Publish MeltAssist independent v4 terminal audit with evidence limits

This commit is contained in:
Frank14f committed 2026-11-16 22:33:58 +08:00
1 parent fb74b273e2
commit 271c47a698
7 files changed
+298985

No files matched your search

@@ -0,0 +1,328 @@
{
"status": "PASS_WITH_STATED_LIMITATIONS",
"started_unix": 1794838882.9465945,
"finished_unix": 1794838889.7867684,
"audit_cpu_seconds": 6.819323239,
"checks": 42843,
"failed_checks": [],
"files_hashed": 13946,
"bytes_hashed": 4867218740,
"hash_manifest_sha256": "078557ffedc0fcb66fe07ce46d43fa64e7ee33d1c6987c1828993ade1dd0e80c",
"checks_sha256": "0778ab57b8df742060b6a77960cfef2baa5a0bb1baf5adf27b3c6de06fc66c92",
"preparation": {
"requested": 629,
"successful": 615,
"failed": 14,
"failure_details": [
{
"case": "00000027_ad34a3f60c4a4caa99646600_step_007",
"stop_reason": null,
"returncode": 1,
"error_lines": [
"ValueError: Invalid fill time on full tetrahedral domain"
],
"cpu_seconds": 228.527997,
"wall_seconds": 242.16197866998846
},
{
"case": "00000026_ad34a3f60c4a4caa99646600_step_006",
"stop_reason": null,
"returncode": 1,
"error_lines": [
"ValueError: Invalid fill time on full tetrahedral domain"
],
"cpu_seconds": 389.07906299999996,
"wall_seconds": 411.82913551601814
},
{
"case": "00000033_ad34a3f60c4a4caa99646600_step_013",
"stop_reason": "wall_limit",
"returncode": -9,
"error_lines": [],
"cpu_seconds": 1703.8102840000001,
"wall_seconds": 1800.1185044309823
},
{
"case": "00000216_5324c79b172f41e8a49afc6f_step_003",
"stop_reason": "wall_limit",
"returncode": -9,
"error_lines": [],
"cpu_seconds": 1710.2251780000001,
"wall_seconds": 1800.1801030740025
},
{
"case": "00000575_5a4cef68211d4706b1ec8586_step_004",
"stop_reason": "wall_limit",
"returncode": -9,
"error_lines": [],
"cpu_seconds": 1696.9662660000001,
"wall_seconds": 1800.1311887949705
},
{
"case": "00000589_2417b410de78416ebe50d460_step_002",
"stop_reason": "wall_limit",
"returncode": -9,
"error_lines": [],
"cpu_seconds": 1700.627005,
"wall_seconds": 1800.0867463279865
},
{
"case": "00000614_c710d414bbbc4340b682c58a_step_000",
"stop_reason": "wall_limit",
"returncode": -9,
"error_lines": [],
"cpu_seconds": 1708.278232,
"wall_seconds": 1800.111270613037
},
{
"case": "00000625_6af98f5458b347bb843f0562_step_000",
"stop_reason": "wall_limit",
"returncode": -9,
"error_lines": [],
"cpu_seconds": 1705.598771,
"wall_seconds": 1800.3204157999717
},
{
"case": "00000628_60653f03c5044ef6a9b2e188_step_000",
"stop_reason": "wall_limit",
"returncode": -9,
"error_lines": [],
"cpu_seconds": 1713.5742189999999,
"wall_seconds": 1800.1707399750012
},
{
"case": "00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000",
"stop_reason": "wall_limit",
"returncode": -9,
"error_lines": [],
"cpu_seconds": 1713.8793269999999,
"wall_seconds": 1800.114591200021
},
{
"case": "00000954_a741c7966d2c40a8a511263e_step_000",
"stop_reason": null,
"returncode": 1,
"error_lines": [
"ValueError: Invalid fill time on full tetrahedral domain"
],
"cpu_seconds": 48.101245,
"wall_seconds": 51.47026148799341
},
{
"case": "00001466_a45f6c99e2154f3b94955175_step_050",
"stop_reason": "wall_limit",
"returncode": -9,
"error_lines": [],
"cpu_seconds": 1696.46238,
"wall_seconds": 1800.0429721549735
},
{
"case": "00001470_a45f6c99e2154f3b94955175_step_054",
"stop_reason": "wall_limit",
"returncode": -9,
"error_lines": [],
"cpu_seconds": 1704.355495,
"wall_seconds": 1800.0915159799624
},
{
"case": "00001575_e962204720bd4897a379cb67_step_005",
"stop_reason": null,
"returncode": 1,
"error_lines": [
"ValueError: Invalid fill time on full tetrahedral domain"
],
"cpu_seconds": 78.72382,
"wall_seconds": 84.44957338302629
}
]
},
"coverage": [
{
"split": 0,
"test_requested": 315,
"test_scored": 304,
"test_missing": 11,
"train_available": 311,
"fnn_learning_available": 279,
"fnn_validation_available": 32
},
{
"split": 1,
"test_requested": 315,
"test_scored": 311,
"test_missing": 4,
"train_available": 304,
"fnn_learning_available": 275,
"fnn_validation_available": 29
},
{
"split": 2,
"test_requested": 315,
"test_scored": 308,
"test_missing": 7,
"train_available": 307,
"fnn_learning_available": 275,
"fnn_validation_available": 32
},
{
"split": 3,
"test_requested": 315,
"test_scored": 309,
"test_missing": 6,
"train_available": 306,
"fnn_learning_available": 274,
"fnn_validation_available": 32
},
{
"split": 4,
"test_requested": 315,
"test_scored": 305,
"test_missing": 10,
"train_available": 310,
"fnn_learning_available": 279,
"fnn_validation_available": 31
}
],
"fits": [
{
"key": "0/GBRT",
"guard_cpu": 444.30884,
"guard_wall": 64.59357198397629,
"started_unix": 1794835360.5721865,
"guard_mtime": 1794835425.1661687,
"epochs": null,
"best_epoch": null
},
{
"key": "1/GBRT",
"guard_cpu": 419.32342,
"guard_wall": 59.64662213396514,
"started_unix": 1794835425.1713574,
"guard_mtime": 1794835484.818123,
"epochs": null,
"best_epoch": null
},
{
"key": "2/GBRT",
"guard_cpu": 466.953004,
"guard_wall": 66.54219851002563,
"started_unix": 1794835484.8215375,
"guard_mtime": 1794835551.3641121,
"epochs": null,
"best_epoch": null
},
{
"key": "3/GBRT",
"guard_cpu": 409.482998,
"guard_wall": 59.313435489020776,
"started_unix": 1794835551.368381,
"guard_mtime": 1794835610.6823335,
"epochs": null,
"best_epoch": null
},
{
"key": "4/GBRT",
"guard_cpu": 393.21184999999997,
"guard_wall": 56.46241221902892,
"started_unix": 1794835610.6887429,
"guard_mtime": 1794835667.1516871,
"epochs": null,
"best_epoch": null
},
{
"key": "0/FNN",
"guard_cpu": 147.222804,
"guard_wall": 147.01360946299974,
"started_unix": 1794835677.4308667,
"guard_mtime": 1794835824.4482975,
"epochs": 6,
"best_epoch": 1
},
{
"key": "1/FNN",
"guard_cpu": 145.419526,
"guard_wall": 145.05509280704428,
"started_unix": 1794835839.6410906,
"guard_mtime": 1794835984.7003708,
"epochs": 6,
"best_epoch": 1
},
{
"key": "2/FNN",
