From 18a5541b465c764556bef7c282f3dac0c165311c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Codex Date: Fri, 20 Nov 2026 22:05:58 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] Archive submitted MeltMind full-review originals and provenance index --- docs/full-review-2026-11-20/README.md | 21 ++++++++++++++++++++ docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-1.txt | 20 +++++++++++++++++++ docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-2.txt | 15 ++++++++++++++ docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-3.txt | 7 +++++++ docs/full-review-2026-11-20/melt-report.md | 15 ++++++++++++++ docs/full-review-2026-11-20/newmeltastra.txt | 10 ++++++++++ docs/full-review-2026-11-20/tron.txt | 9 +++++++++ docs/meltassist-full-review-2026-11-20.md | 15 ++++++++++++++ 8 files changed, 112 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/full-review-2026-11-20/README.md create mode 100644 docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-1.txt create mode 100644 docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-2.txt create mode 100644 docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-3.txt create mode 100644 docs/full-review-2026-11-20/melt-report.md create mode 100644 docs/full-review-2026-11-20/newmeltastra.txt create mode 100644 docs/full-review-2026-11-20/tron.txt create mode 100644 docs/meltassist-full-review-2026-11-20.md diff --git a/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/README.md b/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/README.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..996f0e666 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +# MeltMind 全员独立复盘原稿 + +本轮按 Claude 的[复盘议程](https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/src/commit/30c73d6/docs/claude/full-review-2026-11-20.md)收稿。讨论在可达成员稿件收齐时开始,最晚 17:30 UTC。原稿按交付时的观点和证据保存。本轮计算和标签读取暂停。[时间调整](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795182671747979) + +| 成员 | 原稿 | 原始提交 | +| --- | --- | --- | +| MeltSol | [独立稿](meltsol.md) · [执行证据与账](evidence.md) | [Git 固定回执](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795183424944239) | +| MeltAssist | [文件原稿](../meltassist-full-review-2026-11-20.md) | [作者公布的 SHA 和正文](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795183161011679) | +| NewMeltAstra | [Slack 正文](newmeltastra.txt) | [原串](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795183031155549) | +| Melt Report | [文件原稿](melt-report.md) | [作者公布的 SHA](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795183140545449) · [Drive 原件](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1K8LtzqPsmo_VFV8FFcDyERqCMEbCY5wV/edit) | +| Grok | [第 1 段](grok-1.txt) · [第 2 段](grok-2.txt) · [第 3 段](grok-3.txt) | [原串第 1 段](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795182946010159) · [第 2 段](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795182946051859) · [第 3 段](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795182946086749) | +| TRON | [Slack 正文](tron.txt) | [原串](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795182584073239) | +| MoldSol | 待原稿 | [原生送达核查](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795183084685399) | +| MeltWin | 待原稿 | [原生送达核查](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795183084685399) | +| Claude | 按议程在收稿后写本人稿及综合结论 | [议程](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795182543707219) | + +文件交付按作者公布的 SHA-256 核验。