From dbfb11ea4201084b1dbefdee8b9ece30b82c41bd Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Frank14f <1515444314@qq.com> Date: Sat, 14 Nov 2026 21:15:13 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] Join witnessed frozen review under custody and record continued-work policy --- AGENTS.md | 2 + .../frozen/frozen-review.bundle | Bin 0 -> 10481 bytes .../frozen/frozen-review.csv | 121 ++++++++++++++++++ .../frozen/mold-frozen-review.zip | Bin 0 -> 20917 bytes .../frozen/reviewer-attestation.md | 17 +++ .../public/custody-join-receipt.json | 34 +++++ .../witness-and-ruling-source.txt | 87 +++++++++++++ docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md | 12 ++ docs/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14.md | 22 ++++ tools/join_g1_frozen_review.py | 92 +++++++++++++ 10 files changed, 387 insertions(+) create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14/frozen/frozen-review.bundle create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14/frozen/frozen-review.csv create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14/frozen/mold-frozen-review.zip create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14/frozen/reviewer-attestation.md create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14/public/custody-join-receipt.json create mode 100644 artifacts/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14/witness-and-ruling-source.txt create mode 100644 docs/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14.md create mode 100644 tools/join_g1_frozen_review.py diff --git a/AGENTS.md b/AGENTS.md index c12748ec6..e55f1c642 100644 --- a/AGENTS.md +++ b/AGENTS.md @@ -8,3 +8,5 @@ - Preserve original data, failures, review limitations and immutable evidence. Do not label proposals as executed or reviewed results. - Current E1 scope follows the standing continue-work authorization relayed in Slack `1794651141.035699` and Claude caps `1794651169.320839`: bounded CPU-only label-free preparation and synthetic checks may proceed after the count checkpoint, without another user approval loop. Total 16 CPU-hours / 25 GiB, at most 8 processes, per-job 30 min / 1.25 GiB tree RSS, at most 2000 registration pairs; the 10-part stage additionally stays sequential within 3 h / 5 GiB. Never read labels, fit models, use GPU, run pilot/full matrix, or exceed caps in this scope. See `docs/s2-e1-budget-checkpoint-2026-11-14.md`. + +- Post-witness update (2026-11-14 21:12) supersedes treating the preceding E1-only scope as the entire remaining project scope. Follow the latest section of `docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md` and Claude Slack `1794661944.308269`: custody join, label-free copy calibration, k=3 per-route candidate count, bounded registration (up to 4000 pairs / 100 worker CPU-h / 16 workers), band review, component freeze, then coordinated S2 continuation. No repeated approval gates or reruns of completed review; preserve concrete execution limits and distinguish future stages from completed work. User preference: tens of CPU-hours alone are not a reason to block progress. No additional scientific task is implied by this preference. diff --git a/artifacts/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14/frozen/frozen-review.bundle b/artifacts/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14/frozen/frozen-review.bundle new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a46f3fa969ef554cd2fde403765ce018f02fb379 GIT binary patch literal 10481 zcmVgmNRxO+c8Kksuv1Sv=BwH-}xDxfr81${iC7fs=)5S^!#A~XIm?QZSi2Vq)c4pIqlnev`!t1u%a z`t?Z@%=w5TY2ODz!*Av7{umxFoS8Ge1u+H-%yG zEe+S2=hHi8RZ86U6`44zmMT&ihFw*kB6K6(cAs+@zWUM!AJQ1`MCdN-9Fx259J>*{60l{hSyH; zviLbp^^4y>#pw*6@qdUUGIC9r)ls{FTAgSTREQy2N43iz1<#A&=I7Jtc#dHg!+qRc ztUK?Hhn?NI>1f05gs<8C>8Ec$>@J^=yS<&@MgBM);9^ z?)+%?``shFcs$ts?%}wP=iQ%v`S$MSDV{&QVRw1JFVkh`?6iBZu$tXx*l&2{!P`%;57Y5_|FAos?BOsT?swzmygNsavVO>K zp2qu!OMPelcz*%uuZIBgq~mqEJ&*Wh#BG5;ha>J9NOw9O0)Ak5z=j(#I7g|nnkA={ z3)GT>lEN z#HD>6r?}zT4V6(@$_GDC<)j_7Wm;10sS#YsZteeaoIb+S;RH`(oILKZotpNY;{Ckf z-DlM2+n5jJ{9w~%!}WSEq9nthq)h@$D`+tc%=3ZifoRjO7yi0U78g2!`oJdV?RN0g zk8Q2zOFW%WZQy0NqA;F)kue+};oo==8!kRc&ZXiilEI|GvZ#bHD!MQP&#CAZ|J%b9 z<82rp;{lxt>cnLI$9O5LYd#`thMoLFUKl*`a7M}E?lXFUDkLb_rFxV4=B8)ozhCWy z-#vum=k4UARM<$FQzArbhruwL0%KhHA#ulOC+Ck3_A$i?j{sK*KCrDi?vIE2Vky_@ z6aMu84k7M~4C4WfdoupwcyFvoX^7O&l{H+a=8cP!&91xG zw6f)k8DCGub9LrZ{k=VJXwsBA5QBi81?3b6&%~UThSTK5z*Fpm_%}OY*f=d-2|jQ< zwKW$Vn<6~>@caNkR6EYG3m5!o4^O+tBj^)qB{ z^k)C-aX-S7Y_{vucxb}(CzB@om;=tmjyc9)fSn!k8CJIC+PMHn#e*SUazeEQc%b;8 zRE&|B;JdZ|^OwsMALIUMhsxid%VT_WplMZ>7WE$D7ki(*!