From bfb4b7c84dcad6361819f15a7f282747667737b0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: MeltAstra Date: Wed, 18 Nov 2026 20:14:13 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] Record accepted recovery review and unexecuted auto-review launch rejection --- .../audit-attempt1.txt | 6 + .../audit.py | 83 ++++++++++ .../evidence.json | 103 ++++++++++++ .../review.json | 78 +++++++++ .../validation.json | 17 ++ .../approval-block.json | 23 +++ .../launch-plan.json | 46 ++++++ docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md | 10 ++ docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md | 8 + ...ack-a-recovery-launch-status-2026-11-18.md | 8 + .../host-precheck.json | 151 ++++++++++++++++++ .../implementation-review-authorization.json | 4 + .../implementation-review-git-freeze.json | 21 +++ .../review-adoption.json | 45 ++++++ .../track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/review.json | 78 +++++++++ 15 files changed, 681 insertions(+) create mode 100644 artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/audit-attempt1.txt create mode 100644 artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/audit.py create mode 100644 artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json create mode 100644 artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/review.json create mode 100644 artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/validation.json create mode 100644 artifacts/track-a-recovery-launch-approval-2026-11-18/approval-block.json create mode 100644 artifacts/track-a-recovery-launch-approval-2026-11-18/launch-plan.json create mode 100644 docs/track-a-recovery-launch-status-2026-11-18.md create mode 100644 home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/host-precheck.json create mode 100644 home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/implementation-review-authorization.json create mode 100644 home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/implementation-review-git-freeze.json create mode 100644 home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/review-adoption.json create mode 100644 home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/review.json diff --git a/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/audit-attempt1.txt b/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/audit-attempt1.txt new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3c8f58e1f --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/audit-attempt1.txt @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +Independent synthetic audit attempt 1 exited 1 before epoch replay. +KeyError: 'id' at tools/track_a_h2_common.py:89, project_cell. +Cause: review author's synthetic cfg omitted job id; fixed cfg to include id=i. +All binding/hash/preservation/config checks preceding replay had completed. +This was a review fixture error, not a production failure. No scientific computation occurred. +Original tool session: 16222; output chunk 691dfc. diff --git a/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/audit.py b/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/audit.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7d0dbad9a --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/audit.py @@ -0,0 +1,83 @@ +"""Independent binding audit and synthetic actual-control-flow survivor replay.""" +import ast, hashlib, json, subprocess, tempfile, time +from pathlib import Path +from types import SimpleNamespace +from track_a_recovery_common import config, project_cell, project_total, OLD + +B=Path('/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind') +R=Path('/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18') +OUT=Path(__file__).resolve().parent +def read(p):return json.loads(Path(p).read_text()) +def sha(p): + h=hashlib.sha256() + with Path(p).open('rb') as f: + for chunk in iter(lambda:f.read(1048576),b''):h.update(chunk) + return h.hexdigest() +def save(p,d): + p=Path(p);p.parent.mkdir(parents=True,exist_ok=True);p.write_text(json.dumps(d,indent=2)+'\n') + +c=read(R/'contract.json');p=read(R/'implementation-git-freeze.json');binding=read(R/'expected-review-binding.json') +expected=dict(reviewed_commit=p['commit'],contract_sha256=sha(R/'contract.json'),implementation_proof_sha256=sha(R/'implementation-git-freeze.json'),comparison_contract_sha256=sha(R/'comparison-contract.json'),code_sha256=c['code_sha256']) +assert expected==binding +assert p['commit']=='8a8ebd1f9f29f73b26cc0cacde27b9d1d8ca333b' +assert expected['contract_sha256']=='4b21dedde07534bbe059e9886d7d5fbd7f6d3c33a5b08f4564c9bb360ef511aa' +assert expected['implementation_proof_sha256']=='8baec54ffea1b51c96de857072c4a6cb074792626d9e679e29fd3390b2ffc048' +assert sha(R/'expected-review-binding.json')=='8c13e9ebde5793cc5f25965e5f280c87cd0310f22f19eeaae7a8992c70bcc3c7' +for mapping in [c['code_sha256'],c['source_sha256'],p['files']]: + for path,h in mapping.items():assert sha(path)==h,path +for path,h in p['files'].items(): + raw=subprocess.check_output(['git','-C',p['local_repository'],'show',p['commit']+':'+p['git_paths'][path]]) + assert hashlib.sha256(raw).hexdigest()==h,path +pres=read(B/'artifacts/track-a-recovery-boundary-fix-2026-11-18/preservation.json') +for row in pres['preserved_files']:assert sha(row['snapshot'])==row['sha256'],row['snapshot'] +oldc=read(next(x['snapshot'] for x in pres['preserved_files'] if x['original']==str(R/'contract.json'))) +delta=sorted(k for k in set(oldc)|set(c) if oldc.get(k)!=c.get(k)) +assert delta==['boundary_fix','code_sha256'],delta +changed=sorted(Path(k).name for k in c['code_sha256'] if c['code_sha256'][k]!