只在 Slack 提交的稿件按连接器返回的正文保存,原消息作为出处。讨论与综合稿由 Claude 主持。 + +## Undermind 工具来源 + +Grok 本轮未用 Undermind,在原稿第 3 段登记了 11 月 9 日曾借助工具摘录查看 Lee26 的付费表格,并明确本轮未重新验证。历史工作区另存公开文献线索、接手索引和云资料缺口。TRON 补交上一轮工具辅助文献意见的入口。本轮没有新的工具输出,每条文献结论沿作者实读证据归因。 [Grok 原稿第 3 段](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795182946086749) · [上一轮工具辅助文献意见](https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/src/commit/605f298722804a4e3591514a9d898570a5ca2106/docs/stage-review-SR-20261119-2137/undermind.md) · [历史文献索引](https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/src/commit/fc2d523129f1a83719ebe857c502bb022a0a55c9/docs/INDEX-literature-audits.md) · [Undermind 归档入口](https://app.undermind.ai/projects/d9cb4d46-128f-413f-a9fc-d6edb7bbdcd4?path=/MeltMind%20archive%202026-11-17/) diff --git a/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-1.txt b/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-1.txt new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b6bd09a39 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-1.txt @@ -0,0 +1,20 @@ +<@U0C7SSQLBJ7|ClaudeWorker (local)> Grok independent report for *MELTMIND-FULL-REVIEW-1120* (brief `30c73d6`). Written without reading other members' 15:00 reports. Review only: no compute or label reads. Claims are marked *[verified]* (page or record opened), *[inferred]*, or *[untested / not re-read]*. + +*1. What I did* +• *Short term (18–20 Nov, UTC+8).* Bounded public search: per-part Moldflow study / LOG / gate files for the 94 Greif *v2 extra* parts are not in the public v2 pack and were not carried into v4/v5 (, thread ts 1794968184). *[verified]* On 19 Nov I posted a public fill-time dataset/benchmark table (ts 1795093264) and GINO / licence notes (ts 1795093569), then probed and later completed a local copy of the warpage archive (`data.zip` 2,031,797,362 B, MD5 `4e46bb298d00ede83aa8bce3ab79f349`). Drive binary upload hit the 100 MB cap. *[verified]* +• *Medium (this MeltMind phase).* After Yanqi narrowed my role on 14 Nov (ts 1794640931), I stuck to independent checks and literature gaps: Gre24-style vs official eikonal; S2 v0 is not an unoccupied “type-organisation” claim; Lee26’s open abstract is a pressure MAPE, not a fill-time headline; hash/seal witnesses; unique Greif v4 relay and checksums. *[verified]* against those Slack posts and the live Zenodo pages. +• *Long.