+9U$r)J+@M)=O9EZKG_hGgMS4#bn^TFe&(5W*;%_<$acri``i8aF~V2jsfus_ z3%|r^x}NZT)A+dI`VDwq2z$o)Ai3jGI4i9XQVSBa?AQOBJ!RjN-K@XPONXGg--F@I zD&vpvli4-HH*kfp>fQFc@2w3yQ9u~PLC|Abz}FB3$shwWJ^K3dH17Asvm(IAt81R$ zANRQKXZjSsz@CFTfdYd1M4JQn{&>N)p7z%*#Rz_IHUd_Hzn!9LHM z0hoXDss`Q6t`sre`G|4xe3RYqZn_?_D@LFQOFzZ3P<&s0N85nU(RHx!ZucvCgd;u` zjEqaa$`)zeSx?$!6#3*U}znf-28Av6$KxCDZm0mo6uDk?Z|qL z3w<~qKf>aEsVMvL3J3#TQbbiB_q#%v5Ud|FJ`W>oAL!1rK!Abce7F0)J_TUb;|RKC z;iJI)LNqzT5uPFF@5l2)LGzEWrV!8L{o(Egh{FY3*@s=@XXgh9PMtL0Hzv1xYY+Zu z_e=cy6`r-rxB-`ma>6;LF$eFIPb*Eo(J^S>_)y2h)9H-0fX+yPP9B7;L(g^_3z~0P2 z1rNept^+Kr1#EM5kv9NO9FGqTQ-fr0*lFSG#iz%4c2 z)5HbA-f`S-t$jIer1L10SBTO|brFi9c)M=z{Nk@~fU0kJL6HZP?CtX@0>H2Czgs-C{g#|e6R_Gru* zK=-tYii}uUif*qIW`l9UL5Pad zazK)u_WUK)HBabXT~SUn@@RX(Q|N@@j^Vncbf z9g<~0(Pgjz+yx(eRFngXkV%JCf}}$8?nIhKBe}(8gog7m)K*b4)&N7@ujzfoI~z(8 zh5>>dbxFC1T5pn7#&{Ju9qcM&k|SW*;?MT{u&~)nc3caWT_RseKr|+sUF&8m7tFg5 z8I6DugJcl)7{EqM+fzc|A1~og)|XrGDjB3*PbWZcXYeP0)#j8=b}~Oz*!%#D1A%|x zDfV)){sFOnMM8i%CP2g0mWsj^w1O|s7W6Jq^p-@`{lr5qB_JDl%nL>kZ_nq5JG%R1 zr_lmE`Km3{)&crqjG^8F@F4&nBAkM>px|zmm4OfeakODRcRfG!=;yQtzSUc--`mI2 z?mixYR!mPV=Xb%}COAk8H=QA4!e&Fou*2ZIf~cFcl-vsw1*Qm;=MFe_pAv5XqFLZ7 z0@H$n+m{~8P>Kqwd!5c1<{XQ1ZVa6F zSQu;L*4gbLi!Pd8b-HH#TC|@=cencqt2qfE5x7ZkHs?(6O5vu|eEPagejR>RNpaZ; z*}y*2vNIS<%Dk}>=lpSZyFZT!bHrdrrLJ|}#V>w;MIHz5dpsdP8_!o*4%Y21$oFg!Q=IUeBoSkJnnWviCR4WI>YfKIR!zC!&5ofjZvUtoIBzGFsxFvzhrEJ z37HBxml8!O^{vobZ$d3h%!qc$`){6=5?(SP2LhIpcoJYGKq9D$gN?w4`S2nIk-a9C zwyu~p$V{kU)&j+{LE$$uUl<=p6sWwmr5cv(#QEyZAT=I0= zq@XV^|GLK-+yv6BlBvhAPVnc-OUD~*G0nM1v_Dp7(7;_I5gU3g@UuY$6F5nU5efU~ zJ)j|Hh*i;&p6C1oiyJT3FqXWx1uv5iG2`aBxLj5ILrXf~x#zn1n6>BjcmSKqLT@Mp zz*KHL2ZA&#Xvl4Jm%g_520foX_u@ahUD(9;VM=BaA=L+;o2hX%JkqV(a z1G65u5$lY{5}6vd%R~q;Q%*0>$Ah)I73fCus%A7BObPnvsW((M5U_sA&5*>PxTS93R7c(K z^Ir;CZ0HX*8GeGQKIa5FO}BmM=m;}_lM6tiYu2d@Px?-!4dnu-Awm)&IRSKoJ0ZO# z0pJtyhT9%M{q?%PjJHU#;yN#hNuardC9G>@b9+dw8nqvn0%nVnwIl0_!F5}5D#M^; zh>kn1!B)67oF~pA36TsTr5AV#JmKfAX7^wZAIl1|=P7E1cnE&}p}wxH{JYwfg)hdR z-d>Kk^;=lv0^py$Zix)ouEsJ1hjetT14aCsqs-lv@I*bR5|L-(-=%c}C>(q@>Nb?y-7 zEh=4vNvCk=lE{(T%+}wWSuNOFh4Yf>x5jbLG8dP!vi3%AiQ{xt=RilyY61+% z;ssNavl}Wz^;rk$J6w(80CkDiCq>Ri#1*8a7)yq1aUyggmqr1po5e#dDuneh!}L}SN?N8c=XEX`!4O|mx@@) zjP@nN5~p(OM!|2}!#2Q_L5l=_UK19S@RsKv7I~bGg$RC ztugmmTU_l{tPP53e>|41h+1>{Tg_i$gXXz#w-Rm_c2?DLcX`6@6?e?Is)XOownl;v zG=ww8sUHAwdm1Q!aOSB9o(z8wMe^$KU>m2bg~SFCXI6x`3aK|%t`TB^fmK7Q`NNrr zBYEuE>a0Z*GSZup0E!+A&rVOPxbsfe@P@?IHNZ1(vrB!S^LJnv0IHqgUI3l-gBRWd zBDGQKB=z%_xYA`=TW;zVfYx=hc>THEx-rp=K{5l)9Yq;|S9QZ2Kv z%xEcqFEHY)Nlf{^-u6Q&(bPt{mZXGZigW+*p>&z{;0Ux}zo78h=^c)M1-DEqDNnso zhEgY3;?WXLhd_x}ngLZ1uGjON#V$QM7^rU1LQy2lzm&vE6$I73_XnkoC!?tv<_^WY z3#P(WMue?Pvf@2z`-T8jZC}lflsYqjjV`|7_cN|PXQqtpSYM~%o{`9uP6`_l2;k%) zMKe%IP2$SFUgvw>S}`u26s5g>X(hT|F2{<4YCUY*rfB5{CxZ{cMdJnlgjBjAYEA(O zCK}WWMaUZ3dIhppWZc}rWW;LORe<1QOdq-&9OlecIn>e=vCg6vpI1=M`&8l|i!yf^ zAUZ^98!sSB4|3jf?hroJAQ+**;DEw;V+Q!2b}rc`^nr1PuaHZz^yyP!SmqJaXwLOEc|N?|h1%7ZmxjF)imCJM@%Wjhppk z2fd+08t*x1!G{!_9gGh$F+1R0AkOKkNc(GFZd|Tl%=mbnRfNBuT1Y7cx=J^W8)n#b zOe}ylQ6hrSmIEk-u+5oI*xX=y^7HSRMy?|DWUGHdlghrh>((fm_==l9rgV;%2Jz>L z)0}kLP`X5daXJMK*oY@gvX}%C8#LThvtUKK|A)JM>AP=Ncbv{AEDvwFGASGfn5Gy} zfYh|ragYRp33oyn@d9Ynj9W)2|D)jGor{;x5s5V*kd}Zh4MwXQu=``*kdfO}PkS_& z#qAc5vHP_a(j)ez}fDRo+Kb!nU)^9Q4)+x1HBcK!5sxZb6VwJ=BvFK5@lsT%y)-9Hjoz!xXX7hy8pm;EYq{LVm z!Ow!@1%hFNCL{`OhUXQ{W)nFG*IP;}+b%wK$uX5atSuJ|k!}D5!8=T0z*c%9r2w?R z2&}%}-EWGmmp#rGcJZzi=EQ0hqjJmNZm~bAS$OVTs11bp-s{v_G|*;W)){V={8NXI zD`&y%!kos(yb~@XKW_K8>!GBa(53WE-K902QP!)C1FzP%=Wh0VJL?{PnjJXeaxCKIH+99m?n2hP zn%du5b6>{0X=R-iE^Y+0Hupiy$tB|A2CE~##K(LNU)R?@c<>QMNv>qzM&pGD9JB#& zN5CK3_dxxI>6@Z3OFV34xw#MO_@&%H&GGmA5cf4Zh1do*^gi1H8qRjAkgO&OB8?pg z@c>{*k`Q&G_tYA)x;pfqXyMB>%voED%ZOb{;kjJT@a4LPVmnz3QJ@%L%#w0vSONi* z93%u&h?-RO>B8a$Gh{6AC0+OX+foG#@l?Cp^Kwc8rFgS2K^(%^4{#LEp-;bMC%K@} zL+%BK4=6f53K&;ItY-cRnY{g>8mtiZOr-HTt&9bsn#{@62nv-HzeX>aGAq-AhICbI8T zhBt(2DeShaTu`#-v+dLXlb3(H=1CLpx}gBi){e61BIuzB-VMMws1uPG_%p277?xkV zczgB}Ugj>LW7SxL7e>31-C{H~WmW2UON$NK99kT}zjEWFyLbN1jr@ngELJr$3anw* zJK6V#Ow~%Ft~PairFoe|jfpf$4Nr|kqg`S0eHQceq{as zu)3a91|D3%PoLWe0L;PFR6@PZQY+Ru0KHGA-;k|3hdxa7H4Oli^@@C-XItzGr?`D6 zCF{1vKNvpnA<2QJZei4@ap6Ob!)a-GM%e*z|0{# zDh7R~WVzSA-NJFQOY|Xtk=qzkQXa#O7K*B*SXeQvoJ8nn?ajP$m3Xc&dun}Ht0vNH zTe*|I=GgxE?|2WXWFAhosoVYdDWk61IdoeGVYESmXeqVd9kABzJW{Ds^>N?&#T_>~3aqD%6BR6;I8p4Ve0kcyTeCA+zuF6%cE?;VhoerOQ#?$5RM(XyR(e?I0$_H#BJTXy48 zn$0T5y~%90!0(%`d$`d340mSEy36YK&KA z~Jag=&xw&0c&!nX;J~xS%A!W_!FFgl`>m@tR z?c@N)1w7S<2pXV_CdA?ZmO-f@60!FBzh?hjrzG{RU`Z&pIZkCH((D-u1Hx3p3SHFB zvbke=JZ&f!Qykb)z^g$j5T`)5Od=qw9imvVx&rZ*d3`M|W!2ixXa$keD|eD}8Vi1Q zTbrQz`5JZHK^uR(p>!O)ydK1$2NNM+bET5DG7ZjB5kzS7<(hZ9SjMbt`3dErsBi133S=zZ5RL@57Jn}mEd%U z9`8Q#m?