=oldc['code_sha256'][k]) +assert changed==['test_track_a_recovery.py','track_a_recovery_common.py','track_a_recovery_guard.py','track_a_recovery_queue.py'] +config(R) +seed=read(Path('/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-v2-2026-11-18/contract.json')) +for path,h in seed['code_sha256'].items():assert sha(path)==h,path + +# Execute the actual epoch block through all 200 synthetic healthy epochs, +# settle the failed fold via the actual collect function, then the survivor. +tree=ast.parse((B/'tools/track_a_recovery_queue.py').read_text()) +epoch=next(n for n in ast.walk(tree) if isinstance(n,ast.For) and ast.unparse(n.iter)=='list(active)') +collect=next(n for n in ast.walk(tree) if isinstance(n,ast.FunctionDef) and n.name=='collect') +with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as t: + root=Path(t);save(root/'contract.json',{}) + cfg=dict(jobs=[dict(id=i,gpu_seconds=30960) for i in range(5)],postfit_gpu_reserve=7200,gpu_cap=162000) + elapsed=[100.];own=[];global_reasons=[];ledger_calls=[] + def own_stop(i,why): + own.append((i,why));save(root/'jobs'/str(i)/'stop.json',dict(reason=why)) + def process(rc):return SimpleNamespace(poll=lambda:rc) + active={i:dict(process=process(None),log=SimpleNamespace(close=lambda:None),wait=0) for i in [3,4]} + terminal={} + ns=dict(root=root,c=cfg,active=active,terminal=terminal,estimates={},last_epoch={},read=read,save=save,sha=sha,age=lambda:elapsed[0],live=lambda:{i:60+elapsed[0] for i in active},project_cell=project_cell,project_total=project_total,time=time,own_stop=own_stop,global_stop=global_reasons.append,ledger=lambda:ledger_calls.append(dict(terminal)),accepted_guard=lambda rc,g:rc==0 and g['synthetic_pass']) + for i,seconds in [(3,1000),(4,50)]:save(root/'jobs'/str(i)/'worker/history/001.json',dict(epoch=1,train_epoch_seconds=seconds)) + code=compile(ast.fix_missing_locations(ast.Module(body=[epoch],type_ignores=[])),'actual_epoch_block','exec') + exec(code,ns) + first=read(root/'jobs/3/first-epoch-projection.json') + assert first['cell']['projected_gpu_seconds']==249030 + assert first['total']['cumulative_projected_gpu_seconds']==OLD+61920+7200 + assert own==[(3,'OWN_PROJECTED_CAP')] and not global_reasons + exec(compile(ast.fix_missing_locations(ast.Module(body=[collect],type_ignores=[])),'actual_collect','exec'),ns) + elapsed[0]=130;active[3]['process']=process(1) + save(root/'jobs/3/complete.json',dict(synthetic_pass=False,gpu_seconds_charged=190)) + assert ns['collect'](3,active[3]);assert terminal[3]['status']=='STOPPED_OR_FAILED' + for e in range(2,201): + elapsed[0]=100+50*(e-1) + save(root/'jobs/4/worker/history'/f'{e:03}.json',dict(epoch=e,train_epoch_seconds=50)) + exec(code,ns) + assert not global_reasons and not (root/'jobs/4/stop.json').exists() + active[4]['process']=process(0) + save(root/'jobs/4/complete.json',dict(synthetic_pass=True,gpu_seconds_charged=60+elapsed[0])) + assert ns['collect'](4,active[4]);assert terminal[4]['status']=='PASS' and not active + total=project_total(cfg,ns['estimates'],terminal,{}) + assert total['status']=='PASS' and ns['estimates'][3]['projected_gpu_seconds']==249030 + replay=dict(failed_raw_projection=249030,first_conservative_total=first['total']['cumulative_projected_gpu_seconds'],healthy_epochs=200,synthetic_terminal=terminal,final_total=total,global_stop_calls=global_reasons,receipt_acceptance='Synthetic stub; actual collector and epoch control flow, no real model or training') + +evidence=dict(status='PASS',binding=expected,binding_file_sha256=sha(R/'expected-review-binding.json'),code_files=len(c['code_sha256']),source_files=len(c['source_sha256']),git_files=len(p['files']),preserved_files=len(pres['preserved_files']),changed_contract_keys=delta,changed_code=changed,seed1_pins=len(seed['code_sha256']),config='PASS',survivor_replay=replay,scientific_execution=False,postfit_reviewed=False) +with (OUT/'evidence.json').open('x') as f:json.dump(evidence,f,indent=2);f.write('\n') +print(json.dumps({k:v for k,v in evidence.items() if k not in ['binding','survivor_replay']})) +print(json.dumps(replay)) diff --git a/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json b/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0df35fbb2 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json @@ -0,0 +1,103 @@ +{ + "status": "PASS", + "binding": { + "reviewed_commit": "8a8ebd1f9f29f73b26cc0cacde27b9d1d8ca333b", + "contract_sha256": "4b21dedde07534bbe059e9886d7d5fbd7f6d3c33a5b08f4564c9bb360ef511aa", + "implementation_proof_sha256": "8baec54ffea1b51c96de857072c4a6cb074792626d9e679e29fd3390b2ffc048", + "comparison_contract_sha256": "828530e4a02e70f81172fede011788f4ad90c6b01060d2a014ce38898b16364b", + "code_sha256": { + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/freeze_g1_components.py": "d0cee60d95243ac2c59ef3f2244ba818315718c4e3d1895f2f9f064f1f7f5ecd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_models.py": "53b6fee8b700b9b982b06d29908ce2ce23e0c57512c46dbf74b2aade79e3ac3a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_gate_outcome_review.py": "915617aeb8292d03c654e637bc34a014c254fd178a773f135d1806c4b41372a8", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h1_worker_v2.py": "1543df85b615bb69b79bacd572074a7c77ae19dab110197601573a7e5805ed20", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_data.py": "7e03dd7a94e7bb43593277f183c222473d7cb7aaf2f60e53b45ab8d9499fcb09", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_model.py": "fab2470dd0654ca74c3b7d893f35ad1f3ae6c5c08ffe334ef6312cf6ec87892a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_pilot_worker.py": "14651ca402e6d02466d8afdb77bc9e62fb2e752f0c0c3d20d98593157d5ebe81", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_common.py": "38a29a34663a5d6310571eeff53b5d18a0355e51b9fa58a08033f64fa379a9df", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_home_freeze_io.py": "bf09204b85ed2a7038acdd202257f618474d1110a9d6d772f105a3ffb334d3ff", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_local_freeze_io.py": "60adf3382577613c5234f5cf30779336b9951b66e90c075cb7cd0adab9cc42dd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_residual_math.py": "ffbd9624dec79bdaabf95244fe87209055908f31a977e73ea4377045d6f8fe62", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_track_a_recovery.py": "f1d7cc6d1f073c8f41063f82a620abcca810d0595a8d2dbacdf1c5e03aa634c6", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_gpu_idle_gate.py": "e2b1613e7e6ea398a8d555220a9365a1ad998ab4ef4b2bf8ec7cc4e31f8b4b9f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_main_memory_guard.py": "e094f5443e11518efe9018215c11718a8e18aa462a977bf43e974b2d0b2aebb1", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_pilot_train.py": "e9cceead51a5cc092aad23409ad98909c84a62e7e10571e750d1e9be1ad3b948", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_precision_continuation_guard.py": "01235d897c7c03e5ffa109c58b14f5d24d128e8f1ba873e1f76cfb14e02f7a7f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_gpu_supervisor.py": "689c0f3179e4fcd362e546d90214829a9e4f8739abdbdf74b560763e5a392f15", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_monitoring.py": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_track_a_recovery.py": "108e4c27d9743d30baa8faf9c16ab6b139d911a5a72f