Files
MeltMind/docs/o1-v2-panel-stop-results-2026-11-17.md
T

11 KiB
Raw Blame History

O1 v2:同60件预检未达到共同几何覆盖门

2026-11-17 05:35:31 Asia/Shanghai,唯一队列已停止,实际协调541230及全部O1 worker消失。原始终态为 V2_PANEL_IDENTIFIABILITY_STOP,global_stop=null、monitor_errors=[]、accounting_complete=true。systemd保留真实ExecMainPID541230/exit1及开始/结束时间;exit1是预定科学门停止,不是基础设施故障。无重试、参数放宽、第三版设计、后续几何或拟合。

预定检查 实际结果 门槛 结论
件级共同几何合格 E/60 14/60 = 23.3333% ≥80% 未过
合格件两接口同时达标 H/E 14/14 = 100% 严格>70% 通过
全60中同时合格且达标 H/60 14/60 = 23.3333% 描述项 —
面板组件完整配对 2/21 = 9.5238% ≥80% 未过
配对组件两接口均值达标 2/2 = 100% 严格>70% 通过

21是此非随机调度面板实际出现的组件数,不是全库209。组件只有面板内所有出现件均合格才配对,先分别平均两接口再等权计数;同组件未入面板成员完整列于panel-feasibility.json。原60包含v1全部11不合格、3中止,无替换。不能把14/14当全库成功率,也未运行完整209组件门。

资格失败与干预分开解释

60个工程guard全部PASS,科学结果14PASS+46INELIGIBLE,每件恰好G/T/C三次seed0调用,共180次,无候选挑选。所有60都有三臂接口差异。12件至少一臂实际体积平衡不合格:G4件、T3件、C6件,其中1件G/C同时失败。其余48件三臂单独物理条件通过,其中34件三臂互检不合格。互检失败维度可重叠:15件排序体积分数配对差越界、22件切面面积max/min>1.25、2件排序直径max/min>1.25;不是39个不同件。48件可计算三臂互检中,原±5%口径通过0件;其余12件的三臂互检未计算,已因单臂物理条件失败而不合格。此项仅描述,不替换v2判据。

在14件共同合格子集,TG和TC接口差均≥0.10,说明本次类型面权确能形成接口干预;覆盖不足使预定实验无法在此共同域继续。v2同时改生成目标与形状界,不能用v1/v2差分别归因两项。接口改变不等于预测改善;没有训练或预测收益结果。结论限定为此数据、K8、固定类型/读出与一次v2干预未达到预定可辨识条件,不否定所有类型、拓扑或真实连通路线。

固定来源、审计与费用

主审Claude1794863409/h-2e3bd8ed;完整Mold规格SHA632688217e59dd134922245e524ff1c0f63933be64600be21379f7aa74947a5f。实现a946adfb0222998be9b6d68776239a0afc26c164,合同90caf09948fe2b0cc51c54c7cf87986f5daaa86f222dd2d1cf231bf5bc70a874,原60名单c4193a57dc2fa942ffe3e87f7f23c885f2caa5aa83509cf7ecb110e700b935d3,门结果5b82bf8a13b353533db3f575080396e35e6f764d2da457296efb06734e0b774a。源码/合同/名单独立远端HTTP哈希读回PASS。14项合成通过;终态只读审计逐件回执、输出指纹与全部552数组SHA通过,source pins PASS,不重新解码、分区、拟合或改原记录。

新60 worker369.598083CPU秒;含旧账/新合成/metadata预留的队列累计1001.411572CPU秒,加独立只读审计guard2.960984,最终累计1004.372556/43200CPU秒。guard75.679929091、协调34.662186425另列。科学队列墙钟134.481641秒。原v1全部60记录及625.377883费用一次保留,原失败不被v2替换。

551其余可准备件从未尝试,6原缺特征仍保留;全库617/209身份不变。没有标签解码、模型、预测或评分。按主审停止此尺度,不进入全库准备或O1拟合,不请求重复go。交Claude/Mold按既有阶段规则统一回顾;R4bc独立原队列不因本结果改变。