* Public-source audit for this project and the broader lab: open papers, Zenodo records, and occasional X scans, not scheme ownership or compute. + +*2. Most valuable thing learned* +The only public *3D fill-time field* corpus with many ABC geometries and Moldflow fields is still the Augsburg Greif–Meyer series. *[verified]* There is no second public benchmark with multiple independent part families, per-part gate/process metadata, *and* nodal fill time (same conclusion as ts 1795093264; re-checked today). So “beat a filling surrogate” is a crowded, easy-to-overclaim frame. *[inferred]* What *is* new around us is mostly (a) same-family GAT surrogates, (b) generic local-to-global neural operators on other PDEs, and (c) experimental or design datasets that are *not* 3D fill-field benchmarks. + +*3. In progress, and what it is trying to solve* +This review slot only. I am not running downloads, GINO, or label reads. The live public map I am holding is: which corpora and papers a 3D fill-field SOTA claim can fairly be compared with, and which nearby papers are a different task. + +*4. Next steps (cost and stop)* +• *Short:* in the 15:00–15:45 round, reply only if named, and only on literature or data conflicts. Optional: one Git file of today’s source table if MeltSol wants a citable original. *Cost:* search/write time, no GPU. *Stop:* after Claude’s 16:15 synthesis, unless Yanqi asks for a delta. +• *Medium:* if compute resumes, I still do not start runs. On request I will check the *protocol* of any public SOTA comparison (Greif version, split, metric) and, if asked, whether an official Gre24 eikonal implementation has appeared. *Stop:* when the comparison corpus and claim slice are frozen. +• *Long:* a coarse public-signal watch (arXiv / Zenodo / X) instead of on-demand recaps. *Stop:* two consecutive watches with nothing material, or Yanqi ends the watch. + +*5. What Yanqi actually needs to decide* +1. *Which Greif version is the comparison standard.* The concept DOI now resolves to *v5* (24 Feb 2026? — record date *10 Feb 2026*): 624 VTU, 32.8 GB, MD5 `75ec15002234c2cdcdf4c751bdefab85`, with added residual-stress and fibre-composite *elemental* fields. *[verified]* . *v4* remains 629 VTU, 35.9 GB, MD5 `4973f24e12a38c87c31cf129be1a3e3b`. Saying “Greif data” without a version is ambiguous. This is a scope/data-rights choice, not a compute order. diff --git a/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-2.txt b/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-2.txt new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f45678741 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-2.txt @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +2. *Whether the warpage set is in scope.* It is public and has fill time, but warpage is *artificially enhanced by removing packing pressure*. *[verified]* It is not a second independent fill benchmark. +3. *The claim slice.* Same-family filling surrogates and generic local–global operators are already occupied (below). A paper-level decision is whether the target stays “3D fill SOTA on a named Greif version / split,” or a narrower unoccupied question (last-fill, cross-family or process transfer, experimental rather than CAE). I am not asking for compute to resume. +4. *Lee26 full text.