00db7a4df7334f8d122a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_common.py": "79918e7de887d1f0a2de5523156b27d00dc2d85ac930a07efc34d817d904fe65", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_prepare.py": "f657be036dc48fc5936f56c4b8510a4b295d4787af6877cc5ccaad663107be17", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_common.py": "a932d069340909465a5a1e66be1504e28c8df159a5ce304b0586295003d2e734", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_guard.py": "63364eda4f0fbb0d288b71f359661e6c004aab5443b17dd7f15570cce4f4efb0", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_monitor.py": "4c423f8b0dff69304d0046c0a9c319bb31aa0c6d1cbaeb3942726b5e6caa0496", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_queue.py": "d35e57de98ec0f4a3d40232925fe5d31bf05ebc93855e6b1e7d9fe0592cdfba9", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_supervisor.py": "5ccb2a6eec95b0700b2063a2f8df414037528e90c206648c1c5e49c5e89e741d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_worker.py": "82944fc3aa113a6005999449faf1c10635ff19073c7eb8fa682967725bc206e5" + } + }, + "binding_file_sha256": "8c13e9ebde5793cc5f25965e5f280c87cd0310f22f19eeaae7a8992c70bcc3c7", + "code_files": 27, + "source_files": 60, + "git_files": 83, + "preserved_files": 47, + "changed_contract_keys": [ + "boundary_fix", + "code_sha256" + ], + "changed_code": [ + "test_track_a_recovery.py", + "track_a_recovery_common.py", + "track_a_recovery_guard.py", + "track_a_recovery_queue.py" + ], + "seed1_pins": 51, + "config": "PASS", + "survivor_replay": { + "failed_raw_projection": 249030, + "first_conservative_total": 117063.94719455298, + "healthy_epochs": 200, + "synthetic_terminal": { + "3": { + "id": 3, + "status": "STOPPED_OR_FAILED", + "returncode": 1, + "gpu_seconds_charged": 190, + "guard_complete_sha256": "7c28275a6dff05dd521c027de437f6d8f7bc618e5f3c5744fbb10bf239b44a80", + "pre_dispatch_wait_seconds": 0, + "receipt_error": null + }, + "4": { + "id": 4, + "status": "PASS", + "returncode": 0, + "gpu_seconds_charged": 10110, + "guard_complete_sha256": "fe8343bdb02fd14b544c3888cf442a85619a8a1ee86c824ee05bb4e26c7209f7", + "pre_dispatch_wait_seconds": 0, + "receipt_error": null + } + }, + "final_total": { + "status": "PASS", + "rows": [ + { + "id": 3, + "projected_gpu_seconds": 190, + "basis": "terminal_actual" + }, + { + "id": 4, + "projected_gpu_seconds": 10110, + "basis": "terminal_actual" + } + ], + "new_projected_gpu_seconds": 17500, + "old_gpu_seconds_once": 47943.94719455298, + "cumulative_projected_gpu_seconds": 65443.94719455298, + "postfit_reserve": 7200 + }, + "global_stop_calls": [], + "receipt_acceptance": "Synthetic stub; actual collector and epoch control flow, no real model or training" + }, + "scientific_execution": false, + "postfit_reviewed": false +} diff --git a/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/review.json b/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/review.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..701c20295 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/review.json @@ -0,0 +1,78 @@ +{ + "reviewed_commit": "8a8ebd1f9f29f73b26cc0cacde27b9d1d8ca333b", + "contract_sha256": "4b21dedde07534bbe059e9886d7d5fbd7f6d3c33a5b08f4564c9bb360ef511aa", + "implementation_proof_sha256": "8baec54ffea1b51c96de857072c4a6cb074792626d9e679e29fd3390b2ffc048", + "comparison_contract_sha256": "828530e4a02e70f81172fede011788f4ad90c6b01060d2a014ce38898b16364b", + "code_sha256": { + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/freeze_g1_components.py": "d0cee60d95243ac2c59ef3f2244ba818315718c4e3d1895f2f9f064f1f7f5ecd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_models.py": "53b6fee8b700b9b982b06d29908ce2ce23e0c57512c46dbf74b2aade79e3ac3a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_gate_outcome_review.py": "915617aeb8292d03c654e637bc34a014c254fd178a773f135d1806c4b41372a8", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h1_worker_v2.py": "1543df85b615bb69b79bacd572074a7c77ae19dab110197601573a7e5805ed20", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_data.py": "7e03dd7a94e7bb43593277f183c222473d7cb7aaf2f60e53b45ab8d9499fcb09", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_model.py": "fab2470dd0654ca74c3b7d893f35ad1f3ae6c5c08ffe334ef6312cf6ec87892a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_pilot_worker.py": "14651ca402e6d02466d8afdb77bc9e62fb2e752f0c0c3d20d98593157d5ebe81", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_common.py": "38a29a34663a5d6310571eeff53b5d18a0355e51b9fa58a08033f64fa379a9df", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_home_freeze_io.py": "bf09204b85ed2a7038acdd202257f618474d1110a9d6d772f105a3ffb334d3ff", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_local_freeze_io.py": "60adf3382577613c5234f5cf30779336b9951b66e90c075cb7cd0adab9cc42dd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_residual_math.py": "ffbd9624dec79bdaabf95244fe87209055908f31a977e73ea4377045d6f8fe62", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_track_a_recovery.py": "f1d7cc6d1f073c8f41063f82a620abcca810d0595a8d2dbacdf1c5e03aa634c6", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_gpu_idle_gate.py": "e2b1613e7e6ea398a8d555220a9365a1ad998ab4ef4b2bf8ec7cc4e31f8b4b9f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_main_memory_guard.py": "e094f5443e11518efe9018215c11718a8e18aa462a977bf43e974b2d0b2aebb1", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_pilot_train.py": "e9cceead51a5cc092aad23409ad98909c84a62e7e10571e750d1e9be1ad3b948", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_precision_continuation_guard.py": "01235d897c7c03e5ffa109c58b14f5d24d128e8f1ba873e1f76cfb14e02f7a7f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_gpu_supervisor.py": "689c0f3179e4fcd362e546d90214829a9e4f8739abdbdf74b560763e5a392f15", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_monitoring.py": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_track_a_recovery.py": "108e4c27d9743d30baa8faf9c16ab6b139d911a5a72f00db7a4df7334f8d122a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_common.py": "79918e7de887d1f0a2de5523156b27d00dc2d85ac930a07efc34d817d904fe65", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_prepare.py": "f657be036dc48fc5936f56c4b8510a4b295d4787af6877cc5ccaad663107be17", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_common.py": "a932d069340909465a5a1e66be1504e28c8df159a5ce304b0586295003d2e734", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_guard.py": "63364eda4f0fbb0d288b71f359661e6c004aab5443b17dd7f15570cce4f4efb0", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_monitor.py": "4c423f8b0dff69304d0046c0a9c319bb31aa0c6d1cbaeb3942726b5e6caa0496", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_queue.py": "d35e57de98ec0f4a3d40232925fe5d31bf05ebc93855e6b1e7d9fe0592cdfba9", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_supervisor.py": "5ccb2a6eec95b0700b2063a2f8df414037528e90c206648c1c5e49c5e89e741d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_worker.py": "82944fc3aa113a6005999449faf1c10635ff19073c7eb8fa682967725bc206e5" + }, + "verdict": "PASS", + "reviewer": "MeltAssist", + "scope": "Same-review