From fd1db63ee1c4fb4415a36ed95a2eedfb73a5c85c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Sat, 14 Nov 2026 09:07:16 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] docs: S2 design v0.1 amendments (target in seconds, grouping, R2 stop, slices) Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- docs/claude/s2-design-v0.1-2026-11-14.md | 65 ++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 65 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/claude/s2-design-v0.1-2026-11-14.md diff --git a/docs/claude/s2-design-v0.1-2026-11-14.md b/docs/claude/s2-design-v0.1-2026-11-14.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4ab00e7b5 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/claude/s2-design-v0.1-2026-11-14.md @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +# S2 design v0.1: amendments to v0 (Claude, 2026-11-14) + +v0 (`d8aa0f42`, s2-design-v0-2026-11-14.md) still stands except where amended below. + +Inputs: +- MeltAstra's target catch (Slack, 17:0x); +- Grok's targeted gaps (17:0x); +- MoldAstra's stage-review note (Drive 10aMWqeBFKuAmKgssaWv-qf-cteNQuVcz). + +MeltAstra's execution-level diff still has to be folded in, as v0.2. Nothing runs, and there is no training without Yanqi's go. + +## A. Scope statement (Grok) +S2 v0 is a **one-factor ablation of O2 edge-direction readings**: E vs N, with the same backbone and the same g12/g23, plus R2. + +It does **not** test the organisation claim we identified as unoccupied. That claim is whether type organisation still helps once a strong whole-part model, a matched generic partition, a control cut and a costed distance baseline are in the same table. S2 results must not be summarised as evidence for or against O1, or for "geometry organisation" in general. + +Entering S2 on the edge readings is a *ranking-based* entry. S1 showed only about 1 % coverage structure for them against the bound-preserving control. It is not a confirmation of the original hypothesis. + +The first test that can separate O1 from generic local-global organisation (matched generic partition vs type partition vs control cut) is **still unscheduled**. It is the next design item after S2 starts. + +## B. Target (replaces v0 §3 "normalised per part by its maximum fill time") +- **Primary target:** Fill_time **in seconds**. + - Training may use log(1 + T/tau), with tau fitted on the training pool only. + - Predictions are mapped back to seconds before scoring. + - No per-part normalisation uses labels. +- In Greif v5 the filling control is Automatic: Moldflow picks injection time from the geometry, so the seconds scale is learnable from geometry inputs. The LOG's injection time/flow rate is **not** an input in S2, because it is ambiguous whether it is a process setting or an outcome. This waits for the in-house stage. +- **Scale-free secondary metrics:** Kendall tau over sampled node pairs; location of the last-filled region. +- **T/T_max with the true T_max** is a labelled oracle diagnostic only. It is never a primary result, and it is never used to report seconds (MoldAstra ②). +- **Coverage:** queries are the S1 mass-PPS draws on d > 0 nodes. Report the covered node mass (positive-distance share x eligible share) per part. Boundary (d = 0) mass is outside the target measure, stated explicitly. + +## C. Grouping (MoldAstra ①; replaces "source key union near-duplicate cluster") +1. **Same source key, same side** (hard constraint). +2. **Across keys:** geometry screening with descriptors fixed before any results. For screen hits, registration, then a blind visual review of narrow bridges and holes. Record each confirmed pair as an **evidence edge**. +3. **Folds:** connected components of (same-key ∪ evidence edges) are the grouping units for the 5 folds and the nested training pools. +4. The earlier 0.5 % / 1 % thresholds were exploratory. There is no corpus-wide threshold acceptance and no final group table yet; both are entry conditions. +5. The 249 filename keys are leak-prevention keys, not verified independent CAD families. + +## D. Baseline protocol and non-identifiability stop (Grok) +- **R2** follows the Gre24 feature recipe on *our* grouped split: + - geodesic/eikonal distance from the gate; + - local geometric scalars; + - GBRT. + Published Gre24 figures are **not** an external bar, since they use a different corpus version and split. +- **Lee26** reports a *pressure* drop (plate to bracket 11.93 % → 36.06 %, confounded). It is not a fill-time bar. +- **Label-resolution floor:** the Greif Moldflow logs show "Maximum % volume to fill per time step = 1 %". Fill-time labels are therefore resolved to roughly 1 % of each part's filling time. +- **Pre-registered stop:** if R2's source-equal relative L2 error on the 100 % pool is **≤ 2 %** (2x the label resolution), public Fill_time is declared **non-identifiable** for the E vs N question. The S2 comparison is then reported as uninformative, not as a win or a loss. The next step moves to harder targets (aligned pressure) or to in-house data. + +## E. Added evaluation slices (Grok, from proposal v2.1) +All slices use geometry-only definitions fixed before the run. +- **Thin-feature slice:** nodes with d/t_part ≤ 0.25 that also lie within 2·t_part of a boundary face whose local opposing wall is closer than t_part. Operational definition to be frozen by MoldAstra; until then only the existing near-wall slice is reported. +- **Connectivity violation ("leakage") on predictions:** the bottleneck test from the 2026-11-13 thread. + - m(x) = min over gate paths of the max predicted T along the path. + - Violation if m(x) > T̂(x) + tol. + - tol is a preset fraction of the predicted part fill time. + - Report count and volume, *relative to the same statistic on the ground-truth labels*. + - Uses true tet adjacency only. +- **Freeze time** stays deferred until its field definition is sourced (G1 is open). + +## F. Entry conditions (consolidated) +1. Final grouping table per section C, reviewed. +2. d/t_part on the full corpus, with recorded cost. +3. R2 implemented on the grouped split, with the stop check of section D computable before any neural run. +4. m (10 % candidate), the S2 seed table and slice definitions frozen. +5. Pilot measurement (t_step, memory) on one V100. +6. Yanqi's explicit go for training.