From f58a55d9953ccaadb5d39d8394691cd626f50dd4 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Frank14f <1515444314@qq.com> Date: Sun, 15 Nov 2026 01:39:55 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] Compare frozen band reviews and record three anonymous adjudication items --- .../comparison.csv | 26 +++++ .../receipt.json | 54 ++++++++++ .../sources/claude/band25-review.csv | 26 +++++ .../sources/claude/original-commit.txt | 10 ++ .../sources/claude/reviewer-attestation.md | 8 ++ .../sources/claude/tools/dims.py | 15 +++ .../sources/claude/tools/inv.py | 102 ++++++++++++++++++ .../sources/claude/tools/web2.py | 17 +++ .../sources/mold/frozen-review.bundle | Bin 0 -> 3632 bytes .../sources/mold/frozen-review.csv | 26 +++++ .../sources/mold/original-commit.txt | 5 + .../sources/mold/reviewer-attestation.md | 11 ++ ...-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15.md | 33 ++++++ tools/compare_g1_band25_reviews.py | 81 ++++++++++++++ 14 files changed, 414 insertions(+) create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/comparison.csv create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/receipt.json create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/band25-review.csv create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/original-commit.txt create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/reviewer-attestation.md create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/tools/dims.py create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/tools/inv.py create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/tools/web2.py create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/mold/frozen-review.bundle create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/mold/frozen-review.csv create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/mold/original-commit.txt create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/mold/reviewer-attestation.md create mode 100644 docs/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15.md create mode 100644 tools/compare_g1_band25_reviews.py diff --git a/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/comparison.csv b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/comparison.csv new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1e9b1b62e --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/comparison.csv @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +anonymous_pair_id,agreement,adjudication_status,mold_relation,mold_local_evidence,mold_resolvable,mold_unresolved_reason,mold_reviewer,mold_review_version,claude_relation,claude_local_evidence,claude_resolvable,claude_unresolved_reason,claude_reviewer,claude_review_version +6b6cd06df461493a0ecaf202f77f7ea6,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,圆杆左端面呈圆形,右件端面是宽厚约 2:1 的矩形。轴向长度约为 177.8 与 304.8。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"slender bar vs slender bar; Rg ~49 vs ~90, surface area 3569 vs 11774, cross-section aspect 2.26:2.13 vs 4.75:2.77 (non-uniform); generic bar shape only",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +4a0cceebed4d9cad24528d72421a0b19,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,两件都是薄板。左板长边上有中点孔并带圆角,右板周缘的八孔分布不同。长度约 265 与 140,厚度却均约 3.18。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"flat perforated plates, same thickness 3.27/3.26 but in-plane 268x189 vs 141x103 and chi -12 vs -14 (hole count differs)",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +4d7ca9a4efa1441781a22a52205cef26,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左件端部有缩径凸台和环形肩,右件是平端直圆柱。两件长约 53.82 与 41.50。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"PCA envelope 53.8x13.7x13.6 vs 41.5x10.2x10.0; size ratio 1.30/1.35/1.36 (not rigid, not exactly uniform scale); area 2513 vs 1459",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +7cc6ea12077d363b86faae435cb66988,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左件端视能沿轴看到贯通的管腔;右件有封闭的多边形端面,一端另有细杆段。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,slender parts with different topology (chi 0 vs 2) and Rg ~55 vs ~118,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +6e0d33ac7dfd2eb98ac9bb199b4dd468,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左件是连续实心扁条。右件有长中央穿槽,两端另有横槽。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"Rg ~69 vs ~360, chi 2 vs -8, area 16690 vs 328695",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +698ca7b7d9899110ae75d242ccba5380,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左件截面是实心矩形;右件截面侧壁有相对的纵向凹槽,条身还有局部开孔迹象。仅截面差异即足以区分。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"similar long-bar envelope (Rg ~273 vs ~285) but chi 2 vs -48 (many through-holes on right only), area 61613 vs 45038",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +8cd7f7e79982dc333f874cda29dc37ea,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左侧圆柱端部有环形台阶和端凸台,右侧为无肩平端圆杆;外径分别约 13.55 和 10。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,same left envelope as pair 4d7ca9a4; envelope 53.8x13.7x13.6 vs 41.6x10.2x10.0; non-uniform ratio 1.29/1.34/1.36,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +ff914dd48333a929fd68d3e405498188,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左件端面为平直四边的矩形,宽约为厚的两倍。右件截面近圆形且有细端,长约 425。