diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/778_gap_diagnostics.json b/review/2026-11-14/e6/778_gap_diagnostics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8b5ab74f2 --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/778_gap_diagnostics.json @@ -0,0 +1,626 @@ +{ + "case": "00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003", + "source": "Saved four-point tensor + cached query coordinates, no estimator or distance rerun", + "measure": "Same positive-distance lumped-mass PPS draws; duplicate multiplicity retained", + "gap_definition": "(lambda_i-lambda_(i+1))/lambda_1, descending eigenvalues", + "hard_cut": 0.1, + "near_band_inclusive": [ + 0.05, + 0.15 + ], + "quantile_levels": [ + 0, + 0.05, + 0.5, + 0.95, + 1 + ], + "histogram_edges": [ + 0.0, + 0.05, + 0.1, + 0.15000000000000002, + 0.2, + 0.25, + 0.30000000000000004, + 0.35000000000000003, + 0.4, + 0.45, + 0.5, + 0.55, + 0.6000000000000001, + 0.65, + 0.7000000000000001, + 0.75, + 0.8, + 0.8500000000000001, + 0.9, + 0.9500000000000001, + 1.0, + "infinity" + ], + "histograms": { + "gap12": { + "counts": [ + 462, + 395, + 303, + 128, + 149, + 100, + 238, + 197, + 28, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0 + ], + "conditional_mass_fractions": [ + 0.231, + 0.1975, + 0.1515, + 0.064, + 0.0745, + 0.05, + 0.119, + 0.0985, + 0.014, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "quantiles": [ + 0.002135363629088601, + 0.014007474325661113, + 0.11734647481785483, + 0.37403868323677375, + 0.43612848320931463 + ] + }, + "gap23": { + "counts": [ + 73, + 82, + 60, + 130, + 203, + 153, + 324, + 368, + 425, + 158, + 24, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0 + ], + "conditional_mass_fractions": [ + 0.0365, + 0.041, + 0.03, + 0.065, + 0.1015, + 0.0765, + 0.162, + 0.184, + 0.2125, + 0.079, + 0.012, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "quantiles": [ + 0.0002603551661539985, + 0.07445779239922778, + 0.346320823965579, + 0.4647032730761226, + 0.5498434291152284 + ] + } + }, + "coordinate_summary": { + "all": { + "draw_count": 2000, + "unique_anchor_count": 1856, + "conditional_mass_fraction": 1.0, + "raw_coordinate_mean": [ + -0.016548368810009526, + 0.003822540061502748, + 16.15565277604038 + ], + "raw_coordinate_quantiles": [ + [ + -3.260355437, + -3.190914787, + 0.18002454680000002 + ], + [ + -1.7576180934999999, + -1.6799022155999999, + 1.7141293470500003 + ], + [ + -0.009602375319, + 0.01066109404, + 17.132700569999997 + ], + [ + 1.6776284237999992, + 1.7637025548499996, + 26.722705459 + ], + [ + 3.2470828199999997, + 3.226376648, + 27.5200703 + ] + ], + "normalized_bbox_quantiles": [ + [ + 0.024591956662624627, + 0.03466823449713166, + 0.006639317926531742 + ], + [ + 0.24374936361873523, + 0.2547701537758864, + 0.061873705439135465 + ], + [ + 0.49867787376197925, + 0.5010263637882553, + 0.6170087507634945 + ], + [ + 0.7447415844102974, + 0.7563834649816708, + 0.9622902766413026 + ], + [ + 0.9736289260970054, + 0.9694441510905509, + 0.9909988489693096 + ] + ] + }, + "gap12_near": { + "draw_count": 698, + "unique_anchor_count": 656, + "conditional_mass_fraction": 0.349, + "raw_coordinate_mean": [ + 0.010204604232020496, + 0.0064318940676386955, + 12.829951589675812 + ], + "raw_coordinate_quantiles": [ + [ + -1.483453448, + -1.308166601, + 0.8725263872 + ], + [ + -1.0170948988, + -1.0042398984, + 1.7915547356500001 + ], + [ + 0.0127207763, + 0.032616807615, + 12.78503256 + ], + [ + 1.0401395099999997, + 1.0090607049999998, + 23.33417681 + ], + [ + 1.658780184, + 1.4834487379999999, + 24.42588368 + ] + ], + "normalized_bbox_quantiles": [ + [ + 0.2837332058029441, + 0.30891908925556877, + 0.03157237008803439 + ], + [ + 0.3517463757667913, + 0.35319062731454276, + 0.06466135326902911 + ], + [ + 0.501933455347856, + 0.5042245467739299, + 0.46047395626877874 + ], + [ + 0.6517709678777514, + 0.646458423546602, + 0.8402886347287519 + ], + [ + 0.7419927797851098, + 0.7155602421035652, + 0.8795947892352272 + ] + ] + }, + "gap23_near": { + "draw_count": 142, + "unique_anchor_count": 130, + "conditional_mass_fraction": 0.071, + "raw_coordinate_mean": [ + -0.02757903491152891, + -0.09726574979807044, + 13.15767793890775 + ], + "raw_coordinate_quantiles": [ + [ + -2.288089715, + -2.274076153, + 0.2086568023 + ], + [ + -1.3081723780499999, + -1.308166601, + 0.5243971873 + ], + [ + 0.055912445059999996, + -0.22519603789999998, + 23.414682055 + ], + [ + 1.202222168, + 1.24548442085, + 25.578082913499998 + ], + [ + 1.5254691390000001, + 1.477524879, + 27.17766903 + ] + ], + "normalized_bbox_quantiles": [ + [ + 0.16638602029423136, + 0.16821969980713877, + 0.007670202580167632 + ], + [ + 0.3092959862481714, + 0.30891908925556877, + 0.019038217839377227 + ], + [ + 0.5082324763767089, + 0.46667019204080384, + 0.8431871706686711 + ], + [ + 0.6754089077968468, + 0.6808971268416949, + 0.9210789296567243 + ], + [ + 0.7225508573046564, + 0.7146973421117877, + 0.9786709268945558 + ] + ] + }, + "both": { + "draw_count": 39, + "unique_anchor_count": 35, + "conditional_mass_fraction": 0.0195, + "raw_coordinate_mean": [ + -0.02370167120692306, + 0.12251801822641024, + 10.051378493297436 + ], + "raw_coordinate_quantiles": [ + [ + -1.3149168, + -1.308166601, + 0.9140415599 + ], + [ + -1.1935172049, + -0.98839575626, + 1.04777935067 + ], + [ + 0.15158046979999998, + 0.09466935458, + 1.567893512 + ], + [ + 1.069289069, + 1.2453240719, + 24.216303431 + ], + [ + 1.435886835, + 1.477524879, + 24.304418979999998 + ] + ], + "normalized_bbox_quantiles": [ + [ + 0.30831238786195087, + 0.30891908925556877, + 0.0330670953090172 + ], + [ + 0.3260171588139198, + 0.35549856714267297, + 0.037882232423030474 + ], + [ + 0.5221845860526414, + 0.5132634422415415, + 0.056608584842377914 + ], + [ + 0.6560221045065086, + 0.6808737695829153, + 0.8720489966098683 + ], + [ + 0.7094862818226445, + 0.7146973421117877, + 0.8752215363076508 + ] + ] + }, + "either": { + "draw_count": 801, + "unique_anchor_count": 751, + "conditional_mass_fraction": 0.4005, + "raw_coordinate_mean": [ + 0.005157248406470912, + -0.01760359191378803, + 13.023336723695392 + ], + "raw_coordinate_quantiles": [ + [ + -2.288089715, + -2.274076153, + 0.2086568023 + ], + [ + -1.0323510009999999, + -1.020465412, + 1.3094243859999999 + ], + [ + 0.011490434970000001, + -0.01987137458, + 13.11596374 + ], + [ + 1.074787806, + 1.0217393830000001, + 24.32227642 + ], + [ + 1.658780184, + 1.4834487379999999, + 27.17766903 + ] + ], + "normalized_bbox_quantiles": [ + [ + 0.16638602029423136, + 0.16821969980713877, + 0.007670202580167632 + ], + [ + 0.34952144416921604, + 0.3508271349437714, + 0.047302581847535906 + ], + [ + 0.5017540238479203, + 0.4965788462289844, + 0.47238890564716834 + ], + [ + 0.656824033697705, + 0.6483052654687256, + 0.8758644811447849 + ], + [ + 0.7419927797851098, + 0.7155602421035652, + 0.9786709268945558 + ] + ] + }, + "only_gap12": { + "draw_count": 659, + "unique_anchor_count": 621, + "conditional_mass_fraction": 0.3295, + "raw_coordinate_mean": [ + 0.012211197163915489, + -0.0004381496989654055, + 12.994389147731582 + ], + "raw_coordinate_quantiles": [ + [ + -1.483453448, + -1.100291859, + 0.8725263872 + ], + [ + -1.0088441234, + -1.0041709586, + 2.5894085112 + ], + [ + 0.003283911527, + 0.016715822109999997, + 13.10143543 + ], + [ + 1.0348762482, + 0.99201621857, + 22.849015318000003 + ], + [ + 1.658780184, + 1.4834487379999999, + 24.42588368 + ] + ], + "normalized_bbox_quantiles": [ + [ + 0.2837332058029441, + 0.3391992011155143, + 0.03157237008803439 + ], + [ + 0.3529496589285911, + 0.35320066944296835, + 0.09338752934900818 + ], + [ + 0.5005571943383111, + 0.5019083268467645, + 0.4718658238444698 + ], + [ + 0.651003380106536, + 0.6439756353505464, + 0.822820729113077 + ], + [ + 0.7419927797851098, + 0.7155602421035652, + 0.8795947892352272 + ] + ] + }, + "only_gap23": { + "draw_count": 103, + "unique_anchor_count": 95, + "conditional_mass_fraction": 0.0515, + "raw_coordinate_mean": [ + -0.02904716291618549, + -0.18048484642869897, + 14.333849573653396 + ], + "raw_coordinate_quantiles": [ + [ + -2.288089715, + -2.274076153, + 0.2086568023 + ], + [ + -1.3039728402, + -1.3670695744, + 0.36874982239000004 + ], + [ + 4.688028928e-07, + -0.3251712725, + 23.553306369999998 + ], + [ + 1.2613268689999995, + 1.232182214999999, + 25.627899892 + ], + [ + 1.5254691390000001, + 1.397301758, + 27.17766903 + ] + ], + "normalized_bbox_quantiles": [ + [ + 0.16638602029423136, + 0.16821969980713877, + 0.007670202580167632 + ], + [ + 0.30990844179777294, + 0.30033897699048456, + 0.013434241587328748 + ], + [ + 0.5000783410001568, + 0.4521072814255628, + 0.848178243724522 + ], + [ + 0.684028666310272, + 0.6789594586226188, + 0.9228725556819657 + ], + [ + 0.7225508573046564, + 0.7030116266936349, + 0.9786709268945558 + ] + ] + } + }, + "coordinate_axis_order": [ + "x", + "y", + "z" + ], + "mesh_bbox_min": [ + -3.428979679, + -3.428914248, + -0.0043788649179999995 + ], + "mesh_bbox_span": [ + 6.856885945, + 6.865058589, + 27.774451194917997 + ], + "interpretation": "Near-cut mass is dominated by gap12. Mode 2 to 3 changes the gap12 split. This supports a leading-eigenvalue near-degeneracy hypothesis but does not establish its geometric or discretization cause.", + "limitations": [ + "Bounding-box aspect ratio does not establish actual cross-section shape.", + "Raw coordinates are diagnostic summaries, not a rotation-invariant regional classifier.", + "Local chord proxy is not a whole-wall element count.", + "No new representation, soft weight, O2-B or O1 definition is approved by this postprocessing." + ] +} diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/MeltMind-E6-20261114.zip b/review/2026-11-14/e6/MeltMind-E6-20261114.zip new file mode 100644 index 000000000..062acb906 Binary files /dev/null and b/review/2026-11-14/e6/MeltMind-E6-20261114.zip differ diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/PACKAGE_MANIFEST.json b/review/2026-11-14/e6/PACKAGE_MANIFEST.