From 98519a6c365dd873dc76dfe2d393027592ba1675 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: MeltAstra Date: Wed, 18 Nov 2026 10:32:57 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] Include actual parallel budget review with S2 diagnostic results --- .../handoff.json | 7 ++- .../parallel-budget-review.json | 55 +++++++++++++++++++ docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md | 2 +- docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md | 2 +- docs/s2-tail-diagnostic-results-2026-11-18.md | 2 +- 5 files changed, 63 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) create mode 100644 artifacts/phase2-h2-s2-tail-diagnostic-2026-11-18/parallel-budget-review.json diff --git a/artifacts/phase2-h2-s2-tail-diagnostic-2026-11-18/handoff.json b/artifacts/phase2-h2-s2-tail-diagnostic-2026-11-18/handoff.json index c5b6f0420..9ea021fd9 100644 --- a/artifacts/phase2-h2-s2-tail-diagnostic-2026-11-18/handoff.json +++ b/artifacts/phase2-h2-s2-tail-diagnostic-2026-11-18/handoff.json @@ -5,7 +5,10 @@ "result_sha256": "01b5c3de72ed708b2c4eb8ed1da6efe705aa1809ebd88621dfbbf7c932b25c7c", "no_rerun": true, "item1_unchanged": true, - "review_followup_pending": true, + "review_followup_pending": false, "report": "docs/s2-tail-diagnostic-results-2026-11-18.md", - "unix": 1794969084.0863233 + "unix": 1794969084.0863233, + "parallel_review_verdict": "PASS", + "parallel_review_sha256": "fe843c4a8744fb9b8ab740ac558965fd6469b0b4f4847c59786fddbd02d963ee", + "review_after_launch": true } diff --git a/artifacts/phase2-h2-s2-tail-diagnostic-2026-11-18/parallel-budget-review.json b/artifacts/phase2-h2-s2-tail-diagnostic-2026-11-18/parallel-budget-review.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..330f842c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/phase2-h2-s2-tail-diagnostic-2026-11-18/parallel-budget-review.json @@ -0,0 +1,55 @@ +{ + "reviewer": "MeltAssist", + "kind": "same_light_review_budget_followup", + "verdict": "PASS", + "unix": 1794969062.714741, + "implementation_reported": "1ed44f70fc6923fa8a85b0978f341b21a8ee10e8", + "plan_sha256": "023baa1be5b0216ca9936d0ad12a96ea11242697699c57402cd24c358214fbd4", + "spec_sha256": "05344bacd877de87cbde9eb18139ad124e6cd4a15659e3c469b655b3f5a3f521", + "code_sha256": { + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_tail_diagnostic_math.py": "e7a4abcaa3001234c5244162c893711d54e8766e97db13476335dc1243a30bd9", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_tail_diagnostic.py": "e1b25766c6927f7b5457e7ca3643c0008032568055faf6b767cc0c4b94911ecc", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_s2_tail_diagnostic.py": "fdbaf358d4453dee127533b530e23aa9d869f08f9002128daa5daffd4e9da208", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_s2_tail_diagnostic.py": "76535cfcdb971726ef13032ef26d0690ed9d7a9930f2f216d6db7634d782b0ff", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/r4bc_guard.py": "437a756ddf10b125dce450f463e76e28df52724f8c5766e0a989dfa536805628", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_supervisor.py": "f563ca3c2665f5baf0c04f296616e4640423a59b815fbb00479af0f29e57a919", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_monitoring.py": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/docs/s2-tail-diagnostic-plan-2026-11-18.md": "e1e661bb4a8ca7a7cc6e767bd07e82a075e01db6beacfa04ea7698f1a1c0016f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_tail_diagnostic_guard.py": "d190b705764980d169c861290def90bb4bc39eed10135c57898f098e744f013e" + }, + "previous_review": { + "path": "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-s2-tail-light-review-2026-11-18/review.json", + "sha256": "2c3c60d2979aeb6b79d62e45887dff81c02c6e8cf9204d51f324471837155a3c", + "verdict": "BLOCKED", + "preserved": true + }, + "scope": "Only previous coordinator CPU blocking finding, changed code/plan identities and existing negative-test evidence; original mathematical/input/output static checks carry forward because those sections and input metadata are unchanged.", + "finding_resolution": { + "coordinator_running_limit": "Diagnostic-local supervise checks process CPU since run start each poll, stops process group at >=90 seconds, wait4 reaps child and descendants, returns FAILED; after-exit coordinator check also retained.", + "accounting": "Worker3300 + setup180 + coordinator90 =3570; 30 CPU-s reserve for sampled overshoot, cleanup and receipt. Original max(sampled worker,reaped child) cumulative accounting and <=3600 acceptance retained.", + "shared_sources": "Shared r4bc_guard and mathematical helper byte-identical to original; diagnostic entry changes only local import and coordinator limit arguments.", + "input_plan": "parts, metadata_sources, S2_score, all scientific parameters unchanged; only coordinator90/shutdown30 and source map added or refreshed." + }, + "evidence": { + "synthetic_log_sha256": "5bb929569e925ef83030b7e755f370253b57c77751fd3c9e5eaee3742122b5e0", + "negative_receipt_sha256": "100875a1205eaa63a6da81a80b118681fd2b42c2c2ff4d4cc7b304354606705f", + "acceptance_sha256": "8fb14634a76fc37526c0067106a01e741e10b29aabeeac1f0e955e7f27531b13", + "tests_existing": 17, + "negative_case": "Existing sleep-only real-child test injects prior89.98 coordinator CPU seconds; actual monitored coordinator90.022846584 triggers coordinator_cpu_limit; worker0.020077, returncode-9, monitor_errors=[]; test asserts killed/reaped child and disk receipt equality." + }, + "remaining_blockers": [], + "limits": [ + "Sampled enforcement, not a kernel-exact CPU quota; runtime must retain actual peaks, poll gaps and cumulative charge and reject an overrun.", + "Existing test log/receipt inspected and hashed; reviewer did not rerun tests or negative child.", + "No target/prediction arrays, models, diagnostic execution or scientific computation by reviewer.", + "PASS covers current source/plan and closes this light review only; no result or completion is asserted.", + "Reported Git publication not independently fetched; exact local source bytes identified by checked plan map." + ], + "execution_scope": "Claude1794968891.081169/h-90450a45 explicitly makes this a parallel non-blocking review of the single corrected diagnostic. It is not a launch barrier or a retrospective launch authorization. No duplicate old-version run, retry or item1 change.", + "timing_correction": { + "source_actually_read": "Claude1794968891.081169 and Melt1794968982.776639", + "reported_launch": "Melt reported session82016, coordinator1214068, worker1214071 and progress109/552 before this review delivery; reviewer did not independently inspect runtime progress.", + "permission_distinction": "Executor review-accepted verdict=PASS was explicitly labelled EXECUTOR_LAUNCH_PERMISSION, not this MeltAssist PASS. Preserve chronology; do not claim this review preceded launch.", + "findings_rule": "Any review finding is reported and does not trigger rerun. No remaining budget-path finding in this review." + } +} diff --git a/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md b/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md index 4faeb7a7a..d02fb6dbf 100644 --- a/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md +++ b/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md @@ -586,5 +586,5 @@ Claude1794950613.195499明确一次新代码/比较合同审阅;本条替代 ## 最新 S2 末1%体积事后诊断 COMPLETE(2026-11-18) -Claude1794968891明确立即运行修复版1ed44f70/plan023baa1b,Assist预算复核并行非阻塞。