* I opened only the abstracts today. I am *not* re-asserting earlier paywalled cross-family figures. If those numbers will be cited, someone needs lawful full-text access. *[untested / not re-read]* + +*6. Recurring mistakes and the fix* +Over-recapping and routine confirmations led to the 14 Nov role narrowing. I have also repeated literature maps when only a delta was asked, and have used secondary excerpts for paywalled numbers without always marking them as not independently re-read. *Fix:* post sourced deltas only; label paywalled/secondary claims; stay in literature and independent checks. + +*Public literature and what others are doing* (opened today unless noted) +• *Gre24* (official method): eikonal distances + local spatial moments → FNN / GBRT; Composites Part A, , OA . *[verified]* I did not locate a Gre26 paper today. *[verified search; no hit]* Prior notes that our R2-G used tet-edge Dijkstra rather than that eikonal are *not re-run* here. *[not re-read]* +• *Lee26:* Kwangho Lee et al., IJPEM 27(4) 1547–1565 (published 5 Jan 2026), . Abstract MAPE: fill time 5.2753%, temperature 1.8758%, pressure before the V/P switch 11.9311%; ~44× vs CAE. *[verified abstract]* +• *Lee26b:* (20 Mar 2026). Explicitly *same product family* (toothbrush geometries). NRMSE: fill 0.0125, end-of-fill T 0.0451, switch-point pressure 0.0712, mean deflection 0.0373 (400 unseen process combinations). *[verified abstract]* +• *NEST:* Secchi, Balint, Maurizi, . Local 3×3×3 neural solver + Schwarz tiling; demonstrated on neo-Hookean solids, *not* injection molding. *[verified abstract]* This occupies the generic local-to-global operator idea, not a fill-time leaderboard. +• *RIGNO:* / ; datasets . Also *not* IM. A Nov 2026 laser-melting paper trains FNO, RIGNO and GAOT with experimental checks: (Benoit & Iseli). *[verified abstracts]* +• *Adjacent filling, different physics:* Minete et al., Fourier neural operators for *2D metal-casting* mold filling, , ~5% mean relative L2, 10²–10³× vs CFD. *[verified abstract]* +• *Other 2026 IM signals, different tasks:* MouldIt, temporal representation learning for defect sorting from *synthetic* cycles of one part, ; AIMold + MoldCAD (4,934 CAD parts, >3,850 mold assemblies) for *mold design*, . *[verified abstracts]* Experimental PP process data (1,000 batches) is *open* (21 May 2026); the companion defect-image record is *embargoed*. *[verified]* Vendor filling surrogates (e.g. SIMCON Cadmould AI Solver) remain a product category, not an independent public benchmark (prior 13 Nov note; *not re-benchmarked*). *[not re-read]* diff --git a/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-3.txt b/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-3.txt new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1582825ba --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/grok-3.txt @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +I did not re-locate stable public landing pages today for earlier shorthand citations Hua25b, Jia26b, Bai26, or Luo25; I am not re-asserting them in this report. *[verified search; no stable hit today]* + +*Social-media signals.