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..acb262e88 --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/PACKAGE_MANIFEST.json @@ -0,0 +1,262 @@ +[ + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-independent-2026-11-14/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000.json", + "bytes": 5290, + "sha256": "519ecf3d980352c8966d4bb2cdee9e3ffa113198e888bf038b75216bf0e3f74e" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-independent-2026-11-14/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003.json", + "bytes": 5323, + "sha256": "4acbe9b7650807606ddeaca2643c6b1a6a6535f013014ebe2b47c4aeb3ad64a1" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-independent-2026-11-14/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010.json", + "bytes": 6941, + "sha256": "1c8fe64137fd6d6f8f3406759d3c6e8815d370dc6fdf0a57dd62dba2c61ffe3d" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-independent-2026-11-14/E6.started.json", + "bytes": 87, + "sha256": "c9c9e52a3fe3ea6839d007c45fb9e7ae51baac44acb7e19fc04fc8a5c280284b" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-independent-2026-11-14/E6_result.json", + "bytes": 20001, + "sha256": "439e1f4b442c5e399fd3e6b754c16b9b0bc4b2262240ac1263fd42150169f55d" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-independent-2026-11-14/execution_contract.json", + "bytes": 4962, + "sha256": "76fe9300763f75296c923920148c80c4863146d97985d0d2922ae18ed4a30604" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000_tetra_four_point_anchors.npz", + "bytes": 12205, + "sha256": "df504339743653969b76eb80e8b28d747604fde3e60af69c93d33ece1abc1b89" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000_tetra_four_point_fields.npz", + "bytes": 358663, + "sha256": "1bbb12eec464eada0c844d78c2e5e45a34a716701b3b2c0da14620a1df6f2e08" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000_tetra_four_point_preflight.json", + "bytes": 810, + "sha256": "96f4a191d851656fa9ec3e2047eadccddf72e603cd6190541405f424931ce793" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000_tetra_four_point_run.json", + "bytes": 6603, + "sha256": "cc3b4a4aa717324ef497ba5d79a9ee536a2d1003c52d3f949dd3ccb5b33e27ea" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003_tetra_four_point_anchors.npz", + "bytes": 13532, + "sha256": "cc37d33bef0382697f51ed1114af7612509490a5147322a5ab3cb4ad952d6861" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003_tetra_four_point_fields.npz", + "bytes": 331142, + "sha256": "93bd276509fd208fe997adba00312422996c3561db3925de2dc6b77fc9e4fa40" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003_tetra_four_point_preflight.json", + "bytes": 843, + "sha256": "5260fe17a491cf921366521090247cf1e55254712da3a81ecbbe65225059b8b7" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003_tetra_four_point_run.json", + "bytes": 6618, + "sha256": "3d6a7e1a6c9406d871a67dca65e4e5b6f079555d83014949907db62a419c3cb4" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010_lumped_vertex_anchors.npz", + "bytes": 9148, + "sha256": "a2ec707cd54b05adb919470a6113c11e69da9336d4aaa1bef24357983022e83d" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010_lumped_vertex_fields.npz", + "bytes": 231130, + "sha256": "aef49848b072300901c42d77fbed1045146bb03b7a9ebf3dbd1413ec7ea61a7a" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010_lumped_vertex_preflight.json", + "bytes": 799, + "sha256": "4d3f9aab19d4bb833e9b6e185c410af5e25b1b349db56a329473a07e0ebd53bd" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010_lumped_vertex_run.json", + "bytes": 6594, + "sha256": "f4d546a19475e0ee0081bfc649adb4b1d0a0ac362c2c36a44b2ee9e453cae9a0" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010_tetra_four_point_anchors.npz", + "bytes": 10031, + "sha256": "f95527c9c03e7dbcf71fe2f1b540c40c9f2ba8d834b7252c7c34ad492016046d" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010_tetra_four_point_fields.npz", + "bytes": 229190, + "sha256": "4167acc88b3084d93c656e1d6aed15ef930d08dbbac72c5b26c745d1daa3494a" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010_tetra_four_point_preflight.json", + "bytes": 816, + "sha256": "d1cfc5dcb139024790a7fb7e1edb7b1bd6a4a6edf741ceb7abef026a0b961631" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010_tetra_four_point_run.json", + "bytes": 6602, + "sha256": "62604d794f500fe54b981e9cf3bd8516ad7890d3e8358c3a1f2ffbd97de8872f" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/778_gap_diagnostics.json", + "bytes": 13009, + "sha256": "446f8564db5f2c76dde60f4225489836bc68284414cd7555f8373788f662cf99" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/README.md", + "bytes": 8197, + "sha256": "08528f88a241f7f31ffa4c55e4bc347d950d23e2eef86d6b9295853dbc75a58f" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/execution_contract.json", + "bytes": 6420, + "sha256": "bda819e278f1dd2d5fb472fd51ca1070e13caac3c0a718f509d7fde397c8a20b" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/paired_850.json", + "bytes": 367, + "sha256": "8435e61bacfd3ca64aed346c6d27ca68b582a81752d8377fe7edc076d66f55a8" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/preflight.json", + "bytes": 4083, + "sha256": "b28bdc6ef333f6b3814e9732d3beb1464a2cef9263d36d48d106610ba1c54255" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/preflight.started.json", + "bytes": 87, + "sha256": "ba48b2f81e5ed654248422f3e3dc116da85bd12e54b339673d92308366425a6c" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/run.json", + "bytes": 31082, + "sha256": "2d8bf113e1b73e876a8ee586e03c31661e075c7bdb52dd2374bbdd024d3b80fb" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/run.started.json", + "bytes": 87, + "sha256": "ba48b2f81e5ed654248422f3e3dc116da85bd12e54b339673d92308366425a6c" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/summary.csv", + "bytes": 1475, + "sha256": "24224daf4b45056a1ad7bb4b135eee7584a7e6a300a8cba52a484a614089c0b9" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/verification.json", + "bytes": 2731, + "sha256": "6ebac16b966daede60fe9b72575616eb8509ada573bb1cf8c8e1ed3ef6abca1b" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14/work_receipt.json", + "bytes": 687, + "sha256": "96c8cd54aa6392580ec9dd76ee7aa0d909035097368bf99bde0fc65861bb9cbd" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000.routes.json", + "bytes": 19735, + "sha256": "56067a6a460da06ca83b093a4ecddba3d54aa5b82b2176e3334d213ff9ee5ef9" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003.routes.json", + "bytes": 19777, + "sha256": "e289600562c9d1a89630b3073e07ca05d9756ee70f02947de018fe291304aed1" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010.routes.json", + "bytes": 19717, + "sha256": "a7926001a22f3d189e0ee722852728ce172a5072d63936dd9aad3553462feb18" + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/pose_input_checks.json", + "bytes": 2333, + "sha256": "7063064c65f2c1f738ed85548cc8d10f2611db2c6e172669e75deb662520fdad" + }, + { + "path": "docs/e6-source-rules-2026-11-14.txt", + "bytes": 15117, + "sha256": "3004b0cf8771309572b6bcc3a1a0a50de9ed3b764d0d85a09c87c886f118739f" + }, + { + "path": "tests/test_e6_independent_diagnostics.py", + "bytes": 2140, + "sha256": "8101e5ae1331ce850d4dd19b8c1bafdca693a6950e8505daad568691ed64bc10" + }, + { + "path": "tests/test_e6_real_kernel.py", + "bytes": 2467, + "sha256": "da7ec1bbeb0f306d02851623e11e059d4b20035b55b3e41c5868a42c47cabd04" + }, + { + "path": "tools/analyze_e6_778_gaps.py", + "bytes": 3426, + "sha256": "72e0b95ba7e7f365a83684e6cf9650316e3c452770828909cc299a5ec190b085" + }, + { + "path": "tools/analyze_support_capacity_conditions.py", + "bytes": 8937, + "sha256": "6bfc3ab91c48ff1c28a4b6d56092c7c8bd1f73e7f263c54bf857858cf84fd2c9" + }, + { + "path": "tools/boundary_distance.py", + "bytes": 4574, + "sha256": "a45c1cbce92521a96eb814913b4f465b926c0b3883932ab0b7c37d11db113ed7" + }, + { + "path": "tools/build_e6_review.py", + "bytes": 13626, + "sha256": "dae9ef46cfaea56468b4f30e66560c3953064dfb48a2f301db3c0acdac622248" + }, + { + "path": "tools/physical_support_probe.py", + "bytes": 8770, + "sha256": "4513745d0f2c00e5b5b545ef87382efb2cf8057b1166068b3c85b7c1854a91f7" + }, + { + "path": "tools/projector_remesh_probe.py", + "bytes": 12776, + "sha256": "90411c11dde855d3a17d651c859a0a5c8d3241c47375a0487eea1c9631abc55a" + }, + { + "path": "tools/route_feasibility.py", + "bytes": 13056, + "sha256": "00e6b67d9079fc9c5d371064d5bfeb1a9950ce8b677bbe2c89c9976f45fb23d2" + }, + { + "path": "tools/run_e6_independent_diagnostics.py", + "bytes": 9618, + "sha256": "ad6113d9e612ea8ac9029779e32d05519c65b107df10c524addb64e368dc2b8d" + }, + { + "path": "tools/run_e6_real_kernel.py", + "bytes": 11931, + "sha256": "45a3ade5d1cbc52828b83dcb4a1b884e83063c7eea3f68851e464f4d1e2ce68a" + }, + { + "path": "tools/run_volume_quadrature_trial.py", + "bytes": 11387, + "sha256": "eff0c71b4cb795b1b9992a1111b2f28c23b5f8f5e34b483f79512644008ac725" + }, + { + "path": "tools/validate_distance_extensions.py", + "bytes": 4446, + "sha256": "dd4589df410fdb79a5e6a286804d1fd10f88517db73c8a2cd4e3050cfd2586ec" + }, + { + "path": "tools/verify_e6_results.py", + "bytes": 4068, + "sha256": "fe562d2c0601041ed2da8b2aa79fee61016547a8c9c86215d785e45dfe80556e" + } +] diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/README.md b/review/2026-11-14/e6/README.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..59eb11520 --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,95 @@ +# E6:三件实件的有界几何估计器诊断 + +三件主估计及含浇口的独立旋转重算已完成。新核并非普遍减少近阈值质量:778 从同锚点旧场的 25.90% 升至 40.05%。本轮不能据此冻结物理类型语义、改 O1 的 merge/admission 或启动后续 LP。 + +## 冻结规则与分母 + +依据 [Claude 的抽样确认](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1794626539544669) 与包内原串记录:每件 R=2.5×t_proxy,t_proxy=4×全节点 lumped 体积权重 median(d)。这是尺度代理,不是实测壁厚;理想均匀薄板关系不保证有限网格或复杂实件准确。850 的 R≈12.7,与包围盒宽度接近,会覆盖整个截面。全部长度保持数据原始单位,毫米解释未在本轮另行认证。 + +每件按 d>0 节点的 lumped 质量概率、有放回抽取 2000 次;固定种子,重复点只计算一次,但保留抽样次数。估计时不再乘一次节点质量。以下比例是正距离节点所代表的离散质量条件分布;95% Wilson 区间只反映抽样误差,不包含几何/离散/求积误差。边界节点质量单列未评分,绝不视为零体积或重新归一化掩盖。 + +从缓存标量距离的 P1 四面体梯度建立归一化外积,经有支持单元体积汇集到节点;不做 graph hop 平滑。主估计用四面体四点求积插值该未平滑节点场,核为 max(1-r²/R²,0)²;850 另保留节点 lumped 求积。hard relative gap=0.1,近阈值带闭区间 [0.05,0.15]。模式 -1/0/1/2/3 分别为无支持、整空间组、1+2、2+1、1+1+1 谱分组,不等于 wall/rib/junction 标签。 + +N_eff≥64 只作数值筛选。