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"slender bars, Rg ~84 vs ~118, area 11774 vs 23139, cross-section 4.8:2.7 vs 3.9:3.5",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +bdf377bd08b2c5170b0636837f8cb1e0,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左侧薄条面上沿长度可见三处穿孔;右侧较厚的直条具有连续的矩形截面。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"thin strip chi -4 (Rg ~36, third axis .38) vs solid bar chi 2 (Rg ~90)",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +965b576758b64a76044eeba2e33bc431,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左件为单股光滑闭环,右件在环壁周向有密集重复开口,外跨度约 32 与 670。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,small flat ring part 10.8x10.1x.88 chi 0 vs large plate 222x219x15.8 chi -240; ~20x scale and topology differ,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +3058d0a6c2ca1a763191a43218edbbe8,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,UNRESOLVED,两件的弯折、大小端眼及单面长凹槽高度对应,外长均约 108.5。左件大端眼在凹槽面明显扩口,右件同一端的孔壁保持较直;背面及小端眼相似。,局部差异可辨,关系未决,可辨局部改动,不能确认同件;几何不足以判明设计亲缘。,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,UNRESOLVED,"two-eye cranked link, both chi -2; PCA envelope 108.50x25.05x11.15 vs 108.50x25.01x11.15 (equal to .05); area 5949 vs 6036 (1.5%); both webs show a pocket at width +-4; handedness (proper vs mirror) and the 1.5% area difference not resolvable from geometry at band resolution -> conservatively merged",no,handedness/small-feature difference not resolvable; same envelope and pocket,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +731fb76c6a44dced20b7632559c1bd90,False,CLAUDE_RULE_ADJUDICATION_PENDING,UNRESOLVED,两件外径均约 16,中心孔与外圈相近,但平行端面间厚度约 1.875 与 2.250,无法经刚体运动消除此差值。,局部差异可辨,关系未决,可能是厚度变体;通用环形不足以证明共同母型。,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"flat washers, same OD 16.0 but thickness 1.92 vs 2.40 (25%) and ID ~8.30 vs ~7.91; different part dimensions (parametric variant, not same part)",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +8466a0cb2d9eae11be06c186f3c29c53,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左件是带侧向凹槽的长型材;右件端面近圆且无相应凹槽。轴长约 1000 与 279。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,long bar chi -48 Rg ~287 vs plain bar chi 2 Rg ~77,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +17f4a1b88d4a6590dec111e6c01f0b2c,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左件是实心圆杆;右件宽厚不等、四角明确的矩形端面排除了相同截面。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"slender bars, Rg ~51 vs ~90, area 3569 vs 11774, non-uniform cross-section",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +36a763784b381de2029487902f68b419,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左件一端带局部缩径段,主段截面多边化,长约 425;右件是通体等径的短圆杆,长约 178。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"slender bars, Rg ~112 vs ~52, area 23139 vs 3569",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +ccbe856ce0d8fc785bcc3ebed3888f1b,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左侧薄带有三处沿轴线分布的孔,两个靠端的孔较大;右侧是较厚的连续矩形条。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,thin strip chi -4 vs solid bar chi 2; Rg ~35 vs ~90,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +5adfb2472990878108a970a7c4a517cd,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左件端部缩径并形成同心肩和小凸台,右件平端无肩。原尺度长约 53.82 与 65。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,envelope 53.8x13.7x13.6 vs 65.1x18.2x18.0; ratio 1.21/1.33/1.33 non-uniform; area 2513 vs 4182,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +a7496efbdd612af87016938ca6c29b08,False,CLAUDE_RULE_ADJUDICATION_PENDING,UNRESOLVED,两件都是无孔平板。左件四角方直,右件四角均圆化;厚度约 7.5 与 10.16,长宽也不一致。,局部差异可辨,关系未决,不是相同尺度的刚体副本;仅凭板形及圆角不能判明是否为设计变体。,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"rectangular plates ~175-179 x 80; thickness 7.7 vs 11.1; left sharp edges, right rounded/chamfered edges and corners",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +8de3e0e7c34ae03a8e987047556f6e27,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左件是宽厚约 4:1 的实心扁条,右件为实心细圆杆,两端截面明显不同。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"long bar Rg ~273 vs short bar Rg ~50, area 61613 vs 1639",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +1ead5efb8eed037f8a15292213f1a799,False,CLAUDE_RULE_ADJUDICATION_PENDING,UNRESOLVED,两件均有单一圆形中心孔和约 16 的外径;左环端面间厚度约 2.625,右环约 2.250。,局部差异可辨,关系未决,厚度改变可辨,通用垫圈外形不能区分同源改型和独立设计。,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"flat washers, same OD 16.0 but thickness 2.76 vs 2.40 (15%), ID ~8.01 vs ~7.91; parametric variant, not same part",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +7d513fc054fbee26168e60ff01998015,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左板为四个角孔;右板为沿四边排布的八个孔。厚度相近而板面尺度明显不同。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"perforated plates, 89x60 vs 41x29 principal RMS, chi -6 vs -14",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +19d0722f138d79c4e249e40118cb3e8f,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左端面为宽 12.7、厚 6.35 的矩形,右端面近圆、直径约 6.35;相同的短向尺度不能使截面重合。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"slender bars, Rg ~84 vs ~52, area 11774 vs 3569",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +9276ecc84a7893c4a9ab94f7d729a24d,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左板为宽面四角孔板,长约 420;右板长约 140,周边有八个分散的孔,安装孔布局不同。