delta: RECOVERY-OWN-PROJECTION-ISOLATION and RECOVERY-PRESTART-DEADLINE only", + "previous_review_sha256": "2bd485043af0ebb42aab3bd93da0eedddcb706f652a2868280f011ee486c6599", + "evidence_sha256": "867e20da8d4b76b54275bd4ff27f3a9a4231125f5d5355ca794bb401019cbf93", + "audit_source_sha256": "115722946a029128a53524edae5fd6e905f9ea06a32c5201171c8d33b04149ec", + "validation_sha256": "50cf4ba6321fa6535a9b14985193aaa033674bc5d599d7b86d79d5b3dc6cae11", + "findings": [], + "resolved_blockers": [ + { + "id": "RECOVERY-OWN-PROJECTION-ISOLATION", + "evidence": "Actual epoch AST stops own fold first; rejected249030 remains raw, bounded reserve uses max(actual,30960); first cumulative117063.947194553. Independent actual epoch/collector synthetic replay takes healthy fold through200epochs and PASS, failed fold190 settled once, final65443.947194553 with no global stop. Real cumulative overrun regression still stops." + }, + { + "id": "RECOVERY-PRESTART-DEADLINE", + "evidence": "Actual idle-loop tests verify prequery10s+cleanup20s, postquery, presleep and preworker checks. Alternating two errors then idle reaches own deadline without worker and without three-error false classification. Error logs and Monitor/Supervisor pins unchanged." + } + ], + "identity_checks": { + "code_files": 27, + "source_files": 60, + "git_files": 83, + "preserved_old_files": 47, + "seed1_code_pins": 51, + "changed_files": [ + "test_track_a_recovery.py", + "track_a_recovery_common.py", + "track_a_recovery_guard.py", + "track_a_recovery_queue.py" + ], + "contract_changes": [ + "boundary_fix", + "code_sha256" + ] + }, + "limitations": [ + "CPU synthetic/source review only, not actual recovery success; no scientific arrays, test targets, model weights deserialized or GPU workload queried/launched.", + "Supplementary survivor replay stubs receipt acceptance; actual epoch and collector control flow executed through200synthetic epochs. Real acceptance covered by unchanged code and existing suite.", + "First independent fixture omitted id and failed; audit-attempt1.txt retained; only reviewer fixture corrected.", + "Old BLOCKED and original failed evidence remain immutable. Budgets, scientific worker, retry prohibition and cumulative/shared guards unchanged.", + "Only all-five-success may proceed to separately reviewed identity-only postfit rebind. This review does not approve old983bba99 for mixed sources or any postfit implementation.", + "Local Git bytes verified; publication0886d459 is not implementation8a8ebd1f; no remote raw-byte verification claim." + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/validation.json b/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/validation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4a1a8725f --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/validation.json @@ -0,0 +1,17 @@ +{ + "command": "PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 CUDA_VISIBLE_DEVICES='' PYTHONPATH=tools /home/frank14f/anaconda3/envs/pycuda_3_10/bin/python -m unittest -v tools/test_track_a_recovery.py", + "tests": 28, + "status": "PASS", + "duration_seconds": 0.363, + "tool_session": 91398, + "exit_code": 0, + "deadline_checks": [ + "expired cap queries zero times", + "repeated two errors/one idle expires before cap without worker, monitor max streak remains 2", + "query overrun detected before worker", + "insufficient idle sleep window rejected" + ], + "audit_status": "PASS", + "audit_session": 77280, + "first_audit_fixture_failure_preserved": "audit-attempt1.txt" +} diff --git a/artifacts/track-a-recovery-launch-approval-2026-11-18/approval-block.json b/artifacts/track-a-recovery-launch-approval-2026-11-18/approval-block.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..94d944846 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/track-a-recovery-launch-approval-2026-11-18/approval-block.json @@ -0,0 +1,23 @@ +{ + "unix": 1795004024.408338, + "status": "AUTO_REVIEW_REJECTED_LAUNCH_NOT_EXECUTED", + "action": "start one real Track A GPU recovery systemd service", + "reason": "This starts a real GPU training/recovery service while another queue is active; the available trusted user instructions authorize information sharing and preparation but do not clearly authorize this new scientific computation or its resource contention.", + "tool_call_executed": false, + "root_flags": { + "review.json": true, + "review-adoption.json": true, + "started.json": false, + "launch-attempt.json": false, + "service-launch.json": false, + "complete.json": false + }, + "adopted_review_freeze": "309dadfbfdb1fac0f1a7c19dbbf219b3c1eb2c14", + "checked_sources": [ + "Claude1795003292.974599", + "Assist1795003274.544639", + "docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md" + ], + "authorization_gap": "User compute authorization is relayed by collaborators; no clearer original human authorization established in this check.", + "next": "Await direct human approval or verified original human authorization. Do not retry launch or delegate execution to bypass this rejection." +} diff --git a/artifacts/track-a-recovery-launch-approval-2026-11-18/launch-plan.json b/artifacts/track-a-recovery-launch-approval-2026-11-18/launch-plan.