From 8137f79be6afd37f025f92192dc9a977c34ce157 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: MeltAstra Date: Wed, 18 Nov 2026 17:19:28 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] Adopt independent exact seed1 postfit PASS without execution --- .../evidence.json | 101 ++++++++++++++++++ .../review.json | 93 ++++++++++++++++ docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md | 3 + docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md | 4 + .../implementation-review-authorization.json | 4 + .../implementation-review-git-freeze.json | 19 ++++ .../review-adoption.json | 45 ++++++++ .../review.json | 93 ++++++++++++++++ 8 files changed, 362 insertions(+) create mode 100644 artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json create mode 100644 artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/review.json create mode 100644 home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/implementation-review-authorization.json create mode 100644 home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/implementation-review-git-freeze.json create mode 100644 home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/review-adoption.json create mode 100644 home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/review.json diff --git a/artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json b/artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..70bfdc910 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json @@ -0,0 +1,101 @@ +{ + "timestamp": "2026-11-18T09:16:59.963050+00:00", + "binding_sha256": "e94e24575d26dea0963a59c500c8d58090e6c7692637a78bf9896e2419719623", + "code_files_hash_verified": 55, + "source_files_hash_verified": 1143, + "implementation_files_current_and_local_git_verified": 61, + "training_code_pins_verified": 51, + "config_validation": "PASS; metadata/hash/version checks only, no terminal adoption attempted", + "seed0_reuse": { + "entries": 552, + "components": 204, + "manifest_exact": true, + "roster_and_baseline_reference_exact": true, + "fold_parts": [ + 121, + 91, + 99, + 119, + 122 + ], + "fold_components": [ + 37, + 41, + 41, + 42, + 43 + ], + "score_sha256": "c43a6ab2460affdcafd3d51522e7b5e2d60a684b2b1a79a90e06042b0e19bc45", + "score_values_parsed": false, + "prediction_arrays_decoded": false + }, + "independent_tests": { + "count": 19, + "failures": 0, + "errors": 0, + "status": "PASS", + "wall_seconds": 1.127, + "session": 87915 + }, + "read_sources": [ + "tools/phase3_seed1_postfit.py", + "tools/phase3_seed1_postfit_common.py", + "tools/phase3_seed1_postfit_worker.py", + "tools/phase3_seed1_postfit_guard.py", + "tools/phase3_seed1_postfit_statistics.py", + "tools/prepare_phase3_seed1_postfit.py", + "tools/test_phase3_seed1_postfit.py", + "shared original test loader, roster, query_index, prediction_inputs, cached loader, decoder, part_metrics, pooled and paired_difference definitions" + ], + "runtime_barriers_reviewed": [ + "Exact actual pre-score PASS before model adoption or prediction", + "All five terminal PASS, model/terminal freezes, no global stop and no seed1 training processes", + "Assignment/200epoch/steps/final checkpoint/learning-only19column normalization identities", + "All552 predictions exact role/component/full-query identities and hash freeze before target cache reads", + "One552-part seconds pass, hash reuse seed0 per-part H2 metrics, no recomputation" + ], + "statistics": { + "difference": "seed1 minus seed0", + "metrics": [ + "relative_l2", + "last_location", + "kendall_tau_b" + ], + "aggregation": "Complete per-arm component part means, component equal weights; paired component intersection", + "bootstrap": { + "replicates": 2000, + "seed": 2026111408, + "percentile": "2.5,97.5 linear" + }, + "query": "Original raw ID/order/multiplicity/Rg/near-wall; smallest raw ID tie rule; original deterministic5000-pair tau estimator", + "performance_gate": null + }, + "budget": { + "old_seed1_once": 8482.313407897018, + "phase3_prior_includes_old": 80903.62940728385, + "cumulative_seed1_gpu": 167200, + "cumulative_phase3_gpu": 612000, + "postfit_gpu": 7200, + "postfit_cpu": 3600, + "prediction_gpu_per_fold": 900, + "prediction_cpu_per_fold": 300, + "score_cpu": 900, + "score_wall": 1200, + "gpu": "GPU0 serial", + "retry": 0 + }, + "root_markers": { + "review.json": false, + "started.json": false, + "models-adopted.json": false, + "predictions-manifest.json": false, + "complete.json": false + }, + "remote_publication_independently_read": false, + "science_executed": false, + "real_gpu_queries": false, + "target_values_loaded": false, + "model_values_loaded": false, + "source_edits": false, + "git_writes": false +} diff --git a/artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/review.json b/artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/review.