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,"perforated plates, 120x88 vs 41x29 principal RMS, chi -6 vs -14, area 256705 vs 30026",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +ea7aaf13e0653feec71f4e591122399d,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左件是环壁有重复孔格的大环;右件是光滑闭合的小圆环。孔格在多方向的表面视图中均可见。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,large plate chi -240 vs small ring part chi 0; ~20x scale,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +f7279499523c69b7c9d2efb9128fcd00,True,CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY,unrelated,左件是长约 965 的矩形截面扁条,右件为长约 279 的圆截面细杆,端部轮廓不同。,局部差异可辨,,MoldAstra,MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1,unrelated,long bar Rg ~273 vs bar Rg ~77; area 61613 vs 4114; cross-section 8.8:2.9 vs 1.6:1.6,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 diff --git a/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/receipt.json b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/receipt.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c7299fd00 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/receipt.json @@ -0,0 +1,54 @@ +{ + "status": "TWO_FROZEN_REVIEWS_COMPARED_ADJUDICATION_PENDING", + "created_at": "2026-11-15T01:38:32.096744+08:00", + "anonymous_input_commit": "3864d34141a393b957a09937e609ad827ea21c16", + "mold_commit": "36f2462eb95ad0d67274a49ba5c431fe728fab2f", + "claude_commit": "dfe2c65b9b8afe583f43dd6df8e0afdf520aa1d0", + "pairs": 25, + "matrix": [ + { + "mold": "UNRESOLVED", + "claude": "UNRESOLVED", + "count": 1 + }, + { + "mold": "UNRESOLVED", + "claude": "unrelated", + "count": 3 + }, + { + "mold": "unrelated", + "claude": "unrelated", + "count": 21 + } + ], + "disagreement_ids": [ + "731fb76c6a44dced20b7632559c1bd90", + "a7496efbdd612af87016938ca6c29b08", + "1ead5efb8eed037f8a15292213f1a799" + ], + "same_unresolved_ids": [ + "3058d0a6c2ca1a763191a43218edbbe8" + ], + "comparison_preserves_original_rows_verbatim": true, + "identity_mapping_read": false, + "custody_join_performed": false, + "components_frozen": false, + "splits_created": false, + "geometry_or_registration_rerun": false, + "scripts_from_reviewers_executed": false, + "original_authors_preserved": true, + "source_sha256": { + "sources/claude/band25-review.csv": "93096734186c1247e46e98f26c7c9b0f7a4987c8d8d588e8147110ae3880be2e", + "sources/claude/original-commit.txt": "319b2efafc624d9868ee8ab8660b8551913a4dd74d83ada2aba02e4dd3f04c4b", + "sources/claude/reviewer-attestation.md": "bc5df5dbcf02176b5292dc455aaf9fae34ef14bf65208645d9a7bfd4319af5a4", + "sources/claude/tools/dims.py": "fdedfe96b1410e087be7e955aafd305906a8cf010aa4d69f8ccfdc115d131a51", + "sources/claude/tools/inv.py": "d8eca5b1ef37137d572d5fe613ab8896c7c3f9a7eea5f8891899caf2a34674fb", + "sources/claude/tools/web2.py": "7a3caa6f2fadbdf1149b42e3c7ab273260535ca461da650f772423e944d8f2e5", + "sources/mold/frozen-review.bundle": "c833ad3d521198933ed7fac32dda0d919315136b8e4078cfe5b01e7cfebce045", + "sources/mold/frozen-review.csv": "6479eebdfc09629c7188f18f888494c5d9bea8dd160d92763813b15ef813ce18", + "sources/mold/original-commit.txt": "a9a5c0fe7de012cde0853c51a26eec85b2bd1449eaeae1d32737278787d2114b", + "sources/mold/reviewer-attestation.md": "f317b9c4f790943b45607452c9c381624b17ad5f6fee6b009658415fe4c38085" + }, + "comparison_sha256": "e7603e06ac5529608c23b889475632b5d75cfbeea7686528460a6c81dcd10bfd" +} diff --git a/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/band25-review.csv b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/band25-review.csv new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8ff614b57 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/band25-review.csv @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +anonymous_pair_id,relation,local_evidence,resolvable,unresolved_reason,reviewer,review_version +6b6cd06df461493a0ecaf202f77f7ea6,unrelated,"slender bar vs slender bar; Rg ~49 vs ~90, surface area 3569 vs 11774, cross-section aspect 2.26:2.13 vs 4.75:2.77 (non-uniform); generic bar shape only",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +4a0cceebed4d9cad24528d72421a0b19,unrelated,"flat perforated plates, same thickness 3.27/3.26 but in-plane 268x189 vs 141x103 and chi -12 vs -14 (hole count differs)",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +4d7ca9a4efa1441781a22a52205cef26,unrelated,"PCA envelope 53.8x13.7x13.6 vs 41.5x10.2x10.0; size ratio 1.30/1.35/1.36 (not rigid, not exactly uniform scale); area 2513 vs 1459",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +7cc6ea12077d363b86faae435cb66988,unrelated,slender parts with different topology (chi 0 vs 2) and Rg ~55 vs ~118,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +6e0d33ac7dfd2eb98ac9bb199b4dd468,unrelated,"Rg ~69 vs ~360, chi 2 vs -8, area 16690 vs 328695",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +698ca7b7d9899110ae75d242ccba5380,unrelated,"similar long-bar envelope (Rg ~273 vs ~285) but chi 2 vs -48 (many through-holes on right only), area 61613 vs 45038",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +8cd7f7e79982dc333f874cda29dc37ea,unrelated,same left envelope as pair 4d7ca9a4; envelope 53.8x13.7x13.6 vs 41.6x10.2x10.0; non-uniform ratio 