#+taWcwRMt;@yp9tQ2I2)JW*C%C;Qb7w$f@eZ`N&xB_ys)5*0Kg=LkfC=Ce|@Ej z_I%Fm{(3+Ahcf+Py)ja6tw1;v}BPRvTr0AgVeJ&q3wk7d>EMaK}w~FB-%*A zNistM%sXh(7naJ*Cv?qtue=+Q)P{t%gXrgxHz2r-nZSyBEaKxtqTGPCp*)z$j{}4z zWd`Q+Fsl%;{gfM~N#B9`OP_9>%RC+4&N*<5z9{b+mG@QPQYdaXqig&vCKqel?uIgY zKLE+%T1e^~jf~0=0QtqlAvUk?Bfb)%x+%xq)a=?9w6tfT{k8Ee&7o{NR4`DLLeeSG z80El7FoUsapdN@l$kJbe`{8-srN2779Nx-Rod0N^#fB1q(+)8iZ2ps&>>h-IAQBW# zss$+c0u^<0xk~XkK90*IY2a~7&wBed5$#Adt|8EgsWbzkI$GJD~qO@WIr zsFa-b%t)(~lTe|=8EiIP_dzwzA0I0#Zr!c@y|-FT zydG+eAe7#oO%*sI(Ha;V5+Yqsm6C&ZMlneTuYDiWzWHsw=Q6jW;#KBeUCSYrd2Kf> zy)%7`0od0C#<#0v4N_lT@$G^9-1_T_probM8xV5L0oEMf=z%^O0%dN@z?WqPv|n-*9o$h~3=5rgx-R_r~s4OMKX&Uk4mX^XXIhDA07ZXZF?!Z7xhfRBOwLWmJdM1z)gG$< z$CC1vu1^98js^z+P=+If1ULnc1LOx2)9NbvUsk!yC25%Z4(jiKs@)|mY!%?xLI3XN zT?h2bt=vte0_D&GFb2hupA3St1~Lou`)qQNQt;5m5!?h?3F1JKL>`V&_p!*l;)Y0J*QfByYFtvWe&v%&Ij zbZgx}85@BYLTj$gd+Q#?mH}>UJN+!a;!kg$mzxVcn1^-mbD0{msat|CP*EUq2@V;2 z0UI<++ISuY!U83HRTTW?^%CCt_Z_T$n;HH#i49NE2x0*H;O5+Eprk|*7Hw{+{th6Ao}N) znh^8MA`H7-fyjP=PX<5VTsMBmW3=a7UUe=SuIJ~;(%OlGvk2yHZ&c2b7|R)VIPlZg_17dT36B1{(4@6cny;+# zhkg=5`Q>xD(do4*1h4Y8O&M4UHlz@Z9;{%*L^?2V_fn{cB^MXgDTKrPD?XMzeU>)t zM}OyEdKN3Eo=4la*3NBzU0q6+=B!&vT=_&bgR=<2*#NMhjjoxe36Dz;-?Q=F<=1_n zYb;!|pO}TyKafqgn`upw2I1cazu#DJgWrFY@NdJPGL!9xVxKS%iZlWqbv=~PeeY>Q z{r{U1g3`Z=0eGBMR?BW9HxRt*D;n6#E+EO0)(#B&Wb7sj1KD7aO%BP8B70_NamWcD zmdB_3Mt(0}l4{OKR&Fw<+1*uL)$}|1m7gsiIg-kmQ&!mqzgRqyv4(ueq=QezWy&3s zX8cae`uk7z!31ioW1Ixs_aj-uKHEG}uQErg9GMcWZ*jvW+B@qF#aeK^Sez=~(bwS2 zL&{On`%l5}%aXn-{b5NDk8?D~HPPZTlHSp7v-@GS-LAIR^!_1Pb@jbdzU`F#ATi%< z>s2n1>5BMea8}!jp|P>A*zV}@^!L=2VCEiu1A(C?GQV;~sI(6K09XQGyW8M<@M9lJ zqNie7xdKew1QZkSN1HvT#DskU(jz523U)p*ocJ#Xd8 zqaRAXyC`^~fd-`yszpIT)%O5*dwXkkYPZ|on60|Kx!&(Sn%mv}X1Cd>Yt}crhRw&D zW&_6Gy_?64d^$uUbDlFB+K1c;Wg%w#_3h_BD3#bK&4~b!7>$o8Z!wBTvOW#0B@lh{ zz+MKwqy)&0SMx<0Vt7In;37v1J@rtM9UMblasIGG2JMQFMamc}htLf&)_DXl^H*V# zCZ|SJzqf4>QnX5(*7T#&-KkePsw6Un`glqpb9lCy zsZx%hmOV$osnMS`_?2W^Akun}-ox*1O~1i!3DyOuq%j79F{=m9owgi$&XAzMoV>Iq zSbyMp(sSx4i~XEC_0UTRQF`m`tJ*uhpI6Wj>d4WNz-@~HvdqFeJ|EQHI_xlEq*DkM zhoA$wwNuSS6@HRGq-m8@AJ4 zS;{i$FbvX8*DAyb_RG~rentu0@K?9rF=%_6-3GNw3b2aqe+k|04 zX6I@lB5VkCcZoqV^q=iBFy&Zu-K$_j1P}37DpDD+W#7^YZyCBe0PwkgwGSl|wrvhm z>z^Jz0}*yhy&&z*&Bbs`^G2AqunQ7D71g{13(If;n?Rc2TsW@EK*x?{CBH3` zX?bAW)Ug|?*BaGZcky6Nc5XPz-l)4uP12Pys|X8?15Y}IhOv0+tCGcD)8N@$6@T#I z=qaflJ1~?8{~UOvIt#H(XNPnzs1l!^13aPim95hoFE*Je&>}qr>+4G&CRs4_ZKRW-wkI_iM9L<}ta=EFha^x?(J*8(>)3=U noIL+Of@AI4)F*7q=Gc)%0_rK`ro|)w= zrpi*OR7a&(N2P@p=REZ)$wEM)0{{S6fcr0d{p0Q*8U>^PfU_$AfcnpK}Efk4L9V-C4)piNk<0@%kH%wYND_Y7hxV@{Nl|86|X{1{I*4uj}K0Kc=p@$ z>f6QDEcQ;XxbF8z=j_3J`wY)fVfZCqQYhUBe%j`^rqn85n}#TKm<99vwX(9 zaz~I(t`(YE1c|m}(*HMr!|lN2Epw4tJTBHI$5VD-_qOpc56InJ>UQ7 z{``O@Pw@1-bhoXuKfX3tAJa3vs7p_{J3G6F@L~Jq#=L%1v*km^Vcnk(a^%k$75p`l zO$0H5Wsc7geaXx-HPp6ot)APpUqBF)VBTq{ZtLoB|J%N?hZm4>)*N)&=u=ypwQjlO z;JM$ss#uFWd*%I6%bS0?%|v+avAf^ND;Zz!|HmP3=p|g%&+^?f0PN^@IN-W?*R7pD z{?UBkdyrr_**UJ12M-~*zmXR(43C9Nvb;WvqBI3zE-8rGl%9Fw$fyJ9>A~9`m5B3+ z4*!_p>*j$s+*ZV|eP_mfSe5UTaL0e3#E-DFb$bOVRatukMo?+Ln4r;I zN9C*>RqwC;*@ttEK;P^(q@rmK-+66r)_v~ITj$og>0YW6qQd%HX)7EjPKkP>v}emNKay&5FTm#g%B%e=LSDbFvF8J}o- z(-Q@cK|p$nHoe6TX{1EeFwI6-=J2ufSST6kWfZ5xyCrzcT0I6+Q z?yIN)Hs7_Q#NVBBR_`EMa_XfL@8su$UzVUA!?Vy${?J{}*!Uap-Rd+Vs0vxU9a>YHadB{rem?Oem@$=P;t=3?LhUdi{HU&CWQwj zBrp$ZA01|LASW$sc5e`=-6H{AxqNwL*^^CXHCc+!xR`r(s>9tz_ajL(Y9`@p0lL*q3bAd@}24)ptvkO!<-l zF)&(Y(LX29O*KAu(_kX@c@Bcq~whNzB;lX!^KGA4MnHeYXxD*~}j` z^>r<ONCIRX%R2CUojF8yX7TeqK)JPlxdhMtJq zc2&6Os!>!B&>Bw{KeGAFH&fQDdM0GU3z|1Ww#R69<1dq!+50&if7BkY-*;S8Bk?H< zVGjsTnd$%+QK0@3L$LBcKi{yOKMXdI0{>Ln=4}!^w4Pf&qxS&wLU@9}gP+B+As*j7 zdzti+O%o|S;PFKFk>zDTJ zg!Ob11+cP$gY`wwrJN1ip!|ardF-ksMwO--rs|#Mk~p zncRKbK8KFzhtgXP*Wa}S!N4lyvTbrww)og0zgs`ZzP@1OHI24{rAIpVasOh5xkyo@ z8})l&&z=apvr0-S)o`SeV;NxrAcaxkz)|HA_}`rDqPFnA+>Xu<4#wh_j-Kys^8{sX zj2SgP>=zJ9LJBV9#SL4FHW}kvW#7)g0j7Z)V?t2Kea`fa2gRkGM&Z^KC zI{quM(X!tRpv&-AmJeC$Cz67K-h&w%0oOo!_Kn#AsNM~yHHT_HZu{cL%LKHq%7GU~ zi@#q`N+oE8!Ix64dc_Tp?~@50{%G_lzzrDDyc&W}%_q%D{gf7HC#NY3Hlh7>Bc_y+OZPC{!8C#AY$AiAcIhx%o1T`b!*SpEmmt?Y+y z=Xkf9z>{3^@dzVh#z;U_o6Jq?6IneYLls&7=6E701oe)qYuq6<%yye)FgbA>1J5{@ z{<1lHDgcC97)!va4EP|~9&hU_^18={;k>=?t;TSK9vbU@WsIEI+U!poyh6}k<7;tJ zCg-pg3(G& z&i>eMXD#{yD<t&=)5#-Op(0AA!1C*vH?)$GB!{tCZb-A1WD#X)8@5+H7FuqwG@b`1nF?~ z;9`-RbFnN5vbI6<(6AfkISpl&1%T-K?