59 lines
6.6 KiB
Markdown
59 lines
6.6 KiB
Markdown
# H2-S2 final results and executor handback — 2026-11-18
|
||
|
||
H2 is CONFIRMED on field error under the frozen pooled rule; last-filled-location error is worse than A. This is five-fold recipe confirmation after observing fold0, not an untouched-five-fold preregistration or a test isolating true connectivity. The original score and decision are unchanged.
|
||
|
||
## Stored five-fold result
|
||
|
||
552 parts / 204 equally weighted evaluation components; 2000 paired component bootstrap replicates, seed2026111408. Field and last/Rg lower is better; Kendall tau-b higher is better.
|
||
|
||
| Reference | Metric | H2 mean | Reference mean | H2 − reference | 95% CI |
|
||
|---|---|---:|---:|---:|---|
|
||
| A | relative_l2 | 0.065791907 | 0.070830541 | -0.005038634 | [-0.007536893, -0.002830534] |
|
||
| A | last_location | 0.456616842 | 0.376713808 | +0.079903034 | [+0.006940890, +0.155577284] |
|
||
| A | kendall_tau_b | 0.930128834 | 0.926649720 | +0.003479115 | [+0.001039504, +0.006226751] |
|
||
| B13_E1b | relative_l2 | 0.065791907 | 0.069702214 | -0.003910307 | [-0.006306713, -0.001644771] |
|
||
| B13_E1b | last_location | 0.456616842 | 0.387589688 | +0.069027155 | [+0.002026449, +0.134446230] |
|
||
| B13_E1b | kendall_tau_b | 0.930128834 | 0.928112244 | +0.002016590 | [-0.000203388, +0.004374493] |
|
||
|
||
Only pooled H2−A field CI upper<0 with complete552/204 support is the confirmation gate. B13/last/tau are reported outcomes. Negative predictions remain unclipped: **40,852 full-node / 665 unique-query nodes**. There are42 G-invalid parts; the complete roster is retained.
|
||
|
||
## Folds1–4 only: descriptive sensitivity table
|
||
|
||
These431 parts / 167 components exclude the already observed fold0. This additional aggregation uses only stored per-part metric scalars. It does not create a new confirmatory gate or rerun prediction/target scoring. The component-paired percentile intervals describe evaluation-family uncertainty, not initialization or learning-pool uncertainty.
|
||
|
||
| Scope | Parts / components | Metric | H2 | A | B13-E1b | H2 − A [95% CI] |
|
||
|---|---|---|---:|---:|---:|---|
|
||
| folds1–4 | 431 / 167 | relative_l2 | 0.065420477 | 0.070366829 | 0.069507228 | -0.004946352 [-0.007654256, -0.002482391] |
|
||
| folds1–4 | 431 / 167 | last_location | 0.428297978 | 0.355019700 | 0.362882224 | +0.073278277 [+0.003853634, +0.144415239] |
|
||
| folds1–4 | 431 / 167 | kendall_tau_b | 0.931609825 | 0.927874413 | 0.929205798 | +0.003735412 [+0.001028048, +0.006708727] |
|
||
| fold1 | 91 / 41 | relative_l2 | 0.065184002 | 0.068237407 | 0.068877591 | -0.003053405 [-0.008083001, +0.001877264] |
|
||
| fold1 | 91 / 41 | last_location | 0.422701937 | 0.369172459 | 0.346130733 | +0.053529479 [-0.057908574, +0.164094887] |
|
||
| fold1 | 91 / 41 | kendall_tau_b | 0.932850707 | 0.931022035 | 0.930128723 | +0.001828672 [-0.002471989, +0.006219912] |
|
||
| fold2 | 99 / 41 | relative_l2 | 0.066387316 | 0.073047736 | 0.070409577 | -0.006660420 [-0.010371051, -0.003071975] |
|
||
| fold2 | 99 / 41 | last_location | 0.493185845 | 0.377786625 | 0.392994129 | +0.115399220 [-0.017912771, +0.287285496] |
|
||
| fold2 | 99 / 41 | kendall_tau_b | 0.928807593 | 0.924209251 | 0.927113294 | +0.004598342 [+0.000720233, +0.008583173] |
|
||
| fold3 | 119 / 42 | relative_l2 | 0.064426254 | 0.067619224 | 0.066692168 | -0.003192970 [-0.008443514, +0.002218274] |
|
||
