TRON
53fad76759
Integrate reviewed test changes from 7c1517de819741907fb945ea0ab7864734fa3856 and 340ba4e1dc6386581839c0b28c8fe8a1f4aeb70b unchanged. Document bounded 2D implementation, evidence and open gates; production source and historical manifests are unchanged.
52 lines
4.1 KiB
Markdown
52 lines
4.1 KiB
Markdown
# Bounded 2D implementation and validation scope
|
||
|
||
This inventory uses dev `8403956a9afc0b0bb89265cec374392013d89016` as its
|
||
production source checkpoint. The accompanying tests add coverage; their presence
|
||
is not a passing GPU receipt. Historical campaigns retain their original source
|
||
identities and acceptance gates.
|
||
|
||
## Implementation boundaries
|
||
|
||
- Uniform D2Q9 supports SRT, TRT and MRT. An available collision selector does not
|
||
qualify every wall, inlet/outlet, forcing, storage or LES combination.
|
||
- Fixed refinement supports SRT/MRT, FP32 and double-buffer streaming; TRT and LES
|
||
are rejected. Shifted refinement requires all-blocked storage. Refined channel
|
||
boundaries have narrower configuration guards than uniform boundaries.
|
||
- Uniform checkpoints support compatible same-method continuation. Changing
|
||
collision or LES parameters is a different evolution, not exact continuation.
|
||
Jet checkpoints and refined checkpoints are unsupported; synchronized remapping
|
||
is not persistent restart.
|
||
- Keep these conclusions 2D. Local D3Q19 operator tests do not establish a supported
|
||
3D Simulation runtime.
|
||
|
||
## Evidence and remaining gaps
|
||
|
||
| Area | Available evidence | Boundary of the conclusion |
|
||
|---|---|---|
|
||
| MRT cylinder flow and observation windows | Full matched uniform/refined MRT DFG and the window-ledger campaign passed their frozen periodicity, reference and matched-comparison gates. The window campaign used `185a919`; dev adds only a docstring correction. | This does not qualify other collision/boundary combinations or every refinement interface. Timing improvements are not additional accuracy evidence. |
|
||
| Uniform forced channel | Six Poiseuille GPU cases on `8403956`: SRT/TRT/MRT at wall-normal resolutions H16/H32 passed. | This is the tested analytic channel configuration, not open-boundary or all-layout qualification. |
|
||
| Uniform restart | Ten SRT/MRT checkpoint GPU tests passed on `8403956`. | The new representative TRT same-method double-buffer continuation test still requires its own GPU receipt; no LES, Jet or refined checkpoint claim follows. |
|
||
| Taylor–Green refinement | Independent topology checks for the exact TG setup are available. The companion phase regression checks the actual lattice-rate configuration. | The physical interface-accuracy gate remains open. Topology and phase setup checks do not establish convergence or close that gate. |
|
||
| Porous Couette and annulus | Prior campaign evidence exists and must remain associated with its original setup and source. | The reconstructed annulus is a validation helper, not qualification of a public boundary-condition API. Do not infer absence of evidence from a missing current rerun. |
|
||
| LES and other combinations | Separate scalar and uniform-flow normalization evidence exists for the reviewed temporary correction. | That correction is not integrated into this source checkpoint. Do not transfer its acceptance to unchanged production, or to TRT/MRT LES, forcing, EsoPull, objects or refinement. |
|
||
|
||
Historical uniform SRT cylinder-startup and inlet-rounding findings remain separate
|
||
from the passed MRT DFG result. Raw exchange/window consistency is a measurement
|
||
contract, not a general stress or force-accuracy certification. Existing source-pinned
|
||
runners may intentionally reject a newer checkout; never silently repin old receipts.
|
||
|
||
## Small next batch
|
||
|
||
1. Cross-review the added TRT checkpoint and actual-rate TG phase tests, then run
|
||
their applicable checks with exact checkout/import receipts. Preserve the
|
||
existing SRT checkpoint cases and numerical criteria.
|
||
2. Run the single added TRT checkpoint GPU case with the same method on both sides
|
||
of save/load. Record its result separately from the ten existing SRT/MRT passes.
|
||
3. Continue the existing TG accuracy investigation using its actual fine-level
|
||
rates and the established analytic convention. Keep the accuracy gate open
|
||
until the relevant physical comparison passes.
|
||
|
||
No repeat of the accepted full MRT DFG or Cartesian expansion across unsupported
|
||
combinations is required by this document. Main integration remains a separate
|
||
review of complete, bounded feature scope.
|