1.29/1.34/1.36,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +ff914dd48333a929fd68d3e405498188,unrelated,"slender bars, Rg ~84 vs ~118, area 11774 vs 23139, cross-section 4.8:2.7 vs 3.9:3.5",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +bdf377bd08b2c5170b0636837f8cb1e0,unrelated,"thin strip chi -4 (Rg ~36, third axis .38) vs solid bar chi 2 (Rg ~90)",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +965b576758b64a76044eeba2e33bc431,unrelated,small flat ring part 10.8x10.1x.88 chi 0 vs large plate 222x219x15.8 chi -240; ~20x scale and topology differ,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +3058d0a6c2ca1a763191a43218edbbe8,UNRESOLVED,"two-eye cranked link, both chi -2; PCA envelope 108.50x25.05x11.15 vs 108.50x25.01x11.15 (equal to .05); area 5949 vs 6036 (1.5%); both webs show a pocket at width +-4; handedness (proper vs mirror) and the 1.5% area difference not resolvable from geometry at band resolution -> conservatively merged",no,handedness/small-feature difference not resolvable; same envelope and pocket,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +731fb76c6a44dced20b7632559c1bd90,unrelated,"flat washers, same OD 16.0 but thickness 1.92 vs 2.40 (25%) and ID ~8.30 vs ~7.91; different part dimensions (parametric variant, not same part)",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +8466a0cb2d9eae11be06c186f3c29c53,unrelated,long bar chi -48 Rg ~287 vs plain bar chi 2 Rg ~77,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +17f4a1b88d4a6590dec111e6c01f0b2c,unrelated,"slender bars, Rg ~51 vs ~90, area 3569 vs 11774, non-uniform cross-section",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +36a763784b381de2029487902f68b419,unrelated,"slender bars, Rg ~112 vs ~52, area 23139 vs 3569",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +ccbe856ce0d8fc785bcc3ebed3888f1b,unrelated,thin strip chi -4 vs solid bar chi 2; Rg ~35 vs ~90,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +5adfb2472990878108a970a7c4a517cd,unrelated,envelope 53.8x13.7x13.6 vs 65.1x18.2x18.0; ratio 1.21/1.33/1.33 non-uniform; area 2513 vs 4182,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +a7496efbdd612af87016938ca6c29b08,unrelated,"rectangular plates ~175-179 x 80; thickness 7.7 vs 11.1; left sharp edges, right rounded/chamfered edges and corners",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +8de3e0e7c34ae03a8e987047556f6e27,unrelated,"long bar Rg ~273 vs short bar Rg ~50, area 61613 vs 1639",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +1ead5efb8eed037f8a15292213f1a799,unrelated,"flat washers, same OD 16.0 but thickness 2.76 vs 2.40 (15%), ID ~8.01 vs ~7.91; parametric variant, not same part",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +7d513fc054fbee26168e60ff01998015,unrelated,"perforated plates, 89x60 vs 41x29 principal RMS, chi -6 vs -14",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +19d0722f138d79c4e249e40118cb3e8f,unrelated,"slender bars, Rg ~84 vs ~52, area 11774 vs 3569",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +9276ecc84a7893c4a9ab94f7d729a24d,unrelated,"perforated plates, 120x88 vs 41x29 principal RMS, chi -6 vs -14, area 256705 vs 30026",yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +ea7aaf13e0653feec71f4e591122399d,unrelated,large plate chi -240 vs small ring part chi 0; ~20x scale,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 +f7279499523c69b7c9d2efb9128fcd00,unrelated,long bar Rg ~273 vs bar Rg ~77; area 61613 vs 4114; cross-section 8.8:2.9 vs 1.6:1.6,yes,,Claude (ClaudeWorker),band25-v1 diff --git a/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/original-commit.txt b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/original-commit.txt new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9e703f17f --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/original-commit.txt @@ -0,0 +1,10 @@ +tree efa0675c4fc3038de2b619186dcf0ae7c7db4b83 +parent 9b71d56578c9513fcbc692073dae68d84bb7b377 +author Claude 1794677233 +0000 +committer Claude 1794677233 +0000 + +G1 band25 blind review v1: 24 unrelated, 1 UNRESOLVED (frozen before custody join) + +Inputs: anonymous package 3864d341 only (ZIP/manifest SHA256 re-verified). + +Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 diff --git a/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/reviewer-attestation.md b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/reviewer-attestation.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2fbda6d6c --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/reviewer-attestation.md @@ -0,0 +1,8 @@ +# Reviewer attestation + +I reviewed only the anonymous materials and did not consult census, source archive, identity/rank/residual mappings or registration results. + +Reviewer: Claude (ClaudeWorker) +Date: 2026-11-15 (UTC+8) +Explicit confirmation: Inputs were only the anonymous package at MeltMind commit 3864d34141a393b957a09937e609ad827ea21c16 (blind-package.zip SHA256 e915936ab104ca74807d2fe3d61efa51ce13beb1f10ceff901599267c3c59208, manifest.json SHA256 24bdb46076d3a9674ae0f1de95ac0a97f0f32e49eb4529734724a0137a7ad7e4, both re-verified). Evidence came from the PLY surfaces (tools/inv.py: Euler characteristic, components, area, area-sampled PCA spread, coarse 300-point PCA+ICP P95/Rg physical and scale-normalised, proper and improper; tools/dims.py: exact vertex PCA envelope and in-plane radii; tools/web2.py: web cross-section levels) plus visual reading of the overview/detail PNGs for 3058d0a6, a7496efb, 731fb76c, 1ead5efb. My coarse P95 has a sampling floor of roughly 0.05-0.1 Rg, far above tau, so it was used only to rule out gross mismatches, never as positive evidence. +Frozen label commit/version: band25-v1, this commit on claude/design-record-20261114. diff --git a/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/tools/dims.py b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/tools/dims.