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..10dd20c3f --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/review.json @@ -0,0 +1,93 @@ +{ + "reviewed_commit": "0d8eb0929522a00be735e83b13515107c205968d", + "contract_sha256": "88fab6e55aa87efdce90f32c0f6d1cfdf652e6d69c9142cf66c225a41da2a9ba", + "implementation_proof_sha256": "41972211b674f9a461d6840e9b56bea66fa1ec8b51fe450102029d463778f2aa", + "comparison_contract_sha256": "8b7569e247b76648fc54cafc6d03abfad12beb80ff3d7982e32cf2257207f2bd", + "code_sha256": { + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/audit_samples.py": "a3daf70ec3bcb77bf46d9dc4887d552cf7c422117880a169969780012278cd70", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/boundary_distance.py": "a45c1cbce92521a96eb814913b4f465b926c0b3883932ab0b7c37d11db113ed7", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/freeze_g1_components.py": "d0cee60d95243ac2c59ef3f2244ba818315718c4e3d1895f2f9f064f1f7f5ecd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_features.py": "92bca4d348f31246c2e931949e2ca38103881b1b784a621a42044db56a460026", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_features_v2.py": "7dcd5ac218ffdc1ca149edcd87e8658fb3c59e18c0fb9ce47985c7f1357d2cdf", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_models.py": "53b6fee8b700b9b982b06d29908ce2ce23e0c57512c46dbf74b2aade79e3ac3a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/o1_partition.py": "5e7dbf97604b9ea9646113a9847e7232020e5f9248fad388177c32ae2a7117da", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/o1_prepare.py": "1a695477ee6605d75e7e991205e3e6a49a0907a7733491af8d2771c7bc6a5c23", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/o1_v2.py": "7bfc81d820a1be7d40b97b2c0b65a616812cb7615b99d80c4ac589788282c291", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_b1213_features.py": "d8e975b0a5362be7ff00fbf554f2b438b54af1b6b95f8993e7c2beae77f2c8f2", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_b1213_gate.py": "d5a023749e9d8bb6e04a2a2cbdbb8f0d9568924c534f36102d06707859853e10", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_b12_math.py": "5465b34be5578cc62a7afc67e3cee3cd489ebb75ce6622a3fa320d1b81196c57", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_b13_e1b.py": "e0fb6c9ecb51fdae24706e792edccb5d2259082f06aa2e292e7a23772328330d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_fixed_io.py": "ea17fdfc7508f3f980e3cdf69534b1eb8ceb8a8e469c32451b2d5e16d0ada575", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_gate_outcome_review.py": "915617aeb8292d03c654e637bc34a014c254fd178a773f135d1806c4b41372a8", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h1_worker_v2.py": "1543df85b615bb69b79bacd572074a7c77ae19dab110197601573a7e5805ed20", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_data.py": "7e03dd7a94e7bb43593277f183c222473d7cb7aaf2f60e53b45ab8d9499fcb09", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_model.py": "fab2470dd0654ca74c3b7d893f35ad1f3ae6c5c08ffe334ef6312cf6ec87892a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_common.py": "38a29a34663a5d6310571eeff53b5d18a0355e51b9fa58a08033f64fa379a9df", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_postfit.py": "767621616b2584cf43be9eaf03bb71e92a7bb5e9e120d323bd8e1c1a7e7966ba", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_prediction_guard.py": "5642c166c6627dbbf6fc529454c33c868d887acc60f08fdfa3b9fb26d44f675b", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_test_data.py": "fc0770fe7de50692dd0ce97ad3868a72fd1b65ab339ebdb9b9460adb51632473", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_common.py": "308486507ae3589a0e6cc40565f6e60e6d2f63ae74c4d828bdacf33b3b8b8062", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_postfit_common