From a86a74cbd943e0687ee69fb1cccdc003250113cc Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Frank14f <1515444314@qq.com> Date: Sat, 14 Nov 2026 15:34:35 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] Append formal review release and all 24 LOPO shortfall decisions --- .../ADDENDUM_MANIFEST.json | 27 ++ .../2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/README.md | 12 + .../2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/SHA256SUMS | 8 +- .../evaluate_s1_shortfall.py | 55 ++++ .../s1-sampled-o2-panel/review_release.json | 14 + .../review_release_source.txt | 181 +++++++++++ .../s1-sampled-o2-panel/shortfall.csv | 25 ++ .../s1-sampled-o2-panel/shortfall.json | 304 ++++++++++++++++++ 8 files changed, 625 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) create mode 100644 review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/ADDENDUM_MANIFEST.json create mode 100644 review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/evaluate_s1_shortfall.py create mode 100644 review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/review_release.json create mode 100644 review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/review_release_source.txt create mode 100644 review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/shortfall.csv create mode 100644 review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/shortfall.json diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/ADDENDUM_MANIFEST.json b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/ADDENDUM_MANIFEST.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..512e695a1 --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/ADDENDUM_MANIFEST.json @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@ +[ + { + "path": "review_release.json", + "bytes": 949, + "sha256": "5e0b542cd4d7d614038c78768e2d01db9a740641b8ecbf63206c9c1ffd435683" + }, + { + "path": "shortfall.csv", + "bytes": 1795, + "sha256": "99a837d1be7543d19b232ff9f1ff419f18c07692793a706f3b8eec2ed81030b2" + }, + { + "path": "shortfall.json", + "bytes": 12035, + "sha256": "4d936f9effb10ed9cd6a06420297de3fa110bfd69356abf0bdd71db2ba39d077" + }, + { + "path": "evaluate_s1_shortfall.py", + "bytes": 3258, + "sha256": "9839afe56e6035ad185fbd8efdc81b9e9f3abc1912bd080425dd3b037896cec9" + }, + { + "path": "review_release_source.txt", + "bytes": 26182, + "sha256": "6f00f0399a109bfa4a3eacf8fee1c75574f259f205950a3857f3d393972c1edd" + } +] diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/README.md b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/README.md index 7f077d480..813ed36e7 100644 --- a/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/README.md +++ b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/README.md @@ -1,3 +1,15 @@ +# 当前状态增补:审核暂存已解除,24折短缺门通过 + +Grok已正式认证5e4b406驱动/监督与等价门,Claude15:22:29明确解除HOLD并批准下一步短缺门。[正式裁量](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1794640949342329)。本增补是在Slack连接恢复后取得,原数值包e2345c8已先行发布,因此ZIP内HELD记录保留为当时读取状态。当前以review_release.json及原文为准;这不是改写数值或事前审批历史。 + +24件监督均PASS,现已按固定LOPO-24逐折执行短缺门:24/24可比,0折命中任何训练件n_ref<500或超过20%训练件n_ref<1000。详见shortfall.csv/json和evaluate_s1_shortfall.py;端点499/500、999/1000、恰20%/超过20%、缺失结果测试通过。未执行任何真实S1评分、置换、bootstrap或训练。 + +Claude主审面板回执、短缺门和后续评分代码;Grok仅做必要定点独立核查。后续需先提交评分代码及手算可核synthetic测试供审,真实S1运行尚未放行。 + +**归档边界:**原ZIP保持54,426,009 bytes及SHA256 e268e139ba502477c751c7f58a923cce0c89a68f09cef5c8cddc3c998977d051,不重新压包。它包含489证据文件及原HELD历史;本次5份解除/短缺增补在Git目录直接可读,单列ADDENDUM_MANIFEST.json,并纳入更新的SHA256SUMS。原PACKAGE_MANIFEST.json仍只描述不变ZIP。以下为数值发布时的原说明。 + +--- + # 固定24件 sampled O2:全部结果与监督交付 24件队列完成,24件监督PASS,0件失败并保留记录。当前评审状态:HELD_PENDING_GROK_DRIVER_SUPERVISOR_REVIEW。没有运行S1评分、置换、bootstrap或训练。 diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/SHA256SUMS b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/SHA256SUMS index 5f49d0c93..c214cf0ab 100644 --- a/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/SHA256SUMS +++ b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/SHA256SUMS @@ -64,12 +64,14 @@ fb9c6f7b458e8a86753aaf8b497ab443ab9302fb600b269ad83d256e55b194d9 00001417_a45f6 3512e821a4ca0b8d24cf13087432c8c20c335704b5a915b0f6488f58679ca9de 00001417_a45f6c99e2154f3b94955175_step_001_original.supervisor.json f8d7695763e2ede8d90c2de276253446fa948f613cb09232c2f5f643172d8ae8 00001490_6c8ef6d2f5564d139a5077f8_step_001_original.result.json fc9f8b4c615c03810d864439a0d866b246611e0c02c2db3a032319372a4e44bd 00001490_6c8ef6d2f5564d139a5077f8_step_001_original.supervisor.json +f6e7db02bd307d35a08823f23503e52ebf91fd76315e7b4277409fa0e1c1594b ADDENDUM_MANIFEST.json e268e139ba502477c751c7f58a923cce0c89a68f09cef5c8cddc3c998977d051 MeltMind-sampled-O2-panel-20261114.zip fac2888e7e8774ebeb55fe23c43821597fe14b62f9e6668e9af288c02a2658e2 PACKAGE_MANIFEST.json -52bec0fbe320eb300e44e0035c64004ea95edf122470ae5336802bfcf04d8f13 README.md +000158e8ae4a267626ce2399c7429e2dd841f2af61cc4db4a83271739f404925 README.md 8926e4a7fbb5da604585bfcd7eb70c4c68fa81742cbaec2fb17148113f96f2c4 equivalence.completion.json fcc70dd19a0708bc4d6c304cd866b187aab5beeb5d7bd01a4f3f5cf4c3fa1fc3 equivalence.started.json 51e68b45d96c3cfd89f59c7b267a5ae09a9a0832d5fa319a2358d3d7a22980b1 equivalence_gate.json +9839afe56e6035ad185fbd8efdc81b9e9f3abc1912bd080425dd3b037896cec9 evaluate_s1_shortfall.py 65c390ac72c7875ef793d6a99a4835790c6991e911593e4d1ecad608da39fdb6 execution_contract.json 1e818a7a35d6dd2964246200fbd5aea6aba05d1cb9d099bbd14b82011886cfa7 gate_publication_verification.json b2274512cda38b999f41d261d5b126df3445df7a94bd4232323ac383de8fd5bf monitor_audit.json @@ -77,8 +79,12 @@ bd2f384b6c09ee205c8f062ff19b3eb8329378c6b579208bd1b1b882fa2a5cdb numpy_build_co 02da42fd83a5c91959be86bed106d49dca845e0ffc3b829395dd6da1f25a0c73 panel.completion.json 2cc7c135f2483fc1686d23db8773b8fd8bf79f8f4e0a4affc1c4be5d3d84fe6f panel.started.json a54beba9c18f97072db42d0c9812ba56726e1c23d5e8ad850c8386cb32b1c071 review_hold.json +5e0b542cd4d7d614038c78768e2d01db9a740641b8ecbf63206c9c1ffd435683 review_release.json +6f00f0399a109bfa4a3eacf8fee1c75574f259f205950a3857f3d393972c1edd review_release_source.txt 66ab07068c6553a5d49d5124087d69c338e057919e2fe0c31124ba6d2d2a5d36 run_sampled_o2.py 85866de0c80ac308d325163ea09621c6a28c913c6c87180e2e0ee8fe06d6d690 runtime.json +99a837d1be7543d19b232ff9f1ff419f18c07692793a706f3b8eec2ed81030b2 shortfall.csv +4d936f9effb10ed9cd6a06420297de3fa110bfd69356abf0bdd71db2ba39d077 shortfall.json 9102ebbb3af9a8b67d25b7a820f8d724f9126f3033a777e170ef182c2619ed63 summary.csv 9ba68b5460481683ef0cc3138bdcdd70df4a67fd9d02e90a57b79ef4b1ddc2c8 supervise_sampled_o2.py 0034ac0204e3457b5754efc0690dcccfce479e773598d43f60ed981c175a9926 test_draw_identity_check.json diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/evaluate_s1_shortfall.py b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/evaluate_s1_shortfall.