位置协方差特征值比和核质量/完整球积分 32πR³/105 只报告;没有腔体真值核积分,因此没有支持质量通过或连续求积准确性结论。 + +## 同锚点、同测度的结果 + +| 实件 / 求积 | R | 边界未评分 | 旧场近阈值 | 新场近阈值(95% 抽样区间) | N_eff筛选通过 | +|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| +| 00000850 / tetra_four_point | 12.700000 | 16.096% | 8.050% | 1.250% (0.848%–1.839%) | 100.000% | +| 00000850 / lumped_vertex | 12.700000 | 16.096% | 8.050% | 1.450% (1.011%–2.075%) | 96.450% | +| 00000778 / tetra_four_point | 2.652812 | 21.592% | 25.900% | 40.050% (37.924%–42.215%) | 100.000% | +| 00000666 / tetra_four_point | 1.111089 | 9.848% | 24.850% | 4.650% (3.811%–5.663%) | 99.950% | + +| 实件 / 求积 | mode 0 | mode 1 | mode 2 | mode 3 | +|---|---:|---:|---:|---:| +| 00000850 / tetra_four_point | 0.000% | 1.200% | 0.000% | 98.800% | +| 00000850 / lumped_vertex | 0.000% | 1.600% | 0.000% | 98.400% | +| 00000778 / tetra_four_point | 2.550% | 5.200% | 40.300% | 51.950% | +| 00000666 / tetra_four_point | 0.000% | 96.400% | 0.000% | 3.600% | + +本批没有 trace 无支持锚点。上述模式比例没有把 N_eff 未通过点删除;run.json 另列筛选后的模式贡献和失败比例,分母仍为全部内部抽样质量。每一模式乘以正距离质量占比可得到全离散质量贡献,连同边界 unscored 总和为 1。 + +850 四点与 lumped 的配对模式翻转为 0.400%;兼容方向分组的投影差 p50/p95/max 为 [0.0016687272264450303, 0.005874521641750416, 0.09719084531383479]。N_eff 随求积点数变化,不能把不同规则的数值筛选通过率等同于物理分辨率改善。 + +## 刚体检查、局部分辨率与成本 + +所有四组均以同一个固定正旋转和平移,独立重算网格梯度、节点场、积分源点和核估计;锚点与浇口同步变换,标量边界距离按刚体不变性复用。全部抽样模式与 N_eff 筛选翻转为 0。张量协变最大绝对误差约 1.46e-14,分组投影最大误差约 1.76e-13,投影浇口向量最大误差约 2.76e-12 原始长度单位。这验证几何估计器的该次变换,不是网络预测测试,也不是连续极限或重网格验证。 + +| 实件 | 局部分辨率代理 p5 / p50 / p95 | 零梯度未定义质量 | +|---|---:|---:| +| 00000850 | 0.947 / 4.822 / 16.901 | 0.089% | +| 00000778 | 0.522 / 4.695 / 15.824 | 0.000% | +| 00000666 | 1.000 / 9.335 / 18.547 | 0.000% | + +局部分辨率代理为 2*d_P1(单元重心)/h_tet,其中 h_tet 是沿该单元距离梯度穿过重心的单元弦长;它不是穿壁单元计数。P1 距离不等于真实重心距离,2d 在交汇区不等于壁厚;零梯度保持未定义。分位数按有效梯度单元体积加权,缺失质量另列。 + +预检 4.60 秒、峰值 374.6 MiB;4 个新估计 + 4 个独立旋转估计合计 85.60 秒、峰值 702.2 MiB;R 无关基线/代理诊断 11.76 秒、峰值 227.1 MiB。均为本机本次进程 wall/RSS,不含更早的下载、距离缓存建立或 Git 打包。 + +预检同时限制 p99邻居数×2000≤5e8 和两次去重锚点邻居总数≤5e8(原场+旋转),四组均通过。中件的两次邻居访问规划量约2.636亿,为主要耗时;最大件约109万。未执行可选半径、穿壁射线、任何新距离查询、O2-A重跑、O2-B/S、O1区域准备、LP或训练。 + +## 审阅与复现 + +10 项针对性测试通过;verification.json 核对原始输入哈希、PSD、模式/近阈值/N_eff计数、离散质量守恒、重复抽样身份、旋转模式和球核归一化。此核对检验保存结果一致性,不是独立物理正确性证明。旧3-hop场的全四面体四点体积诊断在 independent 子任务结果中单列,不能与本表条件节点质量直接相减;本表旧新比较已使用同锚点同测度。 + +ZIP 包含代码、测试、执行协议、预检计数、锚点编号/抽样映射、两套新场、结果和旧元数据;不复制完整原始实件网格、原始距离及旧张量缓存。来源路径与 SHA256 在合同中,完整数值重跑需接回这些已有缓存。派生结果复核及测试可在解压目录直接运行: + +```sh +python -m unittest discover -s tests -p "test_e6*.py" -v +python tools/verify_e6_results.py artifacts/e6-kernel-2026-11-14 +``` + +完整重跑应在新的输出目录复制 execution_contract.json,然后分别运行 run_e6_independent_diagnostics.py、run_e6_real_kernel.py preflight/run;已有 started 标记防止意外重复覆盖。需要 NumPy/SciPy。本次 Python 3.10,OMP/OPENBLAS 线程数为2。 + +需要团队裁量的是 778 的谱隙靠近分组阈值是否要求另行诊断,以及类型语义和后续 O1 映射如何独立定义。本报告不预先认定下一实验或新类型阈值。 + +## 778:现有输出的谱隙与位置拆分 + +gap12近阈值34.90%,gap23为7.10%,同时近阈值1.95%,并集40.05%。主导的是gap12;mode 2→3正是新增领先两特征值之间的分裂。它支持领先两特征值接近这一现象描述,但不能仅凭包围盒近方就认定实际截面、解析方杆机制或排除估计器/离散误差。 + +| 谱隙区间(左闭右开) | gap12条件质量 | gap23条件质量 | +|---|---:|---:| +| [0.00, 0.05) | 23.100% | 3.650% | +| [0.05, 0.10) | 19.750% | 4.100% | +| [0.10, 0.15) | 15.150% | 3.000% | +| [0.15, 0.20) | 6.400% | 6.500% | +| [0.20, 0.25) | 7.450% | 10.150% | +| [0.25, 0.30) | 5.000% | 7.650% | +| [0.30, 0.35) | 11.900% | 16.200% | +| [0.35, 0.40) | 9.850% | 18.400% | +| [0.40, 0.45) | 1.400% | 21.250% | +| [0.45, 0.50) | 0.000% | 7.900% | +| [0.50, 0.55) | 0.000% | 1.200% | + +本批大于等于0.55的谱隙质量为0;完整21格计数保存在778_gap_diagnostics.json。以上直方图区间与闭近阈值带的端点定义分别保留。 + +下表为包围盒归一化原坐标的p5–p95,统计保留抽样重复次数;它不是旋转不变区域分类,也没有将坐标位置命名为端部、壁或交汇区。 + +| 抽样子集 | x | y | z | +|---|---:|---:|---:| +| all | 0.244–0.745 | 0.255–0.756 | 0.062–0.962 | +| gap12_near | 0.352–0.652 | 0.353–0.646 | 0.065–0.840 | +| gap23_near | 0.309–0.675 | 0.309–0.681 | 0.019–0.921 | +| both | 0.326–0.656 | 0.355–0.681 | 0.038–0.872 | + +补查仅使用保存的张量和缓存锚点坐标,没有新核或距离运行。连续不变量/软谱权重仍是团队提出的新表示候选,本轮未实现,也不据此放行后续步骤。 diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/SHA256SUMS b/review/2026-11-14/e6/SHA256SUMS new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4f2bf8e6c --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/SHA256SUMS @@ -0,0 +1,12 @@ +446f8564db5f2c76dde60f4225489836bc68284414cd7555f8373788f662cf99 778_gap_diagnostics.json +c82172b87ef869d6d445ba734056f0cb26678f01fd32961b847fd1e817528365 MeltMind-E6-20261114.zip +1e71088fc53ba46a3c9e40bf89aab0c540991ab7897d3ee3e5952301fb3a2123 PACKAGE_MANIFEST.json +08528f88a241f7f31ffa4c55e4bc347d950d23e2eef86d6b9295853dbc75a58f README.md +bda819e278f1dd2d5fb472fd51ca1070e13caac3c0a718f509d7fde397c8a20b execution_contract.json +439e1f4b442c5e399fd3e6b754c16b9b0bc4b2262240ac1263fd42150169f55d independent_diagnostics.json +8435e61bacfd3ca64aed346c6d27ca68b582a81752d8377fe7edc076d66f55a8 paired_850.json +b28bdc6ef333f6b3814e9732d3beb1464a2cef9263d36d48d106610ba1c54255 preflight.json +2d8bf113e1b73e876a8ee586e03c31661e075c7bdb52dd2374bbdd024d3b80fb run.json +24224daf4b45056a1ad7bb4b135eee7584a7e6a300a8cba52a484a614089c0b9 summary.csv +6ebac16b966daede60fe9b72575616eb8509ada573bb1cf8c8e1ed3ef6abca1b verification.json +96c8cd54aa6392580ec9dd76ee7aa0d909035097368bf99bde0fc65861bb9cbd work_receipt.json diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/execution_contract.json b/review/2026-11-14/e6/execution_contract.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9464c51ff --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/execution_contract.json @@ -0,0 +1,94 @@ +{ + "frozen_utc": "2026-11-14T03:24:39.685994+00:00", + "cases": [ + { + "case": "00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010", + "sample": "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/samples/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010.npz", + "tensor_cache": "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010.route_arrays.npz", + "prior_result": "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010.routes.json", + "distance": "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/geometry_validation/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010.boundary_distance_raw.npy", + "lumped_diagnostic": true, + "seed": 20261114, + "rules": [ + "tetra_four_point", + "lumped_vertex" + ] + }, + { + "case": "00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003", + "sample": "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/samples/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003.npz", + "tensor_cache": "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003.route_arrays.npz", + "prior_result": "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003.routes.json", + "distance": "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/geometry_validation/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003.boundary_distance_raw.npy", + "lumped_diagnostic": false, + "seed": 20261115, + "rules": [ + "tetra_four_point" + ] + }, + { + "case": "00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000", + "sample": "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/samples/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000.npz", + "tensor_cache": "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000.route_arrays.npz", + "prior_result": "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000.routes.json", + "distance": "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000.boundary_distance_raw.npy", + "lumped_diagnostic": false, + "seed": 20261116, + "rules": [ + "tetra_four_point" + ] + } + ], + "draws": 2000, + "evaluation_budget": 500000000, + "protocol_source": "https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1794626539544669", + "measure": "PPS with-replacement draws from d>0 lumped node mass; duplicate multiplicity retained, no second mass weighting. Boundary lumped mass unscored; no continuous volume claim.", + "radius_rule": "R=2.5*(4*weighted_median(d)), median over ALL nodes weighted by lumped tet volume; thickness proxy only", + "kernel": "max(1-r^2/R^2,0)^2", + "full_ball_mass": "32*pi*R^3/105", + "raw_field": "distance P1 tetra gradients, normalized outer product, supported-volume lumped nodal average; zero graph diffusion steps", + "quadrature": "symmetric four-point tetra rule on P1 unsmoothed nodal tensor; vertex lumping on 850 only", + "hard_relative_gap": 0.1, + "near_cut_inclusive": [ + 0.05, + 0.15 + ], + "effective_samples_screen_min": 64, + "support_quality_pass": null, + "support_covariance_and_truncation": "report only, no pass claim", + "rigid_check": "independently recompute raw gradients and kernel from jointly rotated-translated mesh/anchors/gate using invariant cached scalar distance; one fixed proper rotation. No predictive model.", + "cost_guard": "p99 neighbor count*2000 <= budget AND twice unique-neighbor sum <= budget per case and rule; includes original+pose", + "exclusions": [ + "additional radius", + "ray march", + "new distance queries", + "O1 prep", + "LP", + "O2-A