.py": "e4616411da44af7bb0a5e8f4e3645754e722f06bb4386054569017c3c4496f81", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_home_freeze_io.py": "bf09204b85ed2a7038acdd202257f618474d1110a9d6d772f105a3ffb334d3ff", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_local_freeze_io.py": "60adf3382577613c5234f5cf30779336b9951b66e90c075cb7cd0adab9cc42dd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_residual_math.py": "ffbd9624dec79bdaabf95244fe87209055908f31a977e73ea4377045d6f8fe62", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_postfit.py": "bb163352c9228e4feac917b892d6869fb5207bcfa0d6c268f4a770f5b0da0142", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_postfit_common.py": "f9ab22f4eede24531d4338fe167e7c210311f24f52c38eafbc6d2c712c29e645", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_postfit_guard.py": "557a16064ee55f09db7010f46dfaf1e4ee64214d0d90a431460fbccc3f8a215d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_postfit_statistics.py": "cf61ecfbf997357e8ab700e6f352ca9e60361c1a0075e764a87e00818100c02a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_postfit_worker.py": "9e475e8e341c450a15c7aab0ab733455364e873098b0910024b49c840246ea75", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_v2_common.py": "25ca6be14027369393bd3616209b08f30e25892cccca83300483c5a116e8d75d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_seed1_postfit.py": "84599d1f8a72ae12075b3a48f2318c0c0a1ef0b6d94ce194a4009847c7d53273", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/r4bc_common.py": "27543fff987975ece767167f9771e6621c825035a053805604e4a696794dfcbd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/r4bc_guard.py": "437a756ddf10b125dce450f463e76e28df52724f8c5766e0a989dfa536805628", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_common.py": "588c646101be0d50f505f9a12a1c98361aa3437c8c594eecb7321831f717a741", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_statistics.py": "188565801f6901d0192f79aec0889e632501e672a4149d76d1835efbb9b45447", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_gpu_idle_gate.py": "e2b1613e7e6ea398a8d555220a9365a1ad998ab4ef4b2bf8ec7cc4e31f8b4b9f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_main_memory_guard.py": "e094f5443e11518efe9018215c11718a8e18aa462a977bf43e974b2d0b2aebb1", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/__init__.py": "a0fa1323d3553172da66c5d442c5fc4fcb0d5055c886c776928604550ea97609", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/attention.py": "7714adfccf6a0fc6b52a44aee3a50321a88898bf3d743680a1108c01e1ff8a61", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/blocks.py": "b13e986cea5f1d7f325a1638c1505197b4a105baacff5a9a515f23fcaf28ea75", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/features.py": "3b34ae61cf8012ebd58b7505a73d7aa43d8ee1890ac54f98d7917b67887a45a4", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/network.py": "5137e845d81d1223afc13bf87e03ccba1132a3baa75d5189a8f320b2752be071", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/normalization.py": "7180696d3845799e28d8c31ddef957d075de6a2e46d96a3a0f0df16fc05234a0", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/objectives.py": "5b6527a45f08690055d572335470ce5979e8bb86e1cab00de594f79ae21316b1", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_pilot_train.py": "e9cceead51a5cc092aad23409ad98909c84a62e7e10571e750d1e9be1ad3b948", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_precision_continuation_guard.py": "01235d897c7c03e5ffa109c58b14f5d24d128e8f1ba873e1f76cfb14e02f7a7f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_gpu_supervisor.py": "689c0f3179e4fcd362e546d90214829a9e4f8739abdbdf74b560763e5a392f15", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_monitoring.py": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_supervisor.py": "f563ca3c2665f5baf0c04f296616e4640423a59b815fbb00479af0f29e57a919", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_seed1_postfit.py": "1211a8d0fe31ff28894288af140bd5aaa405f289c2fe0f6f62cf6a3dc2fc9f65", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_common.py": "79918e7de887d1f0a2de5523156b27d00dc2d85ac930a07efc34d817d904fe65", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_prepare.py": "f657be036dc48fc5936f56c4b8510a4b295d4787af6877cc5ccaad663107be17" + }, + "verdict": "PASS", + "reviewer": "MeltAssist", + "timestamp": "2026-11-18T09:16:59.963050+00:00", + "review_scope": "Independent