"guard_cpu": 202.38473100000002,
"guard_wall": 201.99334281199845,
"started_unix": 1794835999.900543,
"guard_mtime": 1794836201.8976722,
"epochs": 8,
"best_epoch": 3
},
{
"key": "3/FNN",
"guard_cpu": 165.414428,
"guard_wall": 165.10486722900532,
"started_unix": 1794836217.232173,
"guard_mtime": 1794836382.3414316,
"epochs": 7,
"best_epoch": 2
},
{
"key": "4/FNN",
"guard_cpu": 170.470287,
"guard_wall": 170.23347186797764,
"started_unix": 1794836392.489675,
"guard_mtime": 1794836562.727402,
"epochs": 7,
"best_epoch": 2
}
],
"prediction_files": 4611,
"prediction_rows": 1575,
"undefined_score_fields": 0,
"stored_mean_of_split_medians": {
"naive": {
"rrmse_rms": 0.08620606879263487,
"rrmse_maximum": 0.05137172196053522,
"rrmse_mean": 0.09859613379205887
},
"GBRT": {
"rrmse_rms": 0.06616141464205236,
"rrmse_maximum": 0.0395792024306458,
"rrmse_mean": 0.0759905281671669
},
"FNN": {
"rrmse_rms": 0.07576273601385508,
"rrmse_maximum": 0.04522649896759959,
"rrmse_mean": 0.08684266392033663
}
},
"charged_worker_cpu_seconds": 140042.73955399985,
"charged_gpu_seconds": 895.5746158440015,
"chronology": {
"mtimes": {
"contract": 1794816556.6491144,
"input-freeze": 1794816556.6501143,
"splits": 1794816556.6141145,
"model-plan": 1794816556.6491144,
"complete": 1794835358.5356345,
"preparation-freeze": 1794835360.563647,
"training-contract": 1794835360.570647,
"models-freeze": 1794836562.729402,
"predictions-freeze": 1794836747.5655253,
"scores": 1794836753.0485306,
"score-summary": 1794836753.0525308,
"reproduction-complete": 1794836753.5405312
},
"first_fit_start": 1794835360.5721865,
"last_fit_receipt": 1794836562.727402,
"predict_start": 1794836562.7303574,
"score_start": 1794836748.324967
},
"limitations": [
"No model fitting, prediction, scoring or label decoding performed. NPY files hashed as bytes only.",
"Chronology supported by code/linked receipts/local mtimes, not independent tamper-proof timestamps.",
"Archive intake MD5/SHA reused via hashed receipt and matching stat; 35.9GB archive not rehashed.",
"Raw score-summary retains stale v5 limitation text; dataset_version and contract are v4. Preserve raw file; qualify in report.",
"Paper comparison max(y) is retained-tet-domain final arrival time proxy; original author scoring code unavailable.",
"Remote immutable publication binding pending MeltAstra publication; no Git checkout mutated."
]
}
@@ -0,0 +1,191 @@
"""Read-only receipt/hash audit. No project imports, array decoding, or scoring."""
import collections
import hashlib
import json
import math
from pathlib import Path
import time
BASE = Path('/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind')
ROOT = BASE/'artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol'
OUT = BASE/'artifacts/meltassist-v4-terminal-audit-2026-11-16'
started = time.time()
cpu_start = time.process_time()
checks = []
hashes = {}
def read(p):
return json.loads(Path(p).read_text())
def check(name, ok, detail=None):
checks.append(dict(name=name, passed=bool(ok), detail=detail))
def digest(path, expected=None):
path = Path(path)
if not path.is_absolute():
path = BASE/path
key = str(path.relative_to(BASE))
if key not in hashes:
before = path.stat()
h = hashlib.sha256()
with path.open('rb') as f:
for block in iter(lambda: f.read(4*1024*1024), b''):
h.update(block)
after = path.stat()
stable = (before.st_size,before.st_mtime_ns,before.st_ino)==(after.st_size,after.st_mtime_ns,after.st_ino)
hashes[key] = dict(sha256=h.hexdigest(), bytes=after.st_size, mtime_ns=after.st_mtime_ns, stable_during_read=stable)
check('stable:'+key, stable)
value = hashes[key]['sha256']
if expected is not None:
check('sha256:'+key, value==expected, None if value==expected else dict(expected=expected,actual=value))
return value
names = ['contract','input-freeze','splits','model-plan','complete','preparation-freeze','training-contract',
'models-freeze','predictions-freeze','scores','score-summary','reproduction-complete']
d = {n:read(ROOT/(n+'.json')) for n in names}
for n in names:
digest(ROOT/(n+'.json'))
c, inp, splits, plan = [d[k] for k in ['contract','input-freeze','splits','model-plan']]
complete, prep, tc, models, pred, scores, summary, final = [d[k] for k in
['complete','preparation-freeze','training-contract','models-freeze','predictions-freeze','scores','score-summary','reproduction-complete']]
links = [
('contract', inp['contract_sha256']),('splits',inp['splits_sha256']),('model-plan',inp['model_plan_sha256']),
('splits',c['splits_sha256']),('complete',prep['preparation_complete_sha256']),
('preparation-freeze',tc['preparation_freeze_sha256']),('splits',tc['splits_sha256']),
('training-contract',models['training_contract_sha256']),('models-freeze',pred['models_freeze_sha256']),
('predictions-freeze',scores['predictions_freeze_sha256']),('scores',summary['scores_sha256'])]
for n,h in links:
digest(ROOT/(n+'.json'),h)
for obj in [c,plan,tc]:
for p,h in obj['code_sha256'].items():
digest(p,h)
check('training_contract_extends_frozen_plan',all(tc[k]==v for k,v in plan.items()))
archive_verification=BASE/'artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/data/manual-receive-verification.json'
digest(archive_verification,c['archive_verification_sha256'])
ar=Path(c['archive']).stat(); old=c['archive_stat']
check('archive_stat_matches_intake_no_rehash',ar.st_size==old['bytes'] and ar.st_mtime_ns==old['mtime_ns'] and ar.st_ino==old['inode'])
cases=[r['case'] for r in c['parts']]; case_set=set(cases)
check('629_unique_requested',len(cases)==len(case_set)==629)
records=complete['records']; recs={r['case']:r for r in records}
check('629_unique_terminal_no_unattempted',len(records)==len(recs)==629 and set(recs)==case_set and not complete['never_attempted'])
check('preparation_complete_no_global_stop',complete['status']=='COMPLETE' and complete['stop_reason'] is None and complete['accounting_complete'])