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..dbfc91cdf --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/track-a-recovery-launch-approval-2026-11-18/launch-plan.json @@ -0,0 +1,46 @@ +{ + "status": "PREPARED_NOT_EXECUTED", + "unit": "meltmind-track-a-recovery-20261118.service", + "command": [ + "systemd-run", + "--user", + "--unit=meltmind-track-a-recovery-20261118.service", + "--property=Restart=no", + "--property=KillMode=control-group", + "--working-directory=/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind", + "--setenv=OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS=1", + "--setenv=OMP_NUM_THREADS=1", + "--setenv=MKL_NUM_THREADS=1", + "--setenv=PYTHONPATH=/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools", + "--property=StandardOutput=append:/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/service.log", + "--property=StandardError=append:/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/service.log", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/gre24-reproduction-2026-11-15/environment/venv/bin/python", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_queue.py", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18" + ], + "review_sha256": "d66e5ca101348ea8ccd7c167c8428af21eee362c3d74de356be3203fb944870b", + "implementation": "8a8ebd1f9f29f73b26cc0cacde27b9d1d8ca333b", + "fresh_folds": [ + 3, + 4 + ], + "reuse_folds": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "old_gpu_seconds_once": 47943.94719455298, + "remaining_training_gpu_seconds": 106856.05280544702, + "per_fold_cap_seconds": 30960, + "postfit_reserve": 7200, + "total_gpu_cap": 162000, + "no_further_recovery": true, + "launch_preconditions": [ + "actual user compute authorization accepted by approval review", + "refresh RAM/disk and GPU2/3 snapshot", + "no old or recovery queue/guard/worker; no previous launch marker", + "exact config/review/source pins; original models hash reuse", + "fixed dispatcher only uses idle selected GPU; guard three idle polls" + ], + "coexistence": "Seed1 unchanged; GPU3 busy waits and charges original cap; GPU2 snapshot idle. Shared CPU/RAM can affect throughput." +} diff --git a/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md b/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md index 2887a0253..bfccb29d5 100644 --- a/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md +++ b/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md @@ -701,3 +701,13 @@ Claude1795000465/0626允许一次标记恢复:0–2hash复用,3/4同seed0配 已向原Slack串提交并请TRON原生转Assist同次两项delta复核;尚无新实际PASS/review采用/started/训练,不声称Assist已实收。Claude1566全五完成后identity-only postfit新绑定裁量保持,原统计不改,缺折不得评分。原STOP不重启,seed1原队列不动。下方旧c5a67bd4待审记录为历史,不能启动旧版。 + + +## 最新 Track A recovery 实际PASS已采用;启动被自动审批拦截,未运行(2026-11-18) + +Assist1795003274实际PASS d66e5ca1/evidence867e20da/validation50cf4ba6已逐字核SHA与五字段、采用并冻结309dadfb;validate_review/config/reuse_identity PASS。implementation8a8ebd1f/contract4b21dedd/proof8baec54f/comparison828530e4/27map不变。Claude1795003292明确接受并要求启动,原件已实读。 + +主机预检1795003907:available RAM57212502016B、需要36507222016B;free237477957632B、要求100GiB。旧/新Track A均无进程,seed1 51pins保持。GPU2为9MiB/0%,GPU3仍由seed1占用;固定派发可先fold4,fold3计费等待,实际资源须启动前刷新。 + +调用启动命令时自动审批拒绝,命令根本未执行、未创建launch-attempt/service-launch/started;当前不是运行中,也不是新的训练失败。拒绝理由:当前可信用户指令未明确覆盖与另一队列并行的新GPU计算及资源使用。已核现有Claude/TRON裁量与项目记录,未找到更明确的原始人类计算授权;不以共享许可替代。不换执行途径,等待直接用户授权或可验证原始授权。准备范围/命令与原始拒绝见artifacts/track-a-recovery-launch-approval-2026-11-18/launch-plan.json、approval-block.json;seed1不动。 + diff --git a/docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md b/docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md index 898f6d9cc..70208f259 100644 --- a/docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md +++ b/docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md @@ -1,3 +1,11 @@ +## 最新 Track A recovery 实际PASS已采用;启动被自动审批拦截,未运行(2026-11-18) + +Assist1795003274实际PASS d66e5ca1/evidence867e20da/validation50cf4ba6已逐字核SHA与五字段、采用并冻结309dadfb;validate_review/config/reuse_identity PASS。implementation8a8ebd1f/contract4b21dedd/proof8baec54f/comparison828530e4/27map不变。Claude1795003292明确接受并要求启动,原件已实读。 + +主机预检1795003907:available RAM57212502016B、需要36507222016B;free237477957632B、要求100GiB。旧/新Track A均无进程,seed1 51pins保持。GPU2为9MiB/0%,GPU3仍由seed1占用;固定派发可先fold4,fold3计费等待,实际资源须启动前刷新。 + +调用启动命令时自动审批拒绝,命令根本未执行、未创建launch-attempt/service-launch/started;当前不是运行中,也不是新的训练失败。拒绝理由:当前可信用户指令未明确覆盖与另一队列并行的新GPU计算及资源使用。已核现有Claude/TRON裁量与项目记录,未找到更明确的原始人类计算授权;不以共享许可替代。不换执行途径,等待直接用户授权或可验证原始授权。准备范围/命令与原始拒绝见artifacts/track-a-recovery-launch-approval-2026-11-18/launch-plan.json、approval-block.json;seed1不动。 + ## 最新 Track A recovery 两项边界修复固定,待同次定点复核(2026-11-18) 原Assist1795001813 BLOCKED(2bd48504)已实读并保留,原两个AST反例已复现。仅common/queue/guard/test四文件修复;28CPU检查PASS,科学worker、原Track A与seed1 pins保持。新implementation `8a8ebd1f9f29f73b26cc0cacde27b9d1d8ca333b`,contract `4b21dedde07534bbe059e9886d7d5fbd7f6d3c33a5b08f4564c9bb360ef511aa`,proof `8baec54ffea1b51c96de857072c4a6cb074792626d9e679e29fd3390b2ffc048`,comparison828530e4不变,27code/60source。完整binding SHA `8c13e9ebde5793cc5f25965e5f280c87cd0310f22f19eeaae7a8992c70bcc3c7`。config/reuse_identity与新五字段实核PASS;原47文件快照和失败证据完整保留。 diff --git a/docs/track-a-recovery-launch-status-2026-11-18.md b/docs/track-a-recovery-launch-status-2026-11-18.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5584c9975 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/track-a-recovery-launch-status-2026-11-18.md @@ -0,0 +1,8 @@ +## 最新 Track A recovery 实际PASS已采用;启动被自动审批拦截,未运行(2026-11-18) + +Assist1795003274实际PASS d66e5ca1/evidence867e20da/validation50cf4ba6已逐字核SHA与五字段、采用并冻结309dadfb;validate_review/config/reuse_identity PASS。implementation8a8ebd1f/contract4b21dedd/proof8baec54f/comparison828530e4/27map不变。Claude1795003292明确接受并要求启动,原件已实读。 + +主机预检1795003907:available RAM57212502016B、需要36507222016B;free237477957632B、要求100GiB。旧/新Track A均无进程,seed1 51pins保持。GPU2为9MiB/0%,GPU3仍由seed1占用;固定派发可先fold4,fold3计费等待,实际资源须启动前刷新。 + +调用启动命令时自动审批拒绝,命令根本未执行、未创建launch-attempt/service-launch/started;当前不是运行中,也不是新的训练失败。拒绝理由:当前可信用户指令未明确覆盖与另一队列并行的新GPU计算及资源使用。已核现有Claude/TRON裁量与项目记录,未找到更明确的原始人类计算授权;不以共享许可替代。不换执行途径,等待直接用户授权或可验证原始授权。准备范围/命令与原始拒绝见artifacts/track-a-recovery-launch-approval-2026-11-18/launch-plan.json、approval-block.json;seed1不动。 + diff --git a/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/host-precheck.json b/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/host-precheck.