Files
MeltMind/docs/claude/research-tree.md
T

8.2 KiB

MeltMind research tree (Claude maintains it, single writer; started 2026-11-17)

Method (Yanqi): explore many branches; none has to succeed. Each branch gets a cheap gate, learns something and is pruned or expanded. Every probe, counter-example and prune reason is kept here. Goal: state-of-the-art fill prediction.

Rules:

  • A branch starts with a gate: the cheapest test that could prune it (about 2 CPU-h or less, or existing outputs only). Gate criteria are written down before the run.
  • Statuses: OPEN, PROBING, PRUNED (with reason), PROMOTED (gets a contract), PARKED.
  • Every result records what we learned, even when the result is negative.
  • At most 2 promoted branches run at a time; gates can run in parallel on free cores.
  • Single writer per execution root (MeltAstra on Horsea). One review from Claude per contract.
ID Branch Gate (cheapest falsifier) Owner Status
B1 H1: residual on the eikonal volume map (t* - cF, same 19 features) full run is cheap (<= 20 CPU-h) spec Mold, run Melt PROMOTED
B2 H2: geometry-aware operator on the H1 target pilot <= 2 GPU-h with a cost gate spec MeltAssist, run Melt PROMOTED (after the B1 contract)
B3 Arrival-field topology: dry-region H0(-T) maxima and saddles as last-fill / front-meeting diagnostics on about 50 parts, compute the diagnostics from the true T and from the full-node EIK; check whether they are stable and whether EIK's critical points match the truth spec Mold, run Melt OPEN
B4 Filling as a filtration: one scalar potential plus a monotone time map oracle: the best per-part monotone map from the EIK potential to the true T; the remaining error is ordering error that no time map can fix Mold / Melt PRUNED (clock-only on a fixed potential cannot beat A)
B5 Sheet / paired-wall decomposition on real meshes scope a relaxed general-domain certificate on paper; then try 10 Greif parts and report coverage and false connections Mold, then Melt PARKED (coverage unknown: certifier complexity cap)
B6 Intrinsic coordinates (Laplace-Beltrami / spectral) as features 50 parts: does a spectral feature explain A's residual (partial correlation on the learning folds only)? MeltAssist lit, Melt run OPEN
B7 Order-aware objective (pairwise or rank loss) instead of pointwise L2 small GBRT ranker on one fold: Kendall tau and last-fill location against A MeltAssist / Melt OPEN
B8 Fresh hold-out from Greif v2 (42 parts, 40 new source tokens) read-only LOG/YML, field validity and near-duplicate check MeltAssist PARKED (missing process provenance: v2 ZIP has 723 VTU and 0 LOG/YML, so no t_set)
B9 Heat transfer / packing targets (cooling time, shrinkage) read-only inventory of v4/v5 fields MeltAssist DONE (inventory) → opens B10
B10 Freeze time / volumetric shrinkage as targets with the same Gre24-style pipeline (Yanqi: fill first, so low priority) gate: per-field validity (units, stage, mask) on 20 parts, then a Gre24-style GBRT on one fold against Gre24's reported medians (cooling about 0.095, shrinkage about 0.10) Melt / MeltAssist PARKED (priority)
B11 Topological cleaning of predicted fields: persistence simplification removes spurious extrema and saddles before the end-of-fill and event metrics gate: on the B3 panel, apply a fixed persistence threshold to EIK, and later to the A/H1 full-node predictions, and check event precision, last-fill distance and tau (learning folds only) Mold spec, Melt run OPEN
P1 O2 local tensor readings — — PRUNED (S1, S2, S3-A: no gain on the current recipe)
P2 Own graph flow-competition solver — — PRUNED (infeasible: splu resource stop, GMRES numerical failure; the idea itself is untested)
P3 O1 with size-matched K = 8 partitions — — PRUNED (eligibility 23 %; lesson: control cut area as a covariate, do not match it)

Log (newest first):