good=set(prep['successful']); failed={r['case'] for r in prep['failed']}
check('615_success_14_fail_partition',len(good)==615 and len(failed)==14 and not good&failed and good|failed==case_set and prep['requested']==629 and not prep['replacement'])
failure_details=[]
for case,r in recs.items():
folder=ROOT/'parts'/case
guard=read(folder/'guard-result.json'); receipt=read(folder/'worker.receipt.json')
digest(folder/'guard-result.json');digest(folder/'worker.receipt.json')
check('part_guard_record:'+case,guard==r)
check('part_receipt_record:'+case,receipt==r['worker'])
w=r['worker']
check('part_monitor_no_retry:'+case,w['monitor_errors']==0 and not w['retry'])
if case in good:
p=prep['successful'][case]; result=read(r['result_path'])
check('part_pass:'+case,w['status']=='PASS' and result['status']=='PASS')
digest(r['result_path'],r['result_sha256']);check('part_result_pin:'+case,p['result_sha256']==r['result_sha256'])
check('part_output_manifest:'+case,p['output_sha256']==result['output_sha256'])
for filename,h in p['output_sha256'].items():
digest(Path(p['output'])/filename,h)
else:
log=(folder/'worker.log').read_text(errors='replace')
digest(folder/'worker.log')
error=[line for line in log.splitlines() if 'Error:' in line or 'Exception:' in line]
failure_details.append(dict(case=case,stop_reason=w['stop_reason'],returncode=w['returncode'],error_lines=error[-3:],cpu_seconds=w['cpu_seconds'],wall_seconds=w['wall_seconds']))
check('failed_not_pass:'+case,w['status']!='PASS')
print('Preparation receipts and all successful output hashes checked',flush=True)
coverage=[]
check('five_fixed_seeds',[s['seed'] for s in splits]==list(range(2026111601,2026111606)))
for s in splits:
tr,te,learn,val=map(lambda k:set(s[k]),['train','test','fnn_learning','fnn_validation'])
check('split_partition:'+str(s['index']),len(tr)==314 and len(te)==315 and tr|te==case_set and not tr&te and len(learn)==282 and len(val)==32 and learn|val==tr and not learn&val)
coverage.append(dict(split=s['index'],test_requested=len(te),test_scored=len(te&good),test_missing=len(te&failed),
train_available=len(tr&good),fnn_learning_available=len(learn&good),fnn_validation_available=len(val&good)))
fit_details=[]; fit_cpu=0.; all_fit_start=[]; all_fit_end=[]
check('ten_fit_keys',set(models['fits'])=={f'{i}/{name}' for i in range(5) for name in ['GBRT','FNN']})
check('final_fit_manifest',models['fits']==final['fits'] and models['all_fits_terminal'] and not models['test_scores_read'])
for key,f in models['fits'].items():
g=read(f['guard_receipt']);r=read(f['result']);folder=Path(f['result']).parent
st=read(folder/'worker.started.json')
digest(f['guard_receipt'],f['guard_receipt_sha256']);digest(f['checkpoint'],f['checkpoint_sha256']);digest(f['result'])
digest(folder/'worker.started.json')
check('fit_pass:'+key,f['status']=='PASS' and g['status']=='PASS' and g['returncode']==0 and g['monitor_errors']==0 and not g['retry'] and r['status']=='FIT_COMPLETE_NO_TEST_SCORES')
check('fit_checkpoint_agreement:'+key,r['checkpoint_sha256']==f['checkpoint_sha256'])
for witness in g.get('peak_witnesses',{}).values():digest(witness['path'],witness['sha256'])
si,name=key.split('/');split=splits[int(si)];cv=coverage[int(si)]
check('fit_missing_exact:'+key,all(set(r['missing_preparation'][k])==set(split[k])&failed for k in ['train','test','fnn_learning','fnn_validation']))
check('fit_training_geometry_count:'+key,r['train_geometries']==cv['train_available' if name=='GBRT' else 'fnn_learning_available'])
if name=='FNN':
check('fnn_validation_geometry_count:'+key,r['validation_geometries']==cv['fnn_validation_available'])
check('fnn_recorded_peak_cap:'+key,max(g['recorded_peaks'].values())<=plan['gpu_reserved_byte_cap'] and not g['device_monitor']['reasons'])
fit_cpu+=g['cpu_seconds'];all_fit_start.append(st['started_unix']);all_fit_end.append(Path(f['guard_receipt']).stat().st_mtime)
fit_details.append(dict(key=key,guard_cpu=g['cpu_seconds'],guard_wall=g['wall_seconds'],started_unix=st['started_unix'],
guard_mtime=Path(f['guard_receipt']).stat().st_mtime,epochs=r.get('epochs'),best_epoch=r.get('best_epoch')))
prows={(r['split'],r['case']):r for r in pred['rows']};srows={(r['split'],r['case']):r for r in scores['rows']}
requested={(s['index'],case) for s in splits for case in s['test']}
check('1575_prediction_and_score_rows',len(pred['rows'])==len(prows)==len(scores['rows'])==len(srows)==1575 and set(prows)==set(srows)==requested)
prediction_count=0; undefined_count=0
for key,row in prows.items():
sc=srows[key];case=row['case']
if case in failed:
check('failed_row_retained:'+str(key),row['status']==sc['status']=='PREPARATION_FAILED' and not row['predictions'] and not sc['scores'])
continue
check('success_row_scored:'+str(key),row['status']=='PREDICTED' and sc['status']=='SCORED' and set(row['predictions'])==set(sc['scores'])=={'naive','GBRT','FNN'})
p=prep['successful'][case]
check('prediction_raw_ids_link:'+str(key),row['raw_ids_sha256']==p['output_sha256']['raw_ids.npy'])
for name,pr in row['predictions'].items():
digest(pr['path'],pr['sha256']);prediction_count+=1
sm=sc['scores'][name]
check('full_node_count:'+str(key)+name,pr['nodes']==p['nodes']==sm['nodes'] and pr['no_clipping'])
check('three_metrics_present:'+str(key)+name,all(k in sm for k in ['rrmse_rms','rrmse_maximum','rrmse_mean']))
undefined_count+=len(sm['undefined_metrics'])
for name,metrics in summary['summary'].items():
for metric,entry in metrics.items():
for row in entry['per_split']:
cv=coverage[row['split']]
check('summary_coverage:'+name+metric+str(row['split']),row['requested_test_geometries']==315 and row['scored']==cv['test_scored'] and row['missing']==cv['test_missing'])
check('summary_not_full_coverage:'+name+metric,entry['full_requested_coverage'] is False)
post_cpu=0.