原始文件根artifacts/o1-v2-preparation-2026-11-17:panel-parts.csv/json含每件状态、原组件、三接口、体积/面积/直径、成本及指纹;panel-feasibility.json含全部组件和未入面板同组件成员;parts含全部图、面权、置换、分区、读出、日志和失败;panel-independent-audit.json、terminal-process-audit.json、final-cost-ledger.json保存独立核验。小型审阅证据与完整原始数组按顺序发布,远端完成状态以发布回执为准。

R4bc05:36只读快照:原521868在,626终态=625PASS+原job90,fit78795.511600CPU秒;无新失败/globalstop/monitorerror,batch未终态。没有改动其代码、队列或预算。

60件表

件号 科学状态 原因 TG TC GC
3 INELIGIBLE V2_ARM_GEOMETRY_FAIL 0.959389 0.969157 0.950021
4 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.938932 0.956475 0.890804
6 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.986131 0.963119 0.994069
8 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.977439 0.981929 0.970897
9 PASS — 0.981939 0.985839 0.974126
11 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.982817 0.978935 0.961219
21 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.988602 0.979286 0.976240
23 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.953148 0.960676 0.966580
24 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.937219 0.956768 0.941372
30 PASS — 0.972604 0.988063 0.970652
31 PASS — 0.971742 0.979080 0.972552
49 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.940245 0.950702 0.895279
57 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.975084 0.964305 0.961720
58 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.976378 0.980848 0.971634
60 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.976667 0.985516 0.975863
61 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.969663 0.980243 0.969943
65 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.939638 0.923456 0.933062
66 INELIGIBLE V2_ARM_GEOMETRY_FAIL 0.973352 0.976801 0.986344
67 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.968228 0.973679 0.985155
68 INELIGIBLE V2_ARM_GEOMETRY_FAIL 0.945616 0.944527 0.932326
70 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.886098 0.940046 0.842099
72 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.894072 0.953269 0.910502
77 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.969441 0.976787 0.977935
78 INELIGIBLE V2_ARM_GEOMETRY_FAIL 0.942246 0.953537 0.912041
79 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.994816 0.993057 0.983050
87 PASS — 0.945725 0.919835 0.904625
88 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.993851 0.966514 0.970901
93 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.996086 0.985216 0.983268
98 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.979501 0.989453 0.984031
102 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.981619 0.972397 0.973374
103 INELIGIBLE V2_ARM_GEOMETRY_FAIL 0.927603 0.921479 0.843601
104 PASS — 0.978527 0.980992 0.992298
105 INELIGIBLE V2_ARM_GEOMETRY_FAIL 0.966062 0.969933 0.969651
106 INELIGIBLE V2_ARM_GEOMETRY_FAIL 0.960982 0.989365 0.950500
111 PASS — 0.958079 0.979769 0.995533
115 PASS — 0.981213 0.983383 0.978343
116 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.965578 0.967122 0.936732
117 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.962536 0.961935 0.936314
119 PASS — 0.966558 0.975987 0.977738
120 PASS — 0.911760 0.959311 0.931078
125 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.860562 0.939012 0.920277
128 PASS — 0.989857 0.972685 0.990063
129 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.995791 0.979968 0.991720
130 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.991578 0.991644 0.977001
131 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 1.000000 0.988998 0.992075
132 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.999260 0.996466 1.000000
133 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.999809 0.997062 0.979793
140 PASS — 0.973255 0.973742 0.965248
142 INELIGIBLE V2_ARM_GEOMETRY_FAIL 0.975759 0.993503 0.969304
144 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.949126 0.962119 0.953607
145 INELIGIBLE V2_ARM_GEOMETRY_FAIL 0.980273 0.978753 0.959429
152 PASS — 0.985087 0.988102 0.972071
153 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.973625 0.992558 0.990132
154 INELIGIBLE V2_ARM_GEOMETRY_FAIL 0.955661 0.962046 0.947215
157 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.968662 0.967113 0.925952
161 PASS — 0.974258 0.961065 0.959636
162 PASS — 0.947053 0.965062 0.965527
163 INELIGIBLE V2_ARM_GEOMETRY_FAIL 0.973711 0.954484 0.957142
164 INELIGIBLE V2_TRIPLE_MATCH_FAIL 0.965808 0.951004 0.939523
165 INELIGIBLE V2_ARM_GEOMETRY_FAIL 0.962156 0.941868 0.938477

