Close G1 and A1-A4 paper rulings and distinguish execution evidence from design approval

This commit is contained in:
Frank14f committed 2026-11-14 17:44:07 +08:00
1 parent 3d3c2bd4e8
commit bf03ee8dce
5 files changed
+119 -25

No files matched your search

@@ -16,13 +16,13 @@
},
{
"path": "docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md",
"bytes": 2345,
"sha256": "7d33251cded22384e675b106f6e617dcc2a570b3ec543f61aea744accf591dd7"
"bytes": 2636,
"sha256": "a9929d9130abf739624e24c0e4e00d7e8b72f53b3798852ba4c179acfdc36256"
},
{
"path": "docs/s2-execution-diff-v0-2026-11-14.md",
"bytes": 18160,
"sha256": "9f744bc93b473b944ce0447949d234f86c2505d949266dc93e4a6262bf13af45"
"bytes": 19108,
"sha256": "dfbcb31b29124af4fa7eadbdeb932e5a981061058d3b00eff071a6f0dfb2997c"
},
{
"path": "docs/sharing-authorization-2026-11-14.md",
@@ -89,6 +89,16 @@
"bytes": 2511,
"sha256": "c3631c5a1a48707014f820aeead23fd950cf6b3601dad8073d5f5c30d7eba495"
},
{
"path": "references/2026-11-14/s2-design/g1-a1-a4-ruling-receipt.txt",
"bytes": 3056,
"sha256": "cc19fcfaa16eb92078493e8b2506e58954a99eb770198fab2e9f303b34034136"
},
{
"path": "references/2026-11-14/s2-design/moldastra-g1-freeze-sheet.md",
"bytes": 8279,
"sha256": "a108001157de0484811a94a07e2f29c15de5fd7866df14c533ed8106e6ee2c7b"
},
{
"path": "references/2026-11-14/s2-design/moldastra-note13.md",
"bytes": 4513,
@@ -150,5 +160,8 @@
"sha256": "b5adf4a29f800203aeb4ed4bf223b37f6fcf2a6d930106f5f7fb65cdea1a1372"
}
],
"preceding_execution_diff": "33b18e0831ecbc86586f6d0c5d512dbb7adfd4b9"
"preceding_execution_diff": "3d3c2bd4e8a6f87db71ac945ff87cbbf7eee04d6",
"latest_ruling_slack": "1794649083.662649",
"claude_remote_head_at_readback": "69c58a77006325319903f7862054d461b00ca75c",
"v04_published_at_readback": false
}
@@ -0,0 +1,40 @@
(2 total) ===
--- Reply 1 of 2 ---
From: ClaudeWorker (local) <botuser-T0C8JMA61UY-B0C7YUHNDFC@slack-bots.com> (U0C7SSQLBJ7)
Time: 2026-11-14 17:37:34 CST
Message TS: 1794649054.700899
Accepted; working on: “@⁠TRON v0.3(69c58a77)已逐项吸纳到原执行差分/入口表,固定更新: <https://gitea.frank14f.onli>…”
--- Reply 2 of 2 ---
From: ClaudeWorker (local) <botuser-T0C8JMA61UY-B0C7YUHNDFC@slack-bots.com> (U0C7SSQLBJ7)
Time: 2026-11-14 17:38:03 CST
Message TS: 1794649083.662649
*Claude: rulings on A1–A4, and the G1 framework adopted*
*G1 (MoldAstra's freeze sheet): framework adopted.*
• Parts with the same source key always go to the same side.
• Across keys, three cases are coded separately: rigid near-copies; mirror/scale templates; and variants that share a parent design but change the flow paths. *All three go to the same side* to prevent leakage. That says nothing about whether they are physically equivalent for flow.
• Recall uses two routes, one with physical scale and one scale-free.
• Confirmation uses an area-weighted two-way residual plus a check of small holes and thin bridges, and every reviewed pair gets one of three states.
• Any UNRESOLVED pair that could change a group puts S2 on HOLD.
• The 30 old pairs are treated as already exposed, and the old 0.5 %/1 % thresholds are not carried over.
• Thresholds, out-of-screen spot checks and the miss/false-link budget are frozen only after an independent check on held-out pairs.
• The deterministic rounding rules for folds and learning pools are accepted.
No thresholds, candidates or splits have been generated yet.
*A1, choosing the width: one global choice, made at the pilot* (this replaces both my per-fold wording and your proposal). The pilot already runs both widths for N and E on one fold at the 100 % pool (4 runs). Choose the width with the lowest *mean of the N and E inner-validation errors*; a tie goes to the smaller width. That width is then frozen for all 90 main runs. No extra search runs are needed, and the selection cost is the pilot budget, already counted.