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..947abaa1f --- /dev/null +++ b/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/host-precheck.json @@ -0,0 +1,151 @@ +{ + "unix": 1795003907.5770423, + "review_sha256": "d66e5ca101348ea8ccd7c167c8428af21eee362c3d74de356be3203fb944870b", + "no_existing_track_a_process": true, + "existing_track_a": [], + "seed1_processes": [ + { + "pid": 1476593, + "ppid": 2234, + "cmdline": [ + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/gre24-reproduction-2026-11-15/environment/venv/bin/python", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_v2_queue.py", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-v2-2026-11-18" + ] + }, + { + "pid": 1476627, + "ppid": 1476593, + "cmdline": [ + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/gre24-reproduction-2026-11-15/environment/venv/bin/python", + "tools/phase3_seed1_v2_guard.py", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-v2-2026-11-18", + "0", + "498011b74b369fb6c4144659d9ea7449863205446329dc36b08e60a78e0d8134" + ] + }, + { + "pid": 1476628, + "ppid": 1476593, + "cmdline": [ + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/gre24-reproduction-2026-11-15/environment/venv/bin/python", + "tools/phase3_seed1_v2_guard.py", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-v2-2026-11-18", + "1", + "980c49414d8a7b27c63ddb4776606a39fb1654c2d3841bf658cad3f101142dc4" + ] + }, + { + "pid": 1476707, + "ppid": 1476627, + "cmdline": [ + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/gre24-reproduction-2026-11-15/environment/venv/bin/python", + "tools/phase3_seed1_v2_worker.py", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-v2-2026-11-18", + "0", + "498011b74b369fb6c4144659d9ea7449863205446329dc36b08e60a78e0d8134" + ] + }, + { + "pid": 1476726, + "ppid": 1476628, + "cmdline": [ + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/gre24-reproduction-2026-11-15/environment/venv/bin/python", + "tools/phase3_seed1_v2_worker.py", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-v2-2026-11-18", + "1", + "980c49414d8a7b27c63ddb4776606a39fb1654c2d3841bf658cad3f101142dc4" + ] + }, + { + "pid": 1598086, + "ppid": 1476593, + "cmdline": [ + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/gre24-reproduction-2026-11-15/environment/venv/bin/python", + "tools/phase3_seed1_v2_guard.py", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-v2-2026-11-18", + "2", + "e0e4f94ba36fc799534a4d16bbf88edae4e4d647babb188824d197deef1bec34" + ] + }, + { + "pid": 1598144, + "ppid": 1598086, + "cmdline": [ + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/gre24-reproduction-2026-11-15/environment/venv/bin/python", + "tools/phase3_seed1_v2_worker.py", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-v2-2026-11-18", + "2", + "e0e4f94ba36fc799534a4d16bbf88edae4e4d647babb188824d197deef1bec34" + ] + } + ], + "seed1_source_pins": "PASS", + "gpu": { + "command": [ + "nvidia-smi", + "--query-gpu=index,uuid,memory.used,utilization.gpu", + "--format=csv,noheader,nounits" + ], + "returncode": 0, + "stdout": "0, GPU-e8853ae7-a302-6a17-bcfa-aa767e9ed20c, 1717, 19\n1, GPU-f1c9fd5a-e917-56e0-21fb-24035ba44a36, 2607, 95\n2, GPU-b8c11c01-c91f-aa0b-abf6-dad35085cc76, 9, 0\n3, GPU-8b71b032-1b75-2891-935c-ce106a53034a, 1839, 0\n", + "stderr": "" + }, + "gpu_processes": { + "command": [ + "nvidia-smi", + "--query-compute-apps=gpu_uuid,pid,process_name,used_memory", + "--format=csv,noheader,nounits" + ], + "returncode": 0, + "stdout": "GPU-e8853ae7-a302-6a17-bcfa-aa767e9ed20c, 1476707, /home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/gre24-reproduction-2026-11-15/environment/venv/bin/python, 1708\nGPU-f1c9fd5a-e917-56e0-21fb-24035ba44a36, 1476726, /home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/gre24-reproduction-2026-11-15/environment/venv/bin/python, 1710\nGPU-f1c9fd5a-e917-56e0-21fb-24035ba44a36, 1568341, /home/frank14f/anaconda3/envs/pycuda_3_10/bin/python, 888\nGPU-8b71b032-1b75-2891-935c-ce106a53034a, 1598144, /home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/gre24-reproduction-2026-11-15/environment/venv/bin/python, 1830\n", + "stderr": "" + }, + "observations": [ + { + "index": 0, + "gpu_uuid": "GPU-e8853ae7-a302-6a17-bcfa-aa767e9ed20c", + "memory_bytes": 1800404992, + "utilization": 19, + "idle": false + }, + { + "index": 1, + "gpu_uuid": "GPU-f1c9fd5a-e917-56e0-21fb-24035ba44a36", + "memory_bytes": 2733637632, + "utilization": 95, + "idle": false + }, + { + "index": 2, + "gpu_uuid": "GPU-b8c11c01-c91f-aa0b-abf6-dad35085cc76", + "memory_bytes": 9437184, + "utilization": 0, + "idle": true + }, + { + "index": 3, + "gpu_uuid": "GPU-8b71b032-1b75-2891-935c-ce106a53034a", + "memory_bytes": 1928331264, + "utilization": 0, + "idle": false + } + ], + "idle_folds_snapshot": [ + 4 + ], + "memory_available_bytes": 57212502016, + "required_available_memory_bytes": 36507222016, + "disk_free_bytes": 237477957632, + "required_disk_bytes": 107374182400, + "load_average": [ + 4.353515625, + 4.4072265625, + 4.48974609375 + ], + "logical_cpus": 32, + "cpu_percent": 4.0, + "later_dispatch": "Pinned queue checks fixed GPU idle; waiting charged per fold; guard requires three polls; no source changes", + "scientific_execution": false, + "status": "PASS" +} diff --git a/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/implementation-review-authorization.json b/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/implementation-review-authorization.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3bce02007 --- /dev/null +++ b/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/implementation-review-authorization.json @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +{ + "contract_sha256": "4b21dedde07534bbe059e9886d7d5fbd7f6d3c33a5b08f4564c9bb360ef511aa", + "proof_sha256": "77a94d1929ac376ff2675850ecce5e7c787f61eb224ef99ddba0c8b1893d761a" +} diff --git a/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/implementation-review-git-freeze.json b/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/implementation-review-git-freeze.