  • 2026-11-17: B5 PARKED (coverage unknown). On 10 learning parts, 5 had no candidate; on the other 5, the first candidate hit the fixed 70000-operation complexity cap and came out UNKNOWN. 0 certified and 0 rejected; only 5/10 parts have a certified union that is complete and below .20, short of the >= 6/10 threshold.
    • Learned: the relaxed paired-wall certifier is computationally infeasible on real Greif meshes at this cap. That is not a refutation of sheet decomposition.
    • Reopen only with a new certifier design (no cap extension under this gate). Cost 133.7 CPU-s. Commit 6aa7baf6.
  • 2026-11-17: B1 first-cell cost gate PASS (fit projection 3610 CPU-s); fits 01-04 running.
  • 2026-11-17: B3 result (50 learning components):
    • The true-field H0(-T) events are stable under recording-precision perturbation: precision/recall .954/.921 (0.001 grid) and .947/.915 (half grid), above the 0.80 gate.
    • EIK against the truth: 244 TP, 16956 FP, 416 FN, so precision .014 and recall .370; median match distance .049 Rg.
    • Learned: the eikonal field has a very large number of spurious topological events. This supports a stable diagnostic on this panel; it is not a weld-line validation.
    • New branch B11 (topological cleaning).
  • 2026-11-17: B4 PRUNED (clock-only). The post-hoc best monotone map of the fixed D_f potential gives a component-mean relative L2 of .0916, against A's .0664 on the same full-tet domain.
    • Learned (narrowed per MeltAstra): A is not a member of the family of monotone scalar clocks on this fixed D_f, so that family alone cannot explain A's advantage. It does not attribute the advantage solely to order changes.
    • This does not prune new potentials, branch information or learned ordering. Commit a6998f72; push pending.
  • 2026-11-17: B1 contract e751e5b2 approved. Branch decision rule (grouped protocol, 100 % pool, paired component bootstrap, signs as H1 - A):
    • EXPAND: upper bound of the relative-L2 difference < 0.001, and either the last-fill distance/Rg difference has its upper bound < 0 or the Kendall tau difference has its lower bound > 0.
    • PRUNE: lower bound of the relative-L2 difference > 0 and neither of those improves clearly.
    • PARK otherwise.
    • Topology metrics and v4 results are descriptive only.
    • B8/B9 publication fixed at 1153cd8c.
  • 2026-11-17: B9 full-library schema scan (MeltAssist; 1253/1253 files parsed, 0 failures, no numeric decoding). Freeze_time and shrinkage are present in every v4 and v5 part. Temperature, pressure, velocity and deflection are present in 621 of 629 v4 parts (the 8 missing ones are listed) and in all 624 v5 parts. Trajectories have 99 to 110 frames. v5 also carries cell residual stress. This shows the schema exists; the values have not yet passed any eligibility check. Opened B10 as PARKED, behind fill-time priority.
  • 2026-11-17: B8 PARKED (MeltAssist; 4 Range reads, 77,714 B). Reopen if the companion LOG/YML is obtained or the VTU carries equivalent pre-solve metadata. Narrower reopen path (Claude): the 42 parts may still serve as a fresh hold-out for scale-free metrics only (Kendall tau, last-fill location, H0(-T) events), which need no t_set. They then need only field validity and the near-duplicate check, not process provenance. Narrowed by MeltAssist: the models still need the gate as an input, through D_i, D_f and F. Scale-free scoring is therefore not gate-free inference. Without equivalent metadata in the VTU or an original gate source, reopening needs a separate task built only from the available fields; recovering the gate from the minimum of the true T would be label leakage.
  • 2026-11-17: MoldAstra B1 short spec + H0(-T) metric (Drive 1WHFdSP7…, SHA 91ecc62f…); one-page maths judgement (Drive 1I_H_UxU…: an order-preserving clock change cannot move ranking events; in a simplified constant-pressure counter-example, along-path loading gives a 4x fill-time difference that vanishes at constant flow); gate specs for B3/B4/B5 (Drive 1LUaoJn9…) approved as written. MeltAstra B1 contract draft 0a60f5d6 plus a one-page physics finding (gate reachability and early wet islands are more direct than wet-region H0 merges; the volume quantile is a shared progress variable, not the full hydraulic state). B3/B4/B5 move to PROBING once the B1 contract is frozen.
  • 2026-11-17: tree started; B1/B2 promoted on Yanqi's approval; B3-B9 opened.