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f8094ca6a --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/evaluate_s1_shortfall.py @@ -0,0 +1,55 @@ +"""Frozen v1.2 LOPO shortfall gate only; no scoring or training.""" +import csv +import hashlib +import json +from pathlib import Path + + +def read(p):return json.loads(Path(p).read_text()) +def sha(p):return hashlib.sha256(Path(p).read_bytes()).hexdigest() + + +def decision(nrefs): + if not nrefs or any(n is None for n in nrefs): + return dict(comparable=False,reason='missing_training_result',below_500=None,below_1000=None) + assert all(isinstance(n,int) and n>=0 for n in nrefs) + below500=sum(n<500 for n in nrefs);below1000=sum(n<1000 for n in nrefs) + # Strictly greater than 20 percent, expressed exactly with integer arithmetic. + fail=below500>0 or 5*below1000>len(nrefs) + return dict(comparable=not fail,reason='shortfall' if fail else 'PASS',below_500=below500,below_1000=below1000) + + +def main(): + assert decision([500,1000,1000,1000,1000])['comparable'] + assert not decision([499,1000,1000,1000,1000])['comparable'] + assert decision([999,1000,1000,1000,1000])['comparable'] + assert not decision([999,999,1000,1000,1000])['comparable'] + assert not decision([None,2000])['comparable'] + out=Path('artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14') + release=read(out/'review_release.json');assert release['process_hold_cleared'] + c=read(out/'execution_contract.json');assert read(out/'verification.json')['status']=='PASS' + assert len(read(out/'panel.completion.json')['records'])==24 + foldpath=Path('artifacts/s1-sampled-draw-2026-11-14/fold_table.csv') + folds=list(csv.DictReader(foldpath.open()));rows=[];inputs={} + for f in folds: + test=int(f['test_panel_index']);training=list(map(int,f['train_panel_indices'].split(';'))) + assert training==[i for i in range(24) if i!=test] + nrefs=[] + for i in training: + s=c['panel'][i];p=out/'panel'/(s['job']+'.supervisor.json');sup=read(p);inputs[str(p)]=sha(p) + nrefs.append(sup['n_ref'] if sup['status']=='PASS' else None) + d=decision(nrefs) + rows.append(dict(fold_index=int(f['fold_index']),test_panel_index=test,test_case=f['test_case'],training_parts=len(training),training_min_n_ref=min(nrefs) if all(n is not None for n in nrefs) else None,**d)) + with (out/'shortfall.csv').open('x') as f: + w=csv.DictWriter(f,fieldnames=list(rows[0]),lineterminator='\n');w.writeheader();w.writerows(rows) + result=dict(status='COMPLETE',folds=rows,comparable_folds=sum(r['comparable'] for r in rows), + authority='https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1794640949342329', + rule='Any training n_ref<500 OR fraction(training n_ref<1000)>0.20 is not comparable; equality endpoints do not trigger.', + boundary_tests='PASS: 499/500, 999/1000, exactly20percent/above20percent, missing result', + fold_table_sha256=sha(foldpath),supervisor_sha256=inputs,code_sha256=sha(__file__), + process_release_sha256=sha(out/'review_release.json'),S1_scoring=False,training=False) + with (out/'shortfall.json').open('x') as f:json.dump(result,f,indent=2);f.write('\n') + print(json.dumps(dict(folds=len(rows),comparable_folds=result['comparable_folds'],shortfall_failures=sum(not r['comparable'] for r in rows),S1_scoring=False),indent=2)) + + +if __name__=='__main__':main() diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/review_release.json b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/review_release.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4e7611f80 --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/review_release.json @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +{ + "process_hold_cleared": true, + "status": "DRIVER_SUPERVISOR_REVIEW_PASSED_PANEL_COMPLETE_READY_FOR_SHORTFALL_AND_SCORING_CODE_REVIEW", + "grok": "https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1794640926752179", + "claude": "https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1794640949342329", + "later_grok_confirmation": "https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1794641204916349", + "source_snapshot": "docs/s1-sampled-o2-review-release-2026-11-14.txt", + "source_sha256": "6f00f0399a109bfa4a3eacf8fee1c75574f259f205950a3857f3d393972c1edd", + "historical_hold_retained": true, + "panel_numeric_commit": "e2345c8528d9d72d6ffd2b47a4482d91f54df734", + "S1_real_scoring_approved": false, + "training_approved": false, + "note": "Source fetched after transient Slack errors and after initial numeric publication; append-only release, no numerical edits. Claude now primary reviewer; Grok only targeted independent checks." +} diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/review_release_source.txt b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/review_release_source.txt new file mode 100644 index 000000000..33af33e10 --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/review_release_source.txt @@ -0,0 +1,181 @@ + (15 total) === + +--- Reply 1 of 15 --- +From: Grok (local) (U0C7VDY1HEG) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:22:06 CST +Message TS: 1794640926.711639 +*Grok: equivalence gate and sampled driver/supervisor certified at `5e4b406`; process hold on the 24-part queue is cleared* + +<@U0C7U0YA91S|Frank14f> <@U0C7SSQLBJ7|ClaudeWorker (local)> <@U0C7U1KJVPE|frank14wyq-tron> I independently fetched `` ("Publish sampled O2 bitwise equivalence gate and held-run review inputs", 14:58:45 Asia/Shanghai). This is the formal step-3 check of the receipts and sources. + +*Package integrity — PASS.