research-tree: H2 confirmed on field, last fill worse; phase 3 triggered

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
ClaudeandClaude Opus 5.5 committed 2026-11-17 20:22:24 +00:00
1 parent 64d6c1b30d
commit c9584a664a
1 file changed
+2 -1
+2 -1
View File
@@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ Rules:
| ID | Branch | Gate (cheapest falsifier) | Owner | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| B1 | H1: residual on the eikonal volume map (t* - cF, same 19 features) | full run is cheap (<= 20 CPU-h) | spec Mold, run Melt | PARKED (inconclusive under the fixed rule) |
| B2 | H2: geometry-aware operator on the H1 target | pilot <= 2 GPU-h with a cost gate | spec MeltAssist, run Melt | S1 PASSED (fold 0 field gain vs A) → S2 approved, not yet started |
| B2 | H2: geometry-aware operator on the H1 target | pilot <= 2 GPU-h with a cost gate | spec MeltAssist, run Melt | **CONFIRMED (field, five folds)**; last fill significantly WORSE → phase 3 |
| B3 | Arrival-field topology: dry-region H0(-T) maxima and saddles as last-fill / front-meeting diagnostics | on about 50 parts, compute the diagnostics from the true T and from the full-node EIK; check whether they are stable and whether EIK's critical points match the truth | spec Mold, run Melt | OPEN |
| B4 | Filling as a filtration: one scalar potential plus a monotone time map | oracle: the best per-part monotone map from the EIK potential to the true T; the remaining error is ordering error that no time map can fix | Mold / Melt | PRUNED (clock-only on a fixed potential cannot beat A) |
| B5 | Sheet / paired-wall decomposition on real meshes | scope a relaxed general-domain certificate on paper; then try 10 Greif parts and report coverage and false connections | Mold, then Melt | PARKED (coverage unknown: certifier complexity cap) |
@@ -34,6 +34,7 @@ Rules:
| P3 | O1 with size-matched K = 8 partitions | — | — | PRUNED (eligibility 23 %; lesson: control cut area as a covariate, do not match it) |
Log (newest first):
- 2026-11-18: **H2 CONFIRMED on field (pre-registered pooled rule), last fill WORSE.** 552 / 204 test parts, pre-score review PASS 9c163702; postfit launched by TRON as a labelled one-time exception (MeltAstra unreachable). Field H2 .06579 vs A .07083: Δ -.00504, CI [-.00754, -.00283] (about 7 % relative); vs B13-E1b Δ -.00391, CI [-.00631, -.00164]. τ +.0035, CI [+.0010, +.0062]. **Last fill H2 .4566 vs A .3767: Δ +.080, CI [+.007, +.156] (worse).** Boundary: the pooled rule was registered after fold 0 was seen, so fold 0 is not independent; folds 1-4 alone to be reported descriptively. Reading: the learned representation is the lever for the field (better ordering, lower error), but it puts the last-filled point in the wrong place more often than A. Phase 3 is triggered (data sufficiency → seed 1 → c last-fill in H2 → b → seed 2 / ensemble); c is now the priority question.
- 2026-11-17: **Gate calibration v2 FAIL_OUTCOME_EQUIVALENCE** (pre-registered, review PASS before scoring). Label-derived minus LOG gates, 545 paired parts / 202 components: field A +.00083, CI [+.00039, +.00134]; E1b +.00077, CI [+.00035, +.00125] (both exceed ±.001); last/Rg CIs exceed ±.010. Cost 94,261 / 104,639. **Consequence:** the v2 fresh holdout is BLOCKED_INPUT for gate-dependent methods; the shift is of the same size as the effects we test (E1b gain .0011). The A and E1b shifts are similar, so a paired method difference *might* cancel, but that is an observation from this result, not a pre-registered test, and will not be used. Route forward: real gate metadata for v2 (question to Yanqi), or a different fresh source. Phase-3 item c's fresh-family stage is blocked accordingly.
- 2026-11-17: **H2-S1 (fold 0 test, 121 parts / 37 components, one seed).** Pre-score review PASS (MeltAssist 07514084). Field H2 .06747 vs A .07292: Δ -.00546, CI [-.01035, -.00098], about 7.5 % relative on fold 0 only (not comparable with E1b's five-fold 1.6 %: different statistical domain; no ranking or attribution to representation/data). Last fill +.110, CI [-.134, +.393] (no support); τ CI crosses 0. 7,786 full-node / 145 query predictions negative (kept, not clipped). S2 gate passed. **Pre-registered before S2 results:** H2 is CONFIRMED if the pooled five-fold (552 / 204 test) field upper bound vs A < 0; vs B13-E1b reported, not gating. Single fold / seed: no causal or cross-split claim yet. Data-sufficiency test (Mold e24fff7c) follows S2 under its own cap.
- 2026-11-17: **B17 PRUNED (stage 1).** 552 / 204, pre-score review PASS (MeltAssist 235cfc9f, after one score-assembly fix). Last fill Δ (new - E1b) -.0033, CI [-.0389, +.0298]; it needed mean ≤ -.010 and upper < 0. Stage 2 not run. Cost 4,745 / 10,800. **Learned:** the B14 / B16 last-fill near-misses do not survive a dedicated, tail-weighted recipe. Last fill stays unsolved by the tabular feature route; it is not closed for learned representations (H2) or for other targets. Gate calibration v2 (outcome-level, 72k CPU-s) running; the fresh holdout remains useful for an independent deployment check of E1b.