seed1 postfit pre-score review requested in1794993246 under directly read Claude1794992262.078969; training PASS is not reused", + "evidence_path": "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json", + "evidence_sha256": "51c2514c1cbfeaa9531f4864bc0f3d77b87d7487f21c3377bb86ca71589b9429", + "blocking_findings": [], + "conclusions": [ + "Five v2 training terminal and model freeze/exit gate precedes prediction; actual assignment, final200 checkpoint seed1/fold/steps and learning-only19column standardization verified at runtime; no partial cohort adoption", + "Exact new review and all552 prediction/source freeze rechecked before score/target values; old seed0 predictions and original per-part H2 score reference fixed by hash, no seed0 metric recomputation", + "New predictions are full-node seconds, original eligible query IDs and multiplicities checked separately from full raw IDs; original decoder/ties/undefined/negative rules retained", + "552 unique target-cache reads once; seed1 minus seed0 field/last-fill/tau per fold and pooled; complete components equally weighted with original2000 paired bootstrap seed2026111408, no performance gate", + "Old8482.313407897018 counted once for seed1 cumulative; phase3 prior80903.62940728385 already contains it. New training+postfit charged once within167200/612000. GPU7200/CPU3600, serialGPU0 five900s jobs, bounded20s idle+three polls, resource/failure accounting and no retry preserved", + "Worker monitor_errors requires exact integer0; guard reasons/error state and final recorded peaks inspected including failed workers", + "Independent19CPU synthetic checks PASS;55code/1143source/61local fixed implementation files and51training pins verified; original552/204 roster and seed0 manifest exact" + ], + "execution_conditions": [ + "Executor must adopt/freeze this actual exact PASS and validate full binding; no prediction before all five real training terminals, models frozen and training processes exited", + "Actual model/normalization hashes and training cost are future runtime checks, not completed by this pre-score review", + "Preserve both old STOPs and old accounting limitations, all undefined pairs and negative predictions; no retry or automatic expansion", + "No seed2, ensemble,1b,c,b or other stage is authorized by this receipt" + ], + "limitations": [ + "No real model/prediction/target arrays were loaded and no scientific/GPU workload was run during review; source files including old scores were hashed as opaque bytes only", + "Bootstrap intervals describe component variation conditional on these fixed models, not population uncertainty over random training seeds", + "Original tau is the frozen deterministic pair-sampling estimator; no newly substituted exact-tau method", + "Resource guards are sampled; overrun remains failure and charged", + "Remote publication has not been independently read; implementation identity checked against local immutable Git", + "Reviewer made only review artifacts, no scientific source or Git modifications" + ] +} diff --git a/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md b/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md index 1a4bf0849..8456a0c1b 100644 --- a/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md +++ b/docs/collaboration-stage-review-policy.md @@ -678,3 +678,6 @@ Seed1 v2同次独立审阅发现观测覆盖P2(Assist1794991467,BLOCKEDfe873 ## Seed1后处理事前准备(2026-11-18) Claude1794992262要求的独立后处理绑定已固定0d8eb092/88fab6e5,19CPU合成PASS,完整55code map和comparison8b7569e2提交于1794993246并请TRON原生转Assist。原552/204 test配对、seed1−seed0 field/last/tau逐fold/pooled描述性无性能门;seed0预测/逐件指标复用。仍需本入口实际新PASS及五训练终态/模型冻结/进程退出,全部552预测freeze之后才能单次score。无新阶段/seed2/ensemble计算;原科学及累计预算不扩张。当前仅prepared、未review采用/预测/评分,报告phase3-seed1-postfit-entry;不重复主审或sharing授权,不以本地固定当成执行结果。 + + +Seed1 postfit实际独立审阅采用:Assist1794993449的7b4da089/51c2514c原件已核SHA、五字段全等并逐字固定,review freeze 3086504ab049517ed0872a0499845b0a1dd7f092;validate_review/config实际PASS。implementation仍0d8eb092,e49851ba仅共享提交。仅完成审阅门;真实五训练终态/模型哈希/冻结/退出及累计耗时仍待运行时核验,未预测评分/读test目标或新建waiter。原两训练队列与pins保持,不重复主审/检查或自动扩科学范围。 