full review brief (MELTMIND-FULL-REVIEW-1120)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
ClaudeandClaude Opus 5.5 committed 2026-11-20 13:48:48 +00:00
1 parent 95c90dd977
commit 30c73d6c41
1 file changed
+32
+32
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,32 @@
# MeltMind full review (MELTMIND-FULL-REVIEW-1120), Claude chairs
Requested by Yanqi (13:48 UTC). Review only: no compute resumes, no label reads, until Yanqi says continue.
## Timeline (UTC, 2026-11-20)
- 13:55 brief out (this file).
- **15:00** independent reports due (written without reading others; MeltSol publishes all to Git, links in Slack).
- 15:00-15:45 one discussion round: Claude posts agreements and disagreements; members answer only where named.
- **16:15** Claude's synthesis to Yanqi, with links to every original.
## Each report (at most 1.5 pages, plain language)
1. What you did: short term (last 2 days), medium (this phase), long (since start), with the evidence links.
2. The most valuable thing learned (one or two items, with why).
3. What is in progress now and what problem it tries to solve.
4. What you would do next (short / medium / long), with cost and stop criteria.
5. What Yanqi needs to decide (only real decisions: scope, data rights, money, irreversible actions).
6. Your recurring mistakes and the fix (from your error book).
Label every claim: verified (with link) / inferred / untested.
## Roster
| Member | Scope |
|---|---|
| MeltSol (executor) | Everything executed: runs, costs, failures, infrastructure, what slowed us |
| MeltAssist (reviewer) | What reviews caught/missed; review cost vs value; proposals to make reviews lighter where safe |
| MoldSol (maths/specs) | Methods: what the physics/maths says about H2, last fill, readout, generality |
| NewMeltAstra (reserve) | Half page: fresh view on direction and decisions (Astra quota) |
| Melt Report (former MeltAstra) | Report materials: what exists, what was missing, what would make results easier to show |
| MeltWin | One paragraph: Moldflow route status and what would be needed |
| Grok | Public literature and social-media signals since last review; benchmarks/data sources; what competitors do |
| Undermind | Tool, not a participant: Grok/MeltSol list its literature contributions separately (public queries only) |
| TRON | Coordination and routing review, including the delays from re-asking Yanqi |
| Claude | Writes own report after collecting the others; then the synthesis |