* ZIP is 1,110,951 bytes, SHA256 `6c3f8953e9f9f11c5a9eef21dd410a46aec676117f885f5cb659678439105b25`, 79 members (78 manifest paths + `PACKAGE_MANIFEST.json`). All CRC values and all 78 member SHA256s match the manifest. Every `SHA256SUMS` entry matches the git tree, including the ZIP and both sources. Unpacked per-field `equivalence.json` / `result.json` / `supervisor.json` and both `.py` files are byte-identical to the copies next to the README. + +*Sources.* +• `run_sampled_o2.py` SHA256 `66ab07068c6553a5d49d5124087d69c338e057919e2fe0c31124ba6d2d2a5d36` +• `supervise_sampled_o2.py` SHA256 `9ba68b5460481683ef0cc3138bdcdd70df4a67fd9d02e90a57b79ef4b1ddc2c8` +Both match the posted values, the contract, the ZIP `tools/`, and `equivalence_gate.json`. The driver imports the frozen `run_e6_real_kernel` `raw_field` / `samples` / `integrate` and `o2_rep.readout` / `contract_direction`, and asserts every code and input SHA before each field. The panel phase also asserts gate `status=PASS` and the six gate result SHAs, so it cannot start without this package. The other seven frozen tool SHAs in the contract match the copies packed here. Contract: `full_field_commit=f2e5ed0`, `S1_scoring=training=permutations=bootstrap=False`, bit-exact comparison (no numeric tolerance), budget 1,800 s / 1,280 MiB / 20 ms poll. + +*Edge summary / eligibility (the S1-facing block Claude flagged).* Mean and max use only finite, channel-valid endpoints; an anchor with none of those is NaN and fails `complete` / eligibility. `complete` requires every incident true-edge end to have been evaluated. Eligibility is d>0 ∧ spectrum valid ∧ N_eff pass ∧ gate direction and channel valid ∧ complete ∧ finite features. Invalid endpoints are retained and kept out of the summaries. That matches the agreed rule, including gate-undefined nodes. This block is *not* covered by the 30-array bit-exact gate; I reviewed the source and did not re-execute it. Result `n_ref=200` is the eligible-anchor count on this test draw, not a shortfall-gate pass. + +*Equivalence receipts — PASS.* All six fields report 30/30 arrays bitwise equal (dtype, shape, C-order bytes, including NaN patterns), `mismatches=[]`. The 30 names are the agreed node μ/g/B, gate q/status, and selected-anchor true-edge q/status set. I recomputed the six frozen `f2e5ed0` `result.json` SHA256s from git; each receipt's `baseline_result_sha256` matches: +• 850 original `a560e34f…ec056226` / rotated `a9b37541…29abfa5c` +• 778 original `9822a169…6aba183e` / rotated `5eebd998…e942bd60` +• 666 original `edabaddf…51d2ed76` / rotated `c4a4973f…13d87312` +Supervisor result SHAs match the git copies and `equivalence_gate.json`. I did not re-extract the full-node `nodes.npz` / `edges.npz` from the `f2e5ed0` ZIP in this checkout, so I did not myself re-run the subset `tobytes` comparison against those arrays. + +*Test IDs / pin 2 — PASS.* Stored draws have 2,000 slots (d>0 mass PPS, primary seed). Final unique IDs equal the first 200 sorted unique IDs plus extras, with extras at multiplicity 0, identical in both poses: +• 850: 201 anchors; smallest boundary = named gate = 0 +• 778: 202 anchors; boundary 1, named gate 27375 +• 666: 201 anchors; boundary = named gate = 0 + +--- Reply 2 of 15 --- +From: Grok (local) (U0C7VDY1HEG) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:22:06 CST +Message TS: 1794640926.752179 +The recovered nearest-gate IDs equal the named `gate_undefined_node_ids`, so the pin is satisfied and no rerun is required. CSV, npz, and both pose node lists agree. The historical argmin-on-original-coordinates record is kept; nothing was reselected after the fact. Test draws live under `s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/test_draws/` and are not the frozen `94011fd` panel draws. 850/778/666 are not on the 24-part panel. I did not replay the PCG64 draw against the intake geometry; I checked the stored ID lists only. + +*Supervisor — PASS.* Sequential one-field processes, whole-tree RSS/HWM, 20 ms polling *target*, `ru_maxrss` after exit, empty `/proc` fields counted as zero (not `max(empty)`), missing result cannot PASS, budget failure recorded without replacement. All six PASS. Supervised walls 1.242–8.253 s; peak RSS 738.87 MiB (666 original). Max observed poll gaps 0.020–0.286 s, so 20 ms is not a hard real-time guarantee. + +*Process.* README and `review_hold.json` correctly record the 14:56 start-before-step-3 deviation and Claude's 14:56:43 ruling. + +*Ruling.* I certify the published equivalence gate and the sampled driver/supervisor at `5e4b406`. The process hold on the already-started 24-part queue is cleared: those outputs may enter later shortfall / S1 review once the run finishes and its receipts are posted. I have not reviewed any 24-part panel receipts in this check. No shortfall, S1, or training in this package. + +--- Reply 3 of 15 --- +From: ClaudeWorker (local) (U0C7SSQLBJ7) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:22:10 CST +Message TS: 1794640930.506799 +Accepted; working on: “*Grok: equivalence gate and sampled driver/supervisor certified at `5e…” + +--- Reply 4 of 15 --- +From: frank14wyq-tron (U0C7U1KJVPE) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:22:11 CST +Message TS: 1794640931.246839 +<@U0C7SSQLBJ7|ClaudeWorker (local)> <@U0C7VDY1HEG|Grok (local)> TRON 同步 Yanqi 刚才的安排:他观察到 Grok 用量较快,希望 Claude 多分担,尤其是关键决策和设计。 + +接下来请 Claude 承担主要方案取舍、设计收敛和主审,两个 Astra 继续执行与数学推导;Grok 聚焦必要的独立核查、关键文献与信息缺口,减少重复全文复述和常规往返确认。文件仍用固定 Git/Drive 版本,Slack 只给差异、结论和下一步。 + +这不取消当前 5e4b406 驱动/监督代码的既定 Grok 独立审核门,已交审的这项请沿原请求完成;面板结果继续 HELD,后续由 Claude 按实审回执裁量。无需为此次分工调整另写长报告或重复 ACK。 + +--- Reply 5 of 15 --- +From: ClaudeWorker (local) (U0C7SSQLBJ7) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:22:11 CST +Message TS: 1794640931.741399 +Queued behind 1 earlier request(s): “@⁠Grok TRON 同步 Yanqi 刚才的安排:他观察到 Grok 用量较快,希望 Claud…” + +--- Reply 6 of 15 --- +From: ClaudeWorker (local) (U0C7SSQLBJ7) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:22:29 CST +Message TS: 1794640949.342329 +*Claude: Grok has certified `5e4b406`, so the HOLD is cleared.* + +Next, in order: +1. *Panel receipts* once all 24 have finished: per-part supervisor results, valid/unscored/invalid counts, n_ref (distinct eligible IDs), eligible draw counts, and the reason-bit totals. +2. *Shortfall gate* (v1.2, as written): a fold is not comparable if any training part has n_ref < 500, or if more than 20 % of training parts have n_ref < 1000. Evaluate it for each of the 24 LOPO folds and publish the result *before* any scoring. +3. *S1 scoring code review:* MeltAstra publishes the scoring code (rank fit, D_p, 8-NN, the 6 arms, both shuffles, bootstrap 1406, ratio estimators, source-equal aggregation) at a fixed commit, with tests on a synthetic case where the M2 values are known by hand. Grok and I review it before any real S1 run. + +No training. + +--- Reply 7 of 15 --- +From: ClaudeWorker (local) (U0C7SSQLBJ7) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:22:43 CST +Message TS: 1794640963.417559 +*Claude: taking that on.* Grok's check of `5e4b406` is already done (certified at 15:13), so nothing is pending from the earlier request. + +From here on: +• *I do the primary review* of the panel receipts, the shortfall gate and the S1 scoring code, and set the acceptance criteria. +• *Grok is asked only for targeted independent checks:* replaying the draws and seeds, recomputing hashes, and confirming one or two critical formulas in the scoring code. No full re-reads. +• *Execution and derivations* stay with MeltAstra and MoldAstra. +• Slack carries only differences, decisions and next steps; everything else goes in pinned Git or Drive versions. + +--- Reply 8 of 15 --- +From: Grok (local) (U0C7VDY1HEG) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:25:09 CST +Message TS: 1794641109.313009 +*Grok: formal check of `5e4b406` — PASS. HELD-pending-review is cleared; shortfall/S1 still wait for the 24-part queue.* + +<@U0C7U0YA91S|Frank14f> <@U0C7SSQLBJ7|ClaudeWorker (local)> <@U0C7U1KJVPE|frank14wyq-tron> I independently fetched commit `5e4b40603e47fcd67fac47a47d4da88ec9202ba6` (parent `94011fd`, not the old `94011fd` tree) from . + +*Package and hashes.* All 28 git objects match the tree (identity and size). Recomputed SHA256s match the posted values: driver `66ab07068c6553a5d49d5124087d69c338e057919e2fe0c31124ba6d2d2a5d36`, supervisor `9ba68b5460481683ef0cc3138bdcdd70df4a67fd9d02e90a57b79ef4b1ddc2c8`, ZIP 1,110,951 bytes `6c3f8953e9f9f11c5a9eef21dd410a46aec676117f885f5cb659678439105b25` (79 members; all CRC and member SHA passed). The 27 non-ZIP objects are complete byte-for-byte (26 SUMS-listed files match; `SHA256SUMS` is the unlisted 27th). I also hashed the ZIP as 17×64 KiB chunks (last chunk 62,375 bytes); the concatenated SHA equals the full-file SHA. 25 of the 27 non-ZIP files are byte-identical inside the evidence ZIP; `README.md` and `SHA256SUMS` are review wrappers, not ZIP members. All nine frozen tool SHAs in the contract match the copies packed in the ZIP. + +*Test IDs and gate pin.* I rebuilt the anchors from the published draws (2,000 PPS, unique IDs sorted ascending, first 200, plus smallest-boundary and nearest-gate IDs). Reconstructed IDs and multiplicities match the npz and CSV exactly; both poses share one file per part; counts are 201/202/201. Recovered gate IDs equal the named pins (850=0, 778=27375, 666=0); boundary minima are 0/1/0; added-only anchors have multiplicity 0. I did not re-run the coordinate `argmin` on the mesh (geometry is not in this package), but the recorded recovered IDs already equal the named ones, so the pin is satisfied and no gate rerun is required. + +*Equivalence receipts.* All six fields PASS, 30 arrays each (180 total), 0 mismatches, including NaN bit patterns, μ/g/B, gate q/status, and true-edge endpoint q/status/length/ids. Supervisor: all six PASS; walls 1.242–8.253 s; peak RSS 738.87 MiB (666 original); recorded max poll gaps 0.020–0.286 s. Result SHAs match `equivalence_gate.json`. The six `baseline_result_sha256` values match the `f2e5ed0` `result.json` files in `review/2026-11-14/o2-rep-v1.1a/`. Frozen L_med pins match (850 3.546479844, 778 0.286664129, 666 1.942206301). The panel contract lists 24 parts and does not include 850/778/666. S1, training, bootstrap, and permutation are all off. + +*Driver and supervisor, including lines 97–106.* The driver imports frozen `run_e6_real_kernel.integrate` / `raw_field` / `samples` and `o2_rep.readout` / `contract_direction`, and asserts every code and input SHA before it runs. The panel phase also asserts gate status PASS and each gate `result_sha256`. Mean/max use only finite, channel-valid endpoints; if there are none, both are NaN (no placeholder zeros). `complete` requires every true-edge end to have been evaluated, at least one valid end, and a finite summary. Eligibility is d>0 ∧ spectrum valid ∧ N_eff≥64 ∧ gate direction and channel valid ∧ complete ∧ finite features, including rule (i) for nodes without a gate direction. I recomputed mean/max, counts, and eligibility from the stored edge arrays: bit-exact on all six fields. The only ineligible anchors are the added mask nodes with d=0 (850/666 id 0; 778 ids 1 and 27375). As Claude noted, the bitwise gate does not compare these new S1 summary/eligibility arrays to `f2e5ed0`; that is a coverage boundary, not a mismatch. Supervisor: 20 ms poll target, 1,800 s / 1.25 GiB, process-tree RSS, no `max(empty)` after exit, missing result cannot PASS, budget failure recorded without replacement. Equivalence stops on FAIL; the panel continues after a budget FAIL. Max gaps are recorded and are not a hard real-time guarantee. + +--- Reply 9 of 15 --- +From: Grok (local) (U0C7VDY1HEG) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:25:09 CST +Message TS: 1794641109.355279 +*Grok: formal check of `5e4b406` — PASS. HELD-pending-review is cleared; shortfall/S1 still wait for the 24-part queue. (1/2)* + +<@U0C7U0YA91S|Frank14f> <@U0C7SSQLBJ7|ClaudeWorker (local)> <@U0C7U1KJVPE|frank14wyq-tron> I independently fetched commit `5e4b40603e47fcd67fac47a47d4da88ec9202ba6` (parent `94011fd`, not that older tree) from . + +*Package.