diff --git a/docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md b/docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md index af0c2d6ec..d1424767a 100644 --- a/docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md +++ b/docs/phase2-live-handoff-2026-11-17.md @@ -1,3 +1,7 @@ +## 最新 seed1 postfit实际独立PASS已采用,运行门仍待满足(2026-11-18) + +Assist1794993449新审阅review7b4da089/evidence51c2514c已直接读原件、SHA核验并逐字复制;完整binding e94e2457与0d8eb092/88fab6e5/41972211/8b7569e2/55code map全等。implementation-review freeze `3086504ab049517ed0872a0499845b0a1dd7f092`,原validate_review及config实际PASS;receipt在root/review-adoption.json。没有重跑19项合成检查,没有改源、预算或训练。核时训练complete仍未出现;本次不采用模型、不创建waiter/新队列、不预测/评分或读test目标。五训练真实PASS、模型/terminal冻结、退出及无globalstop等运行门仍须执行时实核。原prepared/report中的“待审”现由此实际采用更新,不把代码审阅PASS称作训练/科学结果PASS。 + ## 最新 seed1 postfit独立绑定已提交事前审阅,未启动(2026-11-18) Claude1794992262唯一准备任务已完成:root `/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18`,implementation0d8eb092/contract88fab6e5/proof41972211/comparison8b7569e2/55codes/1143sources,完整binding e94e2457;19CPU合成PASS。Slack1794993246已提交并请TRON按恢复的原生路由转Assist;尚不声称Assist实收/实际PASS。报告docs/phase3-seed1-postfit-entry-2026-11-18.md;无review、started、waiter、模型加载、科学数组解码、test目标读、预测或评分。五v2训练PASS/终态模型冻结/进程退出及本入口新精确审阅满足后,方可按合同执行;训练PASS不得替代评分审阅。 diff --git a/home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/implementation-review-authorization.json b/home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/implementation-review-authorization.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1792ff7c7 --- /dev/null +++ b/home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/implementation-review-authorization.json @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +{ + "contract_sha256": "88fab6e55aa87efdce90f32c0f6d1cfdf652e6d69c9142cf66c225a41da2a9ba", + "proof_sha256": "8bb58e777dae73b8edacfed00bb8982b09a7c22274a3c4d3fc1e6cf05963c0bc" +} diff --git a/home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/implementation-review-git-freeze.json b/home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/implementation-review-git-freeze.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..99f5593b6 --- /dev/null +++ b/home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/implementation-review-git-freeze.json @@ -0,0 +1,19 @@ +{ + "commit": "3086504ab049517ed0872a0499845b0a1dd7f092", + "files": { + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/review.json": "7b4da089f63feba9d10c046d469e333baf0b2f64a173938f35429f15e2b48e6d", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/expected-review-binding.json": "e94e24575d26dea0963a59c500c8d58090e6c7692637a78bf9896e2419719623", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/contract.json": "88fab6e55aa87efdce90f32c0f6d1cfdf652e6d69c9142cf66c225a41da2a9ba", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/review.json": "7b4da089f63feba9d10c046d469e333baf0b2f64a173938f35429f15e2b48e6d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json": "51c2514c1cbfeaa9531f4864bc0f3d77b87d7487f21c3377bb86ca71589b9429" + }, + "git_paths": { + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/review.json": "home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/review.json", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/expected-review-binding.json": "home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/expected-review-binding.json", + "/home/frank14f/MeltMind-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/contract.json": "home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/contract.json", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/review.json": "artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/review.json", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json": "artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json" + }, + "remote_published": false, + "local_repository": "/tmp/meltmind-phase2-local-fixed-20261117" +} diff --git a/home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/review-adoption.json b/home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/review-adoption.