From 54d4217500c87e85c045ff8618bfbeb57ea33f6c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Thu, 19 Nov 2026 06:10:27 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] research-tree: H2 family/seed diagnostic, wording corrected Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- docs/claude/research-tree.md | 1 + 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+) diff --git a/docs/claude/research-tree.md b/docs/claude/research-tree.md index bede615d9..a1b851927 100644 --- a/docs/claude/research-tree.md +++ b/docs/claude/research-tree.md @@ -34,6 +34,7 @@ Rules: | P3 | O1 with size-matched K = 8 partitions | — | — | PRUNED (eligibility 23 %; lesson: control cut area as a covariate, do not match it) | Log (newest first): +- 2026-11-19: **H2 family/seed diagnostic** (descriptive, pre-registered 97f29e53; result 2f8d8787; MeltAssist PASS 77639066; 0 GPU-h). 552 / 204. Family-weighted field L2: A 7.083 %, H2 seed 0 6.579 %, seed 1 6.594 %; both seeds improve in all five folds and no leave-one-family-out flips the sign, so the field gain holds at family level. Tail misses (> .10 Rg from the true tail): both seeds 34 parts / 28 families, seed 0 only 37, seed 1 only 28, neither 453; the reference count expected if the two seeds' misses were independent is 71 × 62 / 552 ≈ 8. **Reading (corrected wording, MeltAssist):** the shared misses are repeated descriptive evidence that gives a candidate list for a mechanism study. They do not establish a mechanism, rule out seed effects, or carry formal significance. (My Slack reply had called it 'systematic, not seed noise'; that was too strong.) Next: pre-registered descriptive attribute study of the 34 parts (MoldAstra attributes, MeltSol), 0 GPU-h. - 2026-11-19: **Planning ruled** (four independent answers at 2c0dd614; ruling in planning-discussion-2026-11-19.md). Short: 1b + a zero-GPU family/seed/fold paired table from frozen scores. Medium chain: GINO reproduction on ShapeNet-611 → H2-P vs GINO on the same protocol → GINO as a Greif fill-time baseline. Long: new families with full process inputs, whole-family holdout and paired gate/process interventions; blocked on data rights (question to Yanqi). - 2026-11-19: **Stage review ruled** (answers at 52c74d25; ruling in stage-review-2026-11-19.md): Track B (GINO ShapeNet protocol) is the main line, starting with the data-mapping check and a GINO reproduction gate (7.12 %); 1b reruns in parallel inside its existing authorisation with a co-located cap and narrow review; no new last-fill loss; Track A closed at the four-split descriptive result; five process rules adopted (contract → real guard CPU simulation, concurrency-measured caps with waiting booked separately, four-state routing, scoped restrictions in handoffs, delta-only reviews of unchanged components). - 2026-11-19: **Item b (H2 + frozen B13 context inputs) DOES_NOT_PASS its fixed screen; PRUNED (this recipe).** Recovery postfit (PASS 029a77a2) COMPLETE, 552 / 204, evidence 192ce24a. b − H2 seed 0: field −.00006, CI [−.0018, +.0017] (needed upper bound < −.001 and |effect| > seed spread .00015: neither met); last fill −.044 Rg, CI [−.130, +.035]; τ-b +.0002, CI crosses 0. Descriptive strata (no gate): 510 parts with valid B13 context −.0008, CI [−.0026, +.0009]; 42 historically missing +.0089, CI [+.0026, +.0156] (worse where the context is absent and zero-filled). **Reading:** B13's tabular context adds nothing measurable to H2; the representation appears to already carry the regional information that helped A. Phase-3 scored set is now complete: H2 confirmed on field; seed noise small for field, large for last fill; c and b pruned; 1b parked; Track A shows H2 < A on our random splits without a paper-level reproduction. **Stage review opened** (docs/claude/stage-review-2026-11-19.md).