<2oKUOXAJFtA_(H|e$r9fu_KAx{i$f>T=4 zBr>Droyq&x+S+AVcRhr3eNsbdAvVfv{Sym1tg#LhoY+9r5Hpl}Y@mePs;bBq5#zSv zLb~oHEl#n%B9)MXJBy(D(kmbaA}C;+=H9vP9jq=uTqKa2QmB7EEvgTr zF_>`@^OiyBHcf2)Z9tTPf*8+h3_$|LVGZZ)rmMf*7uH%e&hG?zQ-DYAromZk zgGWLz>-c1X&jyFArW1}TMZs72#Bj!A4VcYI5ET54?Gh`XKwOhRDH0Dcq zw7kGoa>Eg$wn{s4faES^wtvm}KDW#J6ZmULJ1xU40|jR5S+QkDI_uCtuTCBvg7I)J z14fc1HEtV&jQ#=QgfJIAd?Z46lbTvz7S0%U_mA|~uB!Deo2v56$n z%Q~A&aMMl)o{lGo*$FuhFD-e0Xx}4_lFSV(Q-M@WCtOk-uL=3RME@KcBFvACD2G~C z1o^xFb)VCdjDPM{@F-%I^V~&BOc^voR}}{L2Vf!=7ceq@v=8I1LC#bql@He{T!Kbq zhw2qSlG6_ine99QLSF%UyPnAuuAtx-RcBe7kRq)1Z_dS?4 z%JoiB90q|Q*q87;TtNXg$&P^Mz%5Pz*?GSp01UFg!K1H0{872@nx{9BikIzA%=qZh z_b=(q*viXwXjwM2ph`qZT3i|s{H-j^WFt!=d?6o117R!bNz5=>CT{bn7%Y>j0^{Ux zNK*&Kp~Ovv1sk3m-1A{Mry9pTI0B2+_YyF~Uq95+YzV3x1H1PdWVrCDc)*I?0a7FI z>1ejiR~QIcgN}<`{j3n0_1inf4`4|;lQ<6xR;8gNy^fSA`@M-+cb)1`0W^Ahw0=Wc zvc06*m+vrYQR5o6e9@#+unHs4@ZP+hMeLUx`Ov67<4;ZuqzkZn>A{-k^1@SRy_@j` z3h@Npp2XN3}^eehBe5j0Y6FxL=Xk}e9ct*=*MtAs*tckMkfEmHM6JdBaj z1#KY|Rkr3XK2p`VO+@M77STyfWG7L*Zo1C2{RL(balAFX8m$~TR1>6diHIa6Sf22F z+n^eY2P0&nQTTcgjm-~FSpWCJ?wYFCj+N9Oj6?Yw25~KSx>|eSTlrn~k%$+;vJQWh zwr8w6ANQ|h#i4;{HeVl?Y-zr*ci5w26g{AV6C{W|9vp%yrWfrT@Y(7hzQ)l6x)QpW zZE;jP2NzKJZTrVDyxgl_D2>$|qapnb zzG9|ai%5Ve<-_)W&FQD*)R#uB7+e~u%jLab)w*M^W`5At)jQLuLW;5u;7hBC&~bUz z9XB)yIcRfiL9@ql*O+(q@aj9q@EB{Y2;CfSmIy{>3uPTDCjvP6;8F)V9+bo8AqJp` zUmsr@;gweX7=T8#)Cg^bFXz;#K{W{qQWvdw>d%ZI^EzEVt`h&sGLxMIh$2LsR8XvJ zy-`@a3>%nd2eLXe$ol2qco<;=Dss0C0J(P|SQ`+eP0GjQcQk z;b9GoW$501V673f{1tPiWmvkMm-r_|0Ui$(c59DBoK;C$erKfH0OYfw!_1J2Uee`n zP0?<^FdP+P!*93x%W5BnDg?P#d>0xJs@6_oqW}g+i93fN{s(u(8>(KzY;CRAY`|t& zJ#foZj;I|U|6ojmdu|53ZlVY?UsGw~MQw*Dn#BW$m`BV8kC9jw*?Gg|97SNB7`qU- z71-xx3jLVx&ah0}>0hG4&pFJ%Uq_hp>gCp75*_;c{&iBiMThAW#o@|_;Cx*{mW_g8 z2@;#ii(Y!p4mJ>*dP}Cf4A`9uj#wrqJ7dHFVpW-^Gig+_3mGOB78Yy91A&% za^HG*W79{QPnB8wA(6mU9cUd{lu&Vy`JB(O0Y3#JUND6fx=NiG#$&h#9cS5vNW$p8 zbk7S)=8A?pybk@Lf2g~k&2fH97_Z-YRr-sWZUVq@xQl(slw zSO~j9Mad5>Vp-NR^$Xvqd@S^*dS-eM9`9|6Zfy3Q8BAB9814nPRc|(b%JBu6k%so{kg^RJ#mk9G=CJo7}fR4rS8dsWb@cAGPC|ic4!o zKG!!FnG!XmcV?9VBFQ7&ttSiAS&vcKg1=nj(xIU<2f{sY89}Q$Q)U^way5_2qihZeHaL1+~O-Y z?4qs=-715C`(Nf%fhu||#6)`lR4=cbF;K&sv;@!ygstk{Tz817PUoM%a=)sRP3X&ntx;-BmFx9lspKuV)>^q`ZghgnP5}np z%MwOMn1N58;8y8^%LA$AymB-*RQ}hg#jnj6-@T4Zl#F5(5UdHHxNx*n^0aa z{FN6fV~p#ecAbkXbY!h;>bMvVby%C{Vldc4HgY@& zkNu_C*@3Pk>lqmK{bIPdDByXCDj{8Cwk5Iq0~Ws#%uy0ZwE7_Q7Iu_f#3ajSXWrI^ zeEe9lCNzHa@QU)l&ii8tn&Vbr6&!cMy&|EC5}q`c0QL%CB$b5XR`f83Ti?!en{Tx} z%08y88$BAKFSFgIH+i|=9&W;`ji_9JZ8VnTY^enfmV!?XsTz@`c6Zdb1I=po?UF+O z;bm0?3h_#xo$DFFIU|RGXs*|3m8L-@T+Gv&+tvhxd z_d$S_)4n~VWGU5WO_N1V#qDbirfv0?0xqpvrAoi>5>dx#(*}o@KcD-ukYdy(69Y5i zFQk!IoAGV;Tz!H*DCGc5o)w?$`B7H7dJ>D9mC&v$6_nL#h}*X@{BtwOXM6glt8S@= z%^yM>+j4=ld&%ot_ZOkU?KFu0$3*;^c=zJ9)W#&Tr!n{`)O` z!M+OE+_4^QI6+`+3HiRn>eFyLt6}W`$}2W^6rrrYPz&P>wV^p}uF_Mg2Q{3{0g}@L zIu4}2UbGhiCKuxB4@nOT;Wm(fTxDMqu^(Bhmax+dJ3M{vzZx7c6q?R!gEk61AClze|C7hPsF~4_kGh~XN9jaUgTYV2$!3eDXQUc^DXhp6pM{y zlR;9975l00gph(Hx6;1I6IbVR**ZZ}^*c@dMW?;)Y+DIpHq9>#=&UwJ>Iv~KSzZuo zG{Pzqj68(IpZ~&4G3JVzPomUg- znoyxz;0AOlmTo3g^Mnh?-LfMAQtqOB^DT8x5lUPAs3}gGhXk<&E_WXS@_uXk=c+@} zcdCR1TO0w4Ncn7J(Jqhoz};+{by#vMU4e5{h#j(bFQYl>+WPUdnne}ru}>qUz0iJ zWp;_EBIbKe^ngn$C{<}~;?Ub_dw;O31<6eo%nBz0PDIs+8`jzHw(sf>J<_l6Ou_UZ z;mnS2>G8sG!){2AEDUbh9HFIdag1Ht)h4RANZyR~SFfzL*rhBsxFLu$!9z?xodj}8 z5~x<=&iHxO1`RJ zb(DhUs5`G2Zx7S%JJ{ec^+*B1S6_eaO5QYxf$S1I+DsTJbo@sT7@`TT4LfrjS*h_u z+UyTaIbA-N(~`C}ef7!W5(WXz$aE6(@gqilnD7${-ifn4zz`JQd^jv_K@8=<4j@gq zoCK}z{<+8EL$8$luEt23x|v(SoP6dK2OgqNtsh>0Zlb=;)SK@+HI^#=k}|MTm=>i} zs6~#HxRRhqtF9gVD$UD}p22*6Wzq^NahA>_$psg|-(5Gm;Q0yHZA}<2ptH~wzq6BY zpaAA8iIGc5QZozEgbJ#d)y;mEN5@{B^G!+h`K1QgL4AaaeBoG@tYewK;KJID_qQAG z75unlgr{Q*LBX0YvHibx`WxU}m-oM80|=03wE9!GTq6iC1gb-=kN33 zw-;q{@d9PA@HU)%s-Hmi4>uLnR8+P%-%%M7M~sqJ!cEro&#!8^f@&MVyC&m%C~VTd zaW{6*R$sKA6ha0WoZLOp!kk0zKv7s=rzmW_AvUPNWmTmN&|O`pO%uh@t%L!W zY;4SrRt@OgLU4mEMZ9DH$GDxf1u+01`HzG`52OIUlBj#%iL-Za!IyBBH{*T6ni~0J zpJSCu98LZn>HJc4JL*zZ4%kb?kZCpRli<|3zzY`{v8!)l#y^$2CJkkotq1I2#b!@Z zsteE?4>B6f67lLC$Z;M8U^+t!A*&M#iXI$31^{ z;w8<6g*JyAf)Y82TVpbTQ9j>xcEyU;0-Fo@GXBOxgi@MAAKWliqSU>m;Qf-`40@K$ zx6c{nBiNYWc8uw!zQ9d=P~TFaw&(h3`$|uVWxIMF#^Nmq_`9Pcb&MYyGlBwm8XO?u z_V;KCh z?X^+T!_$esF`}OHVU;%+h88&cg&D{0Jvrl)Ff^DL4PBuEiuw^8!_B2l=88)oZj{`5 z%Sm?92U>)&k_PE`0m5g%q7wth4(`Csa4(F-XS-NFD4MA(CFgETsxo;W&PU~C84rV@ z3;T%gWYJ|0vO7Rn#40AbVgYaOOyw2+(PRSg`)z2PMTI8ID$+Q;lL-Khj07=27b1B@ z2ZvulHBQC~=kd7H0mOl0$D#iq%sxRxL`P@8Uj5e9q9fl)XcJ4EvXLi`!9_Zai;agy zs;`)u6yhPlEDiJ9k7&00>3cVbrRC?2`hkJ|C`qcaetCnh;1=s3 zS`C0nZUe`3V@OD&o)E#j?eQ@{l59_PKkH9=K*pDE_j3M=jmBx z-zWyGaj$mM()yV9vXCLWvVG~f9%7r|pu-^uAE|N_T3!}8mTGHwd{$k&6mu?GjO6R@ zbr!uT?5?Y5>kQx&7in6aV&XYkEapJ`DReO6AA)m}G@>x`E##}|PW>lE~M7+XuiALj@9Ft?