Files
MeltMind/docs/phase3-item-c-tail-spec-reception-2026-11-18.md
T

23 lines
5.5 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# Item c second last-fill endpoint: specification received, paper only
MeltAstra actually read the complete8,440-byte MoldAstra specification from the supplied Drive file and verified SHA256 **05344bacd877de87cbde9eb18139ad124e6cd4a15659e3c469b655b3f5a3f521**. The byte-identical normative attachment is [Mold's full specification](../references/2026-11-18/phase3-item-c/mold-tail-volume-peak-stability-spec.md). This note receives it as a future item c contract input; it is not an implementation, executed metric, synthetic acceptance, scientific result, or launch authorization.
Sources actually read: [Claude1794965849.286219, h-244a0ea3](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1794965849286219), [Mold1794966055.620539](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1794966055620539), and Claude1794966057.622479's receipt acknowledgement. [Original Drive file](https://drive.google.com/file/d/14H0haFNWUwSS_4w4R-B9sqo_3MdiyyoA/view). Claude's acknowledgement is recorded as receipt, not a claim that an item c execution contract has already been approved. Links inside the specification to earlier drafts were not independently reread in this reception.
## Definitions to carry unchanged into the future contract
- Domain and measure: all unique nodes referenced by retained tetrahedra, aligned by raw ID; lumped mass m_i=Σ|K|/4, total M>0, w_i=m_i/M. Positive finite mass, same domain/mass/t_set/Rg in both arms. Query multiplicity must not be multiplied into mass to approximate this measure. This is the discrete lumped measure, not exact P1 interior superlevel volume.
- Time and tail: s=T/t_set, original decoded predictions unclipped; frozen values converted to FP64, exact equality for ties, no new quantization. True and predicted fields independently select the finalα=0.01 volume. Every node on a boundary plateau receives the same fractional membership; do not break that plateau by raw ID. Stable summation; remaining-mass correction only within10⁻¹² of the valid boundary, correction recorded; final tail-mass error≤10⁻¹², larger violations fail.
- Region metric: I=Σw_i min(a_i,b_i), E_tail=1−I/0.01=(Miss+False)/2. Miss and False are equal in exact arithmetic because both tails have equal volume, so retain both as interpretation/error-check columns, not two independent endpoints. Identical fractional tails yield zero; use min, not membership products. A constant true field uses a_i=α, remains in full-roster statistics and is explicitly marked constant_truth/no distinguishable late location. Report tie-platform volume and fractional coefficient.
- Reporting: original552 parts/204 components/five folds, paired c−H2(seed0), component-inner part mean then equal components;2000 paired component bootstrap, seed2026111408, shared resampling indices. E_tail is one secondary endpoint alongside the unchanged original query single-point metric and c decision. Report denominators, undefined reasons, constants and ties. Seed1 regional comparison only if full outputs exist; otherwise not computed. Claude5849 also specifies that seed1−seed0 is a practical screen, not proof that training randomness has been excluded.
- Diagnostics: separately on unique query IDs and all retained-tet nodes, compute same-domainε=max|s_pred−s_true| andγ=true peak minus largest true value farther thanr=0.10Rg. Peak ties use minimum raw ID. γ>2ε is sufficient for the predicted maximum to lie withinr; equality does not pass, failure does not prove wrong-branch error, and average L2 cannot replaceε. Empty exterior givesγ=+∞ and trivial_radius=true. For finiteγ, mark near_boundary when|γ−2ε|≤64u·max(1,max|s_true|,max|s_pred|,2ε), retaining the strict comparison and interpreting it as uncertain at the boundary.
- Interpretation: report distance to the entire true peak set, and on the full domain to the true tail support, plus tie fractions and true-time drop at the predicted peak. Preserve exact-tie/near-peak/near-tail/far-tail categories and continuous E_tail, with no post-hoc small-error threshold. Euclidean proximity can cross thin walls and cannot alone identify a topological branch. ε uses observed labels and is a posthoc diagnostic, not a deployable uncertainty bound.
## Future implementation and cost obligations, not executed here
Retain complete full-node predictions and identities before the original authorized target/scoring stage. Query-only output cannot stand in for1% cavity volume. Additional full output storage, target access and sorting must fit item c's original budget projection. Per-part mass handling isO(N+N_tet), tail sortingO(N log N)/O(N) memory, other peak/error/set-distance scansO(N); no full pairwise-distance matrix or simultaneous full-corpus residency.
The normative attachment lists required synthetic cases: identical fields/fractional ties, disjoint tails, constant truth, one node heavier thanα, nonuniform mass, ID permutation, duplicate query records, zero remaining mass at threshold, strict certificate equality, and certificate-implies-radius. These are requirements only; no implementation or test was run. Finite-input/positive-denominator and missing-full-domain conditions must stay explicit, never replaced with a fabricated full-volume score.
Item1 training and its accepted postfit remain unchanged. Reception checked their26 and47 source pins without reading labels, model tensors or scientific arrays. No item c run, scoring amendment to item1, or new review gate is introduced. Receipt and provenance: `artifacts/phase3-item-c-tail-spec-reception-2026-11-18/receipt.json`.