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6e215a1b6 --- /dev/null +++ b/home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/review-adoption.json @@ -0,0 +1,45 @@ +{ + "status": "EXACT_PRE_SCORE_PASS_ADOPTED", + "unix": 1794993542.0412538, + "implementation": "0d8eb0929522a00be735e83b13515107c205968d", + "contract_sha256": "88fab6e55aa87efdce90f32c0f6d1cfdf652e6d69c9142cf66c225a41da2a9ba", + "review_sha256": "7b4da089f63feba9d10c046d469e333baf0b2f64a173938f35429f15e2b48e6d", + "evidence_sha256": "51c2514c1cbfeaa9531f4864bc0f3d77b87d7487f21c3377bb86ca71589b9429", + "binding_sha256": "e94e24575d26dea0963a59c500c8d58090e6c7692637a78bf9896e2419719623", + "review_freeze_commit": "3086504ab049517ed0872a0499845b0a1dd7f092", + "validate_review": "PASS", + "config": "PASS", + "review_bytes_unchanged": true, + "code_pins_unchanged": true, + "training_live_snapshot": { + "stage": "SEED1_TRAINING", + "unix": 1794993541.7775595, + "active": [ + { + "id": 0, + "guard_pid": 1476627 + }, + { + "id": 1, + "guard_pid": 1476628 + } + ], + "terminal": [], + "pending": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "charged_training_gpu_seconds": 2923.2518568909727, + "postfit_gpu_reserve": 7200 + }, + "training_complete_exists": false, + "training_global_stop_exists": false, + "all_training_runtime_gates_claimed_pass": false, + "postfit_started": false, + "models_adopted": false, + "test_targets_read": false, + "prediction_started": false, + "scoring_started": false, + "no_new_queue": true +} diff --git a/home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/review.json b/home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/review.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..10dd20c3f --- /dev/null +++ b/home-runs/phase3-seed1-postfit-2026-11-18/review.json @@ -0,0 +1,93 @@ +{ + "reviewed_commit": "0d8eb0929522a00be735e83b13515107c205968d", + "contract_sha256": "88fab6e55aa87efdce90f32c0f6d1cfdf652e6d69c9142cf66c225a41da2a9ba", + "implementation_proof_sha256": "41972211b674f9a461d6840e9b56bea66fa1ec8b51fe450102029d463778f2aa", + "comparison_contract_sha256": "8b7569e247b76648fc54cafc6d03abfad12beb80ff3d7982e32cf2257207f2bd", + "code_sha256": { + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/audit_samples.py": "a3daf70ec3bcb77bf46d9dc4887d552cf7c422117880a169969780012278cd70", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/boundary_distance.py": "a45c1cbce92521a96eb814913b4f465b926c0b3883932ab0b7c37d11db113ed7", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/freeze_g1_components.py": "d0cee60d95243ac2c59ef3f2244ba818315718c4e3d1895f2f9f064f1f7f5ecd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_features.py": "92bca4d348f31246c2e931949e2ca38103881b1b784a621a42044db56a460026", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_features_v2.py": "7dcd5ac218ffdc1ca149edcd87e8658fb3c59e18c0fb9ce47985c7f1357d2cdf", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/gre24_models.py": "53b6fee8b700b9b982b06d29908ce2ce23e0c57512c46dbf74b2aade79e3ac3a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/o1_partition.py": "5e7dbf97604b9ea9646113a9847e7232020e5f9248fad388177c32ae2a7117da", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/o1_prepare.py": "1a695477ee6605d75e7e991205e3e6a49a0907a7733491af8d2771c7bc6a5c23", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/o1_v2.py": "7bfc81d820a1be7d40b97b2c0b65a616812cb7615b99d80c4ac589788282c291", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_b1213_features.py": "d8e975b0a5362be7ff00fbf554f2b438b54af1b6b95f8993e7c2beae77f2c8f2", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_b1213_gate.py": "d5a023749e9d8bb6e04a2a2cbdbb8f0d9568924c534f36102d06707859853e10", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_b12_math.py": "5465b34be5578cc62a7afc67e3cee3cd489ebb75ce6622a3fa320d1b81196c57", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_b13_e1b.py": "e0fb6c9ecb51fdae24706e792edccb5d2259082f06aa2e292e7a23772328330d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_fixed_io.py": "ea17fdfc7508f3f980e3cdf69534b1eb8ceb8a8e469c32451b2d5e16d0ada575", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_gate_outcome_review.py": "915617aeb8292d03c654e637bc34a014c254fd178a773f135d1806c4b41372a8", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h1_worker_v2.py": "1543df85b615bb69b79bacd572074a7c77ae19dab110197601573a7e5805ed20", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_data.py": "7e03dd7a94e7bb43593277f183c222473d7cb7aaf2f60e53b45ab8