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..89864707d --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/tools/dims.py @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +import sys,math,os +sys.path.insert(0,os.path.dirname(__file__)) +from inv import readply,jacobi +def frame(V): + n=len(V); m=[sum(v[i] for v in V)/n for i in range(3)] + Q=[(v[0]-m[0],v[1]-m[1],v[2]-m[2]) for v in V] + C=[[sum(q[i]*q[j] for q in Q)/n for j in range(3)] for i in range(3)] + ev,vec=jacobi(C) + return [tuple(sum(q[k]*vec[i][k] for k in range(3)) for i in range(3)) for q in Q] +root,pid=sys.argv[1],sys.argv[2] +for side in('left','right'): + V,F=readply(os.path.join(root,'pairs',pid,side+'.ply')); P=frame(V) + ext=[max(p[i] for p in P)-min(p[i] for p in P) for i in range(3)] + r=[math.hypot(p[0],p[1]) for p in P] + print(pid[:8],side,'bbox_pca',[round(e,3) for e in ext],'rmin_inplane',round(min(r),3),'rmax',round(max(r),3)) diff --git a/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/tools/inv.py b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/tools/inv.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..19227ee7c --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/tools/inv.py @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +import sys, math, random, os, json +def readply(p): + L=open(p).read().split('\n'); i=0; nv=nf=0 + while True: + s=L[i]; i+=1 + if s.startswith('element vertex'): nv=int(s.split()[2]) + if s.startswith('element face'): nf=int(s.split()[2]) + if s=='end_header': break + V=[tuple(map(float,L[i+k].split())) for k in range(nv)]; i+=nv + F=[tuple(map(int,L[i+k].split()[1:4])) for k in range(nf)] + return V,F +def jacobi(A): + n=len(A); A=[r[:] for r in A]; Vv=[[float(i==j) for j in range(n)] for i in range(n)] + for _ in range(100): + off=sum(A[i][j]**2 for i in range(n) for j in range(n) if i!=j) + if off<1e-30: break + for p in range(n): + for q in range(p+1,n): + if abs(A[p][q])<1e-300: continue + th=(A[q][q]-A[p][p])/(2*A[p][q]); t=(1 if th>=0 else -1)/(abs(th)+math.sqrt(th*th+1)) + c=1/math.sqrt(t*t+1); s=t*c + for k in range(n): + akp,akq=A[k][p],A[k][q]; A[k][p]=c*akp-s*akq; A[k][q]=s*akp+c*akq + for k in range(n): + apk,aqk=A[p][k],A[q][k]; A[p][k]=c*apk-s*aqk; A[q][k]=s*apk+c*aqk + for k in range(n): + vkp,vkq=Vv[k][p],Vv[k][q]; Vv[k][p]=c*vkp-s*vkq; Vv[k][q]=s*vkp+c*vkq + ev=[A[i][i] for i in range(n)]; o=sorted(range(n),key=lambda i:-ev[i]) + return [ev[i] for i in o],[[Vv[k][i] for k in range(n)] for i in o] +def sub(a,b): return (a[0]-b[0],a[1]-b[1],a[2]-b[2]) +def cross(a,b): return (a[1]*b[2]-a[2]*b[1],a[2]*b[0]-a[0]*b[2],a[0]*b[1]-a[1]*b[0]) +def info(V,F,rng,N): + E=set(); + for a,b,c in F: + for u,v in ((a,b),(b,c),(c,a)): E.add((min(u,v),max(u,v))) + par=list(range(len(V))) + def f(x): + while par[x]!=x: par[x]=par[par[x]]; x=par[x] + return x + for u,v in E: par[f(u)]=f(v) + comps=len({f(i) for i in range(len(V))}) + areas=[]; vol=0 + for a,b,c in F: + A,B,C=V[a],V[b],V[c]; n=cross(sub(B,A),sub(C,A)); areas.append(0.5*math.sqrt(n[0]**2+n[1]**2+n[2]**2)) + vol+=(A[0]*(B[1]*C[2]-B[2]*C[1])-A[1]*(B[0]*C[2]-B[2]*C[0])+A[2]*(B[0]*C[1]-B[1]*C[0]))/6 + S=sum(areas); cum=[];t=0 + for x in areas: t+=x; cum.append(t) + import bisect + P=[] + for _ in range(N): + k=min(bisect.bisect_left(cum,rng.random()*S),len(F)-1); a,b,c=F[k]; r1,r2=rng.random(),rng.random() + if r1+r2>1: r1,r2=1-r1,1-r2 + A,B,C=V[a],V[b],V[c]; P.append(tuple(A[i]+r1*(B[i]-A[i])+r2*(C[i]-A[i]) for i in range(3))) + m=[sum(p[i] for p in P)/N for i in range(3)]; Q=[sub(p,m) for p in P] + Cv=[[sum(q[i]*q[j] for q in Q)/N for j in range(3)] for i in range(3)] + ev,vec=jacobi(Cv) + return dict(nv=len(V),nf=len(F),ne=len(E),chi=len(V)-len(E)+len(F),comps=comps,area=S,absvol=abs(vol),rg=math.sqrt(sum(ev)),ev=ev,vec=vec,Q=Q) +def proj(Q,vec): return [tuple(sum(q[k]*vec[i][k] for k in range(3)) for i in range(3)) for q in Q] +def nn(P,Q): + out=[] + for p in P: + out.append(math.sqrt(min((p[0]-q[0])**2+(p[1]-q[1])**2+(p[2]-q[2])**2 for q in Q))) + return out +def p95(d): d=sorted(d); return d[int(0.95*(len(d)-1))] +def horn(P,Q): + S=[[sum(p[i]*q[j] for p,q in zip(P,Q)) for j in range(3)] for i in range(3)] + Sxx,Sxy,Sxz=S[0];Syx,Syy,Syz=S[1];Szx,Szy,Szz=S[2] + N=[[Sxx+Syy+Szz,Syz-Szy,Szx-Sxz,Sxy-Syx],[Syz-Szy,Sxx-Syy-Szz,Sxy+Syx,Szx+Sxz],[Szx-Sxz,Sxy+Syx,-Sxx+Syy-Szz,Syz+Szy],[Sxy-Syx,Szx+Sxz,Syz+Szy,-Sxx-Syy+Szz]] + ev,vec=jacobi(N); w,x,y,z=vec[0] + return [[w*w+x*x-y*y-z*z,2*(x*y-w*z),2*(x*z+w*y)],[2*(x*y+w*z),w*w-x*x+y*y-z*z,2*(y*z-w*x)],[2*(x*z-w*y),2*(y*z+w*x),w*w-x*x-y*y+z*z]] +def rot(R,P): return [tuple(sum(R[i][k]*p[k] for k in range(3)) for i in range(3)) for p in P] +def align(A,B,iters=6): + # A,B already in own PCA frames; try sign flips (det +1 and -1), ICP refine on proper ones + res=[] + for sx in (1,-1): + for sy in (1,-1): + for sz in (1,-1): + Bs=[(sx*p[0],sy*p[1],sz*p[2]) for p in B] + det=sx*sy*sz + cur=Bs + for _ in range(iters): + # match cur->A nearest, then Horn (rotation only; centroids already ~0) + idx=[min(range(len(A)),key=lambda j:(c[0]-A[j][0])**2+(c[1]-A[j][1])**2+(c[2]-A[j][2])**2) for c in cur] + R=horn(cur,[A[j] for j in idx]); cur=rot(R,cur) + d=max(p95(nn(A,cur)),p95(nn(cur,A))) + res.append((d,det)) + return res +if __name__=='__main__': + root=sys.argv[1]; pid=sys.argv[2]; N=int(sys.argv[3]) if len(sys.argv)>3 else 400 + rng=random.Random(20261115) + R={} + for side in ('left','right'): + V,F=readply(os.path.join(root,'pairs',pid,side+'.ply')); R[side]=info(V,F,rng,N) + a,b=R['left'],R['right'] + A=proj(a['Q'],a['vec']); B=proj(b['Q'],b['vec']) + al=align(A,B) + rg=(a['rg']+b['rg'])/2 + bp=min(d for d,det in al if det>0)/rg; bi=min(d for d,det in al if det<0)/rg + def s(x): return {k:(round(v,4) if isinstance(v,float) else v) for k,v in x.items() if k in('nv','nf','chi','comps','area','absvol','rg')} + k=a['rg']/b['rg']; Bk=[(p[0]*k,p[1]*k,p[2]*k) for p in B]; al2=align(A,Bk) + sp=min(d for d,det in al2 if det>0)/a['rg']; si=min(d for d,det in al2 if det<0)/a['rg'] + print(json.dumps(dict(sf_proper=round(sp,4),sf_improper=round(si,4),pid=pid[:8],L=s(a),R=s(b),sqrtev_L=[round(math.sqrt(max(e,0)),3) for e in a['ev']],sqrtev_R=[round(math.sqrt(max(e,0)),3) for e in b['ev']],p95_proper_over_rg=round(bp,4),p95_improper_over_rg=round(bi,4)))) diff --git a/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/tools/web2.py b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/tools/web2.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4b321931a --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/claude/tools/web2.py @@ -0,0 +1,17 @@ +import sys,os,collections,math +sys.path.insert(0,os.path.dirname(__file__)) +from inv import readply,jacobi +root,pid=sys.argv[1],sys.argv[2] +for side in('left','right'): + V,F=readply(os.path.join(root,'pairs',pid,side+'.ply')) + n=len(V); m=[sum(v[i] for v in V)/n for i in range(3)] + Q=[(v[0]-m[0],v[1]-m[1],v[2]-m[2]) for v in V] + C=[[sum(q[i]*q[j] for q in Q)/n for j in range(3)] for i in range(3)] + ev,vec=jacobi(C) + P=[tuple(sum(q[k]*vec[i][k] for k in range(3)) for i in range(3)) for q in Q] + web=[p for p in P if abs(p[0])<15] + # cross-section in (axis1, axis2) at web: bin axis2 (width) and axis3 (thickness) values + h=collections.Counter(round(p[2]*2)/2 for p in web) + w=collections.Counter(round(p[1]) for p in web) + print(pid[:8],side,'web n',len(web),'axis3 levels',sorted(h.items())) + print(' axis2',sorted(w.items())) diff --git a/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/mold/frozen-review.bundle b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/mold/frozen-review.bundle new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e5fe212ad7ed975e445d65d195c63886ee593b3f GIT binary patch literal 3632 zcmV-04$tu;Aa*h!XK8dGVs&n0Y-I{FHfAz3HZo;mIW=KqFl072GB-3~G&y2nHDfe0 zF=k~qGB{>oVlrkRa%E<7FKA_9WOFZaWp-(0cQ0*kY-C|`baG)WVqtD%GBqtTI5sq7 zGc++Rb}VbFzj&OJ$9YUy4xrnvv8{DY4IAZ@s(cDz65&6l)u}vuGwcjtOz{=cn&FC(whKQd ze!_jFTi__U^aTAGetB_WF=j!TQmj6+UrZ*T26&t^G%zqTF;Pe>%CAbz(=AFZ%Sxh z&0{g^>W9A_Tj%|qc&9P+dn*7ck|}e!^#XXDtyo)A8_5}c-(R60fK}5ym+sD6s!njJQ^Jt8XisL@I(FNk3`|5{Kvy5dh9Xm@l_N@iSie zlzKE}EM;0ob}M+FRzqg9)Y&ST)4lFNt+(~PS)PF_ruqFZ7jtIusC|Cou6NdIrrI)pm)f&PXRy6exnZ{ESepU0nO&118)+*@s##va^n*Bb@GSdkan^@W1(1w{^vhRnzD z-sHYHt(uFcX0euC?hg(9adcSy_VG7k^6J-v-;)Qi98olU;PWU@en1{PAzua3OA@VP ztpX(ysb~;Vt{4p{kzP#1Cy?6pGMu|N*@Q!9uby?bTJU;62tVMA+2vWg{=Bm}+pZsW zpPre+6?1lC>U#h?tGsluVWnB#?_R6{N;7qUYi3HOKH09%o25C}ZGg2vqtL=6frrm7 ztiyFPe{8m<@vdJa_kmrpL<$+`RFWVdj1x(z3@P=(M5pvxI#2iVoK5Zn#_q*CbNS3n z*UjPw^K!1cP=kzRPu~r)i+Mdeg7w{vV=RR?AK|!p09RWGA@qx!T8IHDhTh%Luq27J zB-CR}`H>&Sgq7La?w%i->b7Z3c4j9!TRT{#eGCwMs83U_cHgx+m8Ly7EO{^hCcUho_pqfpA7KajsdP>Z|}A*D`s~B1H4f;wKGgn z<0s$;GkxZe0Mx8;khRt@SMK~5n!_-QD~n}xvg?s^GDeU?Ehag*ML5}J8YgP z>TysIuNz<{0CZ=ugz zZ#j;|FqL0nI|7%?9AIw|zZixE*rGu0p|R3b5Ue*2h@_w*RS{Rd4!kfBoZQ}6n6G*R zj|u(1u>tKeAa+DkZ8|y!)=$fS3_v0k+$&EB&{O4D*r*N#< z&iOKO+d^%?;AV3l>v4Ai6brfxd#YCIZIpV`^QJtHowc}&i_5RF)BRkud`IXJyN9at zy^t$UMhQ(M0XRMpLsD44trJ6v~x+lg<77S>&mO&e~;X z_FWzV7q6vU1@IUk?7I`~)>db30!jdq4;7J3&LQ={VfqIHB5Pk<+#V|2cj~Bnbl%x~ zZ%Ri)?y6hYSvfP$_bqqNgM4*&s#&#+?>|4m%A0=MZm!}jM{YA^IB!#*bh= z@P%I>t3F9%7A27k0+nb*J^1I-Fcb-imGExnA!nmJoRK}}A+S0`1*!w@Zq5L7XmGsM zECEYoJ9CaSdasY2*RjtQIdd+E7HNn+2-vT4wAwviG&Ae%=66|Z2?EhMnd$wf+&L^` z{Kmf^p4Q3b)@pGL_Jio5_^<3cCLY8vt4%-*&D2K-a;G+LwqJZ%40#Ym;4@>YgqE6+ zSbI@Iz@YdE6-nsdrsH58Q6c*J233VMy8WWFwKNb$7c<9{NRzMMqBb^G+#}9G=X^;# z&vT(<;_l5!SQ&xvsJ19|GMyoW-^Usi?e! zSVK(@2r{1(7G6S@+l>-Jgf!d}Yx)s#3*$lTbD}g1Ga}$jz)TbIIJoBj`>biL9vFN3 zUgw0t?b$Lvhab7ca2|2))iuewvNUUGGoj=FH#~2#9`<9?e*hf$-2sB<(mae3u#!AY z7!Ttl@p0bqIp-;fZ__wHX9pQnwA>swT5eQv?B;x9yADX-4k!=Bu3Q;tA9~Tg{NdUa-%rw_+o1X@O0g>|`c#k8!LPn%xR5;jszwb?#<1Dy#4pG_bCf2<12 z;Y_YWU9hk;ELWS^T4(bIcq_PYGku7oaMP-xosXT8IjusjSVDK`M9We07ZR@0zV7WLhlMz1yx4q&`*pmX)bnZio4MQ2qStKf7G$$_(IE~LWoZS^GODaF-F2WpH@|@X zDXPdx-I!+8z#2$GG9Arh{cbAbXkV!