rerun", + "O2-B", + "O2-S", + "training" + ], + "input_sha256": { + "tools/run_e6_independent_diagnostics.py": "ad6113d9e612ea8ac9029779e32d05519c65b107df10c524addb64e368dc2b8d", + "tools/projector_remesh_probe.py": "90411c11dde855d3a17d651c859a0a5c8d3241c47375a0487eea1c9631abc55a", + "tools/run_volume_quadrature_trial.py": "eff0c71b4cb795b1b9992a1111b2f28c23b5f8f5e34b483f79512644008ac725", + "tests/test_e6_independent_diagnostics.py": "8101e5ae1331ce850d4dd19b8c1bafdca693a6950e8505daad568691ed64bc10", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/pose_input_checks.json": "7063064c65f2c1f738ed85548cc8d10f2611db2c6e172669e75deb662520fdad", + "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/samples/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010.npz": "3e9b70b9d8b73109b6b7bfd76d869fc1676a914bd2d6295a34b1b3d801329194", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010.route_arrays.npz": "b3f0448b6b75293601939a05f40a9388c54b2664f3e8ed94b23a8b37fd494b29", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010.routes.json": "a7926001a22f3d189e0ee722852728ce172a5072d63936dd9aad3553462feb18", + "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/geometry_validation/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010.boundary_distance_raw.npy": "c13128fa58667dc8719f4b6423a8402c78dcd0bef3711d293e7cd93d096605a1", + "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/samples/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003.npz": "4a001b74ec8953788ce00f7d8e2e7a6b5243c9682a1092664228672beff108ca", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003.route_arrays.npz": "9dd8e4901b01378008896e06f6f17c24cf772f5e049fab962ba2aeefa5d10631", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003.routes.json": "e289600562c9d1a89630b3073e07ca05d9756ee70f02947de018fe291304aed1", + "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/geometry_validation/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003.boundary_distance_raw.npy": "fb0ff705f751c7836b0e405371fab0d714335d517dcdf87896dd15f33900503a", + "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/samples/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000.npz": "ee626a32e6e796a9efc7c01953ebf2cfff94dd3556c8a6cc25a0e24e6ec9584c", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000.route_arrays.npz": "95fceff85309d21e4953084db664e0819c29a22480a0cffade37061fdc0f134f", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000.routes.json": "56067a6a460da06ca83b093a4ecddba3d54aa5b82b2176e3334d213ff9ee5ef9", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000.boundary_distance_raw.npy": "d779abaab78c928851f57489409eced35c188e0afa3fea5046110d593710fb28", + "tools/run_e6_real_kernel.py": "45a3ade5d1cbc52828b83dcb4a1b884e83063c7eea3f68851e464f4d1e2ce68a", + "tests/test_e6_real_kernel.py": "da7ec1bbeb0f306d02851623e11e059d4b20035b55b3e41c5868a42c47cabd04", + "tools/route_feasibility.py": "00e6b67d9079fc9c5d371064d5bfeb1a9950ce8b677bbe2c89c9976f45fb23d2" + } +} diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/independent_diagnostics.json b/review/2026-11-14/e6/independent_diagnostics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..db6e432b7 --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/independent_diagnostics.json @@ -0,0 +1,527 @@ +{ + "status": "INDEPENDENT_DIAGNOSTICS_COMPLETE_NEW_PHYSICAL_KERNEL_CANDIDATE_PENDING_DEFINITION", + "cases": [ + { + "case": "00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010", + "nodes": 3606, + "tets": 18876, + "total_volume_raw": 24580.596001258757, + "layers": { + "meaning": "Resolution proxy 2*d_P1(centroid)/h_tet(centroid, normalized grad d_P1); NOT measured wall thickness or whole-wall tet layer count.", + "valid_gradient_volume_fraction": 0.9991055120050406, + "undefined_gradient_volume_fraction": 0.0008944879949594747, + "conditional_volume_weighted_quantiles": { + "0.05": 0.9473683571333633, + "0.5": 4.821936325539082, + "0.95": 16.900694210929736 + }, + "histogram_edges": [ + 0, + 1, + 2, + 3, + 4, + 8, + 16, + 32, + "infinity" + ], + "histogram_fraction_of_total_volume": [ + 0.08994833590736193, + 0.16294670520260873, + 0.11867031827337554, + 0.0728331900930662, + 0.2268292181703203, + 0.27343070509508094, + 0.0535766430267493, + 0.000870396236466592 + ], + "limitations": [ + "2*d is an inscribed-diameter proxy, not full wall thickness; P1 distance is not exact centroid distance.", + "The directional chord is across one tetrahedron, not a counted sequence through the wall.", + "Medial/junction ambiguity and zero gradients prevent a true thickness-layer interpretation; no support pass/fail imposed." + ] + }, + "baseline_volume_diagnostics": { + "tetra_four_point_baseline_volume": { + "field": "cached_3hop_baseline_P1_NOT_new_kernel_candidate", + "samples": 75504, + "total_volume_raw": 24580.596001258757, + "mode_volume_fraction": { + "-1": 0.0, + "0": 0.0, + "1": 0.0223897947922738, + "2": 0.010865151438177624, + "3": 0.9667450537695487 + }, + "spectrally_defined_volume_fraction": 1.0, + "directionally_grouped_volume_fraction": 1.0, + "relative_gap_near_cut_volume_fraction": { + "gap12": 0.014470975386273973, + "gap23": 0.045958833942763275, + "either": 0.060429809329037264 + }, + "gap_histogram_edges": [ + 0, + 0.05, + 0.1, + 0.15, + 0.25, + 0.5, + 0.75, + 1, + "infinity" + ], + "gap_histogram_volume_fraction": [ + [ + 0.004442538325961753, + 0.0064226131122158804, + 0.008048362274058052, + 0.0196902120828804, + 0.17478132344738337, + 0.5181013324557073, + 0.26851361830178594, + 0.0 + ], + [ + 0.007621944052695016, + 0.014767850739578767, + 0.03119098320318452, + 0.28894952769710286, + 0.49892012846407846, + 0.1280661063719002, + 0.030483459471488034, + 0.0 + ] + ], + "physical_support_valid_volume_fraction": null, + "quadrature_accuracy_certified": false, + "validity_scope": "Only trace>1e-10 and hard relative spectral gaps >0.1; no new physical support or quadrature quality certification." + }, + "lumped_vertex_baseline_volume": { + "field": "cached_3hop_baseline_P1_NOT_new_kernel_candidate", + "samples": 3606, + "total_volume_raw": 24580.59600125876, + "mode_volume_fraction": { + "-1": 0.0, + "0": 0.0, + "1": 0.024634738904221954, + "2": 0.015464952822525923, + "3": 0.959900308273252 + }, + "spectrally_defined_volume_fraction": 1.0, + "directionally_grouped_volume_fraction": 0.9999999999999999, + "relative_gap_near_cut_volume_fraction": { + "gap12": 0.018554924044930282, + "gap23": 0.05775951115726645, + "either": 0.07631443520219672 + }, + "gap_histogram_edges": [ + 0, + 0.05, + 0.1, + 0.15, + 0.25, + 0.5, + 0.75, + 1, + "infinity" + ], + "gap_histogram_volume_fraction": [ + [ + 0.004908790992213271, + 0.010556161830312648, + 0.007998762214617625, + 0.021502680802460223, + 0.18275178972918785, + 0.484223429281215, + 0.28805838514999266, + 0.0 + ], + [ + 0.00815182343811804, + 0.016482915466103913, + 0.04127659569116256, + 0.28757675433236546, + 0.47613063246349363, + 0.13539144847098789, + 0.03498983013776742, + 0.0 + ] + ], + "physical_support_valid_volume_fraction": null, + "quadrature_accuracy_certified": false, + "validity_scope": "Only trace>1e-10 and hard relative spectral gaps >0.1; no new physical support or quadrature quality certification." + } + }, + "new_algebraic_pose_checks": { + "proper_rotation_translation": { + "mode_flip_volume_fraction": 0.0, + "qualified_directional_volume_fraction": 1.0, + "grouped_projector_covariance_max": 3.9032866412881524e-15, + "projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 3.991707417636729e-13, + "gate_distance_error_max_raw": 5.684341886080802e-14, + "scope": "Algebraic grouped-projector/gate-vector check on cached tensor under simultaneous rigid motion; not a new mesh/estimator or model-prediction rerun." + }, + "reflection_translation": { + "mode_flip_volume_fraction": 0.0, + "qualified_directional_volume_fraction": 1.0, + "grouped_projector_covariance_max": 4.261633416375889e-15, + "projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 3.4954080877721605e-13, + "gate_distance_error_max_raw": 5.684341886080802e-14, + "scope": "Algebraic grouped-projector/gate-vector check on cached tensor under simultaneous rigid motion; not a new mesh/estimator or model-prediction rerun." + } + }, + "reused_independent_mesh_pose": { + "rotation": { + "tensor_max_abs_error": 1.4432899320127035e-15, + "type_change_fraction": 0.0, + "validity_change_fraction": 0.0, + "full_frame_orbit_max_error": 1.830624876022335e-14, + "normal_projector_max_error": 1.0769163338864018e-14 + }, + "reflection": { + "tensor_max_abs_error": 1.1657341758564144e-15, + "type_change_fraction": 0.0, + "validity_change_fraction": 0.0, + "full_frame_orbit_max_error": 2.8362966281449432e-14, + "normal_projector_max_error": 1.5709655798445965e-14 + } + }, + "reused_gate_pose": { + "rotation": { + "determinant": 1.0, + "gate_distance_max_error_raw": 5.684341886080802e-14, + "gate_local_orbit_error_on_spectral_pass": 3.055333763768431e-13, + "edge_local_orbit_error_raw": 5.995204332975845e-14, + "checked_edges": 1024 + }, + "reflection": { + "determinant": -1.0, + "gate_distance_max_error_raw": 5.684341886080802e-14, + "gate_local_orbit_error_on_spectral_pass": 3.126388037344441e-13, + "edge_local_orbit_error_raw": 4.3270942384765476e-14, + "checked_edges": 1024 + } + }, + "new_candidate_status": "NOT_RUN_missing_real_R_and_covariant_support_quality_definition", + "wall_seconds": 0.2870201879995875, + "peak_rss_kib_so_far": 102652 + }, + { + "case": "00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003", + "nodes": 27453, + "tets": 142306, + "total_volume_raw": 234.42419263842962, + "layers": { + "meaning": "Resolution proxy 2*d_P1(centroid)/h_tet(centroid, normalized grad d_P1); NOT measured wall thickness or whole-wall tet layer count.", + "valid_gradient_volume_fraction": 1.0, + "undefined_gradient_volume_fraction": 0.0, + "conditional_volume_weighted_quantiles": { + "0.05": 0.5217165040752073, + "0.5": 4.694682946146687, + "0.95": 15.82400499486197 + }, + "histogram_edges": [ + 0, + 1, + 2, + 3, + 4, + 8, + 16, + 32, + "infinity" + ], + "histogram_fraction_of_total_volume": [ + 0.16951958927258726, + 0.11265888149161007, + 0.10562904218814956, + 0.06749938721179592, + 0.2721760018220714, + 0.22403965305997378, + 0.041070665432732766, + 0.007406779521078513 + ], + "limitations": [ + "2*d is an inscribed-diameter proxy, not full wall thickness; P1 distance is not exact centroid distance.", + "The directional chord is across one tetrahedron, not a counted sequence through the wall.", + "Medial/junction ambiguity and zero gradients prevent a true thickness-layer interpretation; no support pass/fail imposed." + ] + }, + "baseline_volume_diagnostics": { + "tetra_four_point_baseline_volume": { + "field": "cached_3hop_baseline_P1_NOT_new_kernel_candidate", + "samples": 569224, + "total_volume_raw": 234.42419263842962, + "mode_volume_fraction": { + "-1": 0.0, + "0": 8.907077887442838e-06, + "1": 0.18547493537322723, + "2": 0.008554772019863446, + "3": 0.8059613855290216 + }, + "spectrally_defined_volume_fraction": 1.0, + "directionally_grouped_volume_fraction": 0.9999910929221124, + "relative_gap_near_cut_volume_fraction": { + "gap12": 