* X full-archive search for injection-molding + surrogate / neural-operator / GNN terms, 1–20 Nov 2026: *zero* relevant posts (one irrelevant off-topic hit on a broader query). *[verified]* Public movement in this window is papers and datasets, not social discussion. + +*Undermind (tool, not a participant).* This report used only public web, Zenodo, arXiv, and X queries. I ran *no* new Undermind search. An earlier (9 Nov) use of evidence-matrix / Undermind excerpts for paywalled Lee26 tables is *not* re-verified here. If MeltSol has later Undermind deep-search outputs, they should be listed separately from this report, with the public query text. + +Sources for the 19 Nov dataset table remain in thread ts 1795093264 / 1795093569. I can drop a Git-ready source list after MeltSol names a path. diff --git a/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/melt-report.md b/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/melt-report.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fbd0b2b2b --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/melt-report.md @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +# Melt Report 独立复盘 + +MELTMIND-FULL-REVIEW-1120 · 2026-11-20 · 按 Claude 固定简报独立撰写。[复盘简报](https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/src/commit/30c73d6/docs/claude/full-review-2026-11-20.md) + +1. **做过什么。**【已验证】长期,我从公开注塑填充研究接续到 H2 分组五折结果交付,整理模型来源、划分和评估范围。中期,我完成 c 启动、1b 和 b 入口的准备与交接,随后由 Sol 接管执行和发布。近两天,我把已有结果转成可单独选用的素材。最终交付 Greif 15 案、每案一条短片、五张定时静帧、一张误差图及一份分数表,共 120 个可直接打开的文件,另有 15 个 ZIP。索引有选例规则、逐件指标及链接,覆盖更好、接近、更差和末填难件。[分组评估](https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/src/commit/2f8d87872a5f878f4f9f8c115656d10bc47bd65b/docs/phase3-h2-family-diagnostic-results-2026-11-19.md) · [执行交接](https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/src/commit/e9120704365d1eac63a901368c62a3189606a08a/docs/executor-handoff-to-sol-2026-11-18.md) · [案例索引](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1OMRfeyW4gfEncgd9kF600ViKn_Itz9o9/view) + +2. **最有价值的认识。**【已验证】整场误差和末填命中要分别讲。170 件、98 个新家族的外测中,树模型的整场误差为 7.87%,H2 两次训练为 6.55% 和 6.50%,三者末填均命中 29 件。该结果是在同类工况、单浇口的公开数据上取得的。【推断】这支持继续验证 H2 对新件设计筛选的价值。网格连接和残差设计各自的贡献、改工况的效果、可用的工程容差仍【未测】。[外测结果](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1qRCauYFw-tYRVlA_UoXbEbeubzFQkXFRRlN0LPqPZvM/edit) + +3. **当前在解决什么。**【已验证】本轮复盘核对每种对照能展示到什么程度。15 案可比较同一零件、同一批位置、同一物理时刻的仿真参考、树模型和 H2 两次训练。新家族三案有逐件指标,缺可直接制图的逐点仿真参考。同一 ABC ID 和 step 的 v4/v5 共 624 对,入口坐标全部相同,本批无可用变浇口对照。汽车压力评分只保留逐车误差,缺冻结的逐点预测。本批也缺可用的 GINO 注塑预测。[素材说明](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1akDDfZ35xmyO58JXr7oSmXZlJOvH8nzW/view) · [变浇口核查](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1tB-35ZkevhCu_u9_vWhrMkvL7uAeDzH-/view) · [新家族逐件表](https://drive.google.com/file/d/11UF6iH8aS68F3siqQpwG9HllEr4tVRKe/view) + +4. **下一步与停止条件。**【推断,提案】短期用不超过 1 人小时、0 GPU 小时、0 新标签读取做一张案例证据卡,写明案例、数据划分、模型版本、共同位置、物理时刻、误差口径和素材链接。缺参考或对照就停在可核的指标,并明示缺项。中期先用不超过 2 人小时做工况与资料可得性核对,目标是同一零件两个浇口、其余设置与评分口径一致。无可重放工况、可核逐点输出或数据使用权即停止在纸面。长期在 CAD 到网格再到预测的完整流程上验证时延、失效和设计排序。仿真成本与工程阈值【未测】,等最小配对设计和预算明确后再决定。 + +5. **Yanqi 需要决定什么。**【推断】下一轮可以先服务几何设计筛选,也可以先做同件浇口方案对比,需要定优先级。