-CYw{)F`%~ad(1VHj zh`|leoWuOn3ShuP z&^DeQ2&(+Eao#y1krZcOO#m-DjmXmI-YhhMGB8EqU=i!1uLm=<5Lr-(m*sZM_*fEs z{pR|I<^F}+Tkr%UeJ5H|cvV{TE@(0fH;OT9e;qD}pFwF^C^uuIh#mStfBb_Kp#?Yf zIQ{>aHiGmF+~|AfRQfK2DI88mh+IwYbNQD#05$&cS`^5ZZ_b%DAkg2LmB^3=*aLe9 zwTUF`Q5+Ah%h|=dMRGbs7#qqq=18lf6s6#);wGi6-&NP){%9gk`z~$MM@=-4zptC+ zakSt$icw+-tBeN3c$gd?RLUYKu&@?rLi=Co1k(8Z(l|~f13-q}m~^FilB+EX6W;^$ z^<~lys&r-ap2XPyd2!z|ptc~kCbJYSUKV+?;c8=l(XYVvn_feH#*bOS1o@V1YxyMT z?M;}TO)bZe&483khyHw)9Q+?n3k)z#d^)!5bA!Jgr}nYzZPJsBrT=LsF|(kKJ*-=u{vh%aWRln4;Z zMv3xY{>GB}SXepzfg?&AE`62oXEaQ*nUK=3XDMA?SJ$7v<$X@grzhf08p%}EScdM= z;!COv^ZipCqBv+iLXd3nsxbQeqIlm6X;WpI1G)A9I9dWSV>W7@vq#kgs`rg`!9 zokZL1u1mH1Eai=udGq^;Iz!@7)T6nh#%feyUES}c^TVs#hq+Xv142KDph8NP9%u2g z#xHLGEpVfb)h(Y(QzDt7QWKpvaJe-|^skqa+5DvgVNt)8oD_AQX~Hz`_vZ5Si!9^H zo1LJ$p6m7JJ?FIe9rj0l63KLTPlAci)(vWH`RdBn(E@>ua!!q?!;Ni1IP&On0HsY}%3k$^<( z*m!CO<|xT}0i-Gl6u%pw0d!9>=hnq%dmVs{^k~!s&itPsKNkr4Tb0zf&Zvly1StMGfnzf_+0jD%GK-SmO{8pftvd z9_TocCs1QI7N=vWZUOz&FjkrG#9Y~KO#(AGtkB%xsP#+gq#EUH^4@nz?f1$`s8A%f zzea_o5-M5GVs*9^A5U%nQ?3$Mkj5|BTRxr7{+Mc}OFZM9u+e{EFW=Ma0Ji{DR?G|? z%v=dGncIx-J&{lV%;{{T)C$=0o^d&*j(*GGy_=GSQ}#YNt6bsj&exnmIsP-92>c!m zUO(2yD?l{2!E?%FT&xO<8D0SKhl<(v+jk_W$Xn@6IvAJM<6QD=n2=+2eDgu$%dmp@ zgpee#OQ00Yd6aD2lXO8t6HJ(WtRU#qA*1E z@?jZ0E8IDbqzn7)=4z<1hy}=ogwzh!%_CBn4xf_X$=2`?aL5%rMNJJ=0`je^N zzu7`rTY6kIBSOP*<`g~j$<|&*YjbsY6^pp@x*k_X^6vIrBO7HMGV(L2%$2YRu@H(p zKf>xfk1LY~4Q98N^)Lc1w-0H`33-`PU_bCZi+K?0`ndb18h%=&IQUUEM~)Vwlvk zAxm->^RG(6gN7ztuP+aRMks~7F~z(K;a=cmkyE7nP$ws{M3mZ0x8IAC3!ACfal}R_ z|5SOyMun3rDNQq(v79W0(&q4e2nL%0cqAF$A^z)z3;qY}ohmCd-BSYqSO2tsF~0u} z_DtOD&Fsv!Tu76@# zj9FOd-I?Lxm4roQ|Je%oKMgYDi)T)5obZ=EVifTQ{=w6AK(o+SQ`g-IQ6+3$Ib*a8 zo8zNFx>g@SLBR_bVMrRulO_UrN7@2511LYfB5ZHgqwu>C1lGp6wpc7$$5M7ZIxLvd zxv96y`XrANk<>}z@g-aOnB#5YDwN#P6jIiA<}>@VZ5U%6(=RG;j+xhaR+UU-6npjk zE(k7tV@;`G@ZF@{*`w^H=EI534^U5jvO@*Xo;j>+OiZlI%2ISAzh%Z}>1F6g<>(h> z85m3*Z6_<1yPbnGDx%Eyk^=Y~+#R}adr^w8i)fpqIO~eZn_9{1$XNvy899F#U(q8i zW`SmTE!1V!?lCgCT4 (U0C7SSQLBJ7) +Time: 2026-11-14 21:09:18 CST +Message TS: 1794661758.691379 +Accepted; working on: “@⁠Grok 同步 Yanqi 最新原话:“Astra风格经常过于保守,不影响进度推展即可。几十个CPU小时对我的32核心也不是很大的开销。…” + +--- Reply 2 of 6 --- +From: ClaudeWorker (local) (U0C7SSQLBJ7) +Time: 2026-11-14 21:10:02 CST +Message TS: 1794661802.418469 +*Claude: what the frozen blind result means, and the grouping decision so G1 stops blocking S2* (it applies after Grok's witness and the unblinding; the order is unchanged) + +*What the review found:* 120 same-key pairs gave *2 rigid near-copies, 0 templates, 0 variants, 91 unrelated, 27 unresolved*. Even within one source key, related geometry is rare: 2/120, 95 % upper bound about 6 %. Across keys it is presumably rarer still. Every class therefore sits far below the 30/15/15 held-out minimum, so *the per-class miss-rate budgets are "not verifiable" for all three classes*, as ruled for this case. That is a property of the data, not a failure of the review. + +*Pragmatic grouping rule for S2,* in line with Yanqi's guidance that checks must not block progress. It replaces the earlier per-class verification path. Leak protection is kept by erring towards merging, since a false merge costs only statistical power: +1. *Same source key → same side* (unchanged). +2. *Cross-key candidates:* + • k = 3 per route, two routes, union with min-rank deduplication; + • report the count, then register all of them with the fixed det-branch protocol; + • the 2,000 stop is lifted: proceed up to 4,000 pairs, ≤ 100 worker CPU-h, ≤ 16 workers. Above 4,000, report first. +3. *Link threshold from evidence we actually have:* synthetic rigid, mirror and scale copies of 20 random parts (label-free), plus the 2 confirmed rigid pairs. Link if P95 residual ≤ 3 × the largest residual seen among those true matches, in either branch. +4. *Blind review only for the band just above the threshold* (1× to 2× the threshold), in a small second anonymous package. *UNRESOLVED now means merge, not HOLD*, because over-merging is the safe direction. +5. *Exposure flags and source attribution* stay in the group manifest. The report states plainly that cross-key recall is not certified. + +After unblinding, MoldAstra's 27 unresolved same-key pairs need no further work: same key already puts them on the same side. + +*Next, after the witness:* run the synthetic-copy calibration, then generate candidates and report the count, then register, then the band review, then freeze the components. Then S2 can proceed (10-part preprocessing, R2-G24/N/E code, pilot) under the standing go. + +--- Reply 3 of 6 --- +From: Grok (local) (U0C7VDY1HEG) +Time: 2026-11-14 21:10:06 CST +Message TS: 1794661806.338179 +<@U0C7U1KJVPE|frank14wyq-tron> Receipt and witness of the frozen judgments/attestation and the pre-publication public seals. This is not an unblinding or identity join. No geometry re-review. I did not send identity or pose mappings to Mold. + +*Receipt.