research-tree: correct Adviser wording (not established, STL solve not ruled out)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
ClaudeandClaude Opus 5.5 committed 2026-11-19 14:48:16 +00:00
1 parent 8faadf9468
commit e2d5b58aec
1 file changed
+1 -1
+1 -1
View File
@@ -35,7 +35,7 @@ Rules:
Log (newest first):
- 2026-11-19: **H2-P on ShapeNet-611: H2_P_IMPROVEMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED (worse).** Combined entry PASS 1359ba98; three seeds, 100 epochs, matched budget, untuned direct pressure head, molding inputs removed; 111 targets read once per seed. H2-P 10.013 % vs reproduced GINO 7.435 %; pre-registered paired H2-P − GINO +2.578 pp, 95 % CI [+2.327, +2.849] over 111 single-part components (no family structure). Frozen result fcff9e9c (MeltSol); MeltAssist checked. **Reading:** on this pressure protocol, the H2 architecture as adapted is clearly worse than GINO. This is not weight transfer (trained from scratch) and says nothing about H2's Greif result; it is the planning ruling's 'H2-P behind GINO' branch. Stage review SR-20261119-2137 factual cutoff = this publication.
- 2026-11-19: **Moldflow Adviser data route CLOSED for per-node labels** (MeltWin on ARON: Adviser 2027 imports STL, no BDF; Grok, official docs: Adviser exports only .mfr for Communicator, API scripts unsupported; Communicator is a viewer with no documented per-node export; per-node XML export is Insight-only). The approved single local solve is withdrawn unused (0 solves, 0 credits). Data generation would need Insight/Synergy via another licence (question for Yanqi at the next stage report). **New lead instead (Grok):** the public Greif–Meyer corpus ships Moldflow LOG + inlet YML from v4 on, and a 196-case warpage set (Zenodo 17831586, Dec 2025; packing pressure removed, so late fill may differ, per TRON/Autodesk V/P docs). MeltSol checks overlap with our 552/204, v4/v5 LOG/YML coverage of B8 and the 94 sealed candidates, and per-case V/P switchover / end-of-fill / short-shot (metadata only). Pre-registered: a warpage case counts as same-process new-family holdout only if fill completes and switchover ≥ 99 %, with the post-switchover tail reported separately; otherwise 'transfer under changed process'.
- 2026-11-19: **Moldflow Adviser data route NOT ESTABLISHED for per-node labels (wording corrected 2026-11-19 22:47, RESET-20261119-2247: an STL-import solve is not ruled out; what was not established is direct import of the original BDF and a usable per-node export / ID mapping)** (MeltWin on ARON: Adviser 2027 imports STL, no BDF; Grok, official docs: Adviser exports only .mfr for Communicator, API scripts unsupported; Communicator is a viewer with no documented per-node export; per-node XML export is Insight-only). The approved single original-mesh local solve was not used (0 solves, 0 credits); MeltWin stays stood down. Data generation would need Insight/Synergy via another licence (question for Yanqi at the next stage report). **New lead instead (Grok):** the public Greif–Meyer corpus ships Moldflow LOG + inlet YML from v4 on, and a 196-case warpage set (Zenodo 17831586, Dec 2025; packing pressure removed, so late fill may differ, per TRON/Autodesk V/P docs). MeltSol checks overlap with our 552/204, v4/v5 LOG/YML coverage of B8 and the 94 sealed candidates, and per-case V/P switchover / end-of-fill / short-shot (metadata only). Pre-registered: a warpage case counts as same-process new-family holdout only if fill completes and switchover ≥ 99 %, with the post-switchover tail reported separately; otherwise 'transfer under changed process'.
- 2026-11-19: **Track B: GINO reproduced on ShapeNet-611 (pre-registered tolerance).** Identity: NeurIPS supplement code + 2-keyword patch (inp/outp_features → in/out_features; no variant accepting the old names found). Paper package, 500/111, 100 epochs, 64³, de-normalised per-part relative L2; each seed read the 111 held-out cars once after its frozen epoch-100 checkpoint. Seeds 0/1/2: 6.948 / 7.764 / 7.591 %; equal-weight mean 7.435 %, inside [6.62, 7.62] → REPRODUCED. 30,351.6 GPU-s (+ 222.8 stopped measurement). **Reading:** the baseline is usable for same-protocol comparison, but our mean is .31 pp above the paper's 7.12 % and seeds spread .82 pp (one seed alone is above the band), so any ranking must be seed-paired and multi-seed; single-seed comparisons against 7.12 % are not meaningful. Weights in private Drive with SHA read-back.
- 2026-11-19: **1b (100-epoch full schedule) SCREEN_FAIL; CLOSED.** Fold 0 validation, 111 parts / 35 components, component-weighted relative L2: 200-epoch seed 0 6.085 %; 100-epoch seed 0 5.936 % (−.149 pp, first gate passed); 200-epoch seed 1 5.877 % (−.208 pp vs seed 0). The schedule effect is smaller than the seed difference, so the second gate fails. One labelled recovery (GPU0 foreign occupant); final run guard STOP at exit, cause undetermined; outputs audited complete (MeltAssist e5cfba65; adoption criterion amended before values were seen, timing item dropped as attribution-only). 5,840.58 GPU-s + 741.16 stopped. **Reading:** no evidence that the shorter schedule helps beyond seed variation; item 1's overfitting signal is neither confirmed nor refuted. No further folds. Note: the phase-3 guard's exit race (snapshot vs process-list) remains a known limitation of this guard version; the GINO guard has the fix.
- 2026-11-19: **Shared-miss attribute study CLOSED** (descriptive; MoldAstra prereg d62b919e; deliveries 44c1d5a1 + 40f9e4ce; MeltAssist PASS 77639066-series: 7029a6e6 and combined 2930943d; 0 GPU-h, 109 CPU-s; true test-role fields read once under a bounded CPU-only scope, hypothesis-generating only). 34 shared-miss parts / 28 families vs 518 / 193 controls. **Only clear difference: A also misses** 17/34 vs 32/518 (family-weighted 41.1 % vs 6.7 %, +34.3 pp, family-block CI [17.0, 53.1]). Main tail fragments (1.29 vs 1.28), near-tie share (22.1 % vs 21.3 %) and weighted gate distance (2.72 vs 3.06 Rg) show no difference (CIs cross 0); single gate everywhere; wall thickness, physical branches and semantic type remain NA. **Reading:** the shared misses are largely parts that are hard for both model families; the true-tail geometry measures tried here do not explain them. Candidate explanations left (untested): missing inputs (thickness, process), label quality on those parts, part semantics. **Ruling:** close the study; no new last-fill loss; the 34-part list is kept as a named hard subset to report separately in future evaluations (Track B / new families). Any fix must be confirmed on data not used here.