 (5 total) ===

--- Reply 1 of 5 ---
From: Frank14f <frank14wyq@gmail.com> (U0C7U0YA91S)
Time: 2026-11-14 16:04:08 CST
Message TS: 1794643448.927799
<@U0C7SSQLBJ7|ClaudeWorker (local)> MoldAstra 定点复核：已将 15:43 裁决写入原 M2 v1.2 页首并从 Drive 回读：https://drive.google.com/file/d/1LDZBY2n2OrL2ipnH18wyZLJgV72rqhPd/view 。1407 为全局流，2000 次等权重抽 24 个已算好的来源配对差，双侧 95% linear percentile 单独决定两项主对比排序；1406 按件、200 次同复本配对，只报查询抽样不确定性。请在结果表把 1407 标为「固定 LOPO 配对差的来源重加权区间」：不同折共享 22 个训练来源，重抽时没有重新拟合秩映射或近邻池，不能据此承诺重新拟合后对新来源的 95% 覆盖。区间含零（含端点）为未分出先后，不是等效。本轮未运行评分或重复代码审查。
*发送工具* <@U0C7NBV22BG|ChatGPT>

--- Reply 2 of 5 ---
From: ClaudeWorker (local) <botuser-T0C8JMA61UY-B0C7YUHNDFC@slack-bots.com> (U0C7SSQLBJ7)
Time: 2026-11-14 16:04:11 CST
Message TS: 1794643451.382079
Queued behind 1 earlier request(s): “MoldAstra 定点复核：已将 15:43 裁决写入原 M2 v1.2 页首并从 Drive 回…”

--- Reply 3 of 5 ---
From: ClaudeWorker (local) <botuser-T0C8JMA61UY-B0C7YUHNDFC@slack-bots.com> (U0C7SSQLBJ7)
Time: 2026-11-14 16:05:16 CST
Message TS: 1794643516.496129
*Claude: main review of the S1 scorer (`e425419c`). Approved with two pins; the real run can start once Grok's targeted checks pass.*

*What I read:* all of `s1_scoring.py`, with the SHAs of the scorer, I/O module and tests checked against SHA256SUMS. I did not run the 14 tests (no NumPy/SciPy in my sandbox), so I rely on the posted log for those.

*Checked against the M2 v1.2 contract and the 15:3x rulings, all consistent:*
• *Rank weights* = c/ΣcE/P over eligible draws only, with no second m factor. The rank map is the weighted mid-rank Σw·1(<) + ½Σw·1(=), clamped to 0 and 1 outside the range, fitted once on the *true* training features and never refitted for the shuffled arms ✓.
• *Arm columns:* A = (d/t, gate/R_g), B adds (g₁₂, g₂₃, gate q₁, gate q₂), C adds the 4 edge summaries. A+S permutes columns 2–5 and the edge shuffle permutes 6–9. Both reuse one row index per part and seed, permute within each part, and never touch test queries ✓.
• *Stratified shuffle:* uses its own Generator from the same seed and the fixed stratum order. Strata with fewer than 8 slots stay unchanged. Ratios are only formed where the gap is > 0, and are multiplied by the receiving node's gap. The edge audit formulas (bounds and cross-channel order) match the algebra ✓.
• *k-NN:* exact, with 8 distinct physical nodes. D_p is computed directly, ties are broken by stable physical ID, and the radius padding is only there to retrieve candidates ✓.
• *Ratio estimators:* draw-count weighted and restricted to eligible nodes; a zero denominator gives NA. Query bootstrap: 1406, 200 replicates of draw slots. Source bootstrap: 1407, 2,000 replicates over sorted source keys, with the 95 % linear percentile interval and the decision read from the source level only ✓.
• Shortfall gate, source-leakage check, one part per source ✓.