逐件约束失败分解(原结果只读派生)

12件单臂物理体积失败之后,三臂互检未执行;这些件的其他互检维度是未检验,不记通过。34件互检失败可在多维同时越界,下表不去重删除失败。

件号 实际失败约束
3 T: GeometryFailure: PHYSICAL_VOLUME_BALANCE
4 cut area max/min >1.25
6 cut area max/min >1.25
8 pair volume >0.025;cut area max/min >1.25
11 pair volume >0.025
21 cut area max/min >1.25
23 cut area max/min >1.25
24 pair volume >0.025
49 cut area max/min >1.25
57 cut area max/min >1.25
58 pair volume >0.025
60 pair volume >0.025
61 pair volume >0.025
65 cut area max/min >1.25
66 C: GeometryFailure: PHYSICAL_VOLUME_BALANCE
67 pair volume >0.025
68 G: GeometryFailure: PHYSICAL_VOLUME_BALANCE
70 pair volume >0.025
72 cut area max/min >1.25
77 sorted diameter max/min >1.25
78 C: GeometryFailure: PHYSICAL_VOLUME_BALANCE
79 sorted diameter max/min >1.25
88 cut area max/min >1.25
93 pair volume >0.025
98 cut area max/min >1.25
102 pair volume >0.025
103 G: GeometryFailure: PHYSICAL_VOLUME_BALANCE
105 G: GeometryFailure: PHYSICAL_VOLUME_BALANCE; C: GeometryFailure: PHYSICAL_VOLUME_BALANCE
106 T: GeometryFailure: PHYSICAL_VOLUME_BALANCE
116 cut area max/min >1.25
117 cut area max/min >1.25
125 pair volume >0.025
129 pair volume >0.025;cut area max/min >1.25
130 cut area max/min >1.25
131 cut area max/min >1.25
132 pair volume >0.025;cut area max/min >1.25
133 cut area max/min >1.25
142 C: GeometryFailure: PHYSICAL_VOLUME_BALANCE
144 pair volume >0.025;cut area max/min >1.25
145 T: GeometryFailure: PHYSICAL_VOLUME_BALANCE
153 cut area max/min >1.25
154 G: GeometryFailure: PHYSICAL_VOLUME_BALANCE
157 pair volume >0.025;cut area max/min >1.25
163 C: GeometryFailure: PHYSICAL_VOLUME_BALANCE
164 cut area max/min >1.25
165 C: GeometryFailure: PHYSICAL_VOLUME_BALANCE

Claude1794864979.171309已接受按预裁量停止,下一步仅本逐件分解/最终审计及R4bc原队列全池/INTERIM_100精确比对,再由Claude统一写阶段收束与建议。本报告将结论限定为规定构造与匹配门在此面板不足,不推断其他所有K8构造不可能。

完整原始证据发布完成

原单次push59077退出0,完整552数组/1,457,411,422B固定e7fa46da9b393c49a5ab29e2d040c30f1d9253e5。远端ref与完整文件清单核验通过;首件G分区、末件C分区与审计文件独立HTTP/SHA核验通过,不声称完整1.46GB二次下载。详见raw-publication-complete.json。此前小型审阅入口53d95182已获Claude1794865219接受;科学与逐件结果不变,旧±5%口径明确为48件可计算互检/12件未计算。Claude关于面积匹配可能约束干预的设计启示保留为推断与未来建议,未据此开启新试验。