唯一82016/1214068/1214071已exit0,552/204完整,guardPASS/errors空,总账214.498990/3600 CPU-s(含180setup)。E_tail H2−A=-0.000362500,CI[-0.020169591,+0.019937188];query/full峰集合距离差+0.074383762/+0.087308543,区间均大于0;γ>2ε四组合全0/552。描述性,无gate,不改S2判定,不证明错误拓扑分支。结果01b5c3de,报告docs/s2-tail-diagnostic-results-2026-11-18.md。旧b97674a1未运行,BLOCKED2c3c60d2保持;新17合成PASS,协调90秒运行中清理已测,复核结论待并行回件。禁止重跑;item1训练/后处理未改动,下方旧快照不作其当前状态。 +Claude1794968891明确立即运行修复版1ed44f70/plan023baa1b,Assist预算复核并行非阻塞。唯一82016/1214068/1214071已exit0,552/204完整,guardPASS/errors空,总账214.498990/3600 CPU-s(含180setup)。E_tail H2−A=-0.000362500,CI[-0.020169591,+0.019937188];query/full峰集合距离差+0.074383762/+0.087308543,区间均大于0;γ>2ε四组合全0/552。描述性,无gate,不改S2判定,不证明错误拓扑分支。结果01b5c3de,报告docs/s2-tail-diagnostic-results-2026-11-18.md。旧b97674a1未运行,BLOCKED2c3c60d2保持;新17合成PASS,协调90秒运行中清理已测,并行定点复核Assist1794969101已实际PASS(启动后接收,非追溯事前PASS),无残留预算阻塞。禁止重跑;item1训练/后处理未改动,下方旧快照不作其当前状态。 diff --git a/docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md b/docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md index 14b510a68..2022c880d 100644 --- a/docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md +++ b/docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ ## 最新 S2 末1%体积事后诊断 COMPLETE(2026-11-18) -Claude1794968891明确立即运行修复版1ed44f70/plan023baa1b,Assist预算复核并行非阻塞。唯一82016/1214068/1214071已exit0,552/204完整,guardPASS/errors空,总账214.498990/3600 CPU-s(含180setup)。E_tail H2−A=-0.000362500,CI[-0.020169591,+0.019937188];query/full峰集合距离差+0.074383762/+0.087308543,区间均大于0;γ>2ε四组合全0/552。描述性,无gate,不改S2判定,不证明错误拓扑分支。结果01b5c3de,报告docs/s2-tail-diagnostic-results-2026-11-18.md。旧b97674a1未运行,BLOCKED2c3c60d2保持;新17合成PASS,协调90秒运行中清理已测,复核结论待并行回件。禁止重跑;item1训练/后处理未改动,下方旧快照不作其当前状态。 +Claude1794968891明确立即运行修复版1ed44f70/plan023baa1b,Assist预算复核并行非阻塞。唯一82016/1214068/1214071已exit0,552/204完整,guardPASS/errors空,总账214.498990/3600 CPU-s(含180setup)。E_tail H2−A=-0.000362500,CI[-0.020169591,+0.019937188];query/full峰集合距离差+0.074383762/+0.087308543,区间均大于0;γ>2ε四组合全0/552。描述性,无gate,不改S2判定,不证明错误拓扑分支。结果01b5c3de,报告docs/s2-tail-diagnostic-results-2026-11-18.md。旧b97674a1未运行,BLOCKED2c3c60d2保持;新17合成PASS,协调90秒运行中清理已测,并行定点复核Assist1794969101已实际PASS(启动后接收,非追溯事前PASS),无残留预算阻塞。禁止重跑;item1训练/后处理未改动,下方旧快照不作其当前状态。 最新item c纸面接收交付:a5f44f3a5ad07ca2a0165a49e7c562b492be5b0d远端ref与原稿/接收说明/receipt三HTTP/SHA通过,原稿05344bac逐字保持。仅未来合同输入;没有item c运行或item1改动。 diff --git a/docs/s2-tail-diagnostic-results-2026-11-18.md b/docs/s2-tail-diagnostic-results-2026-11-18.md index 02e16db59..39c32e90f 100644 --- a/docs/s2-tail-diagnostic-results-2026-11-18.md +++ b/docs/s2-tail-diagnostic-results-2026-11-18.md @@ -50,7 +50,7 @@ A/H2在query/full四种组合中,严格γ>2ε证书均0/552;stable证书、6 修复1ed44f70fc6923fa8a85b0978f341b21a8ee10e8/plan023baa1be5b0216ca9936d0ad12a96ea11242697699c57402cd24c358214fbd4:独立诊断guard每次poll限制协调CPU90秒,保留worker3300秒;180+3300+90=3570,留30秒清理余量。17合成PASS;真实sleep-only子进程负例在协调90.022846584/worker0.020077秒触发停止并kill/reap。共享guard和科学定义未改。 -Claude1794968891明确立即运行修复版,审阅并行非阻塞,任何发现入报告而不重跑;旧未修复版从未运行。执行接收文件的兼容verdict=PASS仅代表EXECUTOR_LAUNCH_PERMISSION,不是伪称Assist PASS;原BLOCKED未改。发布本文时修复定点复核结论尚未收到,后续原件需附入同一报告,不触发计算重跑。 +Claude1794968891明确立即运行修复版,审阅并行非阻塞,任何发现入报告而不重跑;旧未修复版从未运行。执行接收文件的兼容verdict=PASS仅代表EXECUTOR_LAUNCH_PERMISSION,不是伪称Assist PASS;原BLOCKED未改。已实际接收MeltAssist1794969101同次定点复核PASS,原件SHAfe843c4a8744fb9b8ab740ac558965fd6469b0b4f4847c59786fddbd02d963ee(parallel-budget-review.json),9源码与plan匹配、无残留预算阻塞。复核晚于实际启动,是依Claude1794968891的并行非阻断复核,不能回填为启动前PASS;没有重跑。审阅范围为预算修复/既有合成证据与身份,不声称独立验证真实数值结果。采样式边界及实际poll gap/费用限制保留。 唯一session82016/协调1214068/worker1214071已退出0。Guard PASS、monitor_errors=[],worker CPU31.448029秒、协调CPU3.049330秒、墙钟31.749067秒、RSS峰79994880B、最大poll gap0.633371秒。含180秒准备预留的总账214.498990/3600 CPU秒。额外发布/审阅开销未混入科学worker账;实际科学计算仅一次。