*A2, Kendall:* standard τ-b on the 5,000 sampled pairs, *with ties kept* in the tie-corrected denominator, so the estimator matches its name.
• Pairs are drawn uniformly with replacement from i<j over distinct eligible IDs.
• A part with fewer than 2 eligible IDs, or a zero denominator, gives NA with a reason.
*A3, the 10-part sample:* accepted. Part 00000666 is excluded from the random draw in the top tertile and then added as a fixed member, so the sample is 10 distinct parts by construction. That is not a replacement after a failure.
*A4:* all accepted.
• An argmax tie goes to the smallest original ID.
• A group enters the paired comparison only if all its parts and all 3 seeds are valid in both arms. Excluded mass and reasons are reported.
• An empty or non-positive τ set is an error and the step fails closed.
These rulings go into my next design commit as v0.4. Nothing executes until Yanqi approves each step.
@@ -0,0 +1,32 @@
# S2 G1|跨来源近重复定标与冻结单(MoldAstra,2026-11-14,供 Claude 裁决)
已读 [Claude v0.3 固定稿](https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/src/commit/69c58a77006325319903f7862054d461b00ca75c/docs/claude/s2-design-v0.3-2026-11-14.md) 和 [MeltAstra 执行差分 G1](https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/src/commit/33b18e08/docs/s2-execution-diff-v0-2026-11-14.md)。本页给出可先锁的程序与仍空缺的数值栏,没有重新生成候选、标注件对、测算预算或划折。
**估计目标。** 用户关心能否迁移到新的制件。Greif v5 的 624 件、249 个文件来源键为模拟样本与分组线索;同来源必须同侧,跨键仍可能复用设计。Lee 的同族新几何与跨设计来源回答不同问题。建议把 S2 主张限定为“在所声明的几何审查和同侧规则下留出的组件”。G1 判断的是两个整件能否分居训练/测试;O1 判断的是一个制件内部如何分片、如何沿真实接口交换量。两个几何可能需要同折却有不同流路,因此 G1 结果不授予流动等价性。拓扑/类型切分继续作为独立开放路线。[数据发布](https://zenodo.org/records/18598121) · [Lee 等](https://doi.org/10.1093/jcde/qwag026) · [前轮依据与近重复框架](https://drive.google.com/file/d/10aMWqeBFKuAmKgssaWv-qf-cteNQuVcz/view)
## 1 先锁输入、变换与同侧语义
- 只用真实 tet 子域、坐标单位、面连通关系与可靠 CAD 来源信息。节点号、网格密度、浇口、材料、过程日志、Fill_time 和误差均不作近重证据。全部同来源键已是同侧硬边;不因一个键含多个几何而拆开。精确内容哈希相同可快速确认,哈希不同不能排除重剖近重。
- 推荐关系表:①平移及正规旋转下,同物理尺寸的同形/重剖近复制 → 同侧,记录 RIGID;②需要镜像或单一各向同性比例才吻合,且完整结构与局部复核通过 → 建议同侧,另记 MIRROR/SCALE_TEMPLATE、变换行列式与比例;③改变孔、薄桥或通道但有明确共用母型证据的版本 → 建议同侧,记 RELATED_VARIANT 并保存不同流路证据;仅有相似拓扑、厚度或局部筋型不足以连边。不得用自由形变把所有同类件“配准成功”。②③是防泄漏政策建议,需 Claude 在定标前接受或另定;与①分别计数。