for phase in ['predict','score']:
path=ROOT/'postfit-guards'/phase/'worker.receipt.json';g=read(path);digest(path)
entry=next(x for x in final['postfit'] if x['phase']==phase)
check('postfit_receipt:'+phase,g==entry['receipt'] and g['status']=='PASS' and g['returncode']==0 and g['monitor_errors']==0 and not g['retry'])
post_cpu+=g['cpu_seconds']
predict_start=read(ROOT/'postfit-guards/predict/worker.started.json')['started_unix']
score_start=read(ROOT/'postfit-guards/score/worker.started.json')['started_unix']
mtimes={n:(ROOT/(n+'.json')).stat().st_mtime for n in names}
check('mtime_preparation_before_first_fit',mtimes['complete']<=mtimes['preparation-freeze']<=mtimes['training-contract']<=min(all_fit_start))
check('mtime_all_fit_terminal_before_model_freeze',max(all_fit_end)<=mtimes['models-freeze']<=predict_start)
check('mtime_predictions_frozen_before_score',predict_start<=mtimes['predictions-freeze']<=score_start<=mtimes['scores']<=mtimes['score-summary']<=mtimes['reproduction-complete'])
check('prediction_no_target_declaration',not pred['test_targets_read'] and pred['device']=='CPU' and pred['prediction_units']=='seconds')
prep_cpu=sum(r['worker']['cpu_seconds'] for r in records)
check('preparation_cpu_accounting',math.isclose(prep_cpu,complete['worker_cpu_seconds'],abs_tol=1e-6))
expected_cpu=prep_cpu+complete['initial_cpu_reserve_seconds']+fit_cpu+post_cpu
check('total_cpu_accounting',math.isclose(expected_cpu,final['charged_worker_cpu_seconds'],abs_tol=1e-6))
check('preparation_cpu_cap',prep_cpu+complete['initial_cpu_reserve_seconds']<=c['limits']['total_worker_cpu_seconds'])
check('total_cpu_gpu_caps',final['charged_worker_cpu_seconds']<=216000 and final['charged_gpu_seconds']<=7200)
check('final_status_v4',final['status']=='SCORED' and final['dataset_version']==summary['dataset_version']==c['dataset_version']=='v4')
for n in names:
key=str((ROOT/(n+'.json')).relative_to(BASE));old=hashes[key]
st=(ROOT/(n+'.json')).stat();check('unchanged_after_audit:'+n,st.st_size==old['bytes'] and st.st_mtime_ns==old['mtime_ns'])
OUT.mkdir(exist_ok=True)
(OUT/'hash-manifest.json').write_text(json.dumps(hashes,indent=2)+'\n')
(OUT/'checks.json').write_text(json.dumps(checks,indent=2)+'\n')
result=dict(status='PASS_WITH_STATED_LIMITATIONS' if all(x['passed'] for x in checks) else 'FINDINGS',
started_unix=started,finished_unix=time.time(),audit_cpu_seconds=time.process_time()-cpu_start,
checks=len(checks),failed_checks=[x for x in checks if not x['passed']],files_hashed=len(hashes),bytes_hashed=sum(x['bytes'] for x in hashes.values()),
hash_manifest_sha256=hashlib.sha256((OUT/'hash-manifest.json').read_bytes()).hexdigest(),
checks_sha256=hashlib.sha256((OUT/'checks.json').read_bytes()).hexdigest(),
preparation=dict(requested=629,successful=len(good),failed=len(failed),failure_details=failure_details),coverage=coverage,
fits=fit_details,prediction_files=prediction_count,prediction_rows=len(prows),undefined_score_fields=undefined_count,
stored_mean_of_split_medians={name:{metric:entry['mean_of_five_split_summaries']['median'] for metric,entry in metrics.items()} for name,metrics in summary['summary'].items()},
charged_worker_cpu_seconds=final['charged_worker_cpu_seconds'],charged_gpu_seconds=final['charged_gpu_seconds'],
chronology=dict(mtimes=mtimes,first_fit_start=min(all_fit_start),last_fit_receipt=max(all_fit_end),predict_start=predict_start,score_start=score_start),
limitations=['No model fitting, prediction, scoring or label decoding performed. NPY files hashed as bytes only.',
'Chronology supported by code/linked receipts/local mtimes, not independent tamper-proof timestamps.',
'Archive intake MD5/SHA reused via hashed receipt and matching stat; 35.9GB archive not rehashed.',
'Raw score-summary retains stale v5 limitation text; dataset_version and contract are v4. Preserve raw file; qualify in report.',
'Paper comparison max(y) is retained-tet-domain final arrival time proxy; original author scoring code unavailable.',
'Remote immutable publication binding pending MeltAstra publication; no Git checkout mutated.'])
(OUT/'audit.json').write_text(json.dumps(result,indent=2)+'\n')
print(json.dumps(result,indent=2))
File diff suppressed because it is too large. Load diff
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
{
"created_unix": 1794839326.3119063,
"agent": "MeltAssist",
"anchor_commit": "c9d8c519833e44ac15a4391e03a47e2f281d6bb6",
"files": {
"docs/meltassist-v4-terminal-audit-2026-11-16.md": "c163e1e48747df49482aa62b3096a454fb6f6604d9a8d352af4c9a525dc5c2b6",
"artifacts/meltassist-v4-terminal-audit-2026-11-16/audit.json": "a89ed8ffcd9827c4d9539dbf65c261c2b4b6301407bc92f7126426a220994b86",
"artifacts/meltassist-v4-terminal-audit-2026-11-16/audit_readonly.py": "07b5552bcbb541e88e2f328b1c8b314705fb072805857ce3b46dccdd754fb241",
"artifacts/meltassist-v4-terminal-audit-2026-11-16/checks.json": "0778ab57b8df742060b6a77960cfef2baa5a0bb1baf5adf27b3c6de06fc66c92",
"artifacts/meltassist-v4-terminal-audit-2026-11-16/hash-manifest.json": "078557ffedc0fcb66fe07ce46d43fa64e7ee33d1c6987c1828993ade1dd0e80c",
"artifacts/meltassist-v4-terminal-audit-2026-11-16/publication-binding.json": "101cd1163d612585c3051b556d3620bc9877a9d39c4276a039f8698bd2404cf5"
}
}
File diff suppressed because it is too large. Load diff
@@ -0,0 +1,500 @@
{
"commit": "c9d8c519833e44ac15a4391e03a47e2f281d6bb6",
"checked_unix": 1794839253.725916,
"status": "VERIFIED_WITH_EXPLICIT_READBACK_SCOPE",
"git_object_rows": [
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/complete.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "b5b94ac111a40537c6802c2ccbb8705339da0cb92f9462de2d063e9f33e38d7b",
"local_sha256": "b5b94ac111a40537c6802c2ccbb8705339da0cb92f9462de2d063e9f33e38d7b",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/contract.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "8ea9bdb9f1aa542a044b383e7191696e6ac8b3ed1aedd9b2b34e7571cd7e2c1e",
"local_sha256": "8ea9bdb9f1aa542a044b383e7191696e6ac8b3ed1aedd9b2b34e7571cd7e2c1e",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-0/FNN/final-guard-receipt.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "4e00a1bf7e6708ade12c48e2b422395fd4183cc97a258a7b1e8ca17c37847c7e",
