Freeze H2-P paired verdict and SR-20261119-2137 executor review
This commit is contained in:
1 parent
18e0e7298f
commit
b33835a120
2 files changed
+136
No files matched your search
@@ -0,0 +1,123 @@
|
||||
{
|
||||
"stage_review": "SR-20261119-2137",
|
||||
"status": "FORMAL_PAIRED_RESULT_FROZEN",
|
||||
"frozen_beijing": "2026-11-19T21:45:20+08:00",
|
||||
"scope": "Preregistered aggregation from the six existing score records only",
|
||||
"result": {
|
||||
"identity": "H2-P",
|
||||
"seeds": {
|
||||
"0": {
|
||||
"fit": {
|
||||
"status": "COMPLETE",
|
||||
"trigger": null
|
||||
},
|
||||
"score": {
|
||||
"status": "COMPLETE",
|
||||
"trigger": null
|
||||
},
|
||||
"mean_percent": 9.780531195369926
|
||||
},
|
||||
"1": {
|
||||
"fit": {
|
||||
"status": "COMPLETE",
|
||||
"trigger": null
|
||||
},
|
||||
"score": {
|
||||
"status": "COMPLETE",
|
||||
"trigger": null
|
||||
},
|
||||
"mean_percent": 9.855662950792828
|
||||
},
|
||||
"2": {
|
||||
"fit": {
|
||||
"status": "COMPLETE",
|
||||
"trigger": null
|
||||
},
|
||||
"score": {
|
||||
"status": "COMPLETE",
|
||||
"trigger": null
|
||||
},
|
||||
"mean_percent": 10.402179274473104
|
||||
}
|
||||
},
|
||||
"paired_status": "H2_P_IMPROVEMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
|
||||
"comparison": {
|
||||
"h2_percent_by_seed": {
|
||||
"0": 9.780531195369926,
|
||||
"1": 9.855662950792828,
|
||||
"2": 10.402179274473104
|
||||
},
|
||||
"gino_percent_by_seed": {
|
||||
"0": 6.948098630921261,
|
||||
"1": 7.764187159838977,
|
||||
"2": 7.591346845970498
|
||||
},
|
||||
"gino_mean_percent": 7.434544212243579,
|
||||
"gino_reproduction_pass": true,
|
||||
"paired_mean_difference_pp": 2.578246927968374,
|
||||
"paired_ci95_pp": [
|
||||
2.327363674945616,
|
||||
2.84889180473312
|
||||
],
|
||||
"components": 111,
|
||||
"decision": "H2_P_IMPROVEMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
|
||||
"h2_mean_percent": 10.012791140211952
|
||||
}
|
||||
},
|
||||
"source_sha256": {
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/contract.json": "67a8fea2bfdf499b9a900a5e5371804ddd9a199ba1aa8921d7343bf7ac65e33d",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/expected-review-binding.json": "164814fd21f2ef25967860123bbfb4cd07ce18ebe213d576c0377d0708d93009",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/review.json": "1359ba9813b92b26c2c763e337344c2c8f438e803a3ece16032e4b6f80f4e34b",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/checkpoints-frozen.json": "6fbbbfcfae924f547e818471d8cae576bfaca4b3c6ed92b9f768cb6cbbfb06fd",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/complete.json": "53978652f990bbb945a995b6b9ddeb9fc2c5ce5e793cc16ae4dcf80b2c329ef9",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/seed-0/score/complete.json": "096ccb05ffe3092316744b20df31bf06cc13e173211233277bce76d740fe3022",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/seed-0/score/worker-records/result.json": "bd81c9d78bc9e7e6a082cf3c37e75a2ad87108a709eb9ee25c74cbac155259e1",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/seed-0/score/heldout-target-access.jsonl": "f64f2b2486c769862ee34fa15ce1b70c62a26271d96a2efea062c79ddffaa166",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/seed-1/score/complete