*Two pins before the real run:*
1. *Which estimate decides:* the primary ranking is made on the *five-seed mean* source-level interval. Per-seed results are reported for stability, with how many of the 5 seeds agree with the five-seed decision. The source bootstrap does not cover permutation randomness, which is why the five-seed mean decides.
2. *Supervision:* run the folds sequentially under the existing supervisor (1,800 s / 1.25 GiB per fold). Record the k-NN query counts actually used against `query_cost.csv`.

A known, accepted point: the plain and stratified shuffles start from the same seed stream, so they are correlated. That is acceptable because the stratified control is secondary.

*Release:* once Grok has replayed `synthetic_seed_vectors.json` and checked the mid-rank weight formula, MeltAstra may run the real S1 on all 24 LOPO folds. Results come back as a fixed package covering all arms, contrasts, shuffle and clamping audits, and supervision receipts. No training.

--- Reply 4 of 5 ---
From: Grok (local) <botuser-T0C8JMA61UY-B0C7LEBB5V3@slack-bots.com> (U0C7VDY1HEG)
Time: 2026-11-14 16:05:23 CST
Message TS: 1794643523.014799
*Grok: independent check PASS — seed replay and (1/P)c_E/K_pE midranks*

Pinned commit `e425419c8012127400e8945baa8d04e2953646bd`. I regenerated <https://gitea.frank14f.online/Frank14f/MeltMind/src/commit/e425419c8012127400e8945baa8d04e2953646bd/review/2026-11-14/s1-scoring-code/synthetic_seed_vectors.json|synthetic_seed_vectors.json> (SHA256 `1fe6ccd51d34ce3c4ac056e527d4b459d16f27546ca58184fc19383dbad001a2`) from the published PCG64/SeedSequence contract, without using `s1_seed_vectors.py`. Replay ran on CPython 3.13 + NumPy 2.5.4 against vectors published from NumPy 1.26.4; every byte and digest comparison was identical.

• Permutation seeds 1401–1405, prefix 993, n=31: ordinary and stratified maps and their published digests all match. The size-7 (0,0) stratum is left unchanged; each size-8 stratum permutes only its own IDs.
• Query bootstrap `PCG64(SeedSequence([2026111406, 993]))`, 200 replicates of 11 draw slots: first-three count rows and digest `1890914cf3cbb38e7a24f861ba89609fec2a85ef34b714dd152ce42e6fe6e3bc` match; every row sums to 11.
• Source bootstrap `PCG64(SeedSequence([2026111407]))` with no prefix, 2000×24 keys s00–s23: first-three index rows and digest `d91fbe3b6a196edd85245aa2b3924fcb4d615e08a3d32bb2bbcf96b4334c21ca` match.

The hand formula in `test_weighted_midrank_hand_values` is exact. With P=3 and K_pE=(3, 2, 4) after dropping the ineligible node, weights are 1/9, 2/9; 1/6, 1/6; 1/4, 1/12. Masses at 0, 1, 2 are 5/18, 17/36, 1/4. Midranks (F_left+F_right)/2 are 5/36, 37/72, 7/8; unseen 1.5 takes F_right(1)=3/4; strict tails are 0 and 1. The scorer’s `rank_weights` and `RankMap.transform` agree with these fractions (atol 2e-16). I did not repeat a full review, and I loaded no real descriptors, ranks, or S1 run.

--- Reply 5 of 5 ---
From: ClaudeWorker (local) <botuser-T0C8JMA61UY-B0C7YUHNDFC@slack-bots.com> (U0C7SSQLBJ7)
Time: 2026-11-14 16:05:32 CST
Message TS: 1794643532.162559
*Claude: agreed.* The results table will show the 1407 interval under that label: *"source-reweighting interval over fixed LOPO paired differences (ranks and reference pools not refitted; not a coverage guarantee for new sources)"*. On the endpoint convention, the code already classifies an interval that touches 0 as "no ranking difference" (`ci[1] < 0` → ahead, `ci[0] > 0` → behind, everything else no difference), and the report will word that as "not separated", not as "equivalent".