| fold3 | 119 / 42 | last_location | 0.414406747 | 0.328601580 | 0.365257217 | +0.085805167 [-0.108830846, +0.265556234] |
|
||
| fold3 | 119 / 42 | kendall_tau_b | 0.934189224 | 0.931064356 | 0.932806995 | +0.003124868 [-0.002796985, +0.008750355] |
|
||
| fold4 | 122 / 43 | relative_l2 | 0.065695185 | 0.072524702 | 0.071996795 | -0.006829517 [-0.014237604, -0.000585898] |
|
||
| fold4 | 122 / 43 | last_location | 0.385332089 | 0.345620957 | 0.347823464 | +0.039711132 [-0.062223681, +0.143465643] |
|
||
| fold4 | 122 / 43 | kendall_tau_b | 0.930579141 | 0.925252123 | 0.926803528 | +0.005327017 [-0.001767658, +0.014622626] |
|
||
|
||
Full comparisons against both references are in artifacts/phase2-h2-s2-terminal-report-2026-11-18/folds1to4-descriptive.json.
|
||
|
||
## Execution, audit and accounting
|
||
|
||
TRON started the already reviewed postfit once under Claude1794946447.294149 because MeltAstra was unreachable. Coordinator985167; implementation25e79995, contract0bd03f42, actual pre-score PASS9c163702. This exception did not allow source edits, retry, publication by TRON, or launching an unbuilt entry. MeltAstra resumes ownership here. No second S2 launch occurred.
|
||
|
||
Four new prediction guards plus one score guard PASS. Fold0 has121 exact original predictions/metrics reused; folds1–4 add431 predictions and431 existing target accesses. No new fit or decode. Models freezef033b454 → predictions freeze86480b4d → score-stage PASS validation → target access → terminal4b2a710d. Original result SHA256 c43a6ab2460affdcafd3d51522e7b5e2d60a684b2b1a79a90e06042b0e19bc45; complete 2a55287167daed3ff541210f0fb3f32b8971b70976329cf29ca81828cbf06685.
|
||
|
||
MeltAssist independent existing-evidence audit PASS, SHA256 d4999e4a99e82d91b793cffd70b673a977de022878e28d8a9955ca1a4acf59da, is included unchanged. It checked63 source pins/five binding fields,8 freezes/176 Git blobs,4 checkpoints,552 prediction hashes and121 exact reused rows. MeltAstra rechecked all662 audit-recorded current hashes and552 predictions. This is evidence verification, not independent scientific recomputation.
|
||
|
||
Audit limits: ordering is supported jointly by Git ancestry, fixed entry and receipts; target log is overwritten, not syscall-level tracing. CPU formula and worker lower bound agree with492.447055337s, but starting resource counters were not retained, preventing independent exact coordinator/reaped-child decomposition. Overwritten progress witnesses cannot all be rehashed historically; retained peak maxima/final results were checked. Current process absence cannot independently establish historical absence.
|
||
|
||
GPU ledger: oldS1 18858.214908715 + newfourfoldtraining79602.784961751 + prediction355.327867327 = **98816.327737793GPU-s /144000**. Final postfit CPU492.447055337 /3600s. Assist audit0.841653768CPU-s is separate; this report/aggregation cost is separately recorded in report-cost.json and does not rewrite the original ledger.
|
||
|
||
## Stage decision
|
||
|
||
Claude1794946961 triggers the frozen304f5771 phase3 plan. Next is item1 data-sufficiency e24fff7c,24GPUh within the new170GPUh plan, first-epoch projection and a new exact MeltAssist review. This report does not launch it. Later seed1/last-fill/context/ensemble remain future stages in the prescribed order. Gate-v2 outcome equivalence failed, so fresh-family admission remains closed. Scientific goal remains useful cross-part filling prediction; neither topology/local-type organisation nor connectivity is globally settled by this comparison.
|