^qzwVN$h^EeYM z&D_HXLs_Jggv0p4g%4aVWGsS|Dd2fY19fZSs%Xh`aywjsi=Qg4H^^mQQ{DHp<$X*k z^odL6OsTWFJCHV0oy~Tquwm+x0O-DQs3nsUG6?1`^i!=9M$$lsf)Gl5A#Q3GQmGxm z@WYK8y8z(Z3){UFJFH#ViNO#DnZN}gXPYHhgH>vu!U?9l4x#{AL`mM+$GlfcX5$hW z0(8O7vG?%3fPu#hgb1mhL?UL1P!uRk5DErFdAEH10W;*X12b&lv%&Z#|K@AqC6>p4 zgzZB2-3=Bxsn42KbN=0ZzPex0r3zej@P@hGqZk1Uw9|H=SU`JPT6D$ezAB@asF>9 zcz2-OF&Q8Hp$}uC-eitqT%smK>`5Zeds<%>gONy;$#sWtOI9rTkf{znjSg?dJ1r@N zG1kZ!>rQsOB(dzXR8oO@u0uTS+-i_^{A)X|-4!;os25;OwnN z(DT>9^3#%TPhG?pM2j~-eM9T>^;J=pMR`fjZ zuINrXQhd}PFX^Y$d5293apdI%=-Lw5ogXOnakq0MRI$M~H}}p`kmZ39A)Y zLgif1eU&)wCNCtlR?X2<%c18S4=eii>C4^M`w!pm-hdd^P@Xb{G?%xSk5-4k%_%w= zXy5Ul6sXlS@Xo}55B~^bP%UYUc!)SVoFI$Y8G-8@ujo^l{Rb^h8KF0bMQg{|hvmaO z4{V|n?3C;CzvmxQ$G}(|FA|mMcpsP=AkuXDq$=8DRGbGwjE6BYZ1Y#?$cT{~0H?x5 zQFj^-r6v>ZCGkI(#8MBAzJjzCT_2{X)#4Xi2*Qq9Z3 1794676843 +0800 +committer MoldAstra 1794676843 +0800 + +Freeze 25 anonymous band-review judgments and AI reviewer attestation diff --git a/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/mold/reviewer-attestation.md b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/mold/reviewer-attestation.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2f812e7b0 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/sources/mold/reviewer-attestation.md @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +# Reviewer attestation + +I reviewed only the anonymous materials for this new 25-pair batch and did not consult census, source archive, identity/rank/residual mappings or registration results. + +Reviewer: MoldAstra (Codex, AI reviewer) +Date: 2026-11-15 (Asia/Shanghai) +Explicit confirmation: I confirm the statement above and freeze all 25 judgments with this declaration before the custody join. +Frozen label version: MoldAstra-G1-band25-3864d341-v1 +Anonymous input commit: 3864d34141a393b957a09937e609ad827ea21c16 + +I inspected both full anonymous PLY surfaces for each pair, using independent single-object proper-axis views including end projections, and compared lengths in original numerical units. I inspected both faces and the large eye of the ambiguous two-eye link. Each view fits its own surface; visible size on the page alone was never taken as a physical dimension. Observations concern geometry. UNRESOLVED preserves a possible design relationship when geometry differs and no independent ancestry information is available. No labels, geometry or other material from the earlier 120-pair batch were re-reviewed. I did not access the original poses, custodian entropy or other repository branches, fit pairwise registration, or unblind any pair. diff --git a/docs/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15.md b/docs/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7c890c0bd --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15.md @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +# 25 对匿名盲审对照:3 项规则边界待裁量 + +两份判定及声明已经分别冻结,匿名 ID 对照完成;本次没有重新审图、运行审员脚本、重做配准或打开身份/姿态映射。**21 对双方均判 unrelated,1 对双方均为 UNRESOLVED,3 对为 Mold UNRESOLVED / Claude unrelated。** 两方均无 rigid / same part。原 CSV、声明、作者、版本和逐项证据分别保存,不以一方覆盖另一方;本对照不产生最终分组判定。 + +来源和实际校验: + +- Mold 原提交 `36f2462eb95ad0d67274a49ba5c431fe728fab2f`,作者 `MoldAstra `。Drive 原 ZIP 已完整下载并核 SHA256 `6be280e09f8f7ee43b4307d062983faf2622736c96465844cd6a39badf7445ba`;bundle 完整历史验证通过,CSV/声明与原 Git blob 逐字节一致。CSV SHA `6479eebdfc09629c7188f18f888494c5d9bea8dd160d92763813b15ef813ce18`;声明 SHA `f317b9c4f790943b45607452c9c381624b17ad5f6fee6b009658415fe4c38085`。 +- Claude 原提交 `dfe2c65b9b8afe583f43dd6df8e0afdf520aa1d0`,作者 `Claude `,保留原 Co-Authored-By 字段。CSV SHA `93096734186c1247e46e98f26c7c9b0f7a4987c8d8d588e8147110ae3880be2e`;声明 SHA `bc5df5dbcf02176b5292dc455aaf9fae34ef14bf65208645d9a7bfd4319af5a4`。从固定提交直接取原字节,三份原脚本仅归档,未执行。 +- 两方各 25 个唯一匿名 ID,均与匿名输入 `3864d34141a393b957a09937e609ad827ea21c16` 的空表完全对应。Mold 的顺序亦逐行一致;对照按原空表顺序、以完整匿名 ID 匹配。声明均明确仅使用匿名输入并在关联前冻结;本次确认的是这些原声明及文件一致性,不独立证明审员全部历史访问行为。 + +完整逐行证据见 `artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15/comparison.csv`;两方原件在同目录 `sources/mold/` 与 `sources/claude/`。CSV 对照哈希 `e7603e06ac5529608c23b889475632b5d75cfbeea7686528460a6c81dcd10bfd`。只含匿名 ID 和原审员证据,没有来源身份、残差、原排名、分支或姿态映射。 + +## 三项分歧 + +| 匿名 ID | Mold 原判定与依据 | Claude 原判定与依据 | 待裁量边界 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| `731fb76c6a44dced20b7632559c1bd90` | UNRESOLVED;外径均约 16,厚度约 1.875 / 2.250,不能刚体重合,但通用环形不能判明是否同母型厚度变体 | unrelated;外径约 16,厚度 1.92 / 2.40,内径约 8.30 / 7.91;尺寸不同、parametric variant 而非同一件 | 几何不相同是否足以排除同侧,还是未知设计关系保留未决 | +| `1ead5efb8eed037f8a15292213f1a799` | UNRESOLVED;外径约 16,厚度约 2.625 / 2.250;不能区分同源改型和独立设计 | unrelated;外径约 16,厚度 2.76 / 2.40,内径约 8.01 / 7.91;parametric variant 而非同一件 | 与上一圆环完全相同的规则边界,需同一标准处理 | +| `a7496efbdd612af87016938ca6c29b08` | UNRESOLVED;左件方角、右件圆角,厚度约 7.5 / 10.16,长宽也不同;无法仅由板形判定设计关系 | unrelated;约 175–179 × 80 的板件,厚度 7.7 / 11.1;方直边与圆化/倒角边不同 | 是否把尺寸/圆角差异视为足够 unrelated,或保留可能变体的未决 | + +这些尺寸是**各审员原记录**,不是本轮新测量;两套厚度数值确有差异,本对照不取平均、不挑选一套冒充统一真值。两方都认为存在可见几何差异,主要分歧是关系标签所用标准。Claude 的“parametric variant”属于其几何解释,并不提供共同母型来源证据;Mold 的未决也不是共同母型已确证。 + +## 一项共同未决及适用规则 + +`3058d0a6c2ca1a763191a43218edbbe8` 双方均未决。Mold 记录两眼弯连杆的大端孔扩口差异;Claude 记录约相同的 PCA 外包络、1.5% 面积差、凹槽对应及不可判定的手性/小特征。理由保留为两份原证据,不合成为“已知等价”。其后续同侧遵循原有 UNRESOLVED 保守并组规则,但本次尚未执行身份关联。 + +既有工程目标是降低跨折泄漏,接受过度并组的统计功效成本;“相同物件/刚体重合”与“应否为泄漏保护而同侧”是不同问题。