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ce22c6c56 --- /dev/null +++ b/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/implementation-review-git-freeze.json @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +{ + "commit": "309dadfbfdb1fac0f1a7c19dbbf219b3c1eb2c14", + "files": { + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/review.json": "d66e5ca101348ea8ccd7c167c8428af21eee362c3d74de356be3203fb944870b", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/expected-review-binding.json": "8c13e9ebde5793cc5f25965e5f280c87cd0310f22f19eeaae7a8992c70bcc3c7", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/contract.json": "4b21dedde07534bbe059e9886d7d5fbd7f6d3c33a5b08f4564c9bb360ef511aa", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/review.json": "d66e5ca101348ea8ccd7c167c8428af21eee362c3d74de356be3203fb944870b", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json": "867e20da8d4b76b54275bd4ff27f3a9a4231125f5d5355ca794bb401019cbf93", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/validation.json": "50cf4ba6321fa6535a9b14985193aaa033674bc5d599d7b86d79d5b3dc6cae11" + }, + "git_paths": { + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/review.json": "home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/review.json", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/expected-review-binding.json": "home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/expected-review-binding.json", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/contract.json": "home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/contract.json", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/review.json": "artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/review.json", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json": "artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/validation.json": "artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/validation.json" + }, + "remote_published": false, + "local_repository": "/tmp/meltmind-phase2-local-fixed-20261117" +} diff --git a/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/review-adoption.json b/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/review-adoption.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..860245e80 --- /dev/null +++ b/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/review-adoption.json @@ -0,0 +1,45 @@ +{ + "unix": 1795003907.3974493, + "original": "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-track-a-recovery-delta-review-2026-11-18/review.json", + "review_sha256": "d66e5ca101348ea8ccd7c167c8428af21eee362c3d74de356be3203fb944870b", + "binding": { + "reviewed_commit": "8a8ebd1f9f29f73b26cc0cacde27b9d1d8ca333b", + "contract_sha256": "4b21dedde07534bbe059e9886d7d5fbd7f6d3c33a5b08f4564c9bb360ef511aa", + "implementation_proof_sha256": "8baec54ffea1b51c96de857072c4a6cb074792626d9e679e29fd3390b2ffc048", + "comparison_contract_sha256": "828530e4a02e70f81172fede011788f4ad90c6b01060d2a014ce38898b16364b", + "code_sha256": { + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/freeze_g1_components.py": "d0cee60d95243ac2c59ef3f2244ba818315718c4e3d1895f2f9f064f1f7f5ecd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_models.py": "53b6fee8b700b9b982b06d29908ce2ce23e0c57512c46dbf74b2aade79e3ac3a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_gate_outcome_review.py": "915617aeb8292d03c654e637bc34a014c254fd178a773f135d1806c4b41372a8", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h1_worker_v2.py": "1543df85b615bb69b79bacd572074a7c77ae19dab110197601573a7e5805ed20", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_data.py": "7e03dd7a94e7bb43593277f183c222473d7cb7aaf2f60e53b45ab8d9499fcb09", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_model.py": "fab2470dd0654ca74c3b7d893f35ad1f3ae6c5c08ffe334ef6312cf6ec87892a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_pilot_worker.py": "14651ca402e6d02466d8afdb77bc9e62fb2e752f0c0c3d20d98593157d5ebe81", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_common.py": "38a29a34663a5d6310571eeff53b5d18a0355e51b9fa58a08033f64fa379a9df", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_home_freeze_io.py": "bf09204b85ed2a7038acdd202257f618474d1110a9d6d772f105a3ffb334d3ff", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_local_freeze_io.py": "60adf3382577613c5234f5cf30779336b9951b66e90c075cb7cd0adab9cc42dd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_residual_math.py": "ffbd9624dec79bdaabf95244fe87209055908f31a977e73ea4377045d6f8fe62", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_track_a_recovery.py": "f1d7cc6d1f073c8f41063f82a620abcca810d0595a8d2dbacdf1c5e03aa634c6", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_gpu_idle_gate.py": "e2b1613e7e6ea398a8d555220a9365a1ad998ab4ef4b2bf8ec7cc4e31f8b4b9f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_main_memory_guard.py": "e094f5443e11518efe9018215c11718a8e18aa462a977bf43e974b2d0b2aebb1", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_pilot_train.py": "e9cceead51a5cc092aad23409ad98909c84a62e7e10571e750d1e9be1ad3b948", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_precision_continuation_guard.py": "01235d897c7c03e5ffa109c58b14f5d24d128e8f1ba873e1f76cfb14e02f7a7f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_gpu_supervisor.py": "689c0f3179e4fcd362e546d90214829a9e4f8739abdbdf74b560763e5a392f15", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_monitoring.py": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_track_a_recovery.py": "108e4c27d9743d30baa8faf9c16ab6b139d911a5a72f00db7a4df7334f8d122a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_common.py": "79918e7de887d1f0a2de5523156b27d00dc2d85ac930a07efc34d817d904fe65", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_prepare.py": "f657be036dc48fc5936f56c4b8510a4b295d4787af6877cc5ccaad663107be17", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_common.py": "a932d069340909465a5a1e66be1504e28c8df159a5ce304b0586295003d2e734", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_guard.py": "63364eda4f0fbb0d288b71f359661e6c004aab5443b17dd7f15570cce4f4efb0", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_monitor.py": "4c423f8b0dff69304d0046c0a9c319bb31aa0c6d1cbaeb3942726b5e6caa0496", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_queue.py": "d35e57de98ec0f4a3d40232925fe5d31bf05ebc93855e6b1e7d9fe0592cdfba9", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_supervisor.py": "5ccb2a6eec95b0700b2063a2f8df414037528e90c206648c1c5e49c5e89e741d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_worker.py": "82944fc3aa113a6005999449faf1c10635ff19073c7eb8fa682967725bc206e5" + } + }, + "review_freeze": "309dadfbfdb1fac0f1a7c19dbbf219b3c1eb2c14", + "actual_slack_review": "1795003274.544639", + "claude_start_ruling": "1795003292.974599", + "validated": true, + "scientific_execution": false +} diff --git a/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/review.json b/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/review.