* All 28 git objects match the tree (identity and size). Recomputed SHA256s match the posted values: +• driver `66ab07068c6553a5d49d5124087d69c338e057919e2fe0c31124ba6d2d2a5d36` +• supervisor `9ba68b5460481683ef0cc3138bdcdd70df4a67fd9d02e90a57b79ef4b1ddc2c8` +• ZIP 1,110,951 bytes `6c3f8953e9f9f11c5a9eef21dd410a46aec676117f885f5cb659678439105b25` (79 members; all CRC and member SHA passed) +The 27 non-ZIP objects are complete byte-for-byte (26 SUMS-listed files match; `SHA256SUMS` is the unlisted 27th). I also hashed the ZIP as 17×64 KiB chunks (last chunk 62,375 bytes); the concatenated SHA equals the full-file SHA. 25 of 27 non-ZIP files are byte-identical inside the ZIP; `README.md` and `SHA256SUMS` are review wrappers, not ZIP members. All nine frozen tool SHAs in the contract match the copies in the ZIP. + +*Test IDs and gate pin.* I rebuilt the anchors from the published draws (2,000 PPS, unique IDs sorted ascending, first 200, plus smallest-boundary and nearest-gate IDs). Reconstructed IDs and multiplicities match the npz and CSV; both poses share one file per part; counts 201/202/201. Recovered gate IDs equal the named pins (850=0, 778=27375, 666=0); boundary minima 0/1/0; added-only anchors have multiplicity 0. Geometry is not in this package, so I did not re-run the coordinate `argmin`; the recorded recovered IDs already equal the named ones, so the pin is satisfied and no gate rerun is required. + +*Receipts.* All six fields PASS, 30 arrays each (180 total), 0 mismatches, including NaN bit patterns, μ/g/B, gate q/status, and true-edge endpoint q/status/length/ids. Supervisor: all six PASS; walls 1.242–8.253 s; peak RSS 738.87 MiB (666 original); max poll gaps 0.020–0.286 s. Result SHAs match `equivalence_gate.json`. The six `baseline_result_sha256` values match the `f2e5ed0` `result.json` files under `review/2026-11-14/o2-rep-v1.1a/`. Frozen L_med pins match (850 3.546479844, 778 0.286664129, 666 1.942206301). The panel contract lists 24 parts and does not include 850/778/666. S1, training, bootstrap, and permutation are all off. + +--- Reply 10 of 15 --- +From: ClaudeWorker (local) (U0C7SSQLBJ7) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:25:10 CST +Message TS: 1794641110.741519 +Accepted; working on: “*Grok: formal check of `5e4b406` — PASS. HELD-pending-review is cleare…” + +--- Reply 11 of 15 --- +From: Grok (local) (U0C7VDY1HEG) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:26:31 CST +Message TS: 1794641191.218839 +*Grok: formal PASS on `5e4b406` — driver, supervisor, test IDs, and six-field gate receipts; shortfall/S1 still wait for the 24-part queue to finish* + +<@U0C7U0YA91S|Frank14f> <@U0C7SSQLBJ7|ClaudeWorker (local)> <@U0C7U1KJVPE|frank14wyq-tron> I independently fetched commit `5e4b40603e47fcd67fac47a47d4da88ec9202ba6` (parent `94011fd`, 14:58:45 Asia/Shanghai) and . That delivery crossed with my earlier “files not yet posted” replies; the files are here now, and I have read them myself. Claude’s SHA check is noted and is not a substitute for this one. + +*What I actually read.* `run_sampled_o2.py`, `supervise_sampled_o2.py`, `equivalence_gate.json`, `execution_contract.json`, `test_draw_identity_check.json`, `README.md`, `review_hold.json`, all six `equivalence.json` / `result.json` / `supervisor.json` receipts, the test-draw `.npz` / ID CSVs, and the corresponding `nodes.npz` / `edges.npz`. I also re-hashed the published ZIP and compared panel-draw SHAs to my previously certified `94011fd` copy. + +*Integrity — PASS.* ZIP 1,110,951 bytes, SHA256 `6c3f8953e9f9f11c5a9eef21dd410a46aec676117f885f5cb659678439105b25`, 79 members, CRC clean. All 78 manifest member SHA256s match (the manifest itself is the 79th member). All 27 `SHA256SUMS` git-dir entries match, and the flattened receipts match the ZIP copies. Driver SHA `66ab07068c6553a5d49d5124087d69c338e057919e2fe0c31124ba6d2d2a5d36`. Supervisor SHA `9ba68b5460481683ef0cc3138bdcdd70df4a67fd9d02e90a57b79ef4b1ddc2c8`. The nine frozen tool SHAs in the contract match the copies packed in the ZIP. The six baseline `result.json` SHA256s cited by the gate match both the contract and my previously fetched `f2e5ed0` receipts. All 24 panel `draw.npz` / receipt / fold-identity SHA256s match the frozen `94011fd` package. + +*Driver — PASS.* It imports frozen `run_e6_real_kernel.integrate`, `raw_field`, `samples` and `o2_rep.readout` / `contract_direction`, and asserts every code and input SHA before each field. `raw_field` and four-point sources stay on the full mesh; only the integrate/readout/edge pass is restricted to the selected anchors. `L_med` is taken from all original true edges and carried to the rotated pose (850 / 778 / 666 = 3.54647984396144 / 0.2866641291291626 / 1.9422063007795314). `R_g` is from all full-part lumped masses before eligibility. The panel phase cannot start unless the gate status is PASS and the six result SHAs match. Comparison is dtype/shape/C-order bytes, including NaN bit patterns; any mismatch exits 2, with no tolerance. + +*Edge summary and common eligibility — PASS on the saved arrays.* Mean/max use only finite, channel-valid true-edge ends; every incident end is retained with flags; `complete` requires every true end to have been evaluated and at least one accepted finite summary; eligibility is `d>0` ∧ spectrum valid ∧ `neff_pass` ∧ gate direction and channel valid ∧ complete ∧ finite features. I recomputed mean/max, degrees, and eligibility from the saved edge/node arrays on all six fields: bitwise match to the stored summaries, 200 complete and 200 eligible unique IDs per field, and the reported eligible-draw counts (323 / 211 / 201). The extra mask anchors are ineligible (`d=0`). As Claude noted, these S1-specific arrays are *not* inside the 30-array bit-exact gate; the check above is on the saved outputs, not a second kernel run. + +--- Reply 12 of 15 --- +From: Grok (local) (U0C7VDY1HEG) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:26:31 CST +Message TS: 1794641191.266989 +*Test IDs — PASS.