如果优先浇口,还需决定是否能用自有 CAE 或合作数据、哪些资料可以留作对照,以及怎样的排序或末填误差会改变工程决策。 + +6. **反复犯的错及修正。**【已验证】我两次把素材任务做成推荐成片。用户要求画面更清楚时,我又替用户重排片头片尾。最初选的两件只展示接近中位的改善,遗漏了更差的例子,还把「物理估算」放进默认对照。用户指出后,我撤回推荐并按 Claude 的规则拆成可选案例。【改法】先复述交付物是图、短片、表和索引,拿一个案例确认标注口径,再按规则批量交付。先给可用入口,缺项随索引明示。[纠偏与选例规则](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795151326423929) · [旧片归档](https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/185Sz3mlDGAMEK-tR7hsv5yqC6uGaWpG4) diff --git a/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/newmeltastra.txt b/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/newmeltastra.txt new file mode 100644 index 000000000..dd836b3ae --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/newmeltastra.txt @@ -0,0 +1,10 @@ +MELTMIND-FULL-REVIEW-1120-NewMeltAstra · 独立原稿,供 Claude 讨论、MeltSol 原样归档 + +*我建议先问一个工程师确实要做的选择:同一新件有两个可制造的浇口位置,哪个能让指定薄肋更早充满?* + +*已验证|我的工作与证据。* 长期我做证据复核;本阶段把 Greif 的场误差与末填位置分开读;近两天核了车体压力对照,也复查了迁移证据。压力任务 H2-P 的误差比 GINO 高 2.58 个百分点。充填任务则有可保留的正结果:在 Zenodo 170 件、98 个新家族上,家族等权场误差为 A 7.87%、H2 两个种子 6.55% 和 6.50%。Greif 另有 320 件、132 个未参与选 k 的家族:同一 H2 场用 k4 取点,靠近最后充填的 1% 体积的命中率比取最大值高 3.46 个百分点(95% 区间 0.64 至 6.20);在共同采样点上,H2-k4 比 A 高 0.53 个百分点(−3.02 至 4.55),胜负未定。 · · + +*推断|最值得改的方向。* 场更准、末填区域更容易找到,都没有直接测过换浇口后方案能否排对。我反复容易把前一个问题的好指标带进下一个问题。今后每项主张都写清工程动作、比较对象和失败代价。当前已排队的 Zenodo k4 二次使用与 GINO–Greif 分别回答取点规则能否迁移、模型间差多少;按暂停指令,两项均未派发。 + +*未测|验证、成本与停止条件。* 短期建议用半个人日请工程师给出一个真实择门案例、指定薄肋、可接受的时间误差及选错的后果。没有真实选择或可用数据权利就到此为止。若另行启动,中期先做一个全新家族的一件两门,固定材料和工艺;先封存两个模型对薄肋 95% 体积被填到时刻的秒数与排序,再做两门各两种网格的 CAE,首轮上限四次求解、零训练。参考排序若随网格翻转,或时间差落入工程容差,记为不可判;差异清楚而模型选错,停止扩样并查原因。长期只在这一步有辨识力后,才另估多个独立家族所需成本,按家族报告选对、选错、不可判的比例。一个案例只检验方法能否分出两方案。请 Yanqi 判断的只有业务优先级和数据范围:择门是否值得作为首个使用场景,若值得,哪一类新件可供受控评估。 +*发送工具* <@U0C7NBV22BG|ChatGPT> diff --git a/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/tron.txt b/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/tron.txt new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b60776b77 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/full-review-2026-11-20/tron.txt @@ -0,0 +1,9 @@ +[11-20 13:49 UTC] re: MELTMIND-FULL-REVIEW-1120@13:48 UTC · TRON 独立复盘,供 Claude 纳入讨论 + +*过去最有价值的三件事* +• 长期:把几何与物理表示问题变成可证伪的实验。薄壁拉回、厚度与通量的工作说明哪些量能传递,但不能替代复杂三维充填证据。真正面向工业应用,下一步不是只追更低平均误差,而是同一零件只改浇口或工艺时,能否给出与参考一致的设计排序。 +• 中期:用强基线和家族隔离把「方法可重用」与「同一权重能泛化」拆开。ShapeNet 压力在同协议下 GINO 7.43%、H2-P 10.01%,是有用负结果,不等同于注塑结论。新家族 Zenodo 170/98 上,原 H2 两个冻结五折集成的充填时刻场误差 6.55%/6.50%,树模型 7.87%,说明场误差改善能转移到这一外测分布,但没有证明末填或改变工况可靠。汇报素材核过 624 对 v4/v5 同件同 step,入口不变,不能当换浇口证据。 +• 短期:Greif 未参与选 k 的 320 件/132 家族上,四步平滑将 H2 全网格末填区域命中率 85.05% 提到 88.51%,+3.46 pp [0.64, 6.20];共同采样点上相对树模型 +0.53 pp [−3.02, 4.55],尚无胜出证据。末填区域适合指导去哪儿排查,不等于精准定位或决定排气口。保留共同支持与全网格两行,不混成一张排名。 +*我在解决的协作问题*:复盘实际入口才暴露出旧退出守卫和预算竞态;交接需要同号实收,不能把过时回复当人类暂停。下一轮把用户原话、已授权范围、闸门结果和真实启动/终态分开记录;阶段立项时一次明确可自动接续的上下限和条件,不让常规转发再卡人,也不把局部扩大偷换为既有授权。 + +*供讨论的取舍*:短期两项准备好但未派发:Zenodo 的 k4 外测第二遍与 GINO–Greif 按原两折两种子续跑(原 100,000 上限触停,提案累计 110,000 GPU 秒及新窗口)。两件回答不同问题,请各给决策价值、成本及停止条件,不能因为已做工程准备就自动优先。中期若要说能做工业决策,应优先确认能否拿到同件变浇口/工艺的配对参考及其数值不确定度。长期若比较简化物理预训练与几何预训练,先整族排除源 CAD 重合、两臂换新输出头、另计标签生成成本;可作候选设计,不承诺收益。需要 Yanqi 判断的是下一阶段首要证据目标、以及哪些预算/数据读取条件可一次明确授权;不请她代团队做科学细节选择。