"local_sha256": "4e00a1bf7e6708ade12c48e2b422395fd4183cc97a258a7b1e8ca17c37847c7e",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-0/FNN/model.pt",
"git_blob_sha256": "7e91897d3a81bd25cff629a1d9c5fa22a9c81fcc4bf247a64a392673c680144b",
"local_sha256": "7e91897d3a81bd25cff629a1d9c5fa22a9c81fcc4bf247a64a392673c680144b",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-0/FNN/result.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "a79ac5d02e6a13ae0f29ba403756324ab7c08b9c626ac15d7741c00bcc88b3d3",
"local_sha256": "a79ac5d02e6a13ae0f29ba403756324ab7c08b9c626ac15d7741c00bcc88b3d3",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-0/FNN/worker.started.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "1403a257716a0afec6fe508b33951ca1dab10bbcd0f3529cedc19b4480e69e3a",
"local_sha256": "1403a257716a0afec6fe508b33951ca1dab10bbcd0f3529cedc19b4480e69e3a",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-0/GBRT/final-guard-receipt.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "f5dee44a81fe412acfe676f97eeeed96b05bc59d04db9b4e43b19b6c876c6cf8",
"local_sha256": "f5dee44a81fe412acfe676f97eeeed96b05bc59d04db9b4e43b19b6c876c6cf8",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-0/GBRT/model.ubj",
"git_blob_sha256": "39bc8ac8335803be274e04cf6a704e930abcab75a75205945038c593047a86ce",
"local_sha256": "39bc8ac8335803be274e04cf6a704e930abcab75a75205945038c593047a86ce",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-0/GBRT/result.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "1e0c54a791d1a4e93aebf7bf12aba31b91deaeb17df653dd0f334dd27ed1e00b",
"local_sha256": "1e0c54a791d1a4e93aebf7bf12aba31b91deaeb17df653dd0f334dd27ed1e00b",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-0/GBRT/worker.started.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "00996482718ccc0d149acbba837853ba78e5f1c33205bbe6dea2867cd6c2b922",
"local_sha256": "00996482718ccc0d149acbba837853ba78e5f1c33205bbe6dea2867cd6c2b922",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-1/FNN/final-guard-receipt.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "e4fc975ca43377584fcfcb7d2f9d88d3e4d643ecb459a028b2d5e46c837be997",
"local_sha256": "e4fc975ca43377584fcfcb7d2f9d88d3e4d643ecb459a028b2d5e46c837be997",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-1/FNN/model.pt",
"git_blob_sha256": "ce61852bc0ae7b5752b62f98afdfb7b9cc832d33d69f2a628fa3dd291ddada88",
"local_sha256": "ce61852bc0ae7b5752b62f98afdfb7b9cc832d33d69f2a628fa3dd291ddada88",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-1/FNN/result.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "772e5eec44c9cd3b94ee6aee7d17ac4e09a2c452731fa38478d63a7ae773cd0e",
"local_sha256": "772e5eec44c9cd3b94ee6aee7d17ac4e09a2c452731fa38478d63a7ae773cd0e",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-1/FNN/worker.started.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "1a0956bf625516e3587e1e7ee6c946387ee5fe6e389cf5a87422f4089c86c924",
"local_sha256": "1a0956bf625516e3587e1e7ee6c946387ee5fe6e389cf5a87422f4089c86c924",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-1/GBRT/final-guard-receipt.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "db0a4ff178f7be9a86d4fe6815288921f43071db9cb97478490138b642f46c95",
"local_sha256": "db0a4ff178f7be9a86d4fe6815288921f43071db9cb97478490138b642f46c95",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-1/GBRT/model.ubj",
"git_blob_sha256": "5d41dcda443617c9a783a7f62e0830b00ec2d0a4032d5a4f34d1e83640f564a6",
"local_sha256": "5d41dcda443617c9a783a7f62e0830b00ec2d0a4032d5a4f34d1e83640f564a6",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-1/GBRT/result.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "6aa4c5d461298568297f2f62ac873fcaaf7ba20ae6cfd40c43693297317dcad4",
"local_sha256": "6aa4c5d461298568297f2f62ac873fcaaf7ba20ae6cfd40c43693297317dcad4",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-1/GBRT/worker.started.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "af9a7807422a1c4e45aedd62198f4cf4354af7c7f4c73326ba608c2d477434fd",
"local_sha256": "af9a7807422a1c4e45aedd62198f4cf4354af7c7f4c73326ba608c2d477434fd",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-2/FNN/final-guard-receipt.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "d3cbe6dc345ba01729d761662a7a98f5baba1435acf4b09f71c0380ab1753faf",
"local_sha256": "d3cbe6dc345ba01729d761662a7a98f5baba1435acf4b09f71c0380ab1753faf",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-2/FNN/model.pt",
"git_blob_sha256": "f1eb72006ee9ed15222e478a6cd2da1593135f9e3b9115da533784d3d4252a53",
"local_sha256": "f1eb72006ee9ed15222e478a6cd2da1593135f9e3b9115da533784d3d4252a53",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-2/FNN/result.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "5f254f31a18a3e2a0a352bad3a02c2ee0093aa6f6b9c2a9ed1d98cc0fac7304d",
"local_sha256": "5f254f31a18a3e2a0a352bad3a02c2ee0093aa6f6b9c2a9ed1d98cc0fac7304d",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-2/FNN/worker.started.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "cf9a7563ec9aa0240fe13fac4058b86796edc5db7cdf486f2f9340952012a676",
"local_sha256": "cf9a7563ec9aa0240fe13fac4058b86796edc5db7cdf486f2f9340952012a676",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-2/GBRT/final-guard-receipt.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "43d376d79a5e24e7d329cbd2e44968175f33db5e2f9b0b752ea77820ee8d31fe",
"local_sha256": "43d376d79a5e24e7d329cbd2e44968175f33db5e2f9b0b752ea77820ee8d31fe",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-2/GBRT/model.ubj",
"git_blob_sha256": "7f3f068e9d1ba8c17509addd553727b1544d74c6b24fa613fd469a4b1d0574bd",
"local_sha256": "7f3f068e9d1ba8c17509addd553727b1544d74c6b24fa613fd469a4b1d0574bd",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-2/GBRT/result.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "5f3b5360e2ab65682ce20651e78d6682df478143663a8a97330f755c73c45dea",
"local_sha256": "5f3b5360e2ab65682ce20651e78d6682df478143663a8a97330f755c73c45dea",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-2/GBRT/worker.started.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "cbc6cb6889ac1e7057612407b528d59a8fba9dcb00ade00689acbc7c6e52b27e",
