diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/README.md b/review/2026-11-14/e6/README.md index 59eb11520..ff679e981 100644 --- a/review/2026-11-14/e6/README.md +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/README.md @@ -93,3 +93,11 @@ gap12近阈值34.90%,gap23为7.10%,同时近阈值1.95%,并集40.05%。主 | both | 0.326–0.656 | 0.355–0.681 | 0.038–0.872 | 补查仅使用保存的张量和缓存锚点坐标,没有新核或距离运行。连续不变量/软谱权重仍是团队提出的新表示候选,本轮未实现,也不据此放行后续步骤。 + +## 审阅补充(不重算核,不重复打包) + +Grok 要求的抽样集中度与完整离散质量贡献见同目录 `sampling_full_mass.csv/json`;850/778/666 的 unique-N 为1275/1856/1991,最大重复次数8/3/2。补表代码 `build_e6_sampling_supplement.py` 只读取 ZIP 解压后的保存结果。全部模式贡献加边界 unscored,以及近阈值/非近阈值贡献加边界 unscored,分别核对和为1。此补表与说明是 ZIP 外的小型审阅附件,ZIP及其内部清单保持原样。 + +按 [Claude 11:32:44 的决定](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1794627164278709),778的gap–局部分辨率代理相关性**未提供**:保存的是单元重心代理的汇总,而谱场位于抽样节点;未定义逐点配对,且单元与核球的支持尺度不同、几何随位置变化。未构造新映射或重算代理。 + +后续1:8细化仅是待审提议,未执行。新中点没有缓存精确距离值;若只插值旧P1距离,父单元内梯度不变,不能声称只改变了梯度离散。若重新查询同一表面距离,则需另立范围及成本。近阈值带质量也不随谱隙减小而保证单调下降,不能以单次变化作因果判决。 diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/SHA256SUMS b/review/2026-11-14/e6/SHA256SUMS index 4f2bf8e6c..72e4c79e7 100644 --- a/review/2026-11-14/e6/SHA256SUMS +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/SHA256SUMS @@ -1,12 +1,15 @@ 446f8564db5f2c76dde60f4225489836bc68284414cd7555f8373788f662cf99 778_gap_diagnostics.json c82172b87ef869d6d445ba734056f0cb26678f01fd32961b847fd1e817528365 MeltMind-E6-20261114.zip 1e71088fc53ba46a3c9e40bf89aab0c540991ab7897d3ee3e5952301fb3a2123 PACKAGE_MANIFEST.json -08528f88a241f7f31ffa4c55e4bc347d950d23e2eef86d6b9295853dbc75a58f README.md +7a2a9f45f06df6bda7b0e4215e8675de1a0a06d564f705434f294fad02040b02 README.md +df2b885e7b2549ea5c78b34a582f45ce097aa2e96d0239c14b3525bf27f2aa06 build_e6_sampling_supplement.py bda819e278f1dd2d5fb472fd51ca1070e13caac3c0a718f509d7fde397c8a20b execution_contract.json 439e1f4b442c5e399fd3e6b754c16b9b0bc4b2262240ac1263fd42150169f55d independent_diagnostics.json 8435e61bacfd3ca64aed346c6d27ca68b582a81752d8377fe7edc076d66f55a8 paired_850.json b28bdc6ef333f6b3814e9732d3beb1464a2cef9263d36d48d106610ba1c54255 preflight.json 2d8bf113e1b73e876a8ee586e03c31661e075c7bdb52dd2374bbdd024d3b80fb run.json +9f1efd409bdf3391dca38c68d9faf58f932d6e2b5a9e35890bfa4e5425654f1f sampling_full_mass.csv +970d581056aed17812b1998f1a0861d173531a8144758de9e432d66afc1ca690 sampling_full_mass.json 24224daf4b45056a1ad7bb4b135eee7584a7e6a300a8cba52a484a614089c0b9 summary.csv 6ebac16b966daede60fe9b72575616eb8509ada573bb1cf8c8e1ed3ef6abca1b verification.json 96c8cd54aa6392580ec9dd76ee7aa0d909035097368bf99bde0fc65861bb9cbd work_receipt.json diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/build_e6_sampling_supplement.py b/review/2026-11-14/e6/build_e6_sampling_supplement.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ceb1af127 --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/build_e6_sampling_supplement.py @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +"""Exact sampling concentration and full discrete mass from saved E6 outputs.""" +import csv +import json +from pathlib import Path +import numpy as np + + +def main(): + out=Path('artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14');r=json.loads((out/'run.json').read_text());rows=[] + for a in r['cases']: + f=np.load(out/(a['name']+'_fields.npz'));counts=np.bincount(f['draw_to_unique']);s=a['statistics'];p=a['plan']['positive_distance_mass_fraction'];b=a['plan']['boundary_unscored_mass_fraction'] + row=dict(case=a['case'][:8],rule=a['rule'],draws=len(f['draw_to_unique']),unique_N=len(counts),max_multiplicity=int(counts.max()),positive_distance_share=p,boundary_unscored=b) + for k,v in s['modes'].items():row['full_mass_mode_'+k]=p*v['estimate'] + for k,v in s['near_cut'].items():row['full_mass_near_'+k]=p*v['estimate'] + row['full_mass_not_near_either']=p-row['full_mass_near_either'] + row['full_mass_neff_failed']=p*s['neff_failed']['estimate'] + np.testing.assert_allclose(sum(row['full_mass_mode_'+str(k)] for k in [-1,0,1,2,3])+b,1) + np.testing.assert_allclose(row['full_mass_near_either']+row['full_mass_not_near_either']+b,1) + rows.append(row) + with (out/'sampling_full_mass.csv').open('w') as f: + w=csv.DictWriter(f,fieldnames=list(rows[0]),lineterminator='\n');w.writeheader();w.writerows(rows) + (out/'sampling_full_mass.json').write_text(json.dumps(dict(measure='Full discrete lumped mass contributions; conditional p multiplied by