Files
MeltMind/review/2026-11-14/e6/independent_diagnostics.json
T

528 lines
20 KiB
JSON

{
"status": "INDEPENDENT_DIAGNOSTICS_COMPLETE_NEW_PHYSICAL_KERNEL_CANDIDATE_PENDING_DEFINITION",
"cases": [
{
"case": "00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010",
"nodes": 3606,
"tets": 18876,
"total_volume_raw": 24580.596001258757,
"layers": {
"meaning": "Resolution proxy 2*d_P1(centroid)/h_tet(centroid, normalized grad d_P1); NOT measured wall thickness or whole-wall tet layer count.",
"valid_gradient_volume_fraction": 0.9991055120050406,
"undefined_gradient_volume_fraction": 0.0008944879949594747,
"conditional_volume_weighted_quantiles": {
"0.05": 0.9473683571333633,
"0.5": 4.821936325539082,
"0.95": 16.900694210929736
},
"histogram_edges": [
0,
1,
2,
3,
4,
8,
16,
32,
"infinity"
],
"histogram_fraction_of_total_volume": [
0.08994833590736193,
0.16294670520260873,
0.11867031827337554,
0.0728331900930662,
0.2268292181703203,
0.27343070509508094,
0.0535766430267493,
0.000870396236466592
],
"limitations": [
"2*d is an inscribed-diameter proxy, not full wall thickness; P1 distance is not exact centroid distance.",
"The directional chord is across one tetrahedron, not a counted sequence through the wall.",
"Medial/junction ambiguity and zero gradients prevent a true thickness-layer interpretation; no support pass/fail imposed."
]
},
"baseline_volume_diagnostics": {
"tetra_four_point_baseline_volume": {
"field": "cached_3hop_baseline_P1_NOT_new_kernel_candidate",
"samples": 75504,
"total_volume_raw": 24580.596001258757,
"mode_volume_fraction": {
"-1": 0.0,
"0": 0.0,
"1": 0.0223897947922738,
"2": 0.010865151438177624,
"3": 0.9667450537695487
},
"spectrally_defined_volume_fraction": 1.0,
"directionally_grouped_volume_fraction": 1.0,
"relative_gap_near_cut_volume_fraction": {
"gap12": 0.014470975386273973,
"gap23": 0.045958833942763275,
"either": 0.060429809329037264
},
"gap_histogram_edges": [
0,
0.05,
0.1,
0.15,
0.25,
0.5,
0.75,
1,
"infinity"
],
"gap_histogram_volume_fraction": [
[
0.004442538325961753,
0.0064226131122158804,
0.008048362274058052,
0.0196902120828804,
0.17478132344738337,
0.5181013324557073,
0.26851361830178594,
0.0
],
[
0.007621944052695016,
0.014767850739578767,
0.03119098320318452,
0.28894952769710286,
0.49892012846407846,
0.1280661063719002,
0.030483459471488034,
0.0
]
],
"physical_support_valid_volume_fraction": null,
"quadrature_accuracy_certified": false,
"validity_scope": "Only trace>1e-10 and hard relative spectral gaps >0.1; no new physical support or quadrature quality certification."
},
"lumped_vertex_baseline_volume": {
"field": "cached_3hop_baseline_P1_NOT_new_kernel_candidate",
"samples": 3606,
"total_volume_raw": 24580.59600125876,
"mode_volume_fraction": {
"-1": 0.0,
"0": 0.0,
"1": 0.024634738904221954,
"2": 0.015464952822525923,
"3": 0.959900308273252
},
"spectrally_defined_volume_fraction": 1.0,
"directionally_grouped_volume_fraction": 0.9999999999999999,
"relative_gap_near_cut_volume_fraction": {
"gap12": 0.018554924044930282,
"gap23": 0.05775951115726645,
"either": 0.07631443520219672
},
"gap_histogram_edges": [
0,
0.05,
0.1,
0.15,
0.25,
0.5,
0.75,
1,
"infinity"
],
"gap_histogram_volume_fraction": [
[
0.004908790992213271,
0.010556161830312648,
0.007998762214617625,
0.021502680802460223,
0.18275178972918785,
0.484223429281215,
0.28805838514999266,
0.0
],
[
0.00815182343811804,
0.016482915466103913,
0.04127659569116256,
0.28757675433236546,
0.47613063246349363,
0.13539144847098789,
0.03498983013776742,
0.0
]
],
"physical_support_valid_volume_fraction": null,
"quadrature_accuracy_certified": false,
"validity_scope": "Only trace>1e-10 and hard relative spectral gaps >0.1; no new physical support or quadrature quality certification."