d9499fcb09", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_model.py": "fab2470dd0654ca74c3b7d893f35ad1f3ae6c5c08ffe334ef6312cf6ec87892a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_common.py": "38a29a34663a5d6310571eeff53b5d18a0355e51b9fa58a08033f64fa379a9df", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_postfit.py": "767621616b2584cf43be9eaf03bb71e92a7bb5e9e120d323bd8e1c1a7e7966ba", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_prediction_guard.py": "5642c166c6627dbbf6fc529454c33c868d887acc60f08fdfa3b9fb26d44f675b", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s1_test_data.py": "fc0770fe7de50692dd0ce97ad3868a72fd1b65ab339ebdb9b9460adb51632473", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_common.py": "308486507ae3589a0e6cc40565f6e60e6d2f63ae74c4d828bdacf33b3b8b8062", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_h2_s2_postfit_common.py": "e4616411da44af7bb0a5e8f4e3645754e722f06bb4386054569017c3c4496f81", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_home_freeze_io.py": "bf09204b85ed2a7038acdd202257f618474d1110a9d6d772f105a3ffb334d3ff", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_local_freeze_io.py": "60adf3382577613c5234f5cf30779336b9951b66e90c075cb7cd0adab9cc42dd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase2_residual_math.py": "ffbd9624dec79bdaabf95244fe87209055908f31a977e73ea4377045d6f8fe62", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_postfit.py": "bb163352c9228e4feac917b892d6869fb5207bcfa0d6c268f4a770f5b0da0142", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_postfit_common.py": "f9ab22f4eede24531d4338fe167e7c210311f24f52c38eafbc6d2c712c29e645", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_postfit_guard.py": "557a16064ee55f09db7010f46dfaf1e4ee64214d0d90a431460fbccc3f8a215d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_postfit_statistics.py": "cf61ecfbf997357e8ab700e6f352ca9e60361c1a0075e764a87e00818100c02a", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_postfit_worker.py": "9e475e8e341c450a15c7aab0ab733455364e873098b0910024b49c840246ea75", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/phase3_seed1_v2_common.py": "25ca6be14027369393bd3616209b08f30e25892cccca83300483c5a116e8d75d", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/prepare_phase3_seed1_postfit.py": "84599d1f8a72ae12075b3a48f2318c0c0a1ef0b6d94ce194a4009847c7d53273", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/r4bc_common.py": "27543fff987975ece767167f9771e6621c825035a053805604e4a696794dfcbd", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/r4bc_guard.py": "437a756ddf10b125dce450f463e76e28df52724f8c5766e0a989dfa536805628", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_common.py": "588c646101be0d50f505f9a12a1c98361aa3437c8c594eecb7321831f717a741", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_custody_statistics.py": "188565801f6901d0192f79aec0889e632501e672a4149d76d1835efbb9b45447", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_gpu_idle_gate.py": "e2b1613e7e6ea398a8d555220a9365a1ad998ab4ef4b2bf8ec7cc4e31f8b4b9f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_main_memory_guard.py": "e094f5443e11518efe9018215c11718a8e18aa462a977bf43e974b2d0b2aebb1", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/__init__.py": "a0fa1323d3553172da66c5d442c5fc4fcb0d5055c886c776928604550ea97609", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/attention.py": "7714adfccf6a0fc6b52a44aee3a50321a88898bf3d743680a1108c01e1ff8a61", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/blocks.py": "b13e986cea5f1d7f325a1638c1505197b4a105baacff5a9a515f23fcaf28ea75", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/features.py": "3b34ae61cf8012ebd58b7505a73d7aa43d8ee1890ac54f98d7917b67887a45a4", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/network.py": "5137e845d81d1223afc13bf87e03ccba1132a3baa75d5189a8f320b2752be071", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/normalization.py": "7180696d3845799e28d8c31ddef957d075de6a2e46d96a3a0f0df16fc05234a0", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_models/objectives.py": "5b6527a45f08690055d572335470ce5979e8bb86e1cab00de594f79ae21316b1", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_pilot_train.py": "e9cceead51a5cc092aad23409