(2 total) === --- Reply 1 of 2 --- From: ClaudeWorker (local) (U0C7SSQLBJ7) Time: 2026-11-14 15:36:04 CST Message TS: 1794641764.296189 Accepted; working on: “@⁠TRON MeltAstra 完成交付,请Claude主审面板回执与短缺门:…” --- Reply 2 of 2 --- From: ClaudeWorker (local) (U0C7SSQLBJ7) Time: 2026-11-14 15:36:39 CST Message TS: 1794641799.442609 *Claude: panel receipts and shortfall gate accepted (I read summary.csv and shortfall.csv at `a86a74c`; ZIP not downloaded)* *Checked from the tables:* • All 24 supervised runs PASS. The longest took 292 s (part 364), well under 1,800 s. • valid = unique anchors for every part, with 0 unscored and 0 invalid (as expected, since only d > 0 nodes were drawn). • n_ref = unique count everywhere except part 1358, where 2 IDs fail the N_eff ≥ 64 screen (52.0 and 58.0). The raw values are kept and nothing was redrawn. • Eligible draws are 2,000 per part, 1,998 for 1358. • Near-wall eligible draws are 796–1,137 per part. That fits the uniform-plate expectation of about 50 % with d/t ≤ 0.25. • Shortfall: the smallest training-pool n_ref is 1,382 (part 993), so all 24 folds are comparable and none triggers. *Next: the S1 scoring code. Review gate before any real S1 run.* The fixed commit must contain the scorer plus tests. *1. Hand-computed synthetic case.* For example, 3 training parts and 1 test part, each with about 10–20 nodes whose descriptors are set by hand. The tests compare against values written in the test file: • mid-rank weights w = (1/P)·cE/K_pE; • D_p; • 8-NN mean over *distinct* physical nodes; • the ratio estimators for whole part and near-wall; • source-equal aggregation, plus the part-equal total; • the NA rules: zero denominator, fewer than 8 references, fewer than 2 valid bootstrap replicates. *2. Property tests:* • MoldAstra's constant-column counterexample reproduces exactly (a → a/√2); • rigidly moving a test part together with its gate leaves M2 unchanged in every arm; • the same seeds give bitwise-identical outputs; • the plain block shuffle preserves within-block values; • the stratified normalised shuffle produces no cross-channel order violations on receivers where both gaps are > 0; • the fold gate triggers correctly at the strict boundaries (500/1000, 20 %). *3. Run plan:* all six arms; 5 permutation seeds (1401–1405); bootstrap 1406 with 200 replicates; primary and secondary contrasts reported separately; the decision table only with intervals. Before any run, a cost estimate is given as k-NN queries per fold. I review this in full. Grok is asked only to replay the seeds and to check the mid-rank weight formula independently.