两圆环的厚度差不是整体等比例缩放,不能直接套用 scale-free 模板关系;这仍不能独立排除设计变体。双方冻结前没有明确的“两审分歧聚合”条款可由本端自行替代。 + +**提交 Claude 裁量:** 三项争议是否沿既有保守原则,只要一审仍未决就保守同侧,因而保留全部 4 个未决候选的合并动作;或由你明确给出另一统一标准及三个匿名 ID 的最终动作。若采用仅相同物件/尺寸匹配才并组的限定,请明确这与既有防泄漏、未决并组规则的关系,并在组件冻结前记录。任何裁量均保留双方原判定;不把尺寸变体默默扩充成已认证关系,也不把可能亲缘默默消去。 + +Claude 提及“约 20 对经 scale-free 路进入阈值带”和细长件 P95/Rg 的局限。前一个路由数量不是本轮仅凭匿名材料可以验证的事实,暂按审员陈述保存,不在此对照认证;几何细长时横截面差异可能被长尺度归一削弱,是后续 G1 限制说明需要区分的问题。此处不打开残差/分支表重新筛选或改阈值。 + +下一步:先取得三个匿名分歧的明确裁量;按既定程序仅由托管方关联判定,保留原映射与完整证据。随后报告组件数量/大小分布、最大组件件数和节点占比、每来源键件数,再按既定顺序进入 split、十件测量和 pilot。当前组件与 split 均未冻结,也未增设用户或 Grok 审批。 diff --git a/tools/compare_g1_band25_reviews.py b/tools/compare_g1_band25_reviews.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9f11aa7fc --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/compare_g1_band25_reviews.py @@ -0,0 +1,81 @@ +"""Compare two frozen anonymous CSVs without opening any identity/pose mapping.""" +from pathlib import Path +import collections +import csv +import datetime +import hashlib +import json +import shutil +import subprocess + +ROOT=Path('artifacts/s2-g1-band25-2026-11-15') +DEST=Path('artifacts/s2-g1-band25-review-comparison-2026-11-15') +CLAUDE='dfe2c65b9b8afe583f43dd6df8e0afdf520aa1d0' +MOLD='36f2462eb95ad0d67274a49ba5c431fe728fab2f' +EXPECTED={ + 'mold/frozen-review.csv':'6479eebdfc09629c7188f18f888494c5d9bea8dd160d92763813b15ef813ce18', + 'mold/reviewer-attestation.md':'f317b9c4f790943b45607452c9c381624b17ad5f6fee6b009658415fe4c38085', + 'claude/band25-review.csv':'93096734186c1247e46e98f26c7c9b0f7a4987c8d8d588e8147110ae3880be2e', + 'claude/reviewer-attestation.md':'bc5df5dbcf02176b5292dc455aaf9fae34ef14bf65208645d9a7bfd4319af5a4', +} + + +def sha(p):return hashlib.sha256(Path(p).read_bytes()).hexdigest() + + +def main(): + DEST.mkdir(exist_ok=False) + sources={ + 'mold':ROOT/'custodian/mold-frozen-received/extracted', + 'claude':ROOT/'custodian/claude-frozen-received', + } + for name,folder in sources.items(): + out=DEST/'sources'/name;out.mkdir(parents=True) + files=['frozen-review.csv','reviewer-attestation.md','frozen-review.bundle'] if name=='mold' else ['band25-review.csv','reviewer-attestation.md','tools/dims.py','tools/inv.py','tools/web2.py'] + for file in files: + target=out/file;target.parent.mkdir(parents=True,exist_ok=True);shutil.copy2(folder/file,target) + commit_source=folder.parent/'original-commit.txt' if name=='mold' else folder/'original-commit.txt' + shutil.copy2(commit_source,out/'original-commit.txt') + for name,digest in EXPECTED.items():assert sha(DEST/'sources'/name)==digest,name + blank=list(csv.DictReader((ROOT/'blind-package/blank-review.csv').open())) + ids=[r['anonymous_pair_id'] for r in blank] + assert len(ids)==len(set(ids))==25 + reviews={} + for who,file in [('mold','frozen-review.csv'),('claude','band25-review.csv')]: + rows=list(csv.DictReader((DEST/'sources'/who/file).open())) + assert len(rows)==25 and {r['anonymous_pair_id'] for r in rows}==set(ids) + assert len({r['anonymous_pair_id'] for r in rows})==25 + assert all(r['relation'] in {'unrelated','UNRESOLVED','rigid / same part'} and r['local_evidence'].strip() and r['reviewer'].strip() and r['review_version'].strip() for r in rows) + reviews[who]={r['anonymous_pair_id']:r for r in rows} + fields=['relation','local_evidence','resolvable','unresolved_reason','reviewer','review_version'] + output=[] + for pid in ids: + a,b=reviews['mold'][pid],reviews['claude'][pid] + same=a['relation']==b['relation'] + row=dict(anonymous_pair_id=pid,agreement=same, + adjudication_status='CONCORDANT_REVIEW_ONLY' if same else 'CLAUDE_RULE_ADJUDICATION_PENDING') + for who,source in [('mold',a),('claude',b)]: + row.update({who+'_'+field:source[field] for field in fields}) + output.append(row) + with (DEST/'comparison.csv').open('w') as f: + writer=csv.DictWriter(f,fieldnames=list(output[0]),lineterminator='\n');writer.writeheader();writer.writerows(output) + disagreement=[r for r in output if not r['agreement']] + assert len(disagreement)==3 + matrix=collections.Counter((r['mold_relation'],r['claude_relation']) for r in output) + summary=dict(status='TWO_FROZEN_REVIEWS_COMPARED_ADJUDICATION_PENDING', + created_at=datetime.datetime.now(datetime.timezone(datetime.timedelta(hours=8))).isoformat(), + anonymous_input_commit='3864d34141a393b957a09937e609ad827ea21c16', + mold_commit=MOLD,claude_commit=CLAUDE,pairs=25, + matrix=[dict(mold=a,claude=b,count=n) for (a,b),n in sorted(matrix.items())], + disagreement_ids=[r['anonymous_pair_id'] for r in disagreement], + same_unresolved_ids=[r['anonymous_pair_id'] for r in output if r['mold_relation']==r['claude_relation']=='UNRESOLVED'], + comparison_preserves_original_rows_verbatim=True,identity_mapping_read=False, + custody_join_performed=False,components_frozen=False,splits_created=False, + geometry_or_registration_rerun=False,scripts_from_reviewers_executed=False, + original_authors_preserved=True,source_sha256={str(p.relative_to(DEST)):sha(p) for p in sorted((DEST/'sources').rglob('*')) if p.is_file()}, + comparison_sha256=sha(DEST/'comparison.csv')) + (DEST/'receipt.json').write_text(json.dumps(summary,indent=2)+'\n') + print(json.dumps({k:v for k,v in summary.items() if k!='source_sha256'},ensure_ascii=False)) + + +if __name__=='__main__':main()