}
},
"new_algebraic_pose_checks": {
"proper_rotation_translation": {
"mode_flip_volume_fraction": 0.0,
"qualified_directional_volume_fraction": 1.0,
"grouped_projector_covariance_max": 3.9032866412881524e-15,
"projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 3.991707417636729e-13,
"gate_distance_error_max_raw": 5.684341886080802e-14,
"scope": "Algebraic grouped-projector/gate-vector check on cached tensor under simultaneous rigid motion; not a new mesh/estimator or model-prediction rerun."
},
"reflection_translation": {
"mode_flip_volume_fraction": 0.0,
"qualified_directional_volume_fraction": 1.0,
"grouped_projector_covariance_max": 4.261633416375889e-15,
"projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 3.4954080877721605e-13,
"gate_distance_error_max_raw": 5.684341886080802e-14,
"scope": "Algebraic grouped-projector/gate-vector check on cached tensor under simultaneous rigid motion; not a new mesh/estimator or model-prediction rerun."
}
},
"reused_independent_mesh_pose": {
"rotation": {
"tensor_max_abs_error": 1.4432899320127035e-15,
"type_change_fraction": 0.0,
"validity_change_fraction": 0.0,
"full_frame_orbit_max_error": 1.830624876022335e-14,
"normal_projector_max_error": 1.0769163338864018e-14
},
"reflection": {
"tensor_max_abs_error": 1.1657341758564144e-15,
"type_change_fraction": 0.0,
"validity_change_fraction": 0.0,
"full_frame_orbit_max_error": 2.8362966281449432e-14,
"normal_projector_max_error": 1.5709655798445965e-14
}
},
"reused_gate_pose": {
"rotation": {
"determinant": 1.0,
"gate_distance_max_error_raw": 5.684341886080802e-14,
"gate_local_orbit_error_on_spectral_pass": 3.055333763768431e-13,
"edge_local_orbit_error_raw": 5.995204332975845e-14,
"checked_edges": 1024
},
"reflection": {
"determinant": -1.0,
"gate_distance_max_error_raw": 5.684341886080802e-14,
"gate_local_orbit_error_on_spectral_pass": 3.126388037344441e-13,
"edge_local_orbit_error_raw": 4.3270942384765476e-14,
"checked_edges": 1024
}
},
"new_candidate_status": "NOT_RUN_missing_real_R_and_covariant_support_quality_definition",
"wall_seconds": 0.2870201879995875,
"peak_rss_kib_so_far": 102652
},
{
"case": "00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003",
"nodes": 27453,
"tets": 142306,
"total_volume_raw": 234.42419263842962,
"layers": {
"meaning": "Resolution proxy 2*d_P1(centroid)/h_tet(centroid, normalized grad d_P1); NOT measured wall thickness or whole-wall tet layer count.",
"valid_gradient_volume_fraction": 1.0,
"undefined_gradient_volume_fraction": 0.0,
"conditional_volume_weighted_quantiles": {
"0.05": 0.5217165040752073,
"0.5": 4.694682946146687,
"0.95": 15.82400499486197
},
"histogram_edges": [
0,
1,
2,
3,
4,
8,
16,
32,
"infinity"
],
"histogram_fraction_of_total_volume": [
0.16951958927258726,
0.11265888149161007,
0.10562904218814956,
0.06749938721179592,
0.2721760018220714,
0.22403965305997378,
0.041070665432732766,
0.007406779521078513
],
"limitations": [
"2*d is an inscribed-diameter proxy, not full wall thickness; P1 distance is not exact centroid distance.",
"The directional chord is across one tetrahedron, not a counted sequence through the wall.",
"Medial/junction ambiguity and zero gradients prevent a true thickness-layer interpretation; no support pass/fail imposed."