"local_sha256": "cbc6cb6889ac1e7057612407b528d59a8fba9dcb00ade00689acbc7c6e52b27e",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-3/FNN/final-guard-receipt.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "59351d74132c619f8c94e7868ff9aea1a80fa525192a040507c44ac94a7f30ee",
"local_sha256": "59351d74132c619f8c94e7868ff9aea1a80fa525192a040507c44ac94a7f30ee",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-3/FNN/model.pt",
"git_blob_sha256": "650cf12e849eabefaa944bc43e3ce292f70b4b752df4a1086d0ea162b3c18618",
"local_sha256": "650cf12e849eabefaa944bc43e3ce292f70b4b752df4a1086d0ea162b3c18618",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-3/FNN/result.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "8d7c6aedc1d2812a7c7d383f9f02a532d3fc6e7b47470b5214f493e7ad5209c8",
"local_sha256": "8d7c6aedc1d2812a7c7d383f9f02a532d3fc6e7b47470b5214f493e7ad5209c8",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-3/FNN/worker.started.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "9ae10c6fd9c483ee16323d41caf488678d54c7e3a1c5aa803378d7e31f6c6e0b",
"local_sha256": "9ae10c6fd9c483ee16323d41caf488678d54c7e3a1c5aa803378d7e31f6c6e0b",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-3/GBRT/final-guard-receipt.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "12352e5af3104b07dbfe5fbcf98cf5cdcb89c943a2e7b256d3c8f95ca7e97bb3",
"local_sha256": "12352e5af3104b07dbfe5fbcf98cf5cdcb89c943a2e7b256d3c8f95ca7e97bb3",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-3/GBRT/model.ubj",
"git_blob_sha256": "e68b940300dc28f8050e5f7cc7891f084de7ff8daaa7c7efcd755a9dc6a50cea",
"local_sha256": "e68b940300dc28f8050e5f7cc7891f084de7ff8daaa7c7efcd755a9dc6a50cea",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-3/GBRT/result.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "395f4b92b8d0fb601843fa5831cb95ccc590d50a5219f881f025caaac77522bc",
"local_sha256": "395f4b92b8d0fb601843fa5831cb95ccc590d50a5219f881f025caaac77522bc",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-3/GBRT/worker.started.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "b83d20b3424fef7401cde09f16368884ffe3c57e96aa65333cbe671c4ed8a8cf",
"local_sha256": "b83d20b3424fef7401cde09f16368884ffe3c57e96aa65333cbe671c4ed8a8cf",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-4/FNN/final-guard-receipt.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "fde009fffb19bd1dca405c8b06c50a4a92ff4509b743e61d7e3b9165463ee887",
"local_sha256": "fde009fffb19bd1dca405c8b06c50a4a92ff4509b743e61d7e3b9165463ee887",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-4/FNN/model.pt",
"git_blob_sha256": "15579fe7cfb4bc741e70375f918e942ba6b0419d321ab663c94cc45d891af2cf",
"local_sha256": "15579fe7cfb4bc741e70375f918e942ba6b0419d321ab663c94cc45d891af2cf",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-4/FNN/result.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "83869946ec985a25145c64750c2497889450ec3dd63def959fc45406d75ff166",
"local_sha256": "83869946ec985a25145c64750c2497889450ec3dd63def959fc45406d75ff166",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-4/FNN/worker.started.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "025a01155d1bd6eea6741f9860218160bfeb3489aa43dbd553491e5606df758b",
"local_sha256": "025a01155d1bd6eea6741f9860218160bfeb3489aa43dbd553491e5606df758b",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-4/GBRT/final-guard-receipt.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "be81106ddb555b7d68ccc24d4176fc5e5787c1dd286d73b029682fb1e18cbbda",
"local_sha256": "be81106ddb555b7d68ccc24d4176fc5e5787c1dd286d73b029682fb1e18cbbda",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-4/GBRT/model.ubj",
"git_blob_sha256": "b16a1020e734450e1b90876ed7e31bcba130c47d28c4d2d129765d11afb1bb26",
"local_sha256": "b16a1020e734450e1b90876ed7e31bcba130c47d28c4d2d129765d11afb1bb26",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-4/GBRT/result.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "b004ac886db580f186cca84b0c1855c7747baf065b657bfbc9e32012abd2bd26",
"local_sha256": "b004ac886db580f186cca84b0c1855c7747baf065b657bfbc9e32012abd2bd26",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/fits/split-4/GBRT/worker.started.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "171459d7661fc0c3e1e42f11492718f863ed6646ce7c28aa8490e04cf66995ef",
"local_sha256": "171459d7661fc0c3e1e42f11492718f863ed6646ce7c28aa8490e04cf66995ef",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/input-freeze.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "a2bc3a24a419c40ce3137961f64e0deefb70678ac92c281ebdff60830ba640fa",
"local_sha256": "a2bc3a24a419c40ce3137961f64e0deefb70678ac92c281ebdff60830ba640fa",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/model-plan.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "15518ad03ee7b9c14e76fbd968c1f5ff7bd523d165a03113c8dbb8c6c88c444c",
"local_sha256": "15518ad03ee7b9c14e76fbd968c1f5ff7bd523d165a03113c8dbb8c6c88c444c",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/models-freeze.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "34af9f16272dc0352fd710c338fc23e245ed521ce840072c90d2308b3ead8fda",
"local_sha256": "34af9f16272dc0352fd710c338fc23e245ed521ce840072c90d2308b3ead8fda",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/predictions-freeze.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "b3b25f021413d197c9bdd00e78ebe4de5852b1132e075e467618b63199c63e86",
"local_sha256": "b3b25f021413d197c9bdd00e78ebe4de5852b1132e075e467618b63199c63e86",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/preparation-freeze.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "ac7add88b54f0cd75b667cacbb813aac40a23b9a7f47557e635efd7dbbc2d3d0",
"local_sha256": "ac7add88b54f0cd75b667cacbb813aac40a23b9a7f47557e635efd7dbbc2d3d0",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/reproduction-complete.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "fd97b7045e2bb12506806350b04c4fc8be0bf9b1614dce3f492ca05daa2969ac",
"local_sha256": "fd97b7045e2bb12506806350b04c4fc8be0bf9b1614dce3f492ca05daa2969ac",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/score-summary.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "e30fc6050878da858026be4bc0c357125e517ebdd4be6a8f0559ba0412aef3ce",
"local_sha256": "e30fc6050878da858026be4bc0c357125e517ebdd4be6a8f0559ba0412aef3ce",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/scores.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "7308e1b74d96e1f003766b72fc751c2cb0eedb9956d906d2446924015fcd04a9",