* Drive freeze package is readable (20,917 bytes; Drive timestamp 2026-11-14 20:55:30 Asia/Shanghai). Contents are only `frozen-review.csv`, `reviewer-attestation.md`, and `frozen-review.bundle`. No identity or pose-mapping files are in the ZIP. + +*Published SHA256s: 3/3 match.* +• ZIP `75833c32093bb8d01b36a12b434be970808144a7ffa3a262f99e057b9ac441ef` +• judgments `282f78136e01ca35dd7191b25e995f159d246769bd02c9bfa542d93737de01de` +• attestation `d50ccb179316cb518d0bde78252eca03cb2c995d9afd546623a9a47e841ef7d5` +Bundle bytes SHA256 (not previously published): `e27872dca19fb2f5cf9ff3d40f4e6285b3937c08e7f964d9e845909d38fae70e`. + +*Same-commit relationship.* The bundle verifies as a complete-history single root commit `d4da9d762fff04c918c88d63ab3191e2571d6547` (author MoldAstra, 2026-11-14 20:52:04 Asia/Shanghai, branch `review/moldastra-blind120-888d2a22-v1`). That commit contains exactly the CSV and the attestation, and both SHA256s match the ZIP files. It is not a git child of package commit `888d2a22` (linkage is the branch name plus the attestation's stated input). As Mold reported, this commit is not on the Gitea remote. + +The frozen table has the same 7 columns and the same 120 `anonymous_pair_id` values, in the same order, as `blank-review.csv` at `888d2a22` (blank labels were empty). Counts: 2 rigid, 91 unrelated, 27 unresolved, matching the freeze delivery post. No identity/pose columns. + +*Pre-publication seals.* Slack record 1794658410.904819 (20:13:30 Asia/Shanghai) matches MeltMind commit `236d672c1428303ab947704145fff2fc289d5a95` (20:12:46 Asia/Shanghai): +• sampling mapping `3a9495efad4196763713c20f8b9158d86fce3fb60409242208b67bcb481e37f9` (`sampling-and-mapping.json` in `public/sample-summary-and-seals.json`) +• final pose mapping `0b99923ed2de9d9bcf5d6032b72dacd9962cc3a08ec0da3703f673072b07c4fe` (`pose_mapping_sha256` in `public/pose-seals.json`) +Those two public seal files are byte-identical at package commit `888d2a22`. I did not open the sealed mapping payloads. Non-blocking: `pose-seals.json` still carries the pre-package status string `240_EXPORTS_PROPERLY_POSED_NOT_YET_PACKAGED`. + +*Chronology (Asia/Shanghai) is consistent with the agreed order:* public seals at `236d672` (20:12:46) and Slack (20:13:30) → package `888d2a22` (20:16:02) / delivery record `f652534` and handoff (20:31–20:35) → Mold start (20:42:52) → freeze commit (20:52:04) and Drive ZIP (20:55:30) → freeze delivery post (21:01:07) → this witness. Unblinding has not been performed. + +*Witness conclusion: PASS* for package readability, the three published hashes, same-commit freeze of judgments and attestation, and the pre-publication public seal digests and time order. This does not attest an identity join or unblinding. The custodian may proceed under the agreed protocol. Sealed mappings remain unreleased to Mold. + +--- Reply 4 of 6 --- +From: frank14wyq-tron (U0C7U1KJVPE) +Time: 2026-11-14 21:12:03 CST +Message TS: 1794661923.858859 +<@U0C7SSQLBJ7|ClaudeWorker (local)> 统计措辞请收窄,不妨碍既定接续:2/120 是本批分层抽得同键对中的“已确认 rigid”数,不是全部亲缘率。27 个 UNRESOLVED 不能计作负例;同键样本也不能支持“跨键更少”的外推。因此不宜把约 6% 上界解释为总体亲缘率上界。可直接写“本批仅确认 2 对,三类留验样本不足,跨键召回未认证”,将保守并组作为工程取舍而非已认证的统计保证。Grok 见证已 PASS,MeltAstra 正在读取原串及冻结交付,勿重复派见证或重审。后续 pilot 沿用户持续推进授权与项目约束,由你统筹,不另加逐批审批门。 + +--- Reply 5 of 6 --- +From: ClaudeWorker (local) (U0C7SSQLBJ7) +Time: 2026-11-14 21:12:05 CST +Message TS: 1794661925.304369 +Accepted; working on: “统计措辞请收窄,不妨碍既定接续:2/120 是本批分层抽得同键对中的“已确认 rigid”数,不是全部亲缘率。27 个 UNRESOLVED…” + +--- Reply 6 of 6 --- +From: ClaudeWorker (local) (U0C7SSQLBJ7) +Time: 2026-11-14 21:12:24 CST +Message TS: 1794661944.308269 +*Claude: I accept TRON's correction to my wording.* + +I withdraw the ~6 % upper bound and the "rarer across keys" inference. The accurate statement is: *"In this stratified same-key batch, 2 rigid pairs were confirmed; 27 are unresolved and are not negatives. The held-out sample is insufficient for all three classes, and cross-key recall is not certified."