]
},
"baseline_volume_diagnostics": {
"tetra_four_point_baseline_volume": {
"field": "cached_3hop_baseline_P1_NOT_new_kernel_candidate",
"samples": 569224,
"total_volume_raw": 234.42419263842962,
"mode_volume_fraction": {
"-1": 0.0,
"0": 8.907077887442838e-06,
"1": 0.18547493537322723,
"2": 0.008554772019863446,
"3": 0.8059613855290216
},
"spectrally_defined_volume_fraction": 1.0,
"directionally_grouped_volume_fraction": 0.9999910929221124,
"relative_gap_near_cut_volume_fraction": {
"gap12": 0.019638046516259763,
"gap23": 0.20309789373462156,
"either": 0.22266693623035394
},
"gap_histogram_edges": [
0,
0.05,
0.1,
0.15,
0.25,
0.5,
0.75,
1,
"infinity"
],
"gap_histogram_volume_fraction": [
[
0.0018787589699147515,
0.006684920127836135,
0.01295312638842362,
0.05441316860414608,
0.3439489927324591,
0.3633772268932226,
0.21674380628399811,
0.0
],
[
0.07235023540218032,
0.11313360704893431,
0.08996428668568708,
0.1550622607427534,
0.3704925432179724,
0.18707441647541118,
0.011922650427061598,
0.0
]
],
"physical_support_valid_volume_fraction": null,
"quadrature_accuracy_certified": false,
"validity_scope": "Only trace>1e-10 and hard relative spectral gaps >0.1; no new physical support or quadrature quality certification."
}
},
"new_algebraic_pose_checks": {
"proper_rotation_translation": {
"mode_flip_volume_fraction": 0.0,
"qualified_directional_volume_fraction": 1.0,
"grouped_projector_covariance_max": 6.044935617013828e-15,
"projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 7.70443585549395e-14,
"gate_distance_error_max_raw": 1.0658141036401503e-14,
"scope": "Algebraic grouped-projector/gate-vector check on cached tensor under simultaneous rigid motion; not a new mesh/estimator or model-prediction rerun."
},
"reflection_translation": {
"mode_flip_volume_fraction": 0.0,
"qualified_directional_volume_fraction": 1.0,
"grouped_projector_covariance_max": 5.950879080884568e-15,
"projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 9.880975563347459e-14,
"gate_distance_error_max_raw": 7.105427357601002e-15,
"scope": "Algebraic grouped-projector/gate-vector check on cached tensor under simultaneous rigid motion; not a new mesh/estimator or model-prediction rerun."
}
},
"reused_independent_mesh_pose": {
"rotation": {
"tensor_max_abs_error": 2.609024107869118e-15,
"type_change_fraction": 0.0,
"validity_change_fraction": 0.0,
"full_frame_orbit_max_error": 3.759633848874784e-14,
"normal_projector_max_error": 2.353672812205332e-14
},
"reflection": {
"tensor_max_abs_error": 2.1649348980190553e-15,
"type_change_fraction": 0.0,
"validity_change_fraction": 0.0,
"full_frame_orbit_max_error": 4.166984602084288e-14,
"normal_projector_max_error": 2.808864252301646e-14
}
},
"reused_gate_pose": {
"rotation": {
"determinant": 1.0,
"gate_distance_max_error_raw": 1.0658141036401503e-14,
"gate_local_orbit_error_on_spectral_pass": 6.927791673660977e-14,
"edge_local_orbit_error_raw": 4.08006961549745e-15,
"checked_edges": 1024
},
"reflection": {
"determinant": -1.0,
"gate_distance_max_error_raw": 7.105427357601002e-15,
"gate_local_orbit_error_on_spectral_pass": 9.50350909079134e-14,
"edge_local_orbit_error_raw": 3.677613769070831e-15,
"checked_edges": 1024
}
},
"new_candidate_status": "NOT_RUN_missing_real_R_and_covariant_support_quality_definition",
"wall_seconds": 1.6569163389794994,
"peak_rss_kib_so_far": 113280
},
{
"case": "00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000",
"nodes": 187345,
"tets": 1045371,
"total_volume_raw": 31155.870302547413,
"layers": {
"meaning": "Resolution proxy 2*d_P1(centroid)/h_tet(centroid, normalized grad d_P1); NOT measured wall thickness or whole-wall tet layer count.",
"valid_gradient_volume_fraction": 1.0,
"undefined_gradient_volume_fraction": 0.0,
"conditional_volume_weighted_quantiles": {
"0.05": 1.0000004801484017,
"0.5": 9.334565451372226,
"0.95": 18.54707516081803
},
"histogram_edges": [
0,
1,
2,
3,
4,
8,
16,
32,
"infinity"
],
"histogram_fraction_of_total_volume": [
0.0352040601268696,
0.06765364714828881,
0.0715593578449531,
0.03683520698144036,
0.21646356447821366,
0.3989000637921128,
0.17332869605508744,
5.5403573033623215e-05
],
"limitations": [
"2*d is an inscribed-diameter proxy, not full wall thickness; P1 distance is not exact centroid distance.",
"The directional chord is across one tetrahedron, not a counted sequence through the wall.",
"Medial/junction ambiguity and zero gradients prevent a true thickness-layer interpretation; no support pass/fail imposed."
