5.3 KiB
Stage research plan (Claude, 2026-11-18)
Yanqi's direction (via TRON, 2026-11-18): keep the current plan; aim first for SOTA on 3D benchmarks (industrial use is a bonus); research graph-network history and frontier, pretraining, similar-physics data, sensible later use of RL; investigate procedural generation of many molding simulations; use GINO and Greif data first and try to beat their results. Comparisons must be same task, same data, fair split. Data generation / pretraining / RL are directions to explore, not validated or authorised expensive jobs.
Undermind deep searches (workspace "Injection Molding Hele Shell Manifold Neural Solvers", folder /phase3 research plan 2026-11-18/): (1) programmatic generation of large molding simulation datasets; (2) graph / neural-operator surrogates on 3D meshes, history, frontier and pretraining; (3) RL with physics simulators for manufacturing and data acquisition.
Tracks
| Track | Question | First step (owner) | Gate before anything expensive |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Greif SOTA | Does H2 beat Gre24 on Gre24's own protocol? Our grouped protocol is stricter, so the paper's numbers (Table C.6: 3.38 % median RRMSE at 100 trees / depth 8; 3.31 % at depth 6, the lowest in that table; MeltAssist 2026-11-18) are not comparable with ours. The exact split seed is not published, so Track A compares A and H2 on the same re-created split(s), never against the paper number alone | Phase 3 continues unchanged (item 1 running). MeltAssist: extract Gre24's exact split, metric and reported numbers. MeltAstra: then evaluate A and H2 on that protocol | Reproduction of Gre24's own number on its protocol first (we have 3.96 % on v4) |
| B. GINO benchmark | Does our mesh model match or beat GINO and later SOTA on GINO's public 3D tasks (ShapeNet car pressure 500/111; Ahmed body 500/51)? | MeltAssist: verify data sources, splits, metrics and the current reported SOTA table. MeltAstra: download, reproduce the GINO baseline | Reproduce a published baseline within its reported error before claiming anything |
| C. Data generation | Can we generate thousands of filling simulations cheaply enough and faithfully enough? | Deep search 1 + MoldAstra: a fidelity ladder (eikonal proxy → Hele-Shaw / 2.5D → open-source 3D VOF → commercial) with cost per part. Question to Yanqi: is a Moldflow or Moldex3D licence available? Greif's own data came from scripted Moldflow 2023, which is the fastest faithful route | A pilot on about 10 Greif parts comparing the generator with the Moldflow labels, with a pre-registered fidelity threshold |
| D. Pretraining | Does pretraining (synthetic labels from C, or self-supervised geometry) improve H2 on Greif at equal fine-tune budget? | MoldAstra: evaluation design (equal compute, same splits). Self-supervised geometry pretraining needs no generator and can be tested first | Only after phase-3 item 1 shows a data limit, or after C passes its fidelity gate |
| E. RL | Where does RL add value over Bayesian optimisation / active learning? | Deep search 3 only. Candidate later uses: choosing which simulations to run (active learning), gate placement as a downstream application | No RL job until a generator exists |
Order
- Now: phase 3 continues (item 1 → seed 1 → c → b → ensemble). Literature (deep searches, MeltAssist synthesis), Track A and B protocol extraction, and Track C/D specs proceed on paper in parallel.
- Next compute after item 1: Track A on Gre24's protocol (cheap), then Track B GINO reproduction.
- Tracks C/D pilots only after their gates and the licence answer.
Update after MeltAssist synthesis (2026-11-18, parts 1-3)
- Track A protocol frozen: five independent random 314/315 splits (our published seeds; protocol-level re-creation), per-part RMSE / max(full truth) proxy, min/median/max over test parts averaged over splits; A and H2 paired on the same splits; family leakage of random splits reported.
- Track B frozen: original GINO decoder protocol only (ShapeNet 611, 500/111; Ahmed 551, 500/51; de-normalised relative L2). Targets: GINO 7.12 % / 8.31 % and same-protocol results confirmed by MeltAssist; other splits in a context table. ShapeNet data (Zenodo 13936501) pre-authorised after the ID-mapping check; Ahmed on hold until the original 551 source is confirmed. Reproduce GINO with the paper recipe first.
- Track C evidence: batch Moldflow automation is proven (Greif; Per23: 1,080 runs, about 22 min/run, 3 geometries). openInjMoldSim's high-fidelity example cost 34 h on 192 cores, so open-source 3D VOF is not a cheap mass generator. Report independent geometries and conditions separately, and acceptance rate and total cost per valid label.
- Track D evidence: GeoPT (13,463 ShapeNet geometries × random dynamics fields, no CFD labels; 144-576 GPU-h) reports 20-60 % label savings on several 3D tasks (not molding). Geometry-only pretraining is therefore the first D arm, compared with scratch at equal fine-tune budget, pretraining cost reported separately.
- Track E: RL evidence (Kim25 surrogate-environment process optimisation; Sza22 VARTM layup) is narrow and not thermoplastic filling; stays literature-only until a trusted environment exists.
- Idle GPUs: approved queue items may use GPUs that item 1 does not need, each after its own review: Track A H2 first, then seed 1.