positive-distance mass, boundary unscored',rows=rows),indent=2)+'\n') + print(json.dumps(rows,indent=2)) + + +if __name__=='__main__':main() diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/sampling_full_mass.csv b/review/2026-11-14/e6/sampling_full_mass.csv new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fd8e7cd59 --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/sampling_full_mass.csv @@ -0,0 +1,5 @@ +case,rule,draws,unique_N,max_multiplicity,positive_distance_share,boundary_unscored,full_mass_mode_-1,full_mass_mode_0,full_mass_mode_1,full_mass_mode_2,full_mass_mode_3,full_mass_near_gap12,full_mass_near_gap23,full_mass_near_either,full_mass_not_near_either,full_mass_neff_failed +00000850,tetra_four_point,2000,1275,8,0.8390441572527976,0.16095584274720232,0.0,0.0,0.010068529887033571,0.0,0.828975627365764,0.0,0.01048805196565997,0.01048805196565997,0.8285561052871376,0.0 +00000850,lumped_vertex,2000,1275,8,0.8390441572527976,0.16095584274720232,0.0,0.0,0.013424706516044762,0.0,0.8256194507367528,0.0,0.012166140280165565,0.012166140280165565,0.826878016972632,0.02978606758247431 +00000778,tetra_four_point,2000,1856,3,0.7840775070957364,0.21592249290426355,0.0,0.01999397643094128,0.04077203036897829,0.3159832353595818,0.40732826493623503,0.273643049976412,0.055669503003797284,0.31402304159184247,0.47005446550389396,0.0 +00000666,tetra_four_point,2000,1991,2,0.9015189998731159,0.0984810001268843,0.0,0.0,0.8690643158776837,0.0,0.03245468399543217,0.0,0.04192063349409989,0.04192063349409989,0.859598366379016,0.000450759499936558 diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/sampling_full_mass.json b/review/2026-11-14/e6/sampling_full_mass.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..487d59f1f --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/sampling_full_mass.json @@ -0,0 +1,81 @@ +{ + "measure": "Full discrete lumped mass contributions; conditional p multiplied by positive-distance mass, boundary unscored", + "rows": [ + { + "case": "00000850", + "rule": "tetra_four_point", + "draws": 2000, + "unique_N": 1275, + "max_multiplicity": 8, + "positive_distance_share": 0.8390441572527976, + "boundary_unscored": 0.16095584274720232, + "full_mass_mode_-1": 0.0, + "full_mass_mode_0": 0.0, + "full_mass_mode_1": 0.010068529887033571, + "full_mass_mode_2": 0.0, + "full_mass_mode_3": 0.828975627365764, + "full_mass_near_gap12": 0.0, + "full_mass_near_gap23": 0.01048805196565997, + "full_mass_near_either": 0.01048805196565997, + "full_mass_not_near_either": 0.8285561052871376, + "full_mass_neff_failed": 0.0 + }, + { + "case": "00000850", + "rule": "lumped_vertex", + "draws": 2000, + "unique_N": 1275, + "max_multiplicity": 8, + "positive_distance_share": 0.8390441572527976, + "boundary_unscored": 0.16095584274720232, + "full_mass_mode_-1": 0.0, + "full_mass_mode_0": 0.0, + "full_mass_mode_1": 0.013424706516044762, + "full_mass_mode_2": 0.0, + "full_mass_mode_3": 0.8256194507367528, + "full_mass_near_gap12": 0.0, + "full_mass_near_gap23": 0.012166140280165565, + "full_mass_near_either": 0.012166140280165565, + "full_mass_not_near_either": 0.826878016972632, + "full_mass_neff_failed": 0.02978606758247431 + }, + { + "case": "00000778", + "rule": "tetra_four_point", + "draws": 2000, + "unique_N": 1856, + "max_multiplicity": 3, + "positive_distance_share": 0.7840775070957364, + "boundary_unscored": 0.21592249290426355, + "full_mass_mode_-1": 0.0, + "full_mass_mode_0": 0.01999397643094128, + "full_mass_mode_1": 0.04077203036897829, + "full_mass_mode_2": 0.3159832353595818, + "full_mass_mode_3": 0.40732826493623503, + "full_mass_near_gap12": 0.273643049976412, + "full_mass_near_gap23": 0.055669503003797284, + "full_mass_near_either": 0.31402304159184247, + "full_mass_not_near_either": 0.47005446550389396, + "full_mass_neff_failed": 0.0 + }, + { + "case": "00000666", + "rule": "tetra_four_point", + "draws": 2000, + "unique_N": 1991, + "max_multiplicity": 2, + "positive_distance_share": 0.9015189998731159, + "boundary_unscored": 0.0984810001268843, + "full_mass_mode_-1": 0.0, + "full_mass_mode_0": 0.0, + "full_mass_mode_1": 0.8690643158776837, + "full_mass_mode_2": 0.0, + "full_mass_mode_3": 0.03245468399543217, + "full_mass_near_gap12": 0.0, + "full_mass_near_gap23": 0.04192063349409989, + "full_mass_near_either": 0.04192063349409989, + "full_mass_not_near_either": 0.859598366379016, + "full_mass_neff_failed": 0.000450759499936558 + } + ] +}