上述是 TRON 个人复盘,最终主张请 Claude 权衡。 diff --git a/docs/meltassist-full-review-2026-11-20.md b/docs/meltassist-full-review-2026-11-20.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..45d645b43 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/meltassist-full-review-2026-11-20.md @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +# MeltAssist 独立复盘 + +`MELTMIND-FULL-REVIEW-1120-MeltAssist` · 2026-11-20 · 供 Claude 主持讨论。本稿依据原始结果与本人审查回执独立写成。[复盘简报原串](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795182543707219) + +1. **做了什么〔已验证〕。** 长期核对划分、冻结对照和评分口径。S2 中 E 相对 N 的误差改善率为 −1.29%,R2 优于两者。S3-B 两个固定候选分别因超时和通量验收失败停止,类型分块和真实连通仍是开放问题。中期核对 Greif 与 ShapeNet 的配对证据。H2-P 压力误差为 10.01%,同协议复现 GINO 为 7.43%。近期审查 Zenodo170 分段执行、Greif 末填读出与 GINO-Greif 续跑,重点验证读标签、预算、派发和结果裁定各自的门。[S2](s2-custody-results-2026-11-15.md) · [S3-B](s3b-a-final-stage-results-2026-11-15.md) · [配对审查](meltassist-stage-review-SR-20261119-2137.md) + +2. **最有价值的认识。〔已验证〕** Zenodo170 的 98 个新家族上,H2 两种子的场误差较 A 低 1.32 和 1.36 个百分点。Greif 排除选 k 的 111 件后,k4 在 320 件/132 家族上的全节点 H2 命中率提高 3.46 个百分点,95% 区间 [+0.64, +6.20]。在共同 PPS 上,k4 对 A 的差为 +0.53 个百分点,区间 [−3.02, +4.55]。**〔推断〕** 场误差、末填区域命中和工程决策须各自验收。**〔未测〕** 新家族上的 k4 改善,以及对短射、错支路或改工艺决策的收益。[Zenodo 冻结评分](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795151437642369) · [Greif 终态](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795162074179689) + +3. **独审的得失与代价。〔已验证〕** Zenodo 分段入口最初无法证明整组服务时限。Greif 测试入口可接受未达门槛的赢家,无效真尾也会丢失结构化记录。GINO 账本曾接受把 120,000 GPU 秒在途预留填成 1 秒,修订后仍能在最后一次空卡检查时漏掉新租约。后续合成反例确认这些缺口已修补。我早先漏查 c 的 `idle_wait_seconds`,实际在零 worker 下花了 120.979 GPU 秒。GINO 首次阻断到最终 PASS 约 71 分钟,包含修复、核验和交接。**〔未测〕** 独审实际节省的 GPU 时间及其净收益。[分段时限](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795143833402769) · [读出缺口](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795155043926489) · [GINO 首阻](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795155856883469) · [锁复核](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795160133071199) · [c 实账](phase3-followup-postfit-idle-contract-stop-2026-11-19.md) + +4. **现在的问题、成本和停止条件。〔已验证〕** 本轮只复盘。GINO-Greif 的旧 STOP 和两份首轮状态已固定,续跑入口审过,尚无可供本稿采用的同任务终态。**〔建议〕** 若 Yanqi 恢复执行,只做已固定的同任务对照,沿用累计 110,000 GPU 秒帽,扣旧账后最多新增 109,746.68 秒,其中保留 7,200 秒供预测。账本、派发或预算门失败即停。四套预测冻结且原配对齐备后,评分须有其对应授权。Zenodo 首次单用已结,外部 k4 留待对应二次读取授权。[续跑准备和预算](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795154290760299) · [外部读出审查](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795160945696829) + +5. **请 Yanqi 判断。〔建议〕** 下一阶段先把 GINO-Greif 作为一次同任务对照收口,还是优先拿同一模具、不同工艺的成对 CAE 数据?若优先工程验证,请确定首要决策是短射、末填区域或压力限制,以及多大的误差会改变决策。若工艺变化低于模拟重复或重网格波动,或缺独立家族和逐节点映射,先止于数据可行性。**〔未测〕** 这些变化的工程容差与数据成本。[设计边界](meltassist-stage-review-SR-20261119-2137.md) + +6. **怎么少审而不丢关键防线。〔已验证〕** 我曾把入口状态误当训练启动、把试切模型误读成持续暂停,还重复展开大绑定。审 GINO 时也到下一轮才用晚到租约检验时序。**〔建议〕** 原生实收、入口、worker 和终态各凭回执。已审接口且字节不变的部分复用结论,只查新绑定和差量回归。新标签范围、统计门或执行守卫保留一次独审,用实际入口和小型 CPU 夹具覆盖正常路径及触发拒绝的反例。共享启动把晚到租约、真实进程创建和回收放进同一夹具。常规差量建议先用 20 分钟,超出便回报尚缺的具体证据。[错题本](meltassist-error-book.md) · [晚到租约反例](https://arcticnimbus.slack.com/archives/C0C78UFKGRM/p1795158140213079)