ad98909c84a62e7e10571e750d1e9be1ad3b948", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_precision_continuation_guard.py": "01235d897c7c03e5ffa109c58b14f5d24d128e8f1ba873e1f76cfb14e02f7a7f", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_gpu_supervisor.py": "689c0f3179e4fcd362e546d90214829a9e4f8739abdbdf74b560763e5a392f15", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_monitoring.py": "442c2a9c75e8c00b30a8f2e91cb52d87c466b19a80aea9128b10c021e61b922e", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/s2_recovery_supervisor.py": "f563ca3c2665f5baf0c04f296616e4640423a59b815fbb00479af0f29e57a919", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/test_phase3_seed1_postfit.py": "1211a8d0fe31ff28894288af140bd5aaa405f289c2fe0f6f62cf6a3dc2fc9f65", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_common.py": "79918e7de887d1f0a2de5523156b27d00dc2d85ac930a07efc34d817d904fe65", + "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/tools/track_a_h2_prepare.py": "f657be036dc48fc5936f56c4b8510a4b295d4787af6877cc5ccaad663107be17" + }, + "verdict": "PASS", + "reviewer": "MeltAssist", + "timestamp": "2026-11-18T09:16:59.963050+00:00", + "review_scope": "Independent seed1 postfit pre-score review requested in1794993246 under directly read Claude1794992262.078969; training PASS is not reused", + "evidence_path": "/home/frank14f/optane/MeltMind/artifacts/meltassist-seed1-postfit-review-2026-11-18/evidence.json", + "evidence_sha256": "51c2514c1cbfeaa9531f4864bc0f3d77b87d7487f21c3377bb86ca71589b9429", + "blocking_findings": [], + "conclusions": [ + "Five v2 training terminal and model freeze/exit gate precedes prediction; actual assignment, final200 checkpoint seed1/fold/steps and learning-only19column standardization verified at runtime; no partial cohort adoption", + "Exact new review and all552 prediction/source freeze rechecked before score/target values; old seed0 predictions and original per-part H2 score reference fixed by hash, no seed0 metric recomputation", + "New predictions are full-node seconds, original eligible query IDs and multiplicities checked separately from full raw IDs; original decoder/ties/undefined/negative rules retained", + "552 unique target-cache reads once; seed1 minus seed0 field/last-fill/tau per fold and pooled; complete components equally weighted with original2000 paired bootstrap seed2026111408, no performance gate", + "Old8482.313407897018 counted once for seed1 cumulative; phase3 prior80903.62940728385 already contains it. New training+postfit charged once within167200/612000. GPU7200/CPU3600, serialGPU0 five900s jobs, bounded20s idle+three polls, resource/failure accounting and no retry preserved", + "Worker monitor_errors requires exact integer0; guard reasons/error state and final recorded peaks inspected including failed workers", + "Independent19CPU synthetic checks PASS;55code/1143source/61local fixed implementation files and51training pins verified; original552/204 roster and seed0 manifest exact" + ], + "execution_conditions": [ + "Executor must adopt/freeze this actual exact PASS and validate full binding; no prediction before all five real training terminals, models frozen and training processes exited", + "Actual model/normalization hashes and training cost are future runtime checks, not completed by this pre-score review", + "Preserve both old STOPs and old accounting limitations, all undefined pairs and negative predictions; no retry or automatic expansion", + "No seed2, ensemble,1b,c,b or other stage is authorized by this receipt" + ], + "limitations": [ + "No real model/prediction/target arrays were loaded and no scientific/GPU workload was run during review; source files including old scores were hashed as opaque bytes only", + "Bootstrap intervals describe component variation conditional on these fixed models, not population uncertainty over random training seeds", + "Original tau is the frozen deterministic pair-sampling estimator; no newly substituted exact-tau method", + "Resource guards are sampled; overrun remains failure and charged", + "Remote publication has not been independently read; implementation identity checked against local immutable Git", + "Reviewer made only review artifacts, no scientific source or Git modifications" + ] +}