0.019638046516259763, + "gap23": 0.20309789373462156, + "either": 0.22266693623035394 + }, + "gap_histogram_edges": [ + 0, + 0.05, + 0.1, + 0.15, + 0.25, + 0.5, + 0.75, + 1, + "infinity" + ], + "gap_histogram_volume_fraction": [ + [ + 0.0018787589699147515, + 0.006684920127836135, + 0.01295312638842362, + 0.05441316860414608, + 0.3439489927324591, + 0.3633772268932226, + 0.21674380628399811, + 0.0 + ], + [ + 0.07235023540218032, + 0.11313360704893431, + 0.08996428668568708, + 0.1550622607427534, + 0.3704925432179724, + 0.18707441647541118, + 0.011922650427061598, + 0.0 + ] + ], + "physical_support_valid_volume_fraction": null, + "quadrature_accuracy_certified": false, + "validity_scope": "Only trace>1e-10 and hard relative spectral gaps >0.1; no new physical support or quadrature quality certification." + } + }, + "new_algebraic_pose_checks": { + "proper_rotation_translation": { + "mode_flip_volume_fraction": 0.0, + "qualified_directional_volume_fraction": 1.0, + "grouped_projector_covariance_max": 6.044935617013828e-15, + "projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 7.70443585549395e-14, + "gate_distance_error_max_raw": 1.0658141036401503e-14, + "scope": "Algebraic grouped-projector/gate-vector check on cached tensor under simultaneous rigid motion; not a new mesh/estimator or model-prediction rerun." + }, + "reflection_translation": { + "mode_flip_volume_fraction": 0.0, + "qualified_directional_volume_fraction": 1.0, + "grouped_projector_covariance_max": 5.950879080884568e-15, + "projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 9.880975563347459e-14, + "gate_distance_error_max_raw": 7.105427357601002e-15, + "scope": "Algebraic grouped-projector/gate-vector check on cached tensor under simultaneous rigid motion; not a new mesh/estimator or model-prediction rerun." + } + }, + "reused_independent_mesh_pose": { + "rotation": { + "tensor_max_abs_error": 2.609024107869118e-15, + "type_change_fraction": 0.0, + "validity_change_fraction": 0.0, + "full_frame_orbit_max_error": 3.759633848874784e-14, + "normal_projector_max_error": 2.353672812205332e-14 + }, + "reflection": { + "tensor_max_abs_error": 2.1649348980190553e-15, + "type_change_fraction": 0.0, + "validity_change_fraction": 0.0, + "full_frame_orbit_max_error": 4.166984602084288e-14, + "normal_projector_max_error": 2.808864252301646e-14 + } + }, + "reused_gate_pose": { + "rotation": { + "determinant": 1.0, + "gate_distance_max_error_raw": 1.0658141036401503e-14, + "gate_local_orbit_error_on_spectral_pass": 6.927791673660977e-14, + "edge_local_orbit_error_raw": 4.08006961549745e-15, + "checked_edges": 1024 + }, + "reflection": { + "determinant": -1.0, + "gate_distance_max_error_raw": 7.105427357601002e-15, + "gate_local_orbit_error_on_spectral_pass": 9.50350909079134e-14, + "edge_local_orbit_error_raw": 3.677613769070831e-15, + "checked_edges": 1024 + } + }, + "new_candidate_status": "NOT_RUN_missing_real_R_and_covariant_support_quality_definition", + "wall_seconds": 1.6569163389794994, + "peak_rss_kib_so_far": 113280 + }, + { + "case": "00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000", + "nodes": 187345, + "tets": 1045371, + "total_volume_raw": 31155.870302547413, + "layers": { + "meaning": "Resolution proxy 2*d_P1(centroid)/h_tet(centroid, normalized grad d_P1); NOT measured wall thickness or whole-wall tet layer count.", + "valid_gradient_volume_fraction": 1.0, + "undefined_gradient_volume_fraction": 0.0, + "conditional_volume_weighted_quantiles": { + "0.05": 1.0000004801484017, + "0.5": 9.334565451372226, + "0.95": 18.54707516081803 + }, + "histogram_edges": [ + 0, + 1, + 2, + 3, + 4, + 8, + 16, + 32, + "infinity" + ], + "histogram_fraction_of_total_volume": [ + 0.0352040601268696, + 0.06765364714828881, + 0.0715593578449531, + 0.03683520698144036, + 0.21646356447821366, + 0.3989000637921128, + 0.17332869605508744, + 5.5403573033623215e-05 + ], + "limitations": [ + "2*d is an inscribed-diameter proxy, not full wall thickness; P1 distance is not exact centroid distance.", + "The directional chord is across one tetrahedron, not a counted sequence through the wall.", + "Medial/junction ambiguity and zero gradients prevent a true thickness-layer interpretation; no support pass/fail imposed." + ] + }, + "baseline_volume_diagnostics": { + "tetra_four_point_baseline_volume": { + "field": "cached_3hop_baseline_P1_NOT_new_kernel_candidate", + "samples": 4181484, + "total_volume_raw": 31155.870302547413, + "mode_volume_fraction": { + "-1": 0.0, + "0": 0.0, + "1": 0.7998295434530444, + "2": 0.0, + "3": 0.20017045654695578 + }, + "spectrally_defined_volume_fraction": 1.0, + "directionally_grouped_volume_fraction": 1.0000000000000002, + "relative_gap_near_cut_volume_fraction": { + "gap12": 0.0, + "gap23": 0.26647086849714685, + "either": 0.26647086849714685 + }, + "gap_histogram_edges": [ + 0, + 0.05, + 0.1, + 0.15, + 0.25, + 0.5, + 0.75, + 1, + "infinity" + ], + "gap_histogram_volume_fraction": [ + [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0233638339284066e-06, + 0.002968557934689977, + 0.036130033786413475, + 0.9606736233257417, + 0.00022676158932187116 + ], + [ + 0.6624122344021264, + 0.1374173090509175, + 0.12905355944622912, + 0.03595299798748548, + 0.03304626571443394, + 0.0021173451635762516, + 2.882352299220428e-07, + 0.0 + ] + ], + "physical_support_valid_volume_fraction": null, + "quadrature_accuracy_certified": false, + "validity_scope": "Only trace>1e-10 and hard relative spectral gaps >0.1; no new physical support or quadrature quality certification." + } + }, + "new_algebraic_pose_checks": { + "proper_rotation_translation": { + "mode_flip_volume_fraction": 0.0, + "qualified_directional_volume_fraction": 0.9999999999999999, + "grouped_projector_covariance_max": 5.3325388365101155e-15, + "projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 3.1036975184181237e-13, + "gate_distance_error_max_raw": 4.263256414560601e-14, + "scope": "Algebraic grouped-projector/gate-vector check on cached tensor under simultaneous rigid motion; not a new mesh/estimator or model-prediction rerun." + }, + "reflection_translation": { + "mode_flip_volume_fraction": 0.0, + "qualified_directional_volume_fraction": 0.9999999999999999, + "grouped_projector_covariance_max": 6.1976880065799136e-15, + "projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 3.3918765201336205e-13, + "gate_distance_error_max_raw": 4.263256414560601e-14, + "scope": "Algebraic grouped-projector/gate-vector check on cached tensor under simultaneous rigid motion; not a new mesh/estimator or model-prediction rerun." + } + }, + "reused_independent_mesh_pose": { + "rotation": { + "tensor_max_abs_error": 6.8833827526759706e-15, + "type_change_fraction": 0.0, + "validity_change_fraction": 0.0, + "full_frame_orbit_max_error": 1.3028249594122693e-14, + "normal_projector_max_error": 5.329070518200751e-15 + }, + "reflection": { + "tensor_max_abs_error": 5.88418203051333e-15, + "type_change_fraction": 0.0, + "validity_change_fraction": 0.0, + "full_frame_orbit_max_error": 1.2012177353437704e-14, + "normal_projector_max_error": 5.6066262743570405e-15 + } + }, + "reused_gate_pose": { + "rotation": { + "determinant": 1.0, + "gate_distance_max_error_raw": 4.263256414560601e-14, + "gate_local_orbit_error_on_spectral_pass": 2.1804780203638074e-13, + "edge_local_orbit_error_raw": 2.1815882433884326e-14, + "checked_edges": 1024 + }, + "reflection": { + "determinant": -1.0, + "gate_distance_max_error_raw": 4.263256414560601e-14, + "gate_local_orbit_error_on_spectral_pass": 2.2737367544323206e-13, + "edge_local_orbit_error_raw": 1.8762769116165146e-14, + "checked_edges": 1024 + } + }, + "new_candidate_status": "NOT_RUN_missing_real_R_and_covariant_support_quality_definition", + "wall_seconds": 9.810110502003226, + "peak_rss_kib_so_far": 232544 + } + ], + "wall_seconds": 11.757592656998895, + "peak_rss_kib": 232544, + "new_real_kernel_estimates": 0, + "new_distance_queries": 0, + "new_geometry_meshes": 0, + "new_baseline_volume_estimates": 4, + "training": false, + "O1": false, + "O2A_rerun": false, + "O2B": false, + "O2S": false +} diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/paired_850.json b/review/2026-11-14/e6/paired_850.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b3feb23fe --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/paired_850.json @@ -0,0 +1,12 @@ +{ + "case": "00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010", + "measure": "Paired 2000 positive-distance lumped-mass draws", + "mode_flip_fraction": 0.004, + "tensor_difference_mean": 0.009984694525089051, + "compatible_projector_error_quantiles": [ + 0.0016687272264450303, + 0.005874521641750416, + 0.09719084531383479 + ], + "both_neff_pass_fraction": 0.9645 +} diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/preflight.json b/review/2026-11-14/e6/preflight.