]
},
"baseline_volume_diagnostics": {
"tetra_four_point_baseline_volume": {
"field": "cached_3hop_baseline_P1_NOT_new_kernel_candidate",
"samples": 4181484,
"total_volume_raw": 31155.870302547413,
"mode_volume_fraction": {
"-1": 0.0,
"0": 0.0,
"1": 0.7998295434530444,
"2": 0.0,
"3": 0.20017045654695578
},
"spectrally_defined_volume_fraction": 1.0,
"directionally_grouped_volume_fraction": 1.0000000000000002,
"relative_gap_near_cut_volume_fraction": {
"gap12": 0.0,
"gap23": 0.26647086849714685,
"either": 0.26647086849714685
},
"gap_histogram_edges": [
0,
0.05,
0.1,
0.15,
0.25,
0.5,
0.75,
1,
"infinity"
],
"gap_histogram_volume_fraction": [
[
0.0,
0.0,
0.0,
1.0233638339284066e-06,
0.002968557934689977,
0.036130033786413475,
0.9606736233257417,
0.00022676158932187116
],
[
0.6624122344021264,
0.1374173090509175,
0.12905355944622912,
0.03595299798748548,
0.03304626571443394,
0.0021173451635762516,
2.882352299220428e-07,
0.0
]
],
"physical_support_valid_volume_fraction": null,
"quadrature_accuracy_certified": false,
"validity_scope": "Only trace>1e-10 and hard relative spectral gaps >0.1; no new physical support or quadrature quality certification."
}
},
"new_algebraic_pose_checks": {
"proper_rotation_translation": {
"mode_flip_volume_fraction": 0.0,
"qualified_directional_volume_fraction": 0.9999999999999999,
"grouped_projector_covariance_max": 5.3325388365101155e-15,
"projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 3.1036975184181237e-13,
"gate_distance_error_max_raw": 4.263256414560601e-14,
"scope": "Algebraic grouped-projector/gate-vector check on cached tensor under simultaneous rigid motion; not a new mesh/estimator or model-prediction rerun."
},
"reflection_translation": {
"mode_flip_volume_fraction": 0.0,
"qualified_directional_volume_fraction": 0.9999999999999999,
"grouped_projector_covariance_max": 6.1976880065799136e-15,
"projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 3.3918765201336205e-13,
"gate_distance_error_max_raw": 4.263256414560601e-14,
"scope": "Algebraic grouped-projector/gate-vector check on cached tensor under simultaneous rigid motion; not a new mesh/estimator or model-prediction rerun."
}
},
"reused_independent_mesh_pose": {
"rotation": {
"tensor_max_abs_error": 6.8833827526759706e-15,
"type_change_fraction": 0.0,
"validity_change_fraction": 0.0,
"full_frame_orbit_max_error": 1.3028249594122693e-14,
"normal_projector_max_error": 5.329070518200751e-15
},
"reflection": {
"tensor_max_abs_error": 5.88418203051333e-15,
"type_change_fraction": 0.0,
"validity_change_fraction": 0.0,
"full_frame_orbit_max_error": 1.2012177353437704e-14,
"normal_projector_max_error": 5.6066262743570405e-15
}
},
"reused_gate_pose": {
"rotation": {
"determinant": 1.0,
"gate_distance_max_error_raw": 4.263256414560601e-14,
"gate_local_orbit_error_on_spectral_pass": 2.1804780203638074e-13,
"edge_local_orbit_error_raw": 2.1815882433884326e-14,
"checked_edges": 1024
},
"reflection": {
"determinant": -1.0,
"gate_distance_max_error_raw": 4.263256414560601e-14,
"gate_local_orbit_error_on_spectral_pass": 2.2737367544323206e-13,
"edge_local_orbit_error_raw": 1.8762769116165146e-14,
"checked_edges": 1024
}
},
"new_candidate_status": "NOT_RUN_missing_real_R_and_covariant_support_quality_definition",
"wall_seconds": 9.810110502003226,
"peak_rss_kib_so_far": 232544
}
],
"wall_seconds": 11.757592656998895,
"peak_rss_kib": 232544,
"new_real_kernel_estimates": 0,
"new_distance_queries": 0,
"new_geometry_meshes": 0,
"new_baseline_volume_estimates": 4,
"training": false,
"O1": false,
"O2A_rerun": false,
"O2B": false,
"O2S": false
}