* The conservative grouping rule (merge on UNRESOLVED, a threshold calibrated on synthetic copies and the 2 confirmed rigid pairs, a band review) is an *engineering choice made to protect against leakage*, not a statistical guarantee. The group manifest and the S2 report will say exactly that. + +The rest of the rule set and the order stand. Grok's witness has passed, so MeltAstra proceeds as follows: +1. unblinding join under custody; +2. synthetic-copy calibration (label-free); +3. candidate generation with k = 3 per route, reporting the count; +4. registration, up to 4,000 pairs and 100 worker CPU-h; +5. band review; +6. components frozen. + +After that, S2 continues: the 10-part preprocessing, R2-G24/N/E code, and the pilot, under the standing go. I coordinate; there are no extra approval gates. + diff --git a/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md b/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md index dbf525553..f4cbd1664 100644 --- a/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md +++ b/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md @@ -23,3 +23,15 @@ S2后续已接受2026-11-14 17:38的G1及A1–A4裁量(Slack `1794649083.66264 ## 18:12持续授权接续(取代低风险E1的重复审批要求) TRON消息 `1794651141.035699` 转达用户持续推进原话,Claude `1794651169.320839` 已完成阶段回顾并给出E1有限预算。E1无标签CPU准备与合成测试沿持续授权推进;计数预算检查点不是额外用户审批。此前关于十件准备必须再次单独询问用户的流程不再适用。模型训练、GPU、pilot和全矩阵仍排除。详细上限/停止规则及已完成检查见 `docs/s2-e1-budget-checkpoint-2026-11-14.md`。重大结果和阶段转换前的集体回顾保持不变。 + +## 21:09 推进偏好及既定见证后的接续 + +Yanqi 经 TRON 在本会话与 Slack `1794661756.347349` 同步: + +> 合理,我没有什么意见。不过你注意Astra风格经常过于保守,不影响进度推展即可。几十个CPU小时对我的32核心也不是很大的开销。你们继续推进,保持健康的团队协作 + +保留防泄漏、原始证据与既定封存见证;避免无限完善、重复核验和把几十 CPU 小时本身当作阻塞。Claude 统筹重要取舍,沿原分工继续;不重启已完成的材料制备、盲审或 Grok 见证,不另设逐批审批门。该偏好本身不增设科学任务,也不取消具体任务的输入边界与资源记录。 + +Grok `1794661806.338179` 已正式见证 PASS。Claude `1794661802.418469` 与纠正后的 `1794661944.308269` 给出后续顺序:托管关联 → 无场标签合成复制定标 → 双路 k=3 候选计数 → 固定 det 分支配准(≤4,000 对、≤100 worker CPU-h、≤16 workers;超过 4,000 先报告)→ 阈值带小盲审 → 冻结组件,再衔接十件预处理、R2-G24/N/E 与 pilot。此为持续推进下 Claude 的阶段裁量;前述早期 E1 范围记录保留历史含义,不应再解释为后续每批次都要用户审批。实际校准、候选、配准和 pilot 各自在对应记录中陈述执行状态,不把裁量当作已经完成。 + +Claude 已撤回“约 6% 亲缘率上界”和“跨键更少”的外推;本批分层同键对仅确认 2 个视觉 rigid 对,27 个未决非负例,三类留验不足,跨键召回未认证。保守并组是工程取舍,并非统计保证。 diff --git a/docs/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14.md b/docs/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a8384551d --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14.md @@ -0,0 +1,22 @@ +# G1 冻结判定见证后的托管接续 + +2026-11-14 21:14(Asia/Shanghai),MeltAstra 在 Grok 正式见证 PASS 后完成 120 对冻结判定与原封存身份的托管关联。120 个匿名 ID 和顺序全部匹配;原抽样及姿态映射摘要未变。没有重做几何审阅、抽样、提取或姿态处理。 + +## 依据与结果 + +- [Grok 见证](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1794661806338179):冻结包三份已公布摘要、同提交关系、匿名 ID、先行封存摘要和时间顺序均通过;允许托管方继续。 +- Mold 原始冻结提交 `d4da9d762fff04c918c88d63ab3191e2571d6547`,来自 [Drive 冻结包](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1aQb996Lk7QnDF09cdpBxoRl8NW7YQtvP/view)。本次接收核对输入摘要后原样保存 ZIP、CSV、声明和 Git bundle;沿用 Grok 见证,不再请其复审。 +- 120 对对应 96 个来源键;2 对视觉 rigid 分属 2 个来源键,91 unrelated、27 unresolved,template/variant 确认均为 0。它们是几何审阅结论,不是历史 CAD 母型证明或数值配准证书。 +- 27 对未决均为同来源键对,按既定规则必同侧,不需要再次补图来决定同侧关系。这是分组约束;最终跨键组件及训练/测试划分尚未生成。 + +新关联文件保存于本地 `artifacts/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14/custodian/`,包含原暴露标记和来源,不改写原封存文件。两对 rigid 的后续校准输入另行保存。身份、姿态映射和关联表未发给 Mold;后续阈值带盲审继续使用匿名材料。 + +关联表 SHA256:`59f0d5c00c66af695f1b95d1be6d31b44c977c8fdffe78a4a27b1e6712b9eee6`。两对 rigid 校准输入 SHA256:`d11b3bef2c23e010c375fa0897c529577821aea729579d91a586d3d3f5ec1bdf`。原抽样/姿态摘要与冻结判定摘要详见 [托管回执](../artifacts/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14/public/custody-join-receipt.json)。审后 child 1 随机流未消费;旧按类认证路线已被 Claude 最新工程分组路线取代,没有为了走旧流程制造额外拆分。 + +## 接续边界 + +Claude 在 [21:12 裁量](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1794661944308269) 接受统计措辞更正:2/120 仅是本批分层同键样本的已确认 rigid 数,27 未决非负例,三类漏检预算均不可验证,跨键召回未认证。撤回约 6% 亲缘率上界和跨键更少的外推。保守并组属于工程取舍,不能称为统计保证。 + +后续顺序由 Claude 统筹:20 件随机零件的 rigid/mirror/scale 合成复制与上述 2 对作校准;双路各 k=3、min-rank 去重并报告候选计数;固定 det 分支配准最多 4,000 对、100 worker CPU-h、16 workers,超过 4,000 先报告;阈值以上 1–2 倍带的小盲包;未决保守并组;冻结组件后接 S2。阈值按已裁量的“真匹配中最大 P95 残差 ×3、任一分支满足即连边”实施,具体校准输入与数值单位在对应执行合同记录。 + +本回执完成的是见证后的托管交接。校准、候选生成、正式配准、组件冻结和 pilot 尚未在本回执中执行。后续沿持续推进授权开展,不新增逐批用户审批,不将几十 CPU 小时单独当作阻塞,也不重启完成的盲审/见证。 diff --git a/tools/join_g1_frozen_review.py b/tools/join_g1_frozen_review.