Depth-2 twin shear validation: execution COMPLETE; scientific FAIL
Exact source 02bde0f75187786a2ce10abc9a863f750b6343a8; production unchanged a135252ae78b47b57d7e77d19001700b3bedac8b.
61 host tests and four source-only dry runs pass. Four fresh serial cases,
611319808 active updates, 20 scalar rows, six actual build sidecars.
Both fresh uniform controls pass. Constant fails own pressure screen and
comparative rate/residual/pressure budgets. Projected passes own screens and
pressure budget but fails comparative rate/residual budgets. No tuning/rerun.
Fixed two outer regions with L2 removed: leaves [7936,33792], hops [2048,4096],
nu [.0384,.0768], tau [.6152,.7304]. Periodic shifted FP32 D2Q9/SRT, Re100/U=.03,
oblique mode (2,1), phase zero, five times 0/.12/.24/.36/.48. No bodies/Jets/LES/forcing.
No snapshots, early traces, checkpoints, populations or field time series retained.
AUDIT ORDER LIMITATION: Sidecars and PTX hashes were captured/verified before cleanup. Independent source/config reconstruction occurred after cleanup; the requested independent pre-cleanup source audit was not performed. No rerun or source fix.
All six source/config reconstructions passed; frozen capture verified PTX bytes
before loading. The ordering limitation is separate from the frozen scientific result.
Historical controls are comparison checks only; fresh runs are assessor inputs.
Control checks: {"uniform128": {"reference_path": "/home/frank14f/CelerisLab/output/nested-shear-335624c-20261019/uniform128.json", "reference_sha256": "b0e9358d9188b1f9901f7bb8956b43e443974d1ea7fe086c527fe1d59fa38189", "checks": {"rows": true, "actual_build_sidecars": true, "runtime_identity": true, "runtime_source": true, "n": true, "re_L": true, "depth": true, "explosion": true, "U": true, "mode": true, "phase": true, "polarization": true, "viscosity": true, "tau_by_level": true, "numerics": true, "initialization": true, "workload": true}, "all_checked_fields_exact": true, "historical_source": "335624c27b8fc9925e708fb61bde5eea5c04d2a4", "fresh_source": "02bde0f75187786a2ce10abc9a863f750b6343a8", "fresh_run_used_for_assessment": true}, "uniform256": {"reference_path": "/home/frank14f/CelerisLab/output/scaled-shear-9748ef9-20261019/uniform256.json", "reference_sha256": "51bb1cb874b9442df9e48ad3cff5b0cd2979233c298b85d4cf1fad59e359a9cf", "checks": {"rows": true, "actual_build_sidecars": true, "runtime_identity": true, "runtime_source": true, "n": true, "re_L": true, "depth": true, "explosion": true, "U": true, "mode": true, "phase": true, "polarization": true, "viscosity": true, "tau_by_level": true, "numerics": true, "initialization": true, "workload": true}, "all_checked_fields_exact": true, "historical_source": "9748ef91ef3bfd366756ef0c8a056df8faa75679", "fresh_source": "02bde0f75187786a2ce10abc9a863f750b6343a8", "fresh_run_used_for_assessment": true}}
Twin versus nested changes finest spacing and refined volume as well as levels;
compare global metrics and signed decay rates, not pure depth or local regions.
Global contrast: {"constant": {"signed_rate_bias": {"twin": 0.007606421676231934, "nested": 0.009174232340854571, "nested_minus_twin": 0.0015678106646226375}, "rate_tstar": {"twin": 1.9889353547883277, "nested": 1.9920300889954548, "nested_minus_twin": 0.0030947342071270256}, "residual_l2": {"twin": 0.008752866652957736, "nested": 0.008957496551892383, "nested_minus_twin": 0.00020462989893464678}, "spurious_pressure_scaled": {"twin": 0.059081663930069896, "nested": 0.06400403350537295, "nested_minus_twin": 0.004922369575303058}, "spurious_pressure_rms": {"twin": 4.37795242423643e-06, "nested": 4.749296469126859e-06, "nested_minus_twin": 3.713440448904284e-07}, "final_amplitude_error": {"twin": -0.007752031614480126, "nested": -0.009165412933747064, "nested_minus_twin": -0.0014133813192669376}}, "projected_linear": {"signed_rate_bias": {"twin": 0.002518325312005576, "nested": 0.0029879928509064513, "nested_minus_twin": 0.0004696675389008753}, "rate_tstar": {"twin": 1.9788918551344208, "nested": 1.9798189416962177, "nested_minus_twin": 0.0009270865617969637}, "residual_l2": {"twin": 0.0033284364167803448, "nested": 0.002869975025822039, "nested_minus_twin": -0.00045846139095830594}, "spurious_pressure_scaled": {"twin": 0.019285597174482652, "nested": 0.022938546030866768, "nested_minus_twin": 0.003652948856384116}, "spurious_pressure_rms": {"twin": 1.6385450337311492e-06, "nested": 1.8407706952257852e-06, "nested_minus_twin": 2.0222566149463607e-07}, "final_amplitude_error": {"twin": -0.002943234188526267, "nested": -0.0033247496558889145, "nested_minus_twin": -0.0003815154673626475}}}