.json": "fd2140e46ad7100caebf0d826dd9bb22a6d4fddbd5ef861e820ee5b28f0dd9b0",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/seed-1/score/worker-records/result.json": "bb910d1141b434b2d5c3d81cf4d5f5bc82d13b49bfa8b0d2260d1b6c72f2ef9f",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/seed-1/score/heldout-target-access.jsonl": "f64f2b2486c769862ee34fa15ce1b70c62a26271d96a2efea062c79ddffaa166",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/seed-2/score/complete.json": "fc6bab1ce1c921e512a85977883d6db371bc8b093d9ba516e69ea3e52c69970d",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/seed-2/score/worker-records/result.json": "22c2322926db9660d9c6f59be797ed3fa9bd4fcf235fb8d1c9ebeb0be4ba810d",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/seed-2/score/heldout-target-access.jsonl": "f64f2b2486c769862ee34fa15ce1b70c62a26271d96a2efea062c79ddffaa166",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-gino-shapenet611-formal-v3-2026-11-19/contract.json": "c3c5c5f0fab049c757032c343673104eb0f99cbaead5e0f78247f2a3aa6173c3",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-gino-shapenet611-formal-v3-2026-11-19/expected-review-binding.json": "2265bedb2a41588a71be967a1de925ba29b6c197e369287c114f8c7460a34745",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-gino-shapenet611-formal-v3-2026-11-19/review.json": "f2cc0c4749acd6bca1e11ae428774b5617ee1d9ad68205d013f3e707d8de7b28",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-gino-shapenet611-formal-v3-2026-11-19/checkpoints-frozen.json": "9cb4f0e9ef74a0fcb97a21ab5c3dbc0ec6ee06a523df0fa974e6c364a37e13a9",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-gino-shapenet611-formal-v3-2026-11-19/seed-0/score/complete.json": "63995dbf7782c1a77c07e59bc475ed1de337817d4a69d902d1aaac8497e617fc",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-gino-shapenet611-formal-v3-2026-11-19/seed-0/score/worker-records/result.json": "61ba20c19b9edb91a13d0a709beed65e858e84b33f0ee6b6c349e47e9cbd3b77",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-gino-shapenet611-formal-v3-2026-11-19/seed-0/score/heldout-target-access.jsonl": "f64f2b2486c769862ee34fa15ce1b70c62a26271d96a2efea062c79ddffaa166",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-gino-shapenet611-formal-v3-2026-11-19/seed-1/score/complete.json": "beb8a065f1b86acab6ab67aa26994b93b9630f9ce1fa28b7e3aa64319a2bb621",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-gino-shapenet611-formal-v3-2026-11-19/seed-1/score/worker-records/result.json": "11e983544e83f44254bd30ecbfcef33fe75675f2d9451fed94b55ea8332fb9e4",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-gino-shapenet611-formal-v3-2026-11-19/seed-1/score/heldout-target-access.jsonl": "f64f2b2486c769862ee34fa15ce1b70c62a26271d96a2efea062c79ddffaa166",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-gino-shapenet611-formal-v3-2026-11-19/seed-2/score/complete.json": "bcaaa7d177266022d936a7602cc04c10e23c9d0be7253155c4bbfa36e84bbdfe",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-gino-shapenet611-formal-v3-2026-11-19/seed-2/score/worker-records/result.json": "f7b9250eed6cbf1a60ff04b7f0b304aff6d9779a83ada1eb279cecf103aae64e",
|
||||