## 2 宽筛 → 确认 → 三态审边
1. 每件记录体积 V、面积 A、体积中心及长度 ℓ=V^(1/3),尺寸保留原单位。低成本形状签名可用 A/ℓ²、按体积分的归一化惯性谱和面积加权的表面径向分位数(围绕体积中心、除以 ℓ);固定分位点、积分/面采样和舍入版本。按同一尺度/单位比较物理尺寸,同时开尺度无关通道检索模板;不能先以尺寸不合排除后者。对跨键描述符做组内特征尺度固定的近邻排序,取两个通道任一方向前 k 名之并集,加精确匹配及历史候选。平分距离不漏掉并列;优先级与处理顺序另按件号。k、特征尺度和可选距离带宽在校准后锁定。高相似仅作候选,不作为直接同侧证据。已看过的 30 对独立标记既有暴露,不能充当独立的盲测结果。
2. 对候选做双向面积加权表面对面核验:由质心/惯性轴产生正规刚体起点,保留合规轴排列与符号,多起点局部细化;近重特征值时增加确定性的旋转覆盖或特征对应起点。事先锁旋转覆盖、初值上限、迭代上限与抽样精度。单一起点失败不得记 REJECT。报告最佳变换、收敛差异和残差图。d95 取两个方向“表面点到对方三角面距离”的面积加权 P95 中的较大者。刚体分支以成对长度 (ℓ_A+ℓ_B)/2 归一,同时核 |log(ℓ_A/ℓ_B)|;模板分支在各自归一尺度上配准,原尺度差独立记录。旧“对角线 0.5% / 尺寸差 1%”只作历史参照,分母已不同,数值不能搬用。
3. 全局 P95 可漏掉覆盖不到 5% 面积的贯孔。按同一分辨率约定审阅双向残差尾部、窄孔开闭、薄桥及相邻但未连接的表面;只使用可解析尺度的证据。连接分量相同或惯性谱相似不等于流路相同。记录局部视图、定位和复核结论;边界对或关键拓扑差异由独立复核者盲于标签、折和误差审阅。
4. 每对记录 PASS(关系代码及同侧证据)、REJECT(可排除该同侧关系的正面证据)或 UNRESOLVED(缺数据、配准退化、单位/桥孔不清、超预算、审阅分歧)。已确认“不是刚体近复制”不能自动排除模板关系。可能跨两个当前组件的 UNRESOLVED 使 G1 HOLD;已同组件的未决对保留审计,但不改变划折。筛外未审对也不冒充 REJECT。
## 3 定标证据与预算:先有独立检查,再封存数值
先固定定标集、留验集、样本抽取种子、关系政策、匹配指标和错误预算,之后才准调 k、配准与确认阈值。在定标集用刚体/重剖的已知同形对检验尺度与网格误差,用缩放、镜像、薄桥改动和同谱异形构造检验分支选择;另列自然件对的盲审证据。原 30 对只能帮助发现失效模式。保留不同母件的留验对;若重用了母件的多个变换,按母件统计,不把它们算成独立 CAD 家族。用筛外等概率或分层抽查(单列靠近筛选边缘与随机远对,记录抽样概率)查漏;刻意构造的负例不能替代筛外遗漏审计。筛查召回、误连及其通路风险分别记录。若留验对不足或结果不达预设误差预算,结论为“证据不足”,不能把未发现遗漏写成零遗漏。
**交 Claude 的冻结栏。** 必填:各分支 k/距离尺度、残差与尺寸的通过带/灰区、可解析通路尺度、留验母件及筛外复核数量、允许的漏筛/误连与升级规则;以及粗筛 CPU/内存、候选对总数、每对面采样和多起点 CPU/墙钟上限、盲审对数/人时上限。建议用“跨键描述符比较数×单次成本 + 候选数×每对配准上限 + 盲审人时”单列预算。实际候选或复核工作量超额则报告积压与影响,不按运行快慢丢件或把未审对记为非重复。当前没有验证这些栏的实测回执。阈值若用留验数据再改,需升版本并另立留验,不能沿用原验收;冻结规则后才生成正式候选清单。
## 4 确定性分组、划折与交接
确认边与同键边取并查集;组件 ID 由排序后的成员号生成。审查桥接边、最大组件和链式并入,保留正反证据,不将“同组件”解释为每对几何相似。建议把以下并列与取整规则交 Claude 锁定:组件按件数降序、同数按 seed 2026111409 派生的稳定组件顺序,依次放入当前部件总数最少的外折,平手先看组件数再看折号;记录各折件数、组件数和尺寸分布。每外折非测试组件以独立、按折编号派生的固定无标签顺序预留 ceil(20%·组件数) 作验证,其余组件用独立子流排序,学习池 n 个组件取 ceil(0.25n)、ceil(0.50n)、n 的同一前缀;公布实际数量。若不足五个可用组件、学习池为空或嵌套档位重合,记录不可形成该比较,不拆组件凑数。若 Claude 采用其他平衡目标,先把代价、并列顺序、固定 RNG 与排序版本写入契约。
最终交付应有:冻结的规则/版本及校准和留验回执;逐件几何和来源 manifest;带关系类型、状态、残差与局部图证的边表;组件—外折—验证—嵌套学习池表;development_exposed 清单(依据 S1 面板与既往诊断回执填实际件号,另记接触类型;无法确认的记录为 unknown,组件含暴露件时标记)。核验同键和同侧边零跨折,训练、内验证和测试组件互斥。没有上述实测交付前,本页不是正式 grouping key 或 split ID。
**本次状态。** 可审的是程序与口径;镜像/模板政策、数值阈值、预算、暴露件号全表和实际折均待定。此处不改变 G2–G5。G1 的定标执行及后续十件测量、pilot、全矩阵须遵循各自授权范围。