Files
MeltMind/artifacts/s2-g1-components-2026-11-15/public/comparison.csv
T

11 KiB

1anonymous_pair_idagreementadjudication_statusmold_relationmold_local_evidencemold_resolvablemold_unresolved_reasonmold_reviewermold_review_versionclaude_relationclaude_local_evidenceclaude_resolvableclaude_unresolved_reasonclaude_reviewerclaude_review_versionfinal_action
26b6cd06df461493a0ecaf202f77f7ea6TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated圆杆左端面呈圆形,右件端面是宽厚约 2:1 的矩形。轴向长度约为 177.8 与 304.8。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedslender bar vs slender bar; Rg ~49 vs ~90, surface area 3569 vs 11774, cross-section aspect 2.26:2.13 vs 4.75:2.77 (non-uniform); generic bar shape onlyyesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
34a0cceebed4d9cad24528d72421a0b19TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated两件都是薄板。左板长边上有中点孔并带圆角,右板周缘的八孔分布不同。长度约 265 与 140,厚度却均约 3.18。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedflat perforated plates, same thickness 3.27/3.26 but in-plane 268x189 vs 141x103 and chi -12 vs -14 (hole count differs)yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
44d7ca9a4efa1441781a22a52205cef26TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左件端部有缩径凸台和环形肩,右件是平端直圆柱。两件长约 53.82 与 41.50。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedPCA envelope 53.8x13.7x13.6 vs 41.5x10.2x10.0; size ratio 1.30/1.35/1.36 (not rigid, not exactly uniform scale); area 2513 vs 1459yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
57cc6ea12077d363b86faae435cb66988TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左件端视能沿轴看到贯通的管腔;右件有封闭的多边形端面,一端另有细杆段。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedslender parts with different topology (chi 0 vs 2) and Rg ~55 vs ~118yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
66e0d33ac7dfd2eb98ac9bb199b4dd468TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左件是连续实心扁条。右件有长中央穿槽,两端另有横槽。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedRg ~69 vs ~360, chi 2 vs -8, area 16690 vs 328695yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
7698ca7b7d9899110ae75d242ccba5380TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左件截面是实心矩形;右件截面侧壁有相对的纵向凹槽,条身还有局部开孔迹象。仅截面差异即足以区分。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedsimilar long-bar envelope (Rg ~273 vs ~285) but chi 2 vs -48 (many through-holes on right only), area 61613 vs 45038yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
88cd7f7e79982dc333f874cda29dc37eaTrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左侧圆柱端部有环形台阶和端凸台,右侧为无肩平端圆杆;外径分别约 13.55 和 10。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedsame left envelope as pair 4d7ca9a4; envelope 53.8x13.7x13.6 vs 41.6x10.2x10.0; non-uniform ratio 1.29/1.34/1.36yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
9ff914dd48333a929fd68d3e405498188TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左件端面为平直四边的矩形,宽约为厚的两倍。右件截面近圆形且有细端,长约 425。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedslender bars, Rg ~84 vs ~118, area 11774 vs 23139, cross-section 4.8:2.7 vs 3.9:3.5yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
10bdf377bd08b2c5170b0636837f8cb1e0TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左侧薄条面上沿长度可见三处穿孔;右侧较厚的直条具有连续的矩形截面。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedthin strip chi -4 (Rg ~36, third axis .38) vs solid bar chi 2 (Rg ~90)yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
11965b576758b64a76044eeba2e33bc431TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左件为单股光滑闭环,右件在环壁周向有密集重复开口,外跨度约 32 与 670。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedsmall flat ring part 10.8x10.1x.88 chi 0 vs large plate 222x219x15.8 chi -240; ~20x scale and topology differyesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
123058d0a6c2ca1a763191a43218edbbe8TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYUNRESOLVED两件的弯折、大小端眼及单面长凹槽高度对应,外长均约 108.5。左件大端眼在凹槽面明显扩口,右件同一端的孔壁保持较直;背面及小端眼相似。局部差异可辨,关系未决可辨局部改动,不能确认同件;几何不足以判明设计亲缘。MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1UNRESOLVEDtwo-eye cranked link, both chi -2; PCA envelope 108.50x25.05x11.15 vs 108.50x25.01x11.15 (equal to .05); area 5949 vs 6036 (1.5%); both webs show a pocket at width +-4; handedness (proper vs mirror) and the 1.5% area difference not resolvable from geometry at band resolution -> conservatively mergednohandedness/small-feature difference not resolvable; same envelope and pocketClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1MERGE_SAME_SIDE_LEAK_PROTECTION
