4.2 KiB
B16: fixed generic context plus H1 residual target
Result: PRUNE_FIXED_COMBINATION_RECIPE. The fixed combination did not establish an incremental field-error benefit over E1b G: new minus G is +0.000137853675176, with descriptive component-paired 95% CI [-0.000514895143340, +0.000794656740248]. The prespecified primary requirement was an upper endpoint below zero. This is failure of this fixed recipe gate, not equivalence or a refutation of context, residual learning, topology or connectivity. E1b's earlier generic-context result remains unchanged.
Stored results
All 552 test parts / 204 components are retained, including 42 invalid G readouts as native NaN. Five fresh fits and all predictions completed in the original root; the reviewed continuation scored those same predictions once. No new fit, prediction, geometry, label decoding, GPU work or retry occurred. Bootstrap: 2000 paired component replicates, seed 2026111408, zero undefined replicates.
| Comparator | Metric | New mean | Comparator mean | New minus comparator | 95% CI |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| G | relative_l2 | 0.06984006798 | 0.0697022143049 | +0.000137853675176 | [-0.00051489514334, +0.000794656740248] |
| G | last_location | 0.348920590302 | 0.387589687577 | -0.0386690972757 | [-0.0902848177246, +0.00402435581842] |
| G | kendall_tau_b | 0.926965260775 | 0.928112243828 | -0.00114698305206 | [-0.00185655087487, -0.000447206669534] |
| A | relative_l2 | 0.06984006798 | 0.0708305408206 | -0.000990472840577 | [-0.00214717081401, +0.000265497906897] |
| A | last_location | 0.348920590302 | 0.376713807712 | -0.0277932174102 | [-0.0830660964936, +0.0242352831725] |
| A | kendall_tau_b | 0.926965260775 | 0.926649719537 | +0.000315541238657 | [-0.00122353850177, +0.00171721860415] |
Field and last-location errors favor negative differences; Kendall tau favors positive differences. Relative to G, last-location CI crosses zero, while tau is lower with its full interval below zero. All three comparisons against A cross zero. These secondary results do not replace the frozen primary gate. The output retains 860 negative predicted query values; no clipping or post-hoc recalibration was introduced.
Execution and review provenance
Score-only root: /home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase2-b16-reviewed-score-2026-11-17. Coordinator 645014 and worker 645021 exited; score guard PASS, CPU 5.20172 s, wall 5.783341419 s, peak tree RSS 182153216 bytes. Final cumulative cost including terminal freeze: 1210.733413603000 / 7200 CPU-s, including original 1145.034677694 once and 60 s engineering setup reserve.
Original root remains STOPPED / RuntimeError: RESOURCE_OR_SIGNAL_STOP after the expressly approved idle retirement, with all ten fit/predict guards PASS. This is engineering retirement, not scientific or numerical failure. It received no score authorization and contains no score output.
Original 34fd7b46272b6a2e09469815b5015c3f9ca6f885 / contract a6841b59 and repair 72d45697b4dba17f133acf1a05a76a39c163f82b remain fixed. Assist PASS SHA 8cdd3ff42f57ea1b6005e8ce47815edcc59dbc856af502328dfc7463bc5f2eb1 was verified and frozen before scoring. The four repair sources were unchanged. Claude 1794913563 revised the requirement to pre-score identity validation only; terminal hash checks are a post-hoc audit, not another gate. Earlier NEEDS receipts remain preserved. The v2 drafts were not authorized or executed. See phase2-b16-score-gate-wording-erratum-2026-11-17.md.
Launch commit 43d0817b29672e06fc2e6ebc0f9d5266a9919e5d; terminal commit 2635a9bfb75875171b220c0c189d9f40167de9ea. Result SHA256 343d11bd930819253100e3811aa051d272f72ec885d7f257825cab2e182d78b1. Local source/prediction/contract hashes and every reused prediction were checked after completion without recomputing metrics. Assist's review covers implementation, not independent numerical replication or utility. Remote Git publication remains pending the existing transport ruling; local fixed evidence is not called a remote backup.
Stage boundary
Submit this actual result and preserved engineering limitations to Claude for the existing stage review. No additional model, tuning, scoring or new hypothesis test follows automatically. H2 remains the original authorized running task; B14/B15/E2 completed results remain immutable.