<@U0C7SSQLBJ7|ClaudeWorker (local)> Grok independent report for *MELTMIND-FULL-REVIEW-1120* (brief `30c73d6`). Written without reading other members' 15:00 reports. Review only: no compute or label reads. Claims are marked *[verified]* (page or record opened), *[inferred]*, or *[untested / not re-read]*.

*1. What I did*
• *Short term (18–20 Nov, UTC+8).* Bounded public search: per-part Moldflow study / LOG / gate files for the 94 Greif *v2 extra* parts are not in the public v2 pack and were not carried into v4/v5 (<https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10523313|v2>, thread ts 1794968184). *[verified]* On 19 Nov I posted a public fill-time dataset/benchmark table (ts 1795093264) and GINO / licence notes (ts 1795093569), then probed and later completed a local copy of the warpage archive <https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17831586|17831586> (`data.zip` 2,031,797,362 B, MD5 `4e46bb298d00ede83aa8bce3ab79f349`). Drive binary upload hit the 100 MB cap. *[verified]*
• *Medium (this MeltMind phase).* After Yanqi narrowed my role on 14 Nov (ts 1794640931), I stuck to independent checks and literature gaps: Gre24-style vs official eikonal; S2 v0 is not an unoccupied “type-organisation” claim; Lee26’s open abstract is a pressure MAPE, not a fill-time headline; hash/seal witnesses; unique Greif v4 relay and checksums. *[verified]* against those Slack posts and the live Zenodo pages.
• *Long.* Public-source audit for this project and the broader lab: open papers, Zenodo records, and occasional X scans, not scheme ownership or compute.

*2. Most valuable thing learned*
The only public *3D fill-time field* corpus with many ABC geometries and Moldflow fields is still the Augsburg Greif–Meyer series. *[verified]* There is no second public benchmark with multiple independent part families, per-part gate/process metadata, *and* nodal fill time (same conclusion as ts 1795093264; re-checked today). So “beat a filling surrogate” is a crowded, easy-to-overclaim frame. *[inferred]* What *is* new around us is mostly (a) same-family GAT surrogates, (b) generic local-to-global neural operators on other PDEs, and (c) experimental or design datasets that are *not* 3D fill-field benchmarks.

*3. In progress, and what it is trying to solve*
This review slot only. I am not running downloads, GINO, or label reads. The live public map I am holding is: which corpora and papers a 3D fill-field SOTA claim can fairly be compared with, and which nearby papers are a different task.

*4. Next steps (cost and stop)*
• *Short:* in the 15:00–15:45 round, reply only if named, and only on literature or data conflicts. Optional: one Git file of today’s source table if MeltSol wants a citable original. *Cost:* search/write time, no GPU. *Stop:* after Claude’s 16:15 synthesis, unless Yanqi asks for a delta.
• *Medium:* if compute resumes, I still do not start runs. On request I will check the *protocol* of any public SOTA comparison (Greif version, split, metric) and, if asked, whether an official Gre24 eikonal implementation has appeared. *Stop:* when the comparison corpus and claim slice are frozen.
• *Long:* a coarse public-signal watch (arXiv / Zenodo / X) instead of on-demand recaps. *Stop:* two consecutive watches with nothing material, or Yanqi ends the watch.

*5. What Yanqi actually needs to decide*
1. *Which Greif version is the comparison standard.* The concept DOI <https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10027027|10.5281/zenodo.10027027> now resolves to *v5* (24 Feb 2026? — record date *10 Feb 2026*): 624 VTU, 32.8 GB, MD5 `75ec15002234c2cdcdf4c751bdefab85`, with added residual-stress and fibre-composite *elemental* fields. *[verified]* <https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18598121|18598121>. *v4* <https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.11370149|11370149> remains 629 VTU, 35.9 GB, MD5 `4973f24e12a38c87c31cf129be1a3e3b`. Saying “Greif data” without a version is ambiguous. This is a scope/data-rights choice, not a compute order.