13731fb76c6a44dced20b7632559c1bd90FalseCLAUDE_RULE_ADJUDICATION_PENDINGUNRESOLVED两件外径均约 16,中心孔与外圈相近,但平行端面间厚度约 1.875 与 2.250,无法经刚体运动消除此差值。局部差异可辨,关系未决可能是厚度变体;通用环形不足以证明共同母型。MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedflat washers, same OD 16.0 but thickness 1.92 vs 2.40 (25%) and ID ~8.30 vs ~7.91; different part dimensions (parametric variant, not same part)yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1MERGE_SAME_SIDE_LEAK_PROTECTION
148466a0cb2d9eae11be06c186f3c29c53TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左件是带侧向凹槽的长型材;右件端面近圆且无相应凹槽。轴长约 1000 与 279。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedlong bar chi -48 Rg ~287 vs plain bar chi 2 Rg ~77yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
1517f4a1b88d4a6590dec111e6c01f0b2cTrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左件是实心圆杆;右件宽厚不等、四角明确的矩形端面排除了相同截面。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedslender bars, Rg ~51 vs ~90, area 3569 vs 11774, non-uniform cross-sectionyesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
1636a763784b381de2029487902f68b419TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左件一端带局部缩径段,主段截面多边化,长约 425;右件是通体等径的短圆杆,长约 178。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedslender bars, Rg ~112 vs ~52, area 23139 vs 3569yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
17ccbe856ce0d8fc785bcc3ebed3888f1bTrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左侧薄带有三处沿轴线分布的孔,两个靠端的孔较大;右侧是较厚的连续矩形条。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedthin strip chi -4 vs solid bar chi 2; Rg ~35 vs ~90yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
185adfb2472990878108a970a7c4a517cdTrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左件端部缩径并形成同心肩和小凸台,右件平端无肩。原尺度长约 53.82 与 65。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedenvelope 53.8x13.7x13.6 vs 65.1x18.2x18.0; ratio 1.21/1.33/1.33 non-uniform; area 2513 vs 4182yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
19a7496efbdd612af87016938ca6c29b08FalseCLAUDE_RULE_ADJUDICATION_PENDINGUNRESOLVED两件都是无孔平板。左件四角方直,右件四角均圆化;厚度约 7.5 与 10.16,长宽也不一致。局部差异可辨,关系未决不是相同尺度的刚体副本;仅凭板形及圆角不能判明是否为设计变体。MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedrectangular plates ~175-179 x 80; thickness 7.7 vs 11.1; left sharp edges, right rounded/chamfered edges and cornersyesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1MERGE_SAME_SIDE_LEAK_PROTECTION
208de3e0e7c34ae03a8e987047556f6e27TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左件是宽厚约 4:1 的实心扁条,右件为实心细圆杆,两端截面明显不同。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedlong bar Rg ~273 vs short bar Rg ~50, area 61613 vs 1639yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
211ead5efb8eed037f8a15292213f1a799FalseCLAUDE_RULE_ADJUDICATION_PENDINGUNRESOLVED两件均有单一圆形中心孔和约 16 的外径;左环端面间厚度约 2.625,右环约 2.250。局部差异可辨,关系未决厚度改变可辨,通用垫圈外形不能区分同源改型和独立设计。MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedflat washers, same OD 16.0 but thickness 2.76 vs 2.40 (15%), ID ~8.01 vs ~7.91; parametric variant, not same partyesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1MERGE_SAME_SIDE_LEAK_PROTECTION
227d513fc054fbee26168e60ff01998015TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左板为四个角孔;右板为沿四边排布的八个孔。厚度相近而板面尺度明显不同。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedperforated plates, 89x60 vs 41x29 principal RMS, chi -6 vs -14yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
2319d0722f138d79c4e249e40118cb3e8fTrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左端面为宽 12.7、厚 6.35 的矩形,右端面近圆、直径约 6.35;相同的短向尺度不能使截面重合。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedslender bars, Rg ~84 vs ~52, area 11774 vs 3569yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
249276ecc84a7893c4a9ab94f7d729a24dTrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左板为宽面四角孔板,长约 420;右板长约 140,周边有八个分散的孔,安装孔布局不同。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedperforated plates, 120x88 vs 41x29 principal RMS, chi -6 vs -14, area 256705 vs 30026yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
25ea7aaf13e0653feec71f4e591122399dTrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左件是环壁有重复孔格的大环;右件是光滑闭合的小圆环。孔格在多方向的表面视图中均可见。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedlarge plate chi -240 vs small ring part chi 0; ~20x scaleyesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED
26f7279499523c69b7c9d2efb9128fcd00TrueCONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLYunrelated左件是长约 965 的矩形截面扁条,右件为长约 279 的圆截面细杆,端部轮廓不同。局部差异可辨MoldAstraMoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1unrelatedlong bar Rg ~273 vs bar Rg ~77; area 61613 vs 4114; cross-section 8.8:2.9 vs 1.6:1.6yesClaude (ClaudeWorker)band25-v1NO_ADDITIONAL_EDGE_BOTH_UNRELATED