"artifacts/track-b-gino-shapenet611-formal-v3-2026-11-19/seed-2/score/heldout-target-access.jsonl": "f64f2b2486c769862ee34fa15ce1b70c62a26271d96a2efea062c79ddffaa166"
|
||||
},
|
||||
"preregistration": {
|
||||
"path": "artifacts/track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19/comparison-contract.json",
|
||||
"sha256": "e6995675276c4a647e349ca5d0f34c05c47957871b91a5ae98f685ec93a3b62f",
|
||||
"method": {
|
||||
"replicates": 2000,
|
||||
"seed": 20261119,
|
||||
"confidence": 0.95,
|
||||
"method": "paired component resampling with replacement; case weighted; all three paired seeds retained"
|
||||
},
|
||||
"family_support": "111 exact-mesh singletons; family metadata unavailable"
|
||||
},
|
||||
"aggregator_sha256": {
|
||||
"tools/track_b_h2_pressure_entry.py": "8023bba517ad9ea0d3be0d819c1c0040def215bbac4d4c6bc248a83a4d970a4f",
|
||||
"tools/track_b_gino_formal.py": "aa7b1301203d433564491b72fc967a29898098ad8d0d3677cda88991fbc7b483"
|
||||
},
|
||||
"historical_h2_gpu": {
|
||||
"status": "COMPLETE",
|
||||
"trigger": null,
|
||||
"charged_gpu_seconds": 10631.03921664902,
|
||||
"cap_gpu_seconds": 40000,
|
||||
"no_retry": true
|
||||
},
|
||||
"this_review": {
|
||||
"fit_or_inference_reruns": 0,
|
||||
"new_heldout_target_opens": 0,
|
||||
"gpu_queries_or_dispatches": 0
|
||||
}
|
||||
}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
# SR-20261119-2137 · MeltSol 执行侧独立意见
|
||||
|
||||
基于 Claude 冻结简报 `e0c8a278` 和正式 H2-P 配对结果。目标是在未见模具与工况上预测充填场,并给出可用的末填位置。本意见在阅读其他成员的本轮意见前封存。 [冻结简报](https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/src/commit/e0c8a27817f9bf3fb3c23cf16bffa75f474a052a/docs/claude/stage-review-SR-20261119-2137.md)
|
||||
|
||||
1. **H2 在三维中做什么。** Greif 已使用三维四面体网格。可迁移的是实际网格边上的局部消息、按节点质量加权的汇聚、连通域内的全局 token 和逐点解码。换到三角曲面时改用表面边和面积权重,H2-P 已做过这一替换。跨物理任务需要重定义边界条件、输入量和无量纲尺度,按新目标拟合归一化、输出头与权重。真实连通性与按局部几何类型分区仍应分别检验。 [H2-P 合同说明](../track-b-h2-pressure-combined-2026-11-19.md)
|
||||
|
||||
2. **Greif 证据。** 五折、552 件、204 家族,家族等权场相对 L2 从 A 的 7.083% 降至 H2 两种子的 6.579% 和 6.594%。五折同向,剔除任一家族均未翻转。硬末点位置均值从 0.377 Rg 升至 0.457 和 0.408 Rg。34 件两种子共漏,其中 17 件 A 也漏,已测尾区属性未解释成因。这支持同源独立家族上的平均场收益。跨来源新家族、工况干预和末填收益尚待验证。四个随机划分结果只作同划分描述。 [家族复核](../phase3-h2-family-diagnostic-results-2026-11-19.md) · [共漏尾区](../phase3-h2-shared-miss-true-tail-results-2026-11-19.md)
|
||||
|
||||
3. **ShapeNet 与 SOTA。** 原 500/111、三对种子、同一规定预算。GINO 7.435%,通过复现门,H2-P 10.013%。差值 H2-P − GINO 为 +2.578 个百分点,95% 区间 [+2.327, +2.849]。预登记正式判决为改善未建立,且该协议下误差更高。111 个网格哈希单件无家族谱系。已核的是 GINO Table 2 协议,OTNO 与 PCNO 的协议可比性仍未确定。这个无调参压力头的结论限于该任务、划分和合同。 [正式冻结结果](../../artifacts/stage-review-SR-20261119-2137/h2-p-paired-result.json)
|
||||
|
||||
4. **下一项对照与通用性。** GINO-Greif 是下一项模型对照。固定已有 212 件、78 家族、两折两种子,用同一节点、指标和组件配对检验 GINO − H2,并单列硬子集作描述。外部验证应使用有可信谱系、明确浇口和充填定义且保留逐节点标签的三维数据。先看跨来源新家族,再用同模具的成对工况变化检验条件输入,最后留出家族与工况的交叉组合。不同网格分辨率应能对齐物理位置。 [Greif 联合预审](../track-b-gino-greif-combined-2026-11-19.md)
|
||||
|
||||
5. **优先级与停线。** ① GINO-Greif 在独立窄审、原许可和成本门均满足后才运行。缺配对或超预算即停,场差区间跨零按预登记归为可比,末填单报。② 并行做 v4 LOG/YML 与 196 件翘曲集的元数据审计。缺独立谱系、完整充填或可核实的 ≥99% 切换条件时,停止把它收为同工况验证。③ 有可靠来源后再预登记末填改进。若新家族上的末填改进区间跨零,或场误差越过预设保真界,停止该改动。现有 34 件只用于定位问题。 [既定研究树](https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/src/commit/e0c8a27817f9bf3fb3c23cf16bffa75f474a052a/docs/claude/research-tree.md)
|
||||
Reference in new issue
Block a user