"local_sha256": "7308e1b74d96e1f003766b72fc751c2cb0eedb9956d906d2446924015fcd04a9",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/splits.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "534b2a25f92dbac2335b6282e1dfe0bb8ecdbc8db55bdfc24c7cffa83f9e931b",
"local_sha256": "534b2a25f92dbac2335b6282e1dfe0bb8ecdbc8db55bdfc24c7cffa83f9e931b",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/training-contract.json",
"git_blob_sha256": "7efc6d5e8fa6079007f2e137e80f8354e1408839413c63d9b4af443d82086cb9",
"local_sha256": "7efc6d5e8fa6079007f2e137e80f8354e1408839413c63d9b4af443d82086cb9",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "docs/gre24-v4-reproduction-results-2026-11-16.md",
"git_blob_sha256": "b80a4dd635e7df38f54c9eb5e26039d9a7466f71203fd5b1db44ad8cb34ae53c",
"local_sha256": "b80a4dd635e7df38f54c9eb5e26039d9a7466f71203fd5b1db44ad8cb34ae53c",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "tools/audit_samples.py",
"git_blob_sha256": "a3daf70ec3bcb77bf46d9dc4887d552cf7c422117880a169969780012278cd70",
"local_sha256": "a3daf70ec3bcb77bf46d9dc4887d552cf7c422117880a169969780012278cd70",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "tools/boundary_distance.py",
"git_blob_sha256": "a45c1cbce92521a96eb814913b4f465b926c0b3883932ab0b7c37d11db113ed7",
"local_sha256": "a45c1cbce92521a96eb814913b4f465b926c0b3883932ab0b7c37d11db113ed7",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "tools/gre24_features_v2.py",
"git_blob_sha256": "7dcd5ac218ffdc1ca149edcd87e8658fb3c59e18c0fb9ce47985c7f1357d2cdf",
"local_sha256": "7dcd5ac218ffdc1ca149edcd87e8658fb3c59e18c0fb9ce47985c7f1357d2cdf",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "tools/gre24_fit.py",
"git_blob_sha256": "63af0305a2c22b524d95ffee50e972848decdd042b1d24f0b3b946d9152f7688",
"local_sha256": "63af0305a2c22b524d95ffee50e972848decdd042b1d24f0b3b946d9152f7688",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "tools/gre24_gpu_guard.py",
"git_blob_sha256": "7c0fd523e917357c07b63983bb0af1653ece12b9f76d9e07dbbad8e7200c47b4",
"local_sha256": "7c0fd523e917357c07b63983bb0af1653ece12b9f76d9e07dbbad8e7200c47b4",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "tools/gre24_job_guard.py",
"git_blob_sha256": "baff57c6748380ea739dde703b20fdd2c6958389da3d24dbf0df8742654052aa",
"local_sha256": "baff57c6748380ea739dde703b20fdd2c6958389da3d24dbf0df8742654052aa",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "tools/gre24_models.py",
"git_blob_sha256": "53b6fee8b700b9b982b06d29908ce2ce23e0c57512c46dbf74b2aade79e3ac3a",
"local_sha256": "53b6fee8b700b9b982b06d29908ce2ce23e0c57512c46dbf74b2aade79e3ac3a",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "tools/gre24_prepare_v2.py",
"git_blob_sha256": "7637e55009005f6a8c77114159d7ac0d3c024c7add3e320afc486927537b78bc",
"local_sha256": "7637e55009005f6a8c77114159d7ac0d3c024c7add3e320afc486927537b78bc",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "tools/gre24_score.py",
"git_blob_sha256": "dbb11b57b7b7b2178ac11fd7243c934adb899d666a4c717dfb6a51ee1c65c705",
"local_sha256": "dbb11b57b7b7b2178ac11fd7243c934adb899d666a4c717dfb6a51ee1c65c705",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "tools/run_gre24_models.py",
"git_blob_sha256": "103ecb6dc8a40481f72da02a02e0a41069a9a747ad0b7af4418c6ed06f0dcbc9",
"local_sha256": "103ecb6dc8a40481f72da02a02e0a41069a9a747ad0b7af4418c6ed06f0dcbc9",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "tools/run_gre24_protocol_preparation.py",
"git_blob_sha256": "74a95323ec43ed089e3768c6b0a5ebd4c369207476d81d03ab1f423d33753499",
"local_sha256": "74a95323ec43ed089e3768c6b0a5ebd4c369207476d81d03ab1f423d33753499",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "tools/s2_recovery_monitoring.py",
"git_blob_sha256": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e",
"local_sha256": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e",
"match": true,
"error": null
},
{
"path": "tools/s2_recovery_supervisor.py",
"git_blob_sha256": "f563ca3c2665f5baf0c04f296616e4640423a59b815fbb00479af0f29e57a919",
"local_sha256": "f563ca3c2665f5baf0c04f296616e4640423a59b815fbb00479af0f29e57a919",
"match": true,
"error": null
}
],
"http_readbacks": [
{
"path": "docs/gre24-v4-reproduction-results-2026-11-16.md",
"url": "https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/raw/commit/c9d8c519833e44ac15a4391e03a47e2f281d6bb6/docs/gre24-v4-reproduction-results-2026-11-16.md",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "b80a4dd635e7df38f54c9eb5e26039d9a7466f71203fd5b1db44ad8cb34ae53c",
"match": true,
"evidence": "HTTP reader exec session13452 printed 200 True before its scoped termination; response body SHA256 compared to local original"
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/contract.json",
"url": "https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/raw/commit/c9d8c519833e44ac15a4391e03a47e2f281d6bb6/artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/contract.json",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "8ea9bdb9f1aa542a044b383e7191696e6ac8b3ed1aedd9b2b34e7571cd7e2c1e",
"match": true,
"evidence": "HTTP reader exec session13452 printed 200 True before its scoped termination; response body SHA256 compared to local original"
},
{
"path": "artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/complete.json",
"url": "https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/raw/commit/c9d8c519833e44ac15a4391e03a47e2f281d6bb6/artifacts/gre24-v4-reproduction-2026-11-16/protocol/complete.json",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "b5b94ac111a40537c6802c2ccbb8705339da0cb92f9462de2d063e9f33e38d7b",
"match": true,
"evidence": "HTTP reader exec session13452 printed 200 True before its scoped termination; response body SHA256 compared to local original"
}
],
"limitations": [
"Only these three remote HTTP bodies independently read back; other listed files checked against the exact locally available Git commit object, not separately HTTP downloaded.",
"The slow HTTP reader was stopped after three successful readbacks; no additional remote file verification is claimed.",
"Large feature/prediction arrays hashed locally; not claimed published remotely."