Case outcomes: {"uniform128": {"rate_fit_valid": true, "rate": 0.00046280430667861245, "exact_rate": 0.00046263770630106365, "rate_tstar": 1.9746317084954133, "exact_rate_tstar": 1.9739208802178718, "rate_error": 0.0003601098122347768, "interval_rate_errors": [0.0003602001132636534, 0.00035935180017721, 0.00036103019394362335], "log_fit_residual_max": 1.3893075667681387e-07, "eps": 0.012047856934923534, "complete": true, "residual_l2": 8.769447958714563e-06, "phase_drift_abs": 5.765294884226217e-07, "spurious_pressure_scaled": 0.001576755289825344, "spurious_pressure_rms": 1.3338225805134667e-07, "amplitude_error_abs": 0.001292207728581296, "velocity_l2": 0.001292221461628662, "mass_relative": 1.391438297946022e-08, "own_screens_pass": true, "runner_screen_pass": true, "execution": {"label": "uniform128", "exit_code": 0, "error": null, "seconds": 1.9967408479424194, "total_active_seconds": 1.9967408479424194, "utc": "2026-10-19T03:01:13.321511+00:00"}}, "uniform256": {"rate_fit_valid": true, "rate": 0.00023133926919910864, "exact_rate": 0.00023131885315053183, "rate_tstar": 1.9740950971657272, "exact_rate_tstar": 1.9739208802178718, "rate_error": 8.825933683631604e-05, "interval_rate_errors": [8.806347306888895e-05, 8.846390536021431e-05, 8.81824425715827e-05], "log_fit_residual_max": 3.1273215572724666e-08, "eps": 0.0030119642337308834, "complete": true, "residual_l2": 1.3235536325304534e-06, "phase_drift_abs": 2.1580595539825034e-07, "spurious_pressure_scaled": 0.0002931951066209423, "spurious_pressure_rms": 1.6152815706128364e-08, "amplitude_error_abs": 0.0002813703650996757, "velocity_l2": 0.0002813722822544183, "mass_relative": 2.482130989785184e-08, "own_screens_pass": true, "runner_screen_pass": true, "execution": {"label": "uniform256", "exit_code": 0, "error": null, "seconds": 2.098474550060928, "total_active_seconds": 4.095215398003347, "utc": "2026-10-19T03:01:18.389798+00:00"}}, "constant128": {"rate_fit_valid": true, "rate": 0.0004661567237785143, "exact_rate": 0.00046263770630106365, "rate_tstar": 1.9889353547883277, "exact_rate_tstar": 1.9739208802178718, "rate_error": 0.007606421676231934, "interval_rate_errors": [0.007624419386097925, 0.007604520188235986, 0.00759095928368736], "log_fit_residual_max": 2.206631056989039e-06, "eps": 0.012047856934923534, "complete": true, "residual_l2": 0.008752866652957736, "phase_drift_abs": 3.0460209075313224e-05, "spurious_pressure_scaled": 0.059081663930069896, "spurious_pressure_rms": 4.37795242423643e-06, "amplitude_error_abs": 0.007752031614480126, "velocity_l2": 0.011692202267407336, "mass_relative": 2.010612676434918e-08, "own_screens_pass": false, "valid": true, "budget": {"rate_error": 0.002, "residual_l2": 0.002, "spurious_pressure_scaled": 0.02}, "budget_pass": false, "control_ratios": {"root": {"rate_error": 21.122506018449894, "residual_l2": 998.1091961734776, "spurious_pressure_scaled": 37.47040793921441, "spurious_pressure_rms": 32.82259940861924}, "finest": {"rate_error": 86.18262893067786, "residual_l2": 6613.156005037327, "spurious_pressure_scaled": 201.5097203053041, "spurious_pressure_rms": 271.0333915699564}}, "controlled_pass": false, "runner_screen_pass": false, "execution": {"label": "constant128", "exit_code": 1, "error": null, "seconds": 3.94413298193831, "total_active_seconds": 8.039348379941657, "utc": "2026-10-19T03:01:25.293897+00:00"}}, "projected128": {"rate_fit_valid": true, "rate": 0.00046380277854712984, "exact_rate": 0.00046263770630106365, "rate_tstar": 1.9788918551344208, "exact_rate_tstar": 1.9739208802178718, "rate_error": 0.002518325312005576, "interval_rate_errors": [0.0025257220829064675, 0.002517308072683244, 0.0025122848601952796], "log_fit_residual_max": 9.161974312554833e-07, "eps": 0.012047856934923534, "complete": true, "residual_l2": 0.0033284364167803448, "phase_drift_abs": 3.855929180870407e-06, "spurious_pressure_scaled": 0.019285597174482652, "spurious_pressure_rms": 1.6385450337311492e-06, "amplitude_error_abs": 0.002943234188526267, "velocity_l2": 0.004443097720097865, "mass_relative": 2.0460466433081784e-08, "own_screens_pass": true, "valid": true, "budget": {"rate_error": 0.002, "residual_l2": 0.002, "spurious_pressure_scaled": 0.02}, "budget_pass": false, "control_ratios": {"root": {"rate_error": 6.993214920685725, "residual_l2": 379.54913837794544, "spurious_pressure_scaled": 12.231192309251046, "spurious_pressure_rms": 12.284580105851687}, "finest": {"rate_error": 28.533245345770165, "residual_l2": 2514.772605335856, "spurious_pressure_scaled": 65.77735009546413, "spurious_pressure_rms": 101.44021101593368}}, "controlled_pass": false, "runner_screen_pass": true, "execution": {"label": "projected128", "exit_code": 0, "error": null, "seconds": 4.237988607957959, "total_active_seconds": 12.277336987899616, "utc": "2026-10-19T03:01:32.538955+00:00"}}}
Resources: {"peak_rss_bytes": 276398080, "peak_rss_plus_supervisor_bytes": 295800832, "minimum_ram_bytes": 63272431616, "minimum_vram_mib": 15816, "peak_campaign_bytes": 6311936, "peak_total_bytes": 1932693504}
Protection: {"all_worktrees_refs_and_root_index_unchanged": true, "exact_source": true, "scratch_clean": true}