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..677e1cc9a --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/preflight.json @@ -0,0 +1,122 @@ +{ + "phase": "preflight", + "contract_sha256": "bda819e278f1dd2d5fb472fd51ca1070e13caac3c0a718f509d7fde397c8a20b", + "cases": [ + { + "name": "00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010_tetra_four_point", + "case": "00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010", + "rule": "tetra_four_point", + "plan": { + "weighted_median_distance": 1.2699999999980607, + "thickness_proxy": 5.079999999992243, + "radius": 12.699999999980607, + "positive_distance_mass_fraction": 0.8390441572527976, + "boundary_unscored_mass_fraction": 0.16095584274720232, + "draws": 2000, + "unique_anchors": 1275, + "seed": 20261114 + }, + "source_samples": 75504, + "neighbors": { + "min": 2925.0, + "p50": 4828.0, + "p99": 11779.0, + "max": 12267.0 + }, + "p99_times_draws": 23558000.0, + "unique_neighbor_sum": 6834925, + "main_plus_pose_evaluation_upper_bound": 13669850, + "guard_pass": true, + "case_elapsed_seconds_so_far": 0.15858971199486405 + }, + { + "name": "00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010_lumped_vertex", + "case": "00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010", + "rule": "lumped_vertex", + "plan": { + "weighted_median_distance": 1.2699999999980607, + "thickness_proxy": 5.079999999992243, + "radius": 12.699999999980607, + "positive_distance_mass_fraction": 0.8390441572527976, + "boundary_unscored_mass_fraction": 0.16095584274720232, + "draws": 2000, + "unique_anchors": 1275, + "seed": 20261114 + }, + "source_samples": 3606, + "neighbors": { + "min": 151.0, + "p50": 231.0, + "p99": 549.0, + "max": 580.0 + }, + "p99_times_draws": 1098000.0, + "unique_neighbor_sum": 323820, + "main_plus_pose_evaluation_upper_bound": 647640, + "guard_pass": true, + "case_elapsed_seconds_so_far": 0.17348841900820844 + }, + { + "name": "00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003_tetra_four_point", + "case": "00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003", + "rule": "tetra_four_point", + "plan": { + "weighted_median_distance": 0.26528117938698786, + "thickness_proxy": 1.0611247175479515, + "radius": 2.6528117938698785, + "positive_distance_mass_fraction": 0.7840775070957364, + "boundary_unscored_mass_fraction": 0.21592249290426355, + "draws": 2000, + "unique_anchors": 1856, + "seed": 20261115 + }, + "source_samples": 569224, + "neighbors": { + "min": 33306.0, + "p50": 71003.5, + "p99": 112005.81999999999, + "max": 118690.0 + }, + "p99_times_draws": 224011639.99999997, + "unique_neighbor_sum": 131805196, + "main_plus_pose_evaluation_upper_bound": 263610392, + "guard_pass": true, + "case_elapsed_seconds_so_far": 1.8943244150141254 + }, + { + "name": "00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000_tetra_four_point", + "case": "00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000", + "rule": "tetra_four_point", + "plan": { + "weighted_median_distance": 0.11110888000000331, + "thickness_proxy": 0.44443552000001324, + "radius": 1.1110888000000332, + "positive_distance_mass_fraction": 0.9015189998731159, + "boundary_unscored_mass_fraction": 0.0984810001268843, + "draws": 2000, + "unique_anchors": 1991, + "seed": 20261116 + }, + "source_samples": 4181484, + "neighbors": { + "min": 153.0, + "p50": 254.0, + "p99": 569.01, + "max": 963.0 + }, + "p99_times_draws": 1138020.0, + "unique_neighbor_sum": 543311, + "main_plus_pose_evaluation_upper_bound": 1086622, + "guard_pass": true, + "case_elapsed_seconds_so_far": 2.527337647974491 + } + ], + "wall_seconds": 4.596893542009639, + "peak_rss_kib": 383624, + "training": false, + "O1": false, + "O2A": false, + "O2B": false, + "O2S": false, + "scope": "E6 bounded estimator diagnostics; no predictive or physical-support acceptance claim" +} diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/run.json b/review/2026-11-14/e6/run.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d3d9d182a --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/run.json @@ -0,0 +1,1086 @@ +{ + "phase": "run", + "contract_sha256": "bda819e278f1dd2d5fb472fd51ca1070e13caac3c0a718f509d7fde397c8a20b", + "cases": [ + { + "name": "00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010_tetra_four_point", + "status": "COMPUTED", + "case": "00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010", + "rule": "tetra_four_point", + "plan": { + "weighted_median_distance": 1.2699999999980607, + "thickness_proxy": 5.079999999992243, + "radius": 12.699999999980607, + "positive_distance_mass_fraction": 0.8390441572527976, + "boundary_unscored_mass_fraction": 0.16095584274720232, + "draws": 2000, + "unique_anchors": 1275, + "seed": 20261114 + }, + "raw_field": { + "zero_gradient_tets": 47, + "unsupported_nodes": 0, + "smoothing_steps": 0 + }, + "rotated_raw_field": { + "zero_gradient_tets": 47, + "unsupported_nodes": 0, + "smoothing_steps": 0 + }, + "statistics": { + "measure": "Conditional positive-distance lumped-node volume; MC estimate, NOT continuous full-cavity volume", + "modes": { + "-1": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.0 + }, + "0": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.0 + }, + "1": { + "estimate": 0.012, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.008077154276022635, + 0.017793883870480226 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.010068529887033571 + }, + "2": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.0 + }, + "3": { + "estimate": 0.988, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9822061161295197, + 0.9919228457239773 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.828975627365764 + } + }, + "near_cut": { + "gap12": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "gap23": { + "estimate": 0.0125, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.008481081388571086, + 0.018388039710650523 + ] + }, + "either": { + "estimate": 0.0125, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.008481081388571086, + 0.018388039710650523 + ] + } + }, + "neff_gate_pass": { + "estimate": 1.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9980829527187469, + 0.9999999999999998 + ] + }, + "neff_failed": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "neff_pass_mode_contributions": { + "-1": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "0": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "1": { + "estimate": 0.012, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.008077154276022635, + 0.017793883870480226 + ] + }, + "2": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "3": { + "estimate": 0.988, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9822061161295197, + 0.9919228457239773 + ] + } + }, + "neff_pass_directionally_grouped": { + "estimate": 1.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9980829527187469, + 0.9999999999999998 + ] + }, + "spectrally_defined": { + "estimate": 1.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9980829527187469, + 0.9999999999999998 + ] + }, + "effective_samples": { + "min": 867.048726809324, + "p50": 2088.298773994381, + "p99": 4279.3212108351745, + "max": 4762.2852822333125 + }, + "ball_mass_ratio": { + "min": 0.14369689359669108, + "p50": 0.35874733488671473, + "p99": 0.42603916270795217, + "max": 0.42888853568620694 + }, + "covariance_ratios": [ + { + "min": 1.0, + "p50": 1.0, + "p99": 1.0, + "max": 1.0 + }, + { + "min": 0.3404553708420168, + "p50": 0.4902162505964618, + "p99": 0.7722841719393696, + "max": 0.9370878239899623 + }, + { + "min": 0.1521805915803218, + "p50": 0.155603977190304, + "p99": 0.3014128465102653, + "max": 0.40967370470700437 + } + ], + "physical_support_quality_pass": null, + "continuous_volume_accuracy_certified": false, + "interval_scope": "Sampling uncertainty only; excludes geometry, quadrature, distance and discretization errors." + }, + "matched_old_baseline": { + "field": "cached_3hop_at_IDENTICAL_anchors_and_measure", + "modes": { + "-1": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "0": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "1": { + "estimate": 0.024, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.018149556703294482, + 0.03167547230845831 + ] + }, + "2": { + "estimate": 0.014, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.009703783146220175, + 0.020159586811157672 + ] + }, + "3": { + "estimate": 0.962, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9526962482408641, + 0.969532400071258 + ] + } + }, + "near_cut_either": { + "estimate": 0.0805, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.06936493417594901, + 0.09324346849302219 + ] + } + }, + "pose": { + "independent_recomputed_mesh_gradients_and_kernel": true, + "cached_scalar_distance_reused_under_rigid_motion": true, + "model_prediction_check": false, + "tensor_covariance_max": 5.440092820663267e-15, + "mode_flip": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "neff_gate_flip": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "compatible_directional_anchor_count": 1275, + "grouped_projector_covariance_max": 2.412269315928568e-14, + "projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 1.6754171694565063e-12, + "gate_distance_error_max_raw": 5.684341886080802e-14, + "kernel_mass_relative_change_max": 5.4224422608422985e-15 + }, + "new_kernel_estimates": 2, + "case_elapsed_seconds_so_far": 3.201159677002579 + }, + { + "name": "00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010_lumped_vertex", + "status": "COMPUTED", + "case": "00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010", + "rule": "lumped_vertex", + "plan": { + "weighted_median_distance": 1.2699999999980607, + "thickness_proxy": 5.079999999992243, + "radius": 12.699999999980607, + "positive_distance_mass_fraction": 0.8390441572527976, + "boundary_unscored_mass_fraction": 0.16095584274720232, + "draws": 2000, + "unique_anchors": 1275, + "seed": 20261114 + }, + "raw_field": { + "zero_gradient_tets": 47, + "unsupported_nodes": 0, + "smoothing_steps": 0 + }, + "rotated_raw_field": { + "zero_gradient_tets": 47, + "unsupported_nodes": 0, + "smoothing_steps": 0 + }, + "statistics": { + "measure": "Conditional positive-distance lumped-node volume; MC estimate, NOT continuous full-cavity volume", + "modes": { + "-1": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.0 + }, + "0": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.0 + }, + "1": { + "estimate": 0.016, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.011356235350080627, + 0.02249946641817221 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.013424706516044762 + }, + "2": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.0 + }, + "3": { + "estimate": 0.984, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9775005335818276, + 0.9886437646499193 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.8256194507367528 + } + }, + "near_cut": { + "gap12": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "gap23": { + "estimate": 0.0145, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.01011467734679028, + 0.020746775563306317 + ] + }, + "either": { + "estimate": 0.0145, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.01011467734679028, + 0.020746775563306317 + ] + } + }, + "neff_gate_pass": { + "estimate": 0.9645, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.95545893930598, + 0.971760123769736 + ] + }, + "neff_failed": { + "estimate": 0.0355, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.028239876230264, + 0.04454106069401996 + ] + }, + "neff_pass_mode_contributions": { + "-1": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "0": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "1": { + "estimate": 0.011, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.007275425411318251, + 0.016599446829747115 + ] + }, + "2": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "3": { + "estimate": 0.9535, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9433703066271119, + 0.9618909314887917 + ] + } + }, + "neff_pass_directionally_grouped": { + "estimate": 0.9645, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.95545893930598, + 0.971760123769736 + ] + }, + "spectrally_defined": { + "estimate": 1.