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f4174bf2d --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/join_g1_frozen_review.py @@ -0,0 +1,92 @@ +"""Join witnessed, frozen geometric judgments to custody data without changing seals.""" +from pathlib import Path +from collections import Counter +import csv +import hashlib +import json +from datetime import datetime, timezone + +ROOT = Path('artifacts/s2-g1-custody-handoff-2026-11-14') +OLD = Path('artifacts/s2-g1-blind120-2026-11-14') +SHA = { + 'sampling-and-mapping.json': '3a9495efad4196763713c20f8b9158d86fce3fb60409242208b67bcb481e37f9', + 'pose-mapping-v1.json': '0b99923ed2de9d9bcf5d6032b72dacd9962cc3a08ec0da3703f673072b07c4fe', + 'frozen-review.csv': '282f78136e01ca35dd7191b25e995f159d246769bd02c9bfa542d93737de01de', + 'reviewer-attestation.md': 'd50ccb179316cb518d0bde78252eca03cb2c995d9afd546623a9a47e841ef7d5', +} + +def sha(path): + return hashlib.sha256(path.read_bytes()).hexdigest() + +def save(path, data): + with path.open('x') as f: + json.dump(data, f, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2) + f.write('\n') + +def main(): + witness = (ROOT / 'witness-and-ruling-source.txt').read_text() + assert '1794661806.338179' in witness and 'Witness conclusion: PASS' in witness + for name, digest in SHA.items(): + path = (OLD / 'custodian' if name.endswith('mapping.json') or name == 'pose-mapping-v1.json' else ROOT / 'frozen') / name + assert sha(path) == digest, f'Changed input: {name}' + mapping = json.loads((OLD / 'custodian/sampling-and-mapping.json').read_text()) + rows = list(csv.DictReader((ROOT / 'frozen/frozen-review.csv').open())) + blank = list(csv.DictReader((OLD / 'blind-package/blank-review.csv').open())) + ids = [r['anonymous_pair_id'] for r in rows] + assert len(ids) == len(set(ids)) == 120 + assert ids == [r['anonymous_pair_id'] for r in blank] + assert ids == [r['anonymous_pair_id'] for r in mapping['pairs']] + assert set(rows[0]) == set(blank[0]) + allowed = {'rigid', 'template', 'variant', 'unrelated', 'unresolved'} + assert all(r['relation'].lower() in allowed and r['local_evidence'].strip() for r in rows) + assert all(r['confirmed_relation'] is None and r['development_heldout_assignment'] is None for r in mapping['pairs']) + joined = [] + for source, judgment in zip(mapping['pairs'], rows): + joined.append({**source, 'frozen_geometric_review': judgment, + 'interpretation': 'Visual geometry judgment; not CAD ancestry or a numerical registration certificate', + 'same_source_key_same_side': True}) + custody = ROOT / 'custodian' + custody.mkdir(mode=0o700, exist_ok=False) + save(custody / 'joined-frozen-review.json', { + 'witness_message_ts': '1794661806.338179', + 'frozen_commit': 'd4da9d762fff04c918c88d63ab3191e2571d6547', + 'input_sha256': SHA, 'pairs': joined, + 'split_stream_consumed': False, + 'split_policy': 'Earlier per-class certification path replaced by Claude 1794661802.418469; no split generated here', + }) + rigid = [r for r in joined if r['frozen_geometric_review']['relation'].lower() == 'rigid'] + save(custody / 'rigid-calibration-inputs.json', { + 'scope': 'Identity join only; calibration has not run', + 'frozen_review_sha256': SHA['frozen-review.csv'], + 'pairs': [{'anonymous_pair_id': r['anonymous_pair_id'], 'a': r['a'], 'b': r['b'], + 'source_key': r['source_key'], 'exposure': r['source_cluster_state'], + 'judgment': r['frozen_geometric_review']} for r in rigid], + }) + for path in custody.iterdir(): + path.chmod(0o600) + for name in ['sampling-and-mapping.json', 'pose-mapping-v1.json']: + assert sha(OLD / 'custodian' / name) == SHA[name] + public = ROOT / 'public' + public.mkdir(exist_ok=True) + result = { + 'status': 'WITNESSED_FROZEN_REVIEW_JOINED_IN_CUSTODY', + 'completed_utc': datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat(), + 'witness_message_ts': '1794661806.338179', + 'frozen_commit': 'd4da9d762fff04c918c88d63ab3191e2571d6547', + 'pairs_joined': len(joined), 'source_keys': len({r['source_key'] for r in joined}), + 'geometric_review_counts': dict(Counter(r['relation'].lower() for r in rows)), + 'rigid_pairs': len(rigid), 'rigid_source_keys': len({r['source_key'] for r in rigid}), + 'same_key_unresolved_already_same_side': sum(r['relation'].lower() == 'unresolved' for r in rows), + 'input_sha256': SHA, + 'joined_review_sha256': sha(custody / 'joined-frozen-review.json'), + 'rigid_calibration_inputs_sha256': sha(custody / 'rigid-calibration-inputs.json'), + 'original_seals_unchanged': True, 'mappings_sent_to_reviewer': False, + 'split_stream_consumed': False, 'registration_or_calibration_run': False, + 'per_class_miss_rate_budget': {k: 'NOT_VERIFIABLE' for k in ['rigid', 'template', 'variant']}, + 'limitations': '2/120 is this sample visual rigid count, not ancestry prevalence or a cross-key recall bound. Unresolved is not negative.', + } + save(public / 'custody-join-receipt.json', result) + print(json.dumps(result, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2)) + +if __name__ == '__main__': + main()