* Each test draw is 2,000 PPS slots whose unique set and multiplicities reconstruct exactly; anchors are the first 200 unique IDs in ascending original-node order, plus the smallest boundary ID and the nearest-gate ID, with duplicates dropped, then re-sorted. Counts are 201 / 202 / 201 for 850 / 778 / 666, identical across poses, and they match the ID CSVs. Actual nearest-gate IDs equal the named frozen IDs: 850=0, 778=27375, 666=0; boundary minima 0 / 1 / 0. The extras were not in the PPS draw (multiplicity 0). The historical nearest-node search is recorded; because the recovered IDs match the named ones, no rerun is required. These test draws are separate from the frozen 24-part `94011fd` bytes. + +*Six-field receipts — PASS, with one stated boundary.* All six fields report 30/30 arrays bitwise equal and zero mismatches (μ, g, B, gate q/status, all selected-anchor true-edge-end q/status, and the other frozen node/edge outputs, including NaN bits). Result SHAs match `equivalence_gate.json` and the supervisor receipts. Supervised walls are 1.24–8.25 s; peak RSS is 738.87 MiB (666 original, 774,758,400 bytes). I did *not* reload the full-node `f2e5ed0` `nodes.npz` / `edges.npz` arrays to repeat the byte comparison myself — those full-mesh arrays are deliberately not in this package — so the 30-array PASS is accepted from the signed receipts plus matching baseline result SHAs, not from a second independent slice of the full-node arrays. + +*Supervisor — PASS.* One field per process; 20 ms is a polling target, not a hard real-time guarantee; each receipt records `max_observed_poll_gap_seconds` (0.020–0.286 s here). Limits are 1,800 s / 1,342,177,280 bytes (1.25 GiB). Missing `/proc` fields are treated as zero observations, never `max(empty)`; `ru_maxrss` is merged after exit; a missing final result cannot PASS. Budget failure is recorded without replacement. On the panel, a budget FAIL is recorded and the queue may continue; an unexpected producer failure stops the queue. The equivalence phase stops on any FAIL. The process deviation and HELD status are recorded honestly in the README and `review_hold.json`. + +*Not in this check.* I did not replay the PCG64 test draws from geometry/masses (those arrays are not in this package). I did not re-run the kernel. I did not review the in-progress 24-part panel outputs or certify the reported 19/24 supervision PASSes. I did not re-verify precheck geometry SHA256s (they are not in the `94011fd` draw package). + +*Disposition.* Step 3 of the 14:54 order is complete for the driver, supervisor, test IDs, and gate receipts. The already-started 24-part queue may finish under Claude’s ruling. Shortfall and S1 still wait until that queue finishes; if a later panel job fails, record it and rerun from the same frozen draws if required — no numerical patching. No new compute or re-upload from me. + +--- Reply 13 of 15 --- +From: ClaudeWorker (local) (U0C7SSQLBJ7) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:26:33 CST +Message TS: 1794641193.847139 +Accepted; working on: “*Grok: formal PASS on `5e4b406` — driver, supervisor, test IDs, and si…” + +--- Reply 14 of 15 --- +From: Grok (local) (U0C7VDY1HEG) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:26:44 CST +Message TS: 1794641204.916349 +*Grok: `5e4b406` formal check (2/2) — driver/supervisor and hold.* + +*Driver/supervisor, including lines 97–106.* The driver imports frozen `run_e6_real_kernel.integrate` / `raw_field` / `samples` and `o2_rep.readout` / `contract_direction`, and asserts every code and input SHA before it runs. The panel phase also asserts gate status PASS and each gate `result_sha256`. Mean/max use only finite, channel-valid endpoints; if there are none, both are NaN (no placeholder zeros). `complete` requires every true-edge end to have been evaluated, at least one valid end, and a finite summary. Eligibility is d>0, spectrum valid, N_eff>=64, gate direction and channel valid, complete, and finite features, including rule (i) for nodes without a gate direction. I recomputed mean/max, counts, and eligibility from the stored edge arrays: bit-exact on all six fields. The only ineligible anchors are the added mask nodes with d=0 (850/666 id 0; 778 ids 1 and 27375). As Claude noted, the bitwise gate does not compare these new S1 summary/eligibility arrays to `f2e5ed0`; that is a coverage boundary, not a mismatch. Supervisor: 20 ms poll target, 1,800 s / 1.25 GiB, process-tree RSS, no `max(empty)` after exit, missing result cannot PASS, budget failure recorded without replacement. Equivalence stops on FAIL; the panel continues after a budget FAIL. Max gaps are recorded and are not a hard real-time guarantee. + +*Hold.* The README and `review_hold.json` record the process deviation honestly. I sign off the equivalence gate and the frozen driver/supervisor at `5e4b406`. The HELD-pending-Grok-review condition is therefore cleared. Let the already-started 24-part queue finish; shortfall and S1 still wait until all 24 supervised jobs have finished. If a later check of the panel outputs fails, void and rerun from the frozen `94011fd` draws; no numerical patching. No training. I did not re-run integrate, and I did not re-open the full `f2e5ed0` node/edge arrays (they are not in this package). The 30-array bit-exact claim is accepted from the receipts plus the matching baseline `result.json` SHAs. The planned post-processing recheck remains useful for the 24-part panel; on the six-field gate I already recomputed those summaries from the stored arrays. + +--- Reply 15 of 15 --- +From: ClaudeWorker (local) (U0C7SSQLBJ7) +Time: 2026-11-14 15:26:47 CST +Message TS: 1794641207.463139 +Accepted; working on: “*Grok: formal check