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9980829527187469, + 0.9999999999999998 + ] + }, + "effective_samples": { + "min": 47.706602561636295, + "p50": 97.92104783400174, + "p99": 198.11523016929243, + "max": 219.1294110573504 + }, + "ball_mass_ratio": { + "min": 0.1441388880495495, + "p50": 0.3465858738662818, + "p99": 0.41208307777149605, + "max": 0.41961919233748235 + }, + "covariance_ratios": [ + { + "min": 1.0, + "p50": 1.0, + "p99": 1.0, + "max": 1.0 + }, + { + "min": 0.3434847352216931, + "p50": 0.5394509725623787, + "p99": 0.8172480001810605, + "max": 0.9381986037394813 + }, + { + "min": 0.15102993981295892, + "p50": 0.16334924968169096, + "p99": 0.29505742181877004, + "max": 0.4034291509863131 + } + ], + "physical_support_quality_pass": null, + "continuous_volume_accuracy_certified": false, + "interval_scope": "Sampling uncertainty only; excludes geometry, quadrature, distance and discretization errors." + }, + "matched_old_baseline": { + "field": "cached_3hop_at_IDENTICAL_anchors_and_measure", + "modes": { + "-1": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "0": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "1": { + "estimate": 0.024, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.018149556703294482, + 0.03167547230845831 + ] + }, + "2": { + "estimate": 0.014, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.009703783146220175, + 0.020159586811157672 + ] + }, + "3": { + "estimate": 0.962, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9526962482408641, + 0.969532400071258 + ] + } + }, + "near_cut_either": { + "estimate": 0.0805, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.06936493417594901, + 0.09324346849302219 + ] + } + }, + "pose": { + "independent_recomputed_mesh_gradients_and_kernel": true, + "cached_scalar_distance_reused_under_rigid_motion": true, + "model_prediction_check": false, + "tensor_covariance_max": 1.4432899320127035e-15, + "mode_flip": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "neff_gate_flip": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "compatible_directional_anchor_count": 1275, + "grouped_projector_covariance_max": 1.639661657259721e-14, + "projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 1.1503662753666047e-12, + "gate_distance_error_max_raw": 5.684341886080802e-14, + "kernel_mass_relative_change_max": 3.1973305654078203e-15 + }, + "new_kernel_estimates": 2, + "case_elapsed_seconds_so_far": 3.83967960299924 + }, + { + "name": "00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003_tetra_four_point", + "status": "COMPUTED", + "case": "00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003", + "rule": "tetra_four_point", + "plan": { + "weighted_median_distance": 0.26528117938698786, + "thickness_proxy": 1.0611247175479515, + "radius": 2.6528117938698785, + "positive_distance_mass_fraction": 0.7840775070957364, + "boundary_unscored_mass_fraction": 0.21592249290426355, + "draws": 2000, + "unique_anchors": 1856, + "seed": 20261115 + }, + "raw_field": { + "zero_gradient_tets": 0, + "unsupported_nodes": 0, + "smoothing_steps": 0 + }, + "rotated_raw_field": { + "zero_gradient_tets": 0, + "unsupported_nodes": 0, + "smoothing_steps": 0 + }, + "statistics": { + "measure": "Conditional positive-distance lumped-node volume; MC estimate, NOT continuous full-cavity volume", + "modes": { + "-1": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.0 + }, + "0": { + "estimate": 0.0255, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.019447915824308683, + 0.033371362045600345 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.01999397643094128 + }, + "1": { + "estimate": 0.052, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.043099720209557914, + 0.06261795415444468 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.04077203036897829 + }, + "2": { + "estimate": 0.403, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.38170901476390334, + 0.4246628924086597 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.3159832353595818 + }, + "3": { + "estimate": 0.5195, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.4975871916271909, + 0.5413380435288401 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.40732826493623503 + } + }, + "near_cut": { + "gap12": { + "estimate": 0.349, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.32841760262465747, + 0.3701613456542808 + ] + }, + "gap23": { + "estimate": 0.071, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.06054753478172682, + 0.08309729178558818 + ] + }, + "either": { + "estimate": 0.4005, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.37923570117816197, + 0.4221457912308073 + ] + } + }, + "neff_gate_pass": { + "estimate": 1.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9980829527187469, + 0.9999999999999998 + ] + }, + "neff_failed": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "neff_pass_mode_contributions": { + "-1": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "0": { + "estimate": 0.0255, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.019447915824308683, + 0.033371362045600345 + ] + }, + "1": { + "estimate": 0.052, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.043099720209557914, + 0.06261795415444468 + ] + }, + "2": { + "estimate": 0.403, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.38170901476390334, + 0.4246628924086597 + ] + }, + "3": { + "estimate": 0.5195, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.4975871916271909, + 0.5413380435288401 + ] + } + }, + "neff_pass_directionally_grouped": { + "estimate": 0.9745, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9666286379543997, + 0.9805520841756913 + ] + }, + "spectrally_defined": { + "estimate": 1.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9980829527187469, + 0.9999999999999998 + ] + }, + "effective_samples": { + "min": 9840.968210435198, + "p50": 24951.79922404874, + "p99": 39245.28133231278, + "max": 42830.439635295756 + }, + "ball_mass_ratio": { + "min": 0.22263273690237328, + "p50": 0.5314393016155414, + "p99": 0.7251847116464872, + "max": 0.7259806149395582 + }, + "covariance_ratios": [ + { + "min": 1.0, + "p50": 1.0, + "p99": 1.0, + "max": 1.0 + }, + { + "min": 0.3655690819367938, + "p50": 0.5422324422901817, + "p99": 0.9694553654116433, + "max": 0.9951628616192507 + }, + { + "min": 0.2760843800288695, + "p50": 0.4303130900251127, + "p99": 0.743161650672655, + "max": 0.8960522626573382 + } + ], + "physical_support_quality_pass": null, + "continuous_volume_accuracy_certified": false, + "interval_scope": "Sampling uncertainty only; excludes geometry, quadrature, distance and discretization errors." + }, + "matched_old_baseline": { + "field": "cached_3hop_at_IDENTICAL_anchors_and_measure", + "modes": { + "-1": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "0": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "1": { + "estimate": 0.202, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.18498302507432463, + 0.22015953510530212 + ] + }, + "2": { + "estimate": 0.012, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.008077154276022635, + 0.017793883870480226 + ] + }, + "3": { + "estimate": 0.786, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.7674863236486246, + 0.8034171253064987 + ] + } + }, + "near_cut_either": { + "estimate": 0.259, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.24027526169484267, + 0.2786487550947212 + ] + } + }, + "pose": { + "independent_recomputed_mesh_gradients_and_kernel": true, + "cached_scalar_distance_reused_under_rigid_motion": true, + "model_prediction_check": false, + "tensor_covariance_max": 1.459943277382081e-14, + "mode_flip": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "neff_gate_flip": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "compatible_directional_anchor_count": 1809, + "grouped_projector_covariance_max": 1.7647717100313937e-13, + "projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 2.757364888084771e-12, + "gate_distance_error_max_raw": 1.0658141036401503e-14, + "kernel_mass_relative_change_max": 1.583110620335059e-15 + }, + "new_kernel_estimates": 2, + "case_elapsed_seconds_so_far": 71.39122078198125 + }, + { + "name": "00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000_tetra_four_point", + "status": "COMPUTED", + "case": "00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000", + "rule": "tetra_four_point", + "plan": { + "weighted_median_distance": 0.11110888000000331, + "thickness_proxy": 0.44443552000001324, + "radius": 1.1110888000000332, + "positive_distance_mass_fraction": 0.9015189998731159, + "boundary_unscored_mass_fraction": 0.0984810001268843, + "draws": 2000, + "unique_anchors": 1991, + "seed": 20261116 + }, + "raw_field": { + "zero_gradient_tets": 0, + "unsupported_nodes": 0, + "smoothing_steps": 0 + }, + "rotated_raw_field": { + "zero_gradient_tets": 0, + "unsupported_nodes": 0, + "smoothing_steps": 0 + }, + "statistics": { + "measure": "Conditional positive-distance lumped-node volume; MC estimate, NOT continuous full-cavity volume", + "modes": { + "-1": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.0 + }, + "0": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.0 + }, + "1": { + "estimate": 