# S2 design v0.2: rulings on MeltAstra's execution diff (Claude, 2026-11-14) Integrates MeltAstra's `docs/s2-execution-diff-v0-2026-11-14.md` (codex/s2-execution-diff-20261114 @ c35b02d9). The diff is adopted except where a ruling below says otherwise. Prior versions (v0 d8aa0f42, v0.1 fd1db63e, v0.1a 4e435a03) stand unless amended here. No computation or training starts without Yanqi's explicit go. ## R1. Target scale (D1) The log scale τ is fitted separately for each (outer fold, budget pool), on that learning pool only. A larger pool never supplies the scale for a smaller one. ## R2. Splits (D2) - **Components:** source key ∪ confirmed near-duplicate evidence edges, following MoldAstra note14. - The rule must be frozen before the candidate list is regenerated. - Unresolved pairs that could change the grouping put S2 on HOLD. - **Outer folds:** 5, over components, with a fixed label-free ordering and seed 2026111409. - **Inner validation:** a fixed 20 % of each outer fold's non-test components (adopted). The 25/50/100 % pools are nested prefixes of the remaining learning pool. Checkpoints and HPO see inner validation only. - **development_exposed:** the S1 panel and the previously diagnosed parts are flagged. The main table keeps the pre-registered 5 folds. Exposed and unexposed subsets are reported as a secondary breakdown. There is no separate untouched set. ## R3. Target domain and eligibility (D3) - **Primary domain:** commonly eligible nodes in the d > 0 PPS draw. Statements are restricted to this domain and never called whole-part results. - **S2 common eligibility:** - d > 0; - O2 spectrum valid; - N_eff ≥ 64; - edge block complete and finite (needed by arm E, and therefore applied to every arm). The S1 gate-direction requirement is **dropped**: gate q is not an S2 input. This is recorded as a difference from S1. - **Draws:** the frozen S1 draws are reused for the 24 panel parts. New parts get the same rule, with seed [2026111400, prefix]. The 2,000 queries are fixed per part and not refreshed per epoch. - **Per-part error (adopted):** e_p = sqrt(Σ c E (T̂−T)² / Σ c E T²). No second mass factor. A zero denominator is NA with a reason. - **Aggregation:** parts are equally weighted within a component, components equally weighted overall. Source-key weighting is descriptive only. - **Coverage table per part:** h, draws, distinct IDs, K, K/2000, h·K/2000, the near-wall share, 1−h, and rejection reasons. - "Last-filled region" and Kendall τ are defined only over the query coverage, and are labelled that way. ## R4. Connectivity bottleneck metric (D8): deferred It needs predictions on the full tet graph, plus full-node O2 for arm E, and neither is in S2's budget. No substitutes are allowed: no ground-truth infill, no query-induced graphs, no zero-filled O2. It moves to a later full-field evaluation stage. The thin slice follows v0.1a. ## R5. Baselines and backbone (D4/D5) - **R2 = "R2-G, Gre24-style approximation".** - Features, as listed in the diff §5.1: - (x−x̄)/R_g; - d/t_part; - ‖x−gate‖/R_g; - ℓ_g/R_g, where ℓ_g is the tet-edge Dijkstra distance from the gate's nearest node; - R_g, V, t_part. - This is **not** called a Gre24 reproduction. - Grok gets one targeted task: Gre24's exact feature list and its eikonal setup. If a feature can be matched cheaply, it is added before the freeze; R2-E (eikonal) is otherwise deferred. - **GBRT:** sklearn HistGradientBoostingRegressor with sample_weight. Weights make components equal, parts equal within a component, and use draw counts within a part. - A fixed HPO grid of at most 12 configurations, selected on inner validation. - With a fixed random_state it is deterministic, so it is counted as **15 independent fits** (5 folds x 3 pools), not 45. - **N/E backbone:** primary candidate is Transolver (thuml, MIT) as the whole-part encoder on all tet nodes with the non-O2 base inputs. Backup is GINO (neuraloperator, MIT). - The query decoder is an MLP over [node embedding, g12, g23] for N and [..., 4 edge q] for E. - Query nodes are mesh nodes, so no interpolation is needed. - The licence and the exact commit are checked before the pilot. - Two capacity tiers are pre-registered (width 128 and width 256, 4 layers), chosen on inner validation. The same tier is used for N and E. ## R6. Statistics (D6) - **Primary contrast (single):** Δ = 1 − Ē_E / Ē_N. - Measured at the 100 % pool, whole primary domain. - Ē is the component-equal error averaged over 3 matched seeds. - m = 10 %, now frozen. - The six-region table applies. - **Interval:** bootstrap over components, with matched seed blocks kept intact. - 2,000 replicates, seed 2026111408, two-sided 95 % percentile. - Both arms are recomputed on the same indices before the ratio is taken. - Stated limitation: overlapping training sets and fixed folds are not resampled. - **Secondary** (reported, no gate, no multiplicity claim): the 25 % and 50 % pools, the near-wall slice, the exposed/unexposed split, Kendall τ. - **R2 usefulness:** report Δ_N/R2 and Δ_E/R2 with the same machinery. The neural route is called useful only if N's lower bound against R2 is > 0. - The query-level Monte Carlo error is not merged into the model-generalisation interval. ## R7. Resources (D7) - **Preprocessing:** before any corpus-wide run, MeltAstra measures a 10-part stratified sample. It covers decode, d/t_part, ℓ_g, the draw, the O2 count and the O2 kernel, with CPU time, RSS and disk recorded for each part. The full-corpus table then lists cases above the limits. Limits stay at 30 min / 1.25 GiB per part; no part is swapped. - **Pilot:** - one outer fold, the 100 % pool, one seed, N and E, both capacity tiers; - at most 4 runs, at most 2 GPU-h in total, one V100 16 GB, FP16 AMP with FP32 loss and normalisation; - test fold sealed. - Exceeding a limit means stop and report; nothing is shrunk silently. - **Full matrix accounting:** 90 neural runs + 15 R2 fits + HPO + pilot + reruns, all counted. GPU-h is computed only from pilot measurements. ## R8. Extensions (not in S2 v0.2) - **N0 (an arm without O2):** conditional. It is added only if Yanqi wants the value of the whole O2 block tested; that costs 45 more neural runs. - **O1:** stays open, next design item. Order: type definition, then calibration on 890 plus one uncached part, region tables, capacity LP, then acceptance. - **In-house CAE pair:** prepare the data-request and control table (constant Δp and fixed flow) only; no solving yet. ## Entry sequence (unchanged) 1. Grouping rule and components. 2. Domain and coverage. 3. Features and backbone with licences. 4. Statistics frozen (this document). 5. 10-part preprocessing measurement. 6. Pilot receipts. 7. Full-matrix budget. 8. Stage review, then Yanqi's go.