of `5e4b406` — PASS. HELD-pending-review is cleare…” + diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/shortfall.csv b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/shortfall.csv new file mode 100644 index 000000000..98e222c88 --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/shortfall.csv @@ -0,0 +1,25 @@ +fold_index,test_panel_index,test_case,training_parts,training_min_n_ref,comparable,reason,below_500,below_1000 +0,0,00000993_ac4ba032d4b5431ca04f542c_step_000,23,1570,True,PASS,0,0 +1,1,00000329_12a935cd9b684f879c0505fe_step_000,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +2,2,00000418_ce5b31679ee845a69ba89d6f_step_000,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +3,3,00000103_52f7124261ae4c558f800775_step_000,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +4,4,00001067_8a2edcf36bcd435092f4c8ae_step_001,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +5,5,00000162_4dcda9fab6dd46cf98fb194e_step_000,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +6,6,00001490_6c8ef6d2f5564d139a5077f8_step_001,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +7,7,00001387_60cf3ad636dd42e0bcec6946_step_000,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +8,8,00000280_5a6ef3285b89452ea6b390e7_step_001,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +9,9,00000140_2fc54fcd110d4f49969163c4_step_003,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +10,10,00000161_a583c6c3cdc143bab3f6c856_step_000,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +11,11,00001041_6baf25f5fe2947e8927797d8_step_000,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +12,12,00000411_305e45c9479f43979b0d7b53_step_000,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +13,13,00000996_6d71695ba3fd475c927a00a7_step_000,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +14,14,00001106_ba88e7579ced4a0aa2de629c_step_000,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +15,15,00000060_767e4372b5f94a88a7a17d90_step_001,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +16,16,00000723_8ed79b6bcb024d1a9f2aa5e7_step_000,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +17,17,00000405_f3759bbb4682423caf207e8e_step_002,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +18,18,00000206_27417003e762409185cb2b69_step_000,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +19,19,00001417_a45f6c99e2154f3b94955175_step_001,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +20,20,00000408_36bcb4030e36417b8dc74b87_step_000,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +21,21,00000364_38d899e2706a4d09960705dd_step_001,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +22,22,00001358_2e314c6e080b40fcb6a6db96_step_001,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 +23,23,00001040_74c42207fa764831b03f7658_step_000,23,1382,True,PASS,0,0 diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/shortfall.json b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/shortfall.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4aea0598e --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/s1-sampled-o2-panel/shortfall.json @@ -0,0 +1,304 @@ +{ + "status": "COMPLETE", + "folds": [ + { + "fold_index": 0, + "test_panel_index": 0, + "test_case": "00000993_ac4ba032d4b5431ca04f542c_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1570, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 1, + "test_panel_index": 1, + "test_case": "00000329_12a935cd9b684f879c0505fe_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 2, + "test_panel_index": 2, + "test_case": "00000418_ce5b31679ee845a69ba89d6f_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 3, + "test_panel_index": 3, + "test_case": "00000103_52f7124261ae4c558f800775_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 4, + "test_panel_index": 4, + "test_case": "00001067_8a2edcf36bcd435092f4c8ae_step_001", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 5, + "test_panel_index": 5, + "test_case": "00000162_4dcda9fab6dd46cf98fb194e_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 6, + "test_panel_index": 6, + "test_case": "00001490_6c8ef6d2f5564d139a5077f8_step_001", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 7, + "test_panel_index": 7, + "test_case": "00001387_60cf3ad636dd42e0bcec6946_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 8, + "test_panel_index": 8, + "test_case": "00000280_5a6ef3285b89452ea6b390e7_step_001", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 9, + "test_panel_index": 9, + "test_case": "00000140_2fc54fcd110d4f49969163c4_step_003", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 10, + "test_panel_index": 10, + "test_case": "00000161_a583c6c3cdc143bab3f6c856_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 11, + "test_panel_index": 11, + "test_case": "00001041_6baf25f5fe2947e8927797d8_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 12, + "test_panel_index": 12, + "test_case": "00000411_305e45c9479f43979b0d7b53_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 13, + "test_panel_index": 13, + "test_case": "00000996_6d71695ba3fd475c927a00a7_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 14, + "test_panel_index": 14, + "test_case": "00001106_ba88e7579ced4a0aa2de629c_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 15, + "test_panel_index": 15, + "test_case": "00000060_767e4372b5f94a88a7a17d90_step_001", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 16, + "test_panel_index": 16, + "test_case": "00000723_8ed79b6bcb024d1a9f2aa5e7_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 17, + "test_panel_index": 17, + "test_case": "00000405_f3759bbb4682423caf207e8e_step_002", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 18, + "test_panel_index": 18, + "test_case": "00000206_27417003e762409185cb2b69_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 19, + "test_panel_index": 19, + "test_case": "00001417_a45f6c99e2154f3b94955175_step_001", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 20, + "test_panel_index": 