ef6312cf6ec87892a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_pilot_worker.py": "14651ca402e6d02466d8afdb77bc9e62fb2e752f0c0c3d20d98593157d5ebe81", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_common.py": "38a29a34663a5d6310571eeff53b5d18a0355e51b9fa58a08033f64fa379a9df", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_home_freeze_io.py": "bf09204b85ed2a7038acdd202257f618474d1110a9d6d772f105a3ffb334d3ff", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_local_freeze_io.py": "60adf3382577613c5234f5cf30779336b9951b66e90c075cb7cd0adab9cc42dd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_residual_math.py": "ffbd9624dec79bdaabf95244fe87209055908f31a977e73ea4377045d6f8fe62", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_capacity.py": "3915da37ead45f42fe620cb89bc7394b576f8e113047a4ad78e1bae50ded120c", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_common.py": "d00069d2ca5a346d8260dfb1829bf941f3ea09ebd7d75c1fe377120b553e02d2", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_data.py": "74e35b6268462c999078383e49e551c9da2562390d22977414713811bab164b3", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_guard.py": "e95cd5126f403881aebe137ed3f00bb6173881eea15709952142cb51136ad699", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_model.py": "13000ce6eb7cccfbefdc1710e37a59412be0391ae820b243f0d8fe7a9be4e986", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_queue.py": "0c6f5c9bde84f28bfc829701d97701188f43ed59fa0c5286228ca325cf88235c", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_worker.py": "d49a5e6f900850aabacc5825168b6f886215aff8c494937bea2238539e58f652", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_v2_common.py": "25ca6be14027369393bd3616209b08f30e25892cccca83300483c5a116e8d75d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_shared_capacity.py": "7c07b0aaf1bc4e6a980d016defcac326c3bd871134d2583bb4dcd88bb34728f8", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item_b.py": "ac46c3c6d01d8023444d2f53f956d94d1d295ae95a3435f355c5c6e0f6ccd962", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_gpu_idle_gate.py": "e2b1613e7e6ea398a8d555220a9365a1ad998ab4ef4b2bf8ec7cc4e31f8b4b9f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_main_memory_guard.py": "e094f5443e11518efe9018215c11718a8e18aa462a977bf43e974b2d0b2aebb1", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/__init__.py": "a0fa1323d3553172da66c5d442c5fc4fcb0d5055c886c776928604550ea97609", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/attention.py": "7714adfccf6a0fc6b52a44aee3a50321a88898bf3d743680a1108c01e1ff8a61", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/blocks.py": "b13e986cea5f1d7f325a1638c1505197b4a105baacff5a9a515f23fcaf28ea75", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/features.py": "3b34ae61cf8012ebd58b7505a73d7aa43d8ee1890ac54f98d7917b67887a45a4", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/network.py": "5137e845d81d1223afc13bf87e03ccba1132a3baa75d5189a8f320b2752be071", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/normalization.py": "7180696d3845799e28d8c31ddef957d075de6a2e46d96a3a0f0df16fc05234a0", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/objectives.py": "5b6527a45f08690055d572335470ce5979e8bb86e1cab00de594f79ae21316b1", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_pilot_train.py": "e9cceead51a5cc092aad23409ad98909c84a62e7e10571e750d1e9be1ad3b948", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_precision_continuation_guard.py": "01235d897c7c03e5ffa109c58b14f5d24d128e8f1ba873e1f76cfb14e02f7a7f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_gpu_supervisor.py": "689c0f3179e4fcd362e546d90214829a9e4f8739abdbdf74b560763e5a392f15", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_monitoring.py": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item_b.py": "bed8e21042971bb688b33c13903a28fab1772b980431a80afd205dbe4350dac2", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_common.py": "79918e7de887d1f0a2de5523156b27d00dc2d85ac930a07efc34d817d904fe65", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_prepare.py": "f657be036dc48fc5936f56c4b8510a4b295d4787af6877cc5ccaad663107be17", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_monitor.py": "4c423f8b0dff69304d0046c0a9c319bb31aa0c6d1cbaeb3942726b5e6caa0496", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_supervisor.py": "5ccb2a6eec95b0700b2063a2f8df414037528e90c206648c1c5e49c5e89e741d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_capacity.py": "771faad0095712fd4fc8131ddcfabaa3901141592d2b055ea2faadf8ea3d3edf", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_common.py": "4e25effe8326ff8c7c3f751590315040209af054b32b0505dc3c6b001589db32", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_guard.py": "08b7d8ab2ac773fab8b749f9f61af259254422128e9634f8b715c81efce2651f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_queue.py": "31dfd71369c63512c1d6fe176fd22e8db646520c92da533bb5530ca3843c388d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_schedule.py": "06cb97594c3a87f42f712dcde6cec8c2d90e0b50a89a6be7954bdd2f5c18d5de", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_worker.py": "b781e56c519401bd38af6a522deb24506cba6993d2af008f85ea4e1715f1d9c6", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item1b.py": "c7bc9f3b7cf4137f52e1efad19dcb7045282d4e9a9c1aae50f066c9e488f7c01", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item1b.py": "b4d78f4384651711fe83ff00eb6719c6c61664699d801ecb34978b9546439da9", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_common.py": "4e85f5d211c4d3e2188422aa4c0cefa40dcfa14ef32e90894ed3412de1fd1d12", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_data.py": "fe3aa3e023f22f4fe55cd47e7ffa677b58f52a041867ac05620cbd329d913cb6", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_guard.py": "7144fa77ffe61a2a3c92c050234