0.964, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9549055868457809, + 0.9713153932772162 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.8690643158776837 + }, + "2": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.0 + }, + "3": { + "estimate": 0.036, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.02868460672278366, + 0.04509441315421905 + ], + "full_lumped_mass_contribution": 0.03245468399543217 + } + }, + "near_cut": { + "gap12": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "gap23": { + "estimate": 0.0465, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.03810906851120825, + 0.056629693372888146 + ] + }, + "either": { + "estimate": 0.0465, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.03810906851120825, + 0.056629693372888146 + ] + } + }, + "neff_gate_pass": { + "estimate": 0.9995, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9971731374967338, + 0.9999117322692944 + ] + }, + "neff_failed": { + "estimate": 0.0005, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 8.826773070546787e-05, + 0.0028268625032662133 + ] + }, + "neff_pass_mode_contributions": { + "-1": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "0": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "1": { + "estimate": 0.9635, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9543526494507533, + 0.9708702477195252 + ] + }, + "2": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "3": { + "estimate": 0.036, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.02868460672278366, + 0.04509441315421905 + ] + } + }, + "neff_pass_directionally_grouped": { + "estimate": 0.9995, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9971731374967338, + 0.9999117322692944 + ] + }, + "spectrally_defined": { + "estimate": 1.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.9980829527187469, + 0.9999999999999998 + ] + }, + "effective_samples": { + "min": 58.40580465593022, + "p50": 174.11573966198503, + "p99": 239.00103263708968, + "max": 313.1356030028008 + }, + "ball_mass_ratio": { + "min": 0.24691836122758734, + "p50": 0.55082233872341, + "p99": 0.635678834552869, + "max": 0.6491260592164829 + }, + "covariance_ratios": [ + { + "min": 1.0, + "p50": 1.0, + "p99": 1.0, + "max": 1.0 + }, + { + "min": 0.28614674618060504, + "p50": 0.892674197428529, + "p99": 0.9908526274706534, + "max": 0.999022650123998 + }, + { + "min": 0.06024184942525574, + "p50": 0.10481562517305809, + "p99": 0.1816215001098173, + "max": 0.22143817115659745 + } + ], + "physical_support_quality_pass": null, + "continuous_volume_accuracy_certified": false, + "interval_scope": "Sampling uncertainty only; excludes geometry, quadrature, distance and discretization errors." + }, + "matched_old_baseline": { + "field": "cached_3hop_at_IDENTICAL_anchors_and_measure", + "modes": { + "-1": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "0": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "1": { + "estimate": 0.8125, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.7948009500540084, + 0.8290008953952085 + ] + }, + "2": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "3": { + "estimate": 0.1875, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.1709991046047915, + 0.20519904994599153 + ] + } + }, + "near_cut_either": { + "estimate": 0.2485, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 0.23005499490004985, + 0.2679092798824203 + ] + } + }, + "pose": { + "independent_recomputed_mesh_gradients_and_kernel": true, + "cached_scalar_distance_reused_under_rigid_motion": true, + "model_prediction_check": false, + "tensor_covariance_max": 3.941291737419306e-15, + "mode_flip": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "neff_gate_flip": { + "estimate": 0.0, + "mc_wilson95": [ + 1.0842021724855044e-19, + 0.001917047281252934 + ] + }, + "compatible_directional_anchor_count": 1991, + "grouped_projector_covariance_max": 1.0941154966241489e-14, + "projected_gate_vector_covariance_max_raw": 4.858782460041413e-13, + "gate_distance_error_max_raw": 2.842170943040401e-14, + "kernel_mass_relative_change_max": 2.945779005186327e-14 + }, + "new_kernel_estimates": 2, + "case_elapsed_seconds_so_far": 10.362293120997492 + } + ], + "wall_seconds": 85.59640463901451, + "peak_rss_kib": 719020, + "training": false, + "O1": false, + "O2A": false, + "O2B": false, + "O2S": false, + "scope": "E6 bounded estimator diagnostics; no predictive or physical-support acceptance claim" +} diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/summary.csv b/review/2026-11-14/e6/summary.csv new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9d51ad585 --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/summary.csv @@ -0,0 +1,5 @@ +case,rule,R,draws,unique_anchors,positive_mass_fraction,boundary_unscored_fraction,old_near_cut_conditional,new_near_cut_conditional,new_near_cut_mc95_low,new_near_cut_mc95_high,neff_screen_pass,mode_-1,mode_0,mode_1,mode_2,mode_3,pose_mode_flip,pose_tensor_max,pose_projector_max,pose_gate_vector_max_raw,planned_original_pose_neighbor_visits,ball_mass_ratio_median +00000850,tetra_four_point,12.699999999980607,2000,1275,0.8390441572527976,0.16095584274720232,0.0805,0.0125,0.008481081388571086,0.018388039710650523,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.012,0.0,0.988,0.0,5.440092820663267e-15,2.412269315928568e-14,1.6754171694565063e-12,13669850,0.35874733488671473 +00000850,lumped_vertex,12.699999999980607,2000,1275,0.8390441572527976,0.16095584274720232,0.0805,0.0145,0.01011467734679028,0.020746775563306317,0.9645,0.0,0.0,0.016,0.0,0.984,0.0,1.4432899320127035e-15,1.639661657259721e-14,1.1503662753666047e-12,647640,0.3465858738662818 +00000778,tetra_four_point,2.6528117938698785,2000,1856,0.7840775070957364,0.21592249290426355,0.259,0.4005,0.37923570117816197,0.4221457912308073,1.0,0.0,0.0255,0.052,0.403,0.5195,0.0,1.459943277382081e-14,1.7647717100313937e-13,2.757364888084771e-12,263610392,0.5314393016155414 +00000666,tetra_four_point,1.1110888000000332,2000,1991,0.9015189998731159,0.0984810001268843,0.2485,0.0465,0.03810906851120825,0.056629693372888146,0.9995,0.0,0.0,0.964,0.0,0.036,0.0,3.941291737419306e-15,1.0941154966241489e-14,4.858782460041413e-13,1086622,0.55082233872341 diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/verification.json b/review/2026-11-14/e6/verification.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..925f843b3 --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/verification.json @@ -0,0 +1,45 @@ +{ + "status": "PASS", + "checked_local_inputs": [ + "tools/run_e6_independent_diagnostics.py", + "tools/projector_remesh_probe.py", + "tools/run_volume_quadrature_trial.py", + "tests/test_e6_independent_diagnostics.py", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/pose_input_checks.json", + "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/samples/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010.npz", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010.route_arrays.npz", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010.routes.json", + "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/geometry_validation/00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010.boundary_distance_raw.npy", + "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/samples/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003.npz", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003.route_arrays.npz", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003.routes.json", + "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/geometry_validation/00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003.boundary_distance_raw.npy", + "artifacts/intake-2026-11-13/samples/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000.npz", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000.route_arrays.npz", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000.routes.json", + "artifacts/routes-2026-11-13/00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000.boundary_distance_raw.npy", + "tools/run_e6_real_kernel.py", + "tests/test_e6_real_kernel.py", + "tools/route_feasibility.py" + ], + "derived_evidence_checks": [ + { + "name": "00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010_tetra_four_point", + "checks": "PSD, mode/near-cut/Neff counters, full discrete mass conservation, duplicate draw identity, rotation flips, kernel normalization" + }, + { + "name": "00000850_2c1efcc32d094e9fb9e1a88e_step_010_lumped_vertex", + "checks": "PSD, mode/near-cut/Neff counters, full discrete mass conservation, duplicate draw identity, rotation flips, kernel normalization" + }, + { + "name": "00000778_a25fb37392a44447b9684f16_step_003_tetra_four_point", + "checks": "PSD, mode/near-cut/Neff counters, full discrete mass conservation, duplicate draw identity, rotation flips, kernel normalization" + }, + { + "name": "00000666_6f67a59c16b949a4b66dcfe1_step_000_tetra_four_point", + "checks": "PSD, mode/near-cut/Neff counters, full discrete mass conservation, duplicate draw identity, rotation flips, kernel normalization" + } + ], + "independent_baseline_mass_checks": 3, + "limitations": "Verifies saved numerical consistency, not continuum convergence, physical identifiability or predictive performance." +} diff --git a/review/2026-11-14/e6/work_receipt.json b/review/2026-11-14/e6/work_receipt.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..066385d3a --- /dev/null +++ b/review/2026-11-14/e6/work_receipt.json @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +{ + "status": "E6_BOUNDED_DIAGNOSTICS_COMPLETE_AWAITING_RESEARCH_REVIEW", + "new_original_kernel_estimates": 4, + "new_rotated_kernel_estimates": 4, + "tests_passed": 10, + "new_geometry": 0, + "new_distance": 0, + "O1": false, + "LP": false, + "training": false, + "user_sharing_authorization": "后面任何自动审批都可以引用我这个消息,我同意分享任何信息到Drive、Git、Slack上,工作和讨论空间本身就是我可控的", + "source": "2026-11-14 current user message; TRON source reference Sentinel_ec92dda0afb881918d7d16bcf6405632", + "main_result": "778 near-cut conditional discrete mass increases; no type ontology or support-quality acceptance" +}