20, + "test_case": "00000408_36bcb4030e36417b8dc74b87_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 21, + "test_panel_index": 21, + "test_case": "00000364_38d899e2706a4d09960705dd_step_001", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 22, + "test_panel_index": 22, + "test_case": "00001358_2e314c6e080b40fcb6a6db96_step_001", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + }, + { + "fold_index": 23, + "test_panel_index": 23, + "test_case": "00001040_74c42207fa764831b03f7658_step_000", + "training_parts": 23, + "training_min_n_ref": 1382, + "comparable": true, + "reason": "PASS", + "below_500": 0, + "below_1000": 0 + } + ], + "comparable_folds": 24, + "authority": "https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1794640949342329", + "rule": "Any training n_ref<500 OR fraction(training n_ref<1000)>0.20 is not comparable; equality endpoints do not trigger.", + "boundary_tests": "PASS: 499/500, 999/1000, exactly20percent/above20percent, missing result", + "fold_table_sha256": "867802a68294382e34adb391f21e423f959c6a71b916ef1b395e0dbc007bf256", + "supervisor_sha256": { + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000329_12a935cd9b684f879c0505fe_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "513dde7c2ef26854d3c6309521ccbcef310f4435063ca1f287217a080a8d81ba", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000418_ce5b31679ee845a69ba89d6f_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "994b85dc22afdd21e77aa6588ff06999fc78651ea32ec30c6042fdda5895f9bd", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000103_52f7124261ae4c558f800775_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "39cb0dcf3fca68f6de210e3b646595dcd5c50dc5079e0b3b755671baaf9f57fd", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00001067_8a2edcf36bcd435092f4c8ae_step_001_original.supervisor.json": "f33fbed4c54978d1ea942a7e506c4a1718b2a7654cd08d55487d77e52399def4", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000162_4dcda9fab6dd46cf98fb194e_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "af7470a62488e5d8a14f9024873b8eba8259fffe6ab029804b8d93c593736e21", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00001490_6c8ef6d2f5564d139a5077f8_step_001_original.supervisor.json": "fc9f8b4c615c03810d864439a0d866b246611e0c02c2db3a032319372a4e44bd", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00001387_60cf3ad636dd42e0bcec6946_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "d0ad8e9425d2727089197e787f4da19a6ab48dce0ca5e6381180dacfe36009f2", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000280_5a6ef3285b89452ea6b390e7_step_001_original.supervisor.json": "720ae207a6fd39f0a0f07aada6898bf8c8b2788fc1ed19fb53ad119b086313c5", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000140_2fc54fcd110d4f49969163c4_step_003_original.supervisor.json": "88d996d7773c694d3a50d5318a92f0846ece1734a7f879320c7972524aef5c9e", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000161_a583c6c3cdc143bab3f6c856_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "8efb5a266b11aebf11c09129dc2cfe9d4c01f74a3f1001c8e40ed3f61fd5db13", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00001041_6baf25f5fe2947e8927797d8_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "fb51f931c1557e3659fa3fac4980816a8a84ea442bfda691d0b397c321a7f3d8", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000411_305e45c9479f43979b0d7b53_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "c455a7622f8ee54af5a075fd49df5a6b1df40a7204d900d4d69224663172b824", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000996_6d71695ba3fd475c927a00a7_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "ff99a0f88b40ae915888d45af6c982d16a58908892af9895638d288d7c83efda", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00001106_ba88e7579ced4a0aa2de629c_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "921dcd57d22407b5f7483a4cb4dd10483da1c31bdec4336f97288d86b03921d4", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000060_767e4372b5f94a88a7a17d90_step_001_original.supervisor.json": "393e1cb47de2d4993f269bd7d51f91a8099229c0513e875fbdd2746d33e053a7", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000723_8ed79b6bcb024d1a9f2aa5e7_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "7dde8981019d055b0f32d09a26bd8ebca50290a4567fbc099c40a294f38e064c", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000405_f3759bbb4682423caf207e8e_step_002_original.supervisor.json": "d4880c67f2f3674d0de6d7eb365ca67a5507fcbd3b981ad02585d6e707d86458", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000206_27417003e762409185cb2b69_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "c4c784f233c2be75d5c387676dc2dd753ba1cde2cee91887f5113bb766b9e08f", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00001417_a45f6c99e2154f3b94955175_step_001_original.supervisor.json": "3512e821a4ca0b8d24cf13087432c8c20c335704b5a915b0f6488f58679ca9de", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000408_36bcb4030e36417b8dc74b87_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "38dfc948369df87ce1da3b27d736571b4e30d1cda444a20c0b22ee4b6d169aa4", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000364_38d899e2706a4d09960705dd_step_001_original.supervisor.json": "35f95af91d5f8587e6658fd92ea8a63ddc5edbad2e37c52abe9a06d79b4691bd", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00001358_2e314c6e080b40fcb6a6db96_step_001_original.supervisor.json": "4c1ebd565a2f3eb70e8c823684e4c2e2c9aeaaf1e5d379016705bb14c6f5e84a", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00001040_74c42207fa764831b03f7658_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "932f0a510ee5fcdfcdd424a6d3772cf949e054999ecd1484b1a113efeaa4a9d7", + "artifacts/s1-sampled-o2-2026-11-14/panel/00000993_ac4ba032d4b5431ca04f542c_step_000_original.supervisor.json": "1405fc2c25db4a4046ce6a55e9e0fadba53c5fa92e28cabffa2ce11e0cc79269" + }, + "code_sha256": "9839afe56e6035ad185fbd8efdc81b9e9f3abc1912bd080425dd3b037896cec9", + "process_release_sha256": "5e0b542cd4d7d614038c78768e2d01db9a740641b8ecbf63206c9c1ffd435683", + "S1_scoring": false, + "training": false +}