]
}
@@ -0,0 +1,58 @@
# MeltAssist:v4 独立终态审计
2026-11-16。本轮为既有终态审计,读取 Horsea 原始文件并独立检查;没有重新拟合、预测、评分或解码标签。数组仅按字节计算 SHA256。未改运行源码、合同、原始失败或共享 Git checkout,也未干预 R4bc。
## 审计结论
**本次文件与回执一致性核查通过,存在下列明确的取证及解释限制。** 此结论不等于论文精确复现认证,也不是独立科学重算。机器回执见 [audit.json](../artifacts/meltassist-v4-terminal-audit-2026-11-16/audit.json),逐项记录见同目录 checks.json、hash-manifest.json,审计程序为 audit_readonly.py。
独立核对 13 份固定源码、629 件准备 guard/worker 回执、615 件成功结果及其 7,380 个输出数组、10 个模型 checkpoint/fit guard、4,611 个预测数组、原冻结及评分 JSON。共读取 13,946 个不同文件、4,867,218,740 字节;全部声明哈希和所查关联一致。审计 CPU 6.819323239 秒单列,不计作科学重跑或修改原运行账。
## 完成、失败与覆盖
629 件全部终态,无未尝试:615 PASS,10 wall_limit,4 件触发 Invalid fill time on full tetrahedral domain。后四件为 26、27、954、1575;本轮只核原日志,不能进一步区分 NaN、Inf、负值或数量。26/27 的已授权后置诊断归 MeltAstra;本审计不扩大解码范围。失败原记录和 NA 行完整保留,无替换或自动重试。
五个固定种子是 2026111601..2026111605,各自独立随机 315 测试/314 训练,**不是五折交叉验证**。每个划分 train/test 无交集并覆盖629件;FNN 282 learning/32 validation 是准备失败前的固定名册,失败后不补抽。
| split | 有效测试/315 | 缺失测试 | 有效训练 | FNN learning | FNN validation |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| 0 | 304 | 11 | 311 | 279 | 32 |
| 1 | 311 | 4 | 304 | 275 | 29 |
| 2 | 308 | 7 | 307 | 275 | 32 |
| 3 | 309 | 6 | 306 | 274 | 32 |
| 4 | 305 | 10 | 310 | 279 | 31 |
10 次拟合全部 PASS;预测和评分 guard 均 PASS。1,575 次测试访问包含38个准备失败行,成功访问对应4,611个预测数组;各模型节点数与冻结全 tet 域一致。原评分中未定义指标字段数量为0,三分母摘要的覆盖数量与固定名册一致。
## 冻结顺序与费用
按原 SHA256 链核实:输入合同/划分/计划 → 准备完成/准备冻结 → training-contract → models-freeze → predictions-freeze → scores/summary。固定代码 run_gre24_models.py 先保存模型冻结再派发预测,gre24_score.py 的预测阶段不读 seconds.npy,评分前要求完整 predictions-freeze 并检查预测哈希。
实际 started_unix 与原文件时间支持如下顺序(UTC+8):准备完成21:22:38.535635;准备冻结21:22:40.563647;首 fit 开始21:22:40.572186;末 fit guard21:42:42.727402;模型冻结21:42:42.729402;预测开始21:42:42.730357;预测冻结21:45:47.565525;评分开始21:45:48.324967;SCORED终态21:45:53.540531。没有用 started.json 的同 tick mtime 推断逆序,也没有更改任何时间。代码、回执和本地时间相互支持,但不是外部防篡改时间证明。
原准备 worker CPU 与逐件回执合计一致;加60秒设置预留、fit 与 postfit guard 后,原共享账为 CPU 140042.739554 /216000 秒,GPU 895.574616 /7200 秒;准备子预算也未超出。10 fit 的 guard 均无监控错误,FNN 已记录显存峰值低于固定上限。本轮未重新运行资源测量。
## 指标和论文比较
以下直接摘录 score-summary.json 中已有的“五个 split 中位数的平均”,没有重新聚合数组或计算新评分:
| 分母 | naive | GBRT | FNN |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| RMS(y),内部预登记主指标 | 0.086206068793 | 0.066161414642 | 0.075762736014 |
| max(y),论文比较代理 | 0.051371721961 | 0.039579202431 | 0.045226498968 |
| mean(y) | 0.098596133792 | 0.075990528167 | 0.086842663920 |
固定评分代码对每件全部保留 tet 节点计算无体积加权的节点 RMSE,并分别除以 RMS、max、mean;摘要先每 split 统计再平均。训练抽样不会替换评分域。论文比较依 Claude1794819388 及后续措辞裁量使用既有 max(y):**tet 域最后到达时间,作为论文 total fill time 的代理;与 §4.1.1 文本一致,但作者评分代码未取得。** 不声称已证实与独立 CAE 工艺终点相等,不凭数字更接近而换主指标。原三分母全部保留。
原 score-summary.limitations[0] 遗留“v5 data instead of paper v4”;合同、冻结及终态身份均为 v4,Melt 的结果报告已明确纠正解释。原 JSON 及固定源码应保持原样。R1 离散补充、t_set 替代缺失 Q、单输出 FNN/早停、随机几何近重复和失败覆盖限制仍成立。本次结果不能直接建立 S2/R4 的组件泛化归因,更不否定未检验的组织/拓扑假说。
对 Claude1794839041 的结果解释补充:本审计能证实失败引入覆盖偏差,不能证实“排除大件必然使测试更容易”。失败件未有同一固定模型的有效误差,计算规模/超时本身不能确定 RRMSE 高低;缺失导致的偏差方向仍未检验。两版已有摘要相近可作描述,但未构成仅改变数据版本的严格配对因果对照。这些是措辞限制,不提出新补跑或新对照。
## 独立取证限制与固定入口
1. 本轮实际 systemctl 查询两个原 v4 服务时,均为 LoadState=not-found、MainPID=0、ExecMainPID=0,且没有服务开始/退出时间。该状态支持“当前无已加载的原服务”,默认 Result=success/ExecMainStatus=0 **不能独立证明 service exit0**。各原 worker 的成功退出有 guard 回执支撑;服务级退出若要单列,须引用已有有效记录,不应重启取证。此项已在 Slack1794839026.420879 交 Claude/TRON 转 Melt。
2. 原包35,925,187,752字节:本轮核对独立接收回执哈希及原包 size/mtime/inode 一致,沿用该回执的官方MD5和SHA256;没有再读36GB原包计算MD5。不要把这一层称作本轮再次独立验包。
3. 绑定 Melt 固定提交 [c9d8c519833e44ac15a4391e03a47e2f281d6bb6](https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/src/commit/c9d8c519833e44ac15a4391e03a47e2f281d6bb6/docs/gre24-v4-reproduction-results-2026-11-16.md)。精确范围见 [publication-binding.json](../artifacts/meltassist-v4-terminal-audit-2026-11-16/publication-binding.json):远端报告、contract、complete 三份HTTP正文已读回并与本地SHA256相同;其余列出的代码/冻结/评分/模型文件与本机该精确 Git commit 对象核对。没有把这两种核对混写成每份文件均完成远端HTTP读回。原 audit.json 的“绑定待定”是早于绑定的原始快照,后续由 publication-binding.json 记录完成。
4. 特征/预测大数组仅在 Horsea 原路径核对,未声称全量远端发布。未改 Melt 主发布 checkout;本审计产物交单一 writer 正常纳入后续证据,不并行推送。
研究目标仍是跨几何泛化与样本效率。此次完成的是固定 v4 复现产物的一致性复核,交 Claude 解释与阶段收束;不自动增加科学任务、改变分母、补跑失败或影响 R4bc 原队列。