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..701c20295 --- /dev/null +++ b/home-runs/track-a-recovery-2026-11-18/review.json @@ -0,0 +1,78 @@ +{ + "reviewed_commit": "8a8ebd1f9f29f73b26cc0cacde27b9d1d8ca333b", + "contract_sha256": "4b21dedde07534bbe059e9886d7d5fbd7f6d3c33a5b08f4564c9bb360ef511aa", + "implementation_proof_sha256": "8baec54ffea1b51c96de857072c4a6cb074792626d9e679e29fd3390b2ffc048", + "comparison_contract_sha256": "828530e4a02e70f81172fede011788f4ad90c6b01060d2a014ce38898b16364b", + "code_sha256": { + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/freeze_g1_components.py": "d0cee60d95243ac2c59ef3f2244ba818315718c4e3d1895f2f9f064f1f7f5ecd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_models.py": "53b6fee8b700b9b982b06d29908ce2ce23e0c57512c46dbf74b2aade79e3ac3a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_gate_outcome_review.py": "915617aeb8292d03c654e637bc34a014c254fd178a773f135d1806c4b41372a8", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h1_worker_v2.py": "1543df85b615bb69b79bacd572074a7c77ae19dab110197601573a7e5805ed20", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_data.py": "7e03dd7a94e7bb43593277f183c222473d7cb7aaf2f60e53b45ab8d9499fcb09", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_model.py": "fab2470dd0654ca74c3b7d893f35ad1f3ae6c5c08ffe334ef6312cf6ec87892a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_pilot_worker.py": "14651ca402e6d02466d8afdb77bc9e62fb2e752f0c0c3d20d98593157d5ebe81", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_common.py": "38a29a34663a5d6310571eeff53b5d18a0355e51b9fa58a08033f64fa379a9df", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_home_freeze_io.py": "bf09204b85ed2a7038acdd202257f618474d1110a9d6d772f105a3ffb334d3ff", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_local_freeze_io.py": "60adf3382577613c5234f5cf30779336b9951b66e90c075cb7cd0adab9cc42dd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_residual_math.py": "ffbd9624dec79bdaabf95244fe87209055908f31a977e73ea4377045d6f8fe62", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_track_a_recovery.py": "f1d7cc6d1f073c8f41063f82a620abcca810d0595a8d2dbacdf1c5e03aa634c6", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_gpu_idle_gate.py": "e2b1613e7e6ea398a8d555220a9365a1ad998ab4ef4b2bf8ec7cc4e31f8b4b9f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_main_memory_guard.py": "e094f5443e11518efe9018215c11718a8e18aa462a977bf43e974b2d0b2aebb1", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_pilot_train.py": "e9cceead51a5cc092aad23409ad98909c84a62e7e10571e750d1e9be1ad3b948", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_precision_continuation_guard.py": "01235d897c7c03e5ffa109c58b14f5d24d128e8f1ba873e1f76cfb14e02f7a7f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_gpu_supervisor.py": "689c0f3179e4fcd362e546d90214829a9e4f8739abdbdf74b560763e5a392f15", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_monitoring.py": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_track_a_recovery.py": "108e4c27d9743d30baa8faf9c16ab6b139d911a5a72f00db7a4df7334f8d122a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_common.py": "79918e7de887d1f0a2de5523156b27d00dc2d85ac930a07efc34d817d904fe65", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_prepare.py": "f657be036dc48fc5936f56c4b8510a4b295d4787af6877cc5ccaad663107be17", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_common.py": "a932d069340909465a5a1e66be1504e28c8df159a5ce304b0586295003d2e734", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_guard.py": "63364eda4f0fbb0d288b71f359661e6c004aab5443b17dd7f15570cce4f4efb0", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_monitor.py": "4c423f8b0dff69304d0046c0a9c319bb31aa0c6d1cbaeb3942726b5e6caa0496", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_queue.py": "d35e57de98ec0f4a3d40232925fe5d31bf05ebc93855e6b1e7d9fe0592cdfba9", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_supervisor.py": "5ccb2a6eec95b0700b2063a2f8df414037528e90c206648c1c5e49c5e89e741d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_recovery_worker.py": "82944fc3aa113a6005999449faf1c10635ff19073c7eb8fa682967725bc206e5" + }, + "verdict": "PASS", + "reviewer": "MeltAssist", + "scope": "Same-review delta: RECOVERY-OWN-PROJECTION-ISOLATION and RECOVERY-PRESTART-DEADLINE only", + "previous_review_sha256": "2bd485043af0ebb42aab3bd93da0eedddcb706f652a2868280f011ee486c6599", + "evidence_sha256": "867e20da8d4b76b54275bd4ff27f3a9a4231125f5d5355ca794bb401019cbf93", + "audit_source_sha256": "115722946a029128a53524edae5fd6e905f9ea06a32c5201171c8d33b04149ec", + "validation_sha256": "50cf4ba6321fa6535a9b14985193aaa033674bc5d599d7b86d79d5b3dc6cae11", + "findings": [], + "resolved_blockers": [ + { + "id": "RECOVERY-OWN-PROJECTION-ISOLATION", + "evidence": "Actual epoch AST stops own fold first; rejected249030 remains raw, bounded reserve uses max(actual,30960); first cumulative117063.947194553. Independent actual epoch/collector synthetic replay takes healthy fold through200epochs and PASS, failed fold190 settled once, final65443.947194553 with no global stop. Real cumulative overrun regression still stops." + }, + { + "id": "RECOVERY-PRESTART-DEADLINE", + "evidence": "Actual idle-loop tests verify prequery10s+cleanup20s, postquery, presleep and preworker checks. Alternating two errors then idle reaches own deadline without worker and without three-error false classification. Error logs and Monitor/Supervisor pins unchanged." + } + ], + "identity_checks": { + "code_files": 27, + "source_files": 60, + "git_files": 83, + "preserved_old_files": 47, + "seed1_code_pins": 51, + "changed_files": [ + "test_track_a_recovery.py", + "track_a_recovery_common.py", + "track_a_recovery_guard.py", + "track_a_recovery_queue.py" + ], + "contract_changes": [ + "boundary_fix", + "code_sha256" + ] + }, + "limitations": [ + "CPU synthetic/source review only, not actual recovery success; no scientific arrays, test targets, model weights deserialized or GPU workload queried/launched.", + "Supplementary survivor replay stubs receipt acceptance; actual epoch and collector control flow executed through200synthetic epochs. Real acceptance covered by unchanged code and existing suite.", + "First independent fixture omitted id and failed; audit-attempt1.txt retained; only reviewer fixture corrected.", + "Old BLOCKED and original failed evidence remain immutable. Budgets, scientific worker, retry prohibition and cumulative/shared guards unchanged.", + "Only all-five-success may proceed to separately reviewed identity-only postfit rebind. This review does not approve old983bba99 for mixed sources or any postfit implementation.", + "Local Git bytes verified; publication0886d459 is not implementation8a8ebd1f; no remote raw-byte verification claim." + ] +}