e370ef4dfeb0e31fafb419f752f969737ff1a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_loss.py": "79e291866bda300ecdc5577c62903d34abeec14f5cc36db05e346f9ffd64c24b", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_queue.py": "a04879cc0169ecb523a88360cddca1e234d91b3adbc20b3ec31d02461ed767eb", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_worker.py": "0f8f35e1422021b2a4f097c2e62267fb935fe4658fd0ee8ccd251609a4062ea7", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item_c.py": "782c415b1f536eb2b85aa2c9c4a9a0dc278f9b7134e8a83e2a6af8199396c53a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_common.py": "588c646101be0d50f505f9a12a1c98361aa3437c8c594eecb7321831f717a741", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_statistics.py": "188565801f6901d0192f79aec0889e632501e672a4149d76d1835efbb9b45447", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item_c.py": "3115aa9049974eac86657aa4cee7b5d716f6ee93268555cc86242029ebefce4c", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase2_h2_s2.py": "4235890fd194b7778e937f0be9245b964512df2c75d962ef703e3a988c5b8805", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_guard.py": "6bc7624b0cfe850591f77153cd2034eefdd62f7e63b93211ccdb87eb8aba346c", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_common.py": "308486507ae3589a0e6cc40565f6e60e6d2f63ae74c4d828bdacf33b3b8b8062", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_fixed_io.py": "ea17fdfc7508f3f980e3cdf69534b1eb8ceb8a8e469c32451b2d5e16d0ada575", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_worker.py": "37dfd75fff50b3d65f4ef37f4255536616582fe5f3d01155a0e037325ab5c7cd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_worker.py": "ecee04b183ef2b93b7b39a447d48c40a5843d3190e48d2d7eb4939811a5db9b0", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_prepare.py": "964fae13ac95e4de4dc50b3c0a80791d86349ce3a9f3c5a6e7dc3cf8ca041fad", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_prepare.py": "3a31af0766f628a80f38e0b7286beb11ca3109188eabc4adfdb2ecb0eef3dc27", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_queue.py": "d82dfb365956e08250758bb4c651a19fbecce92fe209072f5f8ed35970450735", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_launch.py": "480fac25dea5a2006bb84130a4b0a0b253b3040b2150a56c38eada62b2c259e6", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_guard.py": "ae94711adc17a7630f398e8d4120fa3cc8f60979a00122c4cd2dc364c382ced5", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/docs/phase2-h2-s2-execution-contract-2026-11-17.md": "1e8e5ef31650519737cd6cd247abc0bd04744dd93ffb013eff88866d42f03073" + } + }, + "binding_file_sha256": "e5b01d81f8bfee991dee9a2971f8048d77b6c15ab61e3de08b2f97385f413261", + "code_files": 69, + "source_files": 1300, + "local_git_files": 80, + "old_code_pins": { + "phase3-item-c-2026-11-18": 52, + "phase3-item-1b-2026-11-18": 60, + "phase3-seed1-v2-2026-11-18": 51, + "track-a-recovery-2026-11-18": 27 + }, + "shared_code_sha256": "7c07b0aaf1bc4e6a980d016defcac326c3bd871134d2583bb4dcd88bb34728f8", + "context_metadata_counts": { + "GEOMETRY_COMPLETE": 510, + "SCIENTIFIC_MISSING": 42 + }, + "context_join_rows": 552, + "historical_index_cases": 429, + "historical_index_resolution": "Original reused results retain source-local indices; case and hashes join correctly, original source results independently hash-verified", + "first_audit_failure": "audit-attempt1.txt; reviewer incorrectly required historical result index to equal current roster index", + "context_raw_array_values_read": false, + "training_and_validation_loop_ast": "Equal to original S2 after declared context-loader argument and per-fold cost-gate substitutions; original200epoch schedule unchanged", + "tests": { + "exit_code": 0, + "wall_seconds": 6.290130304987542, + "child_cpu_seconds": 6.210590999999999, + "log_sha256": "0d7985c40e8b70c1a576c39915cebde21467d3796ea949746368f49a8dca4654" + }, + "entry_state": { + "review.json": false, + "started.json": false, + "complete.json": false + }, + "scientific_execution": false, + "remote_raw_bytes_independently_checked": false +} diff --git a/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/review.json b/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/review.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5372ef2c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/review.json @@ -0,0 +1,113 @@ +{ + "reviewed_commit": "b2a9dfdc4a2c237416452ff6b4c32bdbf34e172e", + "contract_sha256": "df80f3b4bbb0d4ee285401ff50b40cfc6bfd06f3302abcd53b41f14a20a204de", + "implementation_proof_sha256": "0501275106a0698c9dac6f75554b570bb82f7d4640e76b84f51cf759a8bdadd2", + "comparison_contract_sha256": "06556bf1f7bd5a1a79451bd9eed47fc6ec027e7e06bc63c6f490a50dfbee6d20", + "code_sha256": { + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/freeze_g1_components.py": "d0cee60d95243ac2c59ef3f2244ba818315718c4e3d1895f2f9f064f1f7f5ecd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_models.py": "53b6fee8b700b9b982b06d29908ce2ce23e0c57512c46dbf74b2aade79e3ac3a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_gate_outcome_review.py": "915617aeb8292d03c654e637bc34a014c254fd178a773f135d1806c4b41372a8", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h1_worker_v2.py": "1543df85b615bb69b79bacd572074a7c77ae19dab110197601573a7e5805ed20", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_data.py": "7e03dd7a94e7bb43593277f183c222473d7cb7aaf2f60e53b45ab8d9499fcb09", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_model.py": "fab2470dd0654ca74c3b7d893f35ad1f3ae6c5c08ffe334ef6312cf6ec87892a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_pilot_worker.py": "14651ca402e6d02466d8afdb77bc9e62fb2e752f0c0c3d20d98593157d5ebe81", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_common.py": "38a29a34663a5d6310571eeff53b5d18a0355e51b9fa58a08033f64fa379a9df", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_home_freeze_io.py": "bf09204b85ed2a7038acdd202257f618474d1110a9d6d772f105a3ffb334d3ff", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_local_freeze_io.py": "60adf3382577613c5234f5cf30779336b9951b66e90c075cb7cd0adab9cc42dd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_residual_math.py": "ffbd9624dec79bdaabf95244fe87209055908f31a977e73ea4377045d6f8fe62", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_capacity.py": "3915da37ead45f42fe620cb89bc7394b576f8e113047a4ad78e1bae50ded120c", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_common.py": "d00069d2ca5a346d8260dfb1829bf941f3ea09ebd7d75c1fe377120b553e02d2", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_data.py": "74e35b6268462c999078383e49e551c9da2562390d22977414713811bab164b3", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_guard.py": "e95cd5126f403881aebe137ed3f00bb6173881eea15709952142cb51136ad699", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_model.py": "13000ce6eb7cccfbefdc1710e37a59412be0391ae820b243f0d8fe7a9be4e986", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_queue.py": "0c6f5c9bde84f28bfc829701d97701188f43ed59fa0c5286228ca325cf88235c", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_worker.py": "d49a5e6f900850aabacc5825168b6f886215aff8c494937bea2238539e58f652", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_v2_common.py": "25ca6be14027369393bd3616209b08f30e25892cccca83300483c5a116e8d75d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_shared_capacity.py": "7c07b0aaf1bc4e6a980d016defcac326c3bd871134d2583bb4dcd88bb34728f8", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item_b.py": "ac46c3c6d01d8023444d2f53f956d94d1d295ae95a3435f355c5c6e0f6ccd962", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_gpu_idle_gate.py": "e2b1613e7e6ea398a8d555220a9365a1ad998ab4ef4b2bf8ec7cc4e31f8b4b9f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_main_memory_guard.py": "e094f5443e11518efe9018215c11718a8e18aa462a977bf43e974b2d0b2aebb1", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/__init__.py": "a0fa1323d3553172da66c5d442c5fc4fcb0d5055c886c776928604550ea97609", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/attention.py": "7714adfccf6a0fc6b52a44aee3a50321a88898bf3d743680a1108c01e1ff8a61", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/blocks.py": "b13e986cea5f1d7f325a1638c1505197b4a105baacff5a9a515f23fcaf28ea75", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/features.py": "3b34ae61cf8012ebd58b7505a73d7aa43d8ee1890ac54f98d7917b67887a45a4", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/network.py": "5137e845d81d1223afc13bf87e03ccba1132a3baa75d5189a8f320b2752be071", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/normalization.py": "7180696d3845799e28d8c31ddef957d075de6a2e46d96a3a0f0df16fc05234a0", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/objectives.py": "5b6527a45f08690055d572335470ce5979e8bb86e1cab00de594f79ae21316b1", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_pilot_train.py": "e9cceead51a5cc092aad23409ad98909c84a62e7e10571e750d1e9be1ad3b948", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_precision_continuation_guard.py": "01235d897c7c03e5ffa109c58b14f5d24d128e8f1ba873e1f76cfb14e02f7a7f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_gpu_supervisor.py": "689c0f3179e4fcd362e546d90214829a9e4f8739abdbdf74b560763e5a392f15", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_monitoring.py": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item_b.py": "bed8e21042971bb688b33c13903a28fab1772b980431a80afd205dbe4350dac2", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_common.py": "79918e7de887d1f0a2de5523156b27d00dc2d85ac930a07efc34d817d904fe65", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_prepare.py": "f657be036dc48fc5936f56c4b8510a4b295d4787af6877cc5ccaad663107be17", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_monitor.py": "4c423f8b0dff69304d0046c0a9c319bb31aa0c6d1cbaeb3942726b5e6caa0496", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_supervisor.py": "5ccb2a6eec95b0700b2063a2f8df414037528e90c206648c1c5e49c5e89e741d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_capacity.py": "771faad0095712fd4fc8131ddcfabaa3901141592d2b055ea2faadf8ea3d3edf", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_common.py": "4e25effe8326ff8c7c3f751590315040209af054b32b0505dc3c6b001589db32", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_guard.py": "08b7d8ab2ac773fab8b749f9f61af259254422128e9634f8b715c81efce2651f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_queue.py": "31dfd71369c63512c1d6fe176fd22e8db646520c92da533bb5530ca3843c388d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_schedule.py": "06cb97594c3a87f42f712dcde6cec8c2d90e0b50a89a6be7954bdd2f5c18d5de", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_worker.py": "b781e56c519401bd38af6a522deb24506cba6993d2af008f85ea4e1715f1d9c6", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item1b.py": "c7bc9f3b7cf4137f52e1efad19dcb7045282d4e9a9c1aae50f066c9e488f7c01", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item1b.py": "b4d78f4384651711fe83ff00eb6719c6c61664699d801ecb34978b9546439da9", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_common.py": "4e85f5d211c4d3e2188422aa4c0cefa40dcfa14ef32e90894ed3412de1fd1d12", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_data.py": "fe3aa3e023f22f4fe55cd47e7ffa677b58f52a041867ac05620cbd329d913cb6", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_guard.py": "7144fa77ffe61a2a3c92c050234e370ef4dfeb0e31fafb419f752f969737ff1a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_loss.py": "79e291866bda300ecdc5577c62903d34abeec14f5cc36db05e346f9ffd64c24b", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_queue.py": "a04879cc0169ecb523a88360cddca1e234d91b3adbc20b3ec31d02461ed767eb", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_worker.py": "0f8f35e1422021b2a4f097c2e62267fb935fe4658fd0ee8ccd251609a4062ea7", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item_c.py": "782c415b1f536eb2b85aa2c9c4a9a0dc278f9b7134e8a83e2a6af8199396c53a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_common.py": "588c646101be0d50f505f9a12a1c98361aa3437c8c594eecb7321831f717a741", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_statistics.py": "188565801f6901d0192f79aec0889e632501e672a4149d76d1835efbb9b45447", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item_c.py": "3115aa9049974eac86657aa4cee7b5d716f6ee93268555cc86242029ebefce4c", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase2_h2_s2.py": "4235890fd194b7778e937f0be9245b964512df2c75d962ef703e3a988c5b8805", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_guard.py": "6bc7624b0cfe850591f77153cd2034eefdd62f7e63b93211ccdb87eb8aba346c", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_common.py": "308486507ae3589a0e6cc40565f6e60e6d2f63ae74c4d828bdacf33b3b8b8062", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_fixed_io.py": "ea17fdfc7508f3f980e3cdf69534b1eb8ceb8a8e469c32451b2d5e16d0ada575", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_worker.py": "37dfd75fff50b3d65f4ef37f4255536616582fe5f3d01155a0e037325ab5c7cd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_worker.py": "ecee04b183ef2b93b7b39a447d48c40a5843d3190e48d2d7eb4939811a5db9b0", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_prepare.py": "964fae13ac95e4de4dc50b3c0a80791d86349ce3a9f3c5a6e7dc3cf8ca041fad", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_prepare.py": "3a31af0766f628a80f38e0b7286beb11ca3109188eabc4adfdb2ecb0eef3dc27", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_queue.py": "d82dfb365956e08250758bb4c651a19fbecce92fe209072f5f8ed35970450735", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_launch.py": "480fac25dea5a2006bb84130a4b0a0b253b3040b2150a56c38eada62b2c259e6", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_guard.py": "ae94711adc17a7630f398e8d4120fa3cc8f60979a00122c4cd2dc364c382ced5", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/docs/phase2-h2-s2-execution-contract-2026-11-17.md": "1e8e5ef31650519737cd6cd247abc0bd04744dd93ffb013eff88866d42f03073" + }, + "verdict": "PASS", + "reviewer": "MeltAssist", + "scope": "Independent item b H2+B13-context five-fold200epoch training-entry review; no launch/postfit approval", + "evidence_sha256": "c762a1e578c3a1e6aad39b1bfa6ad1ac0d76668561bea4d61d3d8f223f495b33", + "audit_source_sha256": "5ce7c3131c3d89606eda2c2e5a83d6d35d7af2deb1cfa57b85f3d02590444229", + "findings": [], + "passed_checks": [ + "Exact69code/1300source/80local immutable Git files verified; c52+1b60+seed1 51+TrackA27 code pins unchanged.", + "Moldde120e9d: original19features plus2 B13 means and1 joint-valid flag. Original H2 constructed first, encoder/head each append192 zero weights,384total, same shared parameters and RNG state. Synthetic nonzero-readout function equivalence and original train_step new-column learnability pass.", + "Original nineteen-column normalization unchanged; new mean/population scale over valid learning nodes only with unit-node weighting; zero variance scale1, no valid nodes stops. Invalid both columns zero AFTER normalization plus flag0; valid mean stillflag1.", + "Partial/asymmetric missingness, infinity, bad shape or historical status mismatch stops; original role guard precedes context reads. No new partition, K, geometry or labels.", + "All552 context entries independently joined to original E1b manifests/reuse/source by case, node/feature/rawID/geometry/query metadata and opaque hashes; historical510GEOMETRY_COMPLETE+42SCIENTIFIC_MISSING retained.", + "Original seed0/200epochs/MSE/AdamW/weight decay/clipping/cF/part order retained. Training and every10epoch diagnostic loop AST equals original S2 after declared context-loader argument and per-fold cost-gate changes. Final guard requires200 completeepochs and exact steps.", + "Shared adapter changes only b key/cap178200/GPU0..2; exact reviewed shared code hash7c07b0aa and unchanged functions. Existing pending/RESERVED/GUARD_BOUND/CPU/memory rules remain.", + "178200 includes7200post GPU/3600CPU reserve,prep600/setup/waiting/failures; remaining200epochs+20diagnostics multiplied1.5 pluscleanup;60000onlyactual runaway, totalprojection stop. Phase3reservations711581.3159993868<=720000;TrackA separate.", + "Complete five models freeze before TRAIN_COMPLETE_POSTFIT_PENDING; no automatic prediction/scoring, no retries, failed-worker peaks and freeze-tail charges preserved. Separate future pre-score review and actual worker exit/final-account gates required.", + "Comparison retains552parts/204components,equal components,paired2000bootstrap seed2026111408,95CI upperdelta<-.001 and abs effect>abs matched seed difference; missing seed waits for judgement. Full corpus, validity-subgroup reports and limitations remain.", + "Independent29CPU synthetic tests PASS; full childCPU6.210591s. Production scientific arrays/labels/model values never decoded." + ], + "tests": { + "exit_code": 0, + "wall_seconds": 6.290130304987542, + "child_cpu_seconds": 6.210590999999999, + "log_sha256": "0d7985c40e8b70c1a576c39915cebde21467d3796ea949746368f49a8dca4654" + }, + "limitations": [ + "This PASS is bound onlyb2a9dfdc/df80f3b4 and full69code map. No c/1b entry PASS reused.", + "552context values were not numerically decoded;510/42 are historical metadata states. Runtime array validity and identity checks remain necessary.", + "429immutable results retain original local indices after roster reuse. Initial reviewer audit wrongly asserted index equality, failed before tests, and is preserved in audit-attempt1.txt. Corrected case/hash join traces all429 to original hashed sources; no production defect or edit.", + "Author28-test run did not catch copied guard100epoch condition; author corrected to200 before freeze and added29th assertion. Both logs remain; fixed source and new assertion independently checked.", + "Tests use tiny synthetic CPU networks/arrays and fake queue/registry fixtures only. No real scientific training, GPU query, label decode, live registry/source/Git edits.", + "No fresh-family claim, no pure spatial attribution if gains concentrate on missing-context pieces, no flow-conservation claim and no closure of O1/type/connectivity hypotheses. Uncached partition runtime remains unmeasured.", + "Actual shared-card memory/timing and capacity availability remain runtime checks, not established by entry PASS. This review does not override pending-queue launch holds or executor handover.", + "Postfit implementation and final seed-reference/statistical gates are not executed or reviewed here.", + "Publication31a20abd differs from implementationb2a9dfdc; local Git bytes independently checked, no independent remote raw-byte readback claim." + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/synthetic-tests.log b/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/synthetic-tests.log new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c5284c657 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/synthetic-tests.log @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +test_actual_runaway_stops (tools.test_phase3_item_b.BudgetTests) ... ok +test_incomplete_history_rejected (tools.test_phase3_item_b.BudgetTests) ... ok +test_initial_budget_includes_postfit (tools.test_phase3_item_b.BudgetTests) ... ok +test_late_validation_max_used (tools.test_phase3_item_b.BudgetTests) ... ok +test_no_single_fold_projection_gate (tools.test_phase3_item_b.BudgetTests) ... ok +test_remaining_validation_charged (tools.test_phase3_item_b.BudgetTests) ... ok +test_all_learning_invalid_stops (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok +test_infinity_or_wrong_shape_stops (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok +test_joint_missing_is_zero_after_normalization (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok +test_learning_only_iteration (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok +test_original_role_guard_precedes_context_read (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok +test_partial_missing_stops (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok +test_status_mismatch_not_scientific_missing (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok +test_unit_node_moments_not_equal_part_means (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok +test_valid_mean_still_has_flag (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok +test_zero_variance_scale_one (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ContextTests) ... ok +test_all_shared_parameters_and_rng_match (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ModelTests) ... ok +test_exactly384_additional_parameters (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ModelTests) ... ok +test_guard_accepts_only_complete200_epoch_identity (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ModelTests) ... ok +test_new_columns_can_learn_without_changing_recipe (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ModelTests) ... ok +test_nonzero_readout_still_matches_original_initial_function (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ModelTests) ... ok +test_worker_uses_original200_recipe (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ModelTests) ... ok +test_wrong_input_columns_rejected (tools.test_phase3_item_b.ModelTests) ... ok +test_failure_no_retry_or_test (tools.test_phase3_item_b.QueueTests) ... ok +test_five_fits_stop_before_postfit (tools.test_phase3_item_b.QueueTests) ... ok +test_mixed_pending_c_reservation_blocks_b (tools.test_phase3_item_b.SharedWrapperTests) ... ok +test_mixed_two_visible_allows_only_one_new (tools.test_phase3_item_b.SharedWrapperTests) ... ok +test_shared_c_and_b_registration_independent (tools.test_phase3_item_b.SharedWrapperTests) ... ok +test_wrapper_changes_only_key_cap_gpu_set (tools.test_phase3_item_b.SharedWrapperTests) ... ok + +---------------------------------------------------------------------- +Ran 29 tests in 1.485s + +OK diff --git a/artifacts/phase3-item-b-review-adoption-2026-11-18/review-adoption.json b/artifacts/phase3-item-b-review-adoption-2026-11-18/review-adoption.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d8687bba7 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/phase3-item-b-review-adoption-2026-11-18/review-adoption.json @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +{ + "status": "PASS", + "scope": "independent training-entry review adopted", + "review_sha256": "8360e3f2f88d89fb39786c10e2185f1a04ae696b9e455350fed3a2ba4ceedf1a", + "binding_sha256": "e5b01d81f8bfee991dee9a2971f8048d77b6c15ab61e3de08b2f97385f413261", + "review_freeze": "584d2937bbdaf6aacc6b9c064ddf643a8a89b4c6", + "implementation": "b2a9dfdc4a2c237416452ff6b4c32bdbf34e172e", + "code_pins": 69, + "source_pins": 1300, + "reviewed_by": "MeltAssist", + "adopted_by": "NewMeltAssist", + "claude_acceptance": "1795012816.911319", + "reviewer_delivery": "1795012797.621519", + "slack_handover_confirmation": "1795013045.173339", + "started": false, + "postfit_started": false, + "unix": 1795013137.986224 +} diff --git a/home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/implementation-review-authorization.json b/home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/implementation-review-authorization.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6254d1945 --- /dev/null +++ b/home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/implementation-review-authorization.json @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +{ + "contract_sha256": "df80f3b4bbb0d4ee285401ff50b40cfc6bfd06f3302abcd53b41f14a20a204de", + "proof_sha256": "039291ee8c43ba14495df526ef191a0bc3c39a43d1cbd74e7150d81a20c73109" +} diff --git a/home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/implementation-review-git-freeze.json b/home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/implementation-review-git-freeze.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6add55c7f --- /dev/null +++ b/home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/implementation-review-git-freeze.json @@ -0,0 +1,25 @@ +{ + "commit": "584d2937bbdaf6aacc6b9c064ddf643a8a89b4c6", + "files": { + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/contract.json": "df80f3b4bbb0d4ee285401ff50b40cfc6bfd06f3302abcd53b41f14a20a204de", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/expected-review-binding.json": "e5b01d81f8bfee991dee9a2971f8048d77b6c15ab61e3de08b2f97385f413261", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/review.json": "8360e3f2f88d89fb39786c10e2185f1a04ae696b9e455350fed3a2ba4ceedf1a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/review.json": "8360e3f2f88d89fb39786c10e2185f1a04ae696b9e455350fed3a2ba4ceedf1a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json": "c762a1e578c3a1e6aad39b1bfa6ad1ac0d76668561bea4d61d3d8f223f495b33", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit.py": "5ce7c3131c3d89606eda2c2e5a83d6d35d7af2deb1cfa57b85f3d02590444229", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/synthetic-tests.log": "0d7985c40e8b70c1a576c39915cebde21467d3796ea949746368f49a8dca4654", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit-attempt1.txt": "7ecdad9db43752087e6df86c9cf63c9bd1c30bcd8cf314c0ace9ec873e1d851b" + }, + "git_paths": { + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/contract.json": "home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/contract.json", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/expected-review-binding.json": "home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/expected-review-binding.json", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/review.json": "home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/review.json", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/review.json": "artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/review.json", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json": "artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit.py": "artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit.py", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/synthetic-tests.log": "artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/synthetic-tests.log", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit-attempt1.txt": "artifacts/meltassist-item-b-entry-review-2026-11-18/audit-attempt1.txt" + }, + "remote_published": false, + "local_repository": "/tmp/meltmind-phase2-local-fixed-20261117" +} diff --git a/home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/review.json b/home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/review.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5372ef2c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/home-runs/phase3-item-b-2026-11-18/review.json @@ -0,0 +1,113 @@ +{ + "reviewed_commit": "b2a9dfdc4a2c237416452ff6b4c32bdbf34e172e", + "contract_sha256": "df80f3b4bbb0d4ee285401ff50b40cfc6bfd06f3302abcd53b41f14a20a204de", + "implementation_proof_sha256": "0501275106a0698c9dac6f75554b570bb82f7d4640e76b84f51cf759a8bdadd2", + "comparison_contract_sha256": "06556bf1f7bd5a1a79451bd9eed47fc6ec027e7e06bc63c6f490a50dfbee6d20", + "code_sha256": { + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/freeze_g1_components.py": "d0cee60d95243ac2c59ef3f2244ba818315718c4e3d1895f2f9f064f1f7f5ecd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_models.py": "53b6fee8b700b9b982b06d29908ce2ce23e0c57512c46dbf74b2aade79e3ac3a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_gate_outcome_review.py": "915617aeb8292d03c654e637bc34a014c254fd178a773f135d1806c4b41372a8", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h1_worker_v2.py": "1543df85b615bb69b79bacd572074a7c77ae19dab110197601573a7e5805ed20", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_data.py": "7e03dd7a94e7bb43593277f183c222473d7cb7aaf2f60e53b45ab8d9499fcb09", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_model.py": "fab2470dd0654ca74c3b7d893f35ad1f3ae6c5c08ffe334ef6312cf6ec87892a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_pilot_worker.py": "14651ca402e6d02466d8afdb77bc9e62fb2e752f0c0c3d20d98593157d5ebe81", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_common.py": "38a29a34663a5d6310571eeff53b5d18a0355e51b9fa58a08033f64fa379a9df", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_home_freeze_io.py": "bf09204b85ed2a7038acdd202257f618474d1110a9d6d772f105a3ffb334d3ff", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_local_freeze_io.py": "60adf3382577613c5234f5cf30779336b9951b66e90c075cb7cd0adab9cc42dd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_residual_math.py": "ffbd9624dec79bdaabf95244fe87209055908f31a977e73ea4377045d6f8fe62", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_capacity.py": "3915da37ead45f42fe620cb89bc7394b576f8e113047a4ad78e1bae50ded120c", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_common.py": "d00069d2ca5a346d8260dfb1829bf941f3ea09ebd7d75c1fe377120b553e02d2", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_data.py": "74e35b6268462c999078383e49e551c9da2562390d22977414713811bab164b3", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_guard.py": "e95cd5126f403881aebe137ed3f00bb6173881eea15709952142cb51136ad699", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_model.py": "13000ce6eb7cccfbefdc1710e37a59412be0391ae820b243f0d8fe7a9be4e986", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_queue.py": "0c6f5c9bde84f28bfc829701d97701188f43ed59fa0c5286228ca325cf88235c", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_b_worker.py": "d49a5e6f900850aabacc5825168b6f886215aff8c494937bea2238539e58f652", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_v2_common.py": "25ca6be14027369393bd3616209b08f30e25892cccca83300483c5a116e8d75d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_shared_capacity.py": "7c07b0aaf1bc4e6a980d016defcac326c3bd871134d2583bb4dcd88bb34728f8", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item_b.py": "ac46c3c6d01d8023444d2f53f956d94d1d295ae95a3435f355c5c6e0f6ccd962", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_gpu_idle_gate.py": "e2b1613e7e6ea398a8d555220a9365a1ad998ab4ef4b2bf8ec7cc4e31f8b4b9f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_main_memory_guard.py": "e094f5443e11518efe9018215c11718a8e18aa462a977bf43e974b2d0b2aebb1", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/__init__.py": "a0fa1323d3553172da66c5d442c5fc4fcb0d5055c886c776928604550ea97609", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/attention.py": "7714adfccf6a0fc6b52a44aee3a50321a88898bf3d743680a1108c01e1ff8a61", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/blocks.py": "b13e986cea5f1d7f325a1638c1505197b4a105baacff5a9a515f23fcaf28ea75", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/features.py": "3b34ae61cf8012ebd58b7505a73d7aa43d8ee1890ac54f98d7917b67887a45a4", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/network.py": "5137e845d81d1223afc13bf87e03ccba1132a3baa75d5189a8f320b2752be071", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/normalization.py": "7180696d3845799e28d8c31ddef957d075de6a2e46d96a3a0f0df16fc05234a0", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/objectives.py": "5b6527a45f08690055d572335470ce5979e8bb86e1cab00de594f79ae21316b1", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_pilot_train.py": "e9cceead51a5cc092aad23409ad98909c84a62e7e10571e750d1e9be1ad3b948", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_precision_continuation_guard.py": "01235d897c7c03e5ffa109c58b14f5d24d128e8f1ba873e1f76cfb14e02f7a7f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_gpu_supervisor.py": "689c0f3179e4fcd362e546d90214829a9e4f8739abdbdf74b560763e5a392f15", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_monitoring.py": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item_b.py": "bed8e21042971bb688b33c13903a28fab1772b980431a80afd205dbe4350dac2", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_common.py": "79918e7de887d1f0a2de5523156b27d00dc2d85ac930a07efc34d817d904fe65", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_prepare.py": "f657be036dc48fc5936f56c4b8510a4b295d4787af6877cc5ccaad663107be17", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_monitor.py": "4c423f8b0dff69304d0046c0a9c319bb31aa0c6d1cbaeb3942726b5e6caa0496", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_supervisor.py": "5ccb2a6eec95b0700b2063a2f8df414037528e90c206648c1c5e49c5e89e741d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_capacity.py": "771faad0095712fd4fc8131ddcfabaa3901141592d2b055ea2faadf8ea3d3edf", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_common.py": "4e25effe8326ff8c7c3f751590315040209af054b32b0505dc3c6b001589db32", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_guard.py": "08b7d8ab2ac773fab8b749f9f61af259254422128e9634f8b715c81efce2651f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_queue.py": "31dfd71369c63512c1d6fe176fd22e8db646520c92da533bb5530ca3843c388d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_schedule.py": "06cb97594c3a87f42f712dcde6cec8c2d90e0b50a89a6be7954bdd2f5c18d5de", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item1b_worker.py": "b781e56c519401bd38af6a522deb24506cba6993d2af008f85ea4e1715f1d9c6", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item1b.py": "c7bc9f3b7cf4137f52e1efad19dcb7045282d4e9a9c1aae50f066c9e488f7c01", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item1b.py": "b4d78f4384651711fe83ff00eb6719c6c61664699d801ecb34978b9546439da9", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_common.py": "4e85f5d211c4d3e2188422aa4c0cefa40dcfa14ef32e90894ed3412de1fd1d12", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_data.py": "fe3aa3e023f22f4fe55cd47e7ffa677b58f52a041867ac05620cbd329d913cb6", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_guard.py": "7144fa77ffe61a2a3c92c050234e370ef4dfeb0e31fafb419f752f969737ff1a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_loss.py": "79e291866bda300ecdc5577c62903d34abeec14f5cc36db05e346f9ffd64c24b", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_queue.py": "a04879cc0169ecb523a88360cddca1e234d91b3adbc20b3ec31d02461ed767eb", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_item_c_worker.py": "0f8f35e1422021b2a4f097c2e62267fb935fe4658fd0ee8ccd251609a4062ea7", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_item_c.py": "782c415b1f536eb2b85aa2c9c4a9a0dc278f9b7134e8a83e2a6af8199396c53a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_common.py": "588c646101be0d50f505f9a12a1c98361aa3437c8c594eecb7321831f717a741", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_statistics.py": "188565801f6901d0192f79aec0889e632501e672a4149d76d1835efbb9b45447", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_item_c.py": "3115aa9049974eac86657aa4cee7b5d716f6ee93268555cc86242029ebefce4c", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase2_h2_s2.py": "4235890fd194b7778e937f0be9245b964512df2c75d962ef703e3a988c5b8805", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_guard.py": "6bc7624b0cfe850591f77153cd2034eefdd62f7e63b93211ccdb87eb8aba346c", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_common.py": "308486507ae3589a0e6cc40565f6e60e6d2f63ae74c4d828bdacf33b3b8b8062", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_fixed_io.py": "ea17fdfc7508f3f980e3cdf69534b1eb8ceb8a8e469c32451b2d5e16d0ada575", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_worker.py": "37dfd75fff50b3d65f4ef37f4255536616582fe5f3d01155a0e037325ab5c7cd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_worker.py": "ecee04b183ef2b93b7b39a447d48c40a5843d3190e48d2d7eb4939811a5db9b0", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_prepare.py": "964fae13ac95e4de4dc50b3c0a80791d86349ce3a9f3c5a6e7dc3cf8ca041fad", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_prepare.py": "3a31af0766f628a80f38e0b7286beb11ca3109188eabc4adfdb2ecb0eef3dc27", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_queue.py": "d82dfb365956e08250758bb4c651a19fbecce92fe209072f5f8ed35970450735", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_launch.py": "480fac25dea5a2006bb84130a4b0a0b253b3040b2150a56c38eada62b2c259e6", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_guard.py": "ae94711adc17a7630f398e8d4120fa3cc8f60979a00122c4cd2dc364c382ced5", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/docs/phase2-h2-s2-execution-contract-2026-11-17.md": "1e8e5ef31650519737cd6cd247abc0bd04744dd93ffb013eff88866d42f03073" + }, + "verdict": "PASS", + "reviewer": "MeltAssist", + "scope": "Independent item b H2+B13-context five-fold200epoch training-entry review; no launch/postfit approval", + "evidence_sha256": "c762a1e578c3a1e6aad39b1bfa6ad1ac0d76668561bea4d61d3d8f223f495b33", + "audit_source_sha256": "5ce7c3131c3d89606eda2c2e5a83d6d35d7af2deb1cfa57b85f3d02590444229", + "findings": [], + "passed_checks": [ + "Exact69code/1300source/80local immutable Git files verified; c52+1b60+seed1 51+TrackA27 code pins unchanged.", + "Moldde120e9d: original19features plus2 B13 means and1 joint-valid flag. Original H2 constructed first, encoder/head each append192 zero weights,384total, same shared parameters and RNG state. Synthetic nonzero-readout function equivalence and original train_step new-column learnability pass.", + "Original nineteen-column normalization unchanged; new mean/population scale over valid learning nodes only with unit-node weighting; zero variance scale1, no valid nodes stops. Invalid both columns zero AFTER normalization plus flag0; valid mean stillflag1.", + "Partial/asymmetric missingness, infinity, bad shape or historical status mismatch stops; original role guard precedes context reads. No new partition, K, geometry or labels.", + "All552 context entries independently joined to original E1b manifests/reuse/source by case, node/feature/rawID/geometry/query metadata and opaque hashes; historical510GEOMETRY_COMPLETE+42SCIENTIFIC_MISSING retained.", + "Original seed0/200epochs/MSE/AdamW/weight decay/clipping/cF/part order retained. Training and every10epoch diagnostic loop AST equals original S2 after declared context-loader argument and per-fold cost-gate changes. Final guard requires200 completeepochs and exact steps.", + "Shared adapter changes only b key/cap178200/GPU0..2; exact reviewed shared code hash7c07b0aa and unchanged functions. Existing pending/RESERVED/GUARD_BOUND/CPU/memory rules remain.", + "178200 includes7200post GPU/3600CPU reserve,prep600/setup/waiting/failures; remaining200epochs+20diagnostics multiplied1.5 pluscleanup;60000onlyactual runaway, totalprojection stop. Phase3reservations711581.3159993868<=720000;TrackA separate.", + "Complete five models freeze before TRAIN_COMPLETE_POSTFIT_PENDING; no automatic prediction/scoring, no retries, failed-worker peaks and freeze-tail charges preserved. Separate future pre-score review and actual worker exit/final-account gates required.", + "Comparison retains552parts/204components,equal components,paired2000bootstrap seed2026111408,95CI upperdelta<-.001 and abs effect>abs matched seed difference; missing seed waits for judgement. Full corpus, validity-subgroup reports and limitations remain.", + "Independent29CPU synthetic tests PASS; full childCPU6.210591s. Production scientific arrays/labels/model values never decoded." + ], + "tests": { + "exit_code": 0, + "wall_seconds": 6.290130304987542, + "child_cpu_seconds": 6.210590999999999, + "log_sha256": "0d7985c40e8b70c1a576c39915cebde21467d3796ea949746368f49a8dca4654" + }, + "limitations": [ + "This PASS is bound onlyb2a9dfdc/df80f3b4 and full69code map. No c/1b entry PASS reused.", + "552context values were not numerically decoded;510/42 are historical metadata states. Runtime array validity and identity checks remain necessary.", + "429immutable results retain original local indices after roster reuse. Initial reviewer audit wrongly asserted index equality, failed before tests, and is preserved in audit-attempt1.txt. Corrected case/hash join traces all429 to original hashed sources; no production defect or edit.", + "Author28-test run did not catch copied guard100epoch condition; author corrected to200 before freeze and added29th assertion. Both logs remain; fixed source and new assertion independently checked.", + "Tests use tiny synthetic CPU networks/arrays and fake queue/registry fixtures only. No real scientific training, GPU query, label decode, live registry/source/Git edits.", + "No fresh-family claim, no pure spatial attribution if gains concentrate on missing-context pieces, no flow-conservation claim and no closure of O1/type/connectivity hypotheses. Uncached partition runtime remains unmeasured.", + "Actual shared-card memory/timing and capacity availability remain runtime checks, not established by entry PASS. This review does not override pending-queue launch holds or executor handover.", + "Postfit implementation and final seed-reference/statistical gates are not executed or reviewed here.", + "